what do you think about Scaruffi's list of the best bands off all time?
>>63256663
Well familiar with all except Pop Group and Soft Machine. Only one i have a major problem with is Doors
Haven't listened to half of them, ones I have are between alright and shitty.
>>63256663
Velvet Underground is a pretty decent pick for the top space at least.
>>63256663
>Floyd
No way scruffi likes this elevator muzak
why does scaruffi like the rolling stones so much
>>63256736
But anon, Floyd is the best band on this list next to VU
Some bands I like, some bands I don't, some bands I love.
But mine would be quite different, but a chart like this doesn't really have any sense or purpose.
where is death grips? anco? merzbow? slint? list is honestly p l e b t i e r
>Jefferson Airplane
>Soft Machine
>Rolling Stones
why?
>>63256663
payola
VU, Can, Talking Heads, and maybe Floyd but I'm not a fan, are the only ones you can really make a solid case for
>all dadrock
opinion discarded
>VU
>Pere Ubu
>Jefferson Airplane
>Pop Group
>Pop Group
>The Rolling Stones
>Pop Group
>POP FUCKING GROUP
>2. Pere Ubu
not true by the way
>>63256922
that album's awesome tho
>>63256953
>album
yeah, it may be, but we're talking about the BEST BANDS OF ALL TIME
>Pere Ubu
The fuck? They're a bunch of art rock also-rans. Not even in the top hundred,
>>63257040
who gives a shit about scruffy anyway, and it's not like a chart like this can made objectively.
Why does anyone listen to this turd-burglar? He has shit taste.
>>63256663
These are only his rock top artists, not his overall.
Is velvet underground any good? Never listened to it, should I?
>>63256663
>5. Rolling Stones
>Only one of their albums is rated 8/10 with the rest being lower
>>63256663
looks like a list from someone who is old and generally hates modern music
>>63256663
>Doors
It's The Doors.
>>63256774
what's worse - plebtier or poseurtier?
>>63256881
>Talking Heads
>dadrock
okay, buddy
1, 2, 3, 4 Faust is dece at number 4
>>63257232
my mom used to listen to them
looks like a bunch of slightly more obscure dadrock
>>63256774
Why didn't you name anyone good for your argument?
>>63257232
Pop group shouldn't be there, Y is great but they are fair to inconsistent
honestly some of the guys recs are awesome but this list is shit... his best artists of the decades list are way more helpful.
currently checking out his top shoegaze albums. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l2AFDB07bzs
>>63256663
>Talking Heads
literally a meme band
>>63256663
The Doors, Rolling Stones, Soft Machine, The Pop Group... all utter drivel or capable only of brief moments of greatness (ie: Sticky Fingers, Y)
Scaruffi's generally embarassing so none of this is a surprise.
>>63256774
>death grips? anco?
lol
>>63256922
>he doesn't see the brilliance in Y
i hate this board
what's with all the newfags and underage plebs nowadays?
Y is one of the best albums released in the 20th century
>>63257608
Explain how any of them are bad without resorting to buzzwords
only fucks from the bay area would ever put a frisco psych scene band up in their top 10. theyre obsessed with that bygone culture over there
the doors are bullshit though, why anyone thinks that long winded borefest of organs and deep voiced crooning is good ill never fucking know. and the pop group have one fucking album, how can you even put them up that high, granted its a great album, but its only one
>>63257735
>he hasn't heard For How Much Longer Will We Tolerate Mass Murder?
I feel sorry for you tbqh
I wouldn't trust a thing he says
>>63257762
what an assumption to make based on the part where i mention that y is the good album, presumptuous spongeposter
Only good bands are:
>Faust
>Can
>Floyd
>Soft Machine
>>63257815
> the pop group have one fucking album
It just sounds like a list of some guys favorite bands honestly. He's definitely biased, as everyone is. Some good bands though
>>63257809
>those hoverhand
>>63257898
yep, they have one album
>>63257725
Describe the taste of Scaruffi's asshole without resorting to innuendo or lazy analogies.
>>63256663
>Pere Ubu
>Faust
>Can
Would all be in my top 10
Also,
>all these plebs ITT hating on the Doors
Embarrassing.
I agree with 1, 3, 6, 8, 10, 12.
Scaruffi enjoys rolling stones. AHAHAHAHAHA and this guy is supposed to be the best music critc out there?
Man, I really need to establish a general about older rock music, the hard part should fending off the hordes shitposters screaming DADROCK
>>63256663
I'm alright with it. It's his opinion you know...
>>63256736
he likes the barrett era
>>63256663
all around good list
>>63259489
>the barrett era
One album and a handful of singles is hardly an era
>>63259818
well it was
1. Grateful Dead
2. Talking Heads
3. Can
not really feeling the rest
