Which Pink Floyd album is the best?
Were they better with or without Syd Barrett?
>>63186669
Their first album.
Of course.
>shit barrett
Without
I'm a massive Pink Floyd fan. I like most of their work. I really like that period after Syd Barrett left the band and they were trying to find their own sound, since Syd was the creative leader of the band.
Anyway:
Piper 8/10
Saucerful 6/10
Ummagumma 9/10
More 4/10
AHM 8/10
Meddle 10/10
Obscured 5/10
DSOTM 8/10
WYWH 8/10
Animals 10/10
The Wall 7/10
TFC, 5/10
AMLOR 4/10
DB 4/10
ER 2/10
>>63187221
Make Piper a 7/10 and WYWH a 9/10 and this is spot on.
They became shit after Syd Barrett left.
>>63187895
>they became shit after they gave Roger Waters too much freedom
FTFY
>>63187895
>*contrarianism intensifies*
The only bad track on Piper is the one written solely by Waters.
The rest of the album is fucking grand and you know it. Even The Gnome is good.
>>63186669
>best album
AHM, and it's so clear.
>better with or without
Without, and only tryhards and contrarians think otherwise
>>63187221
This is pretty fucking spot on. Well done.
>>63187221
9 Piper
8 Saucerful
7 Ummagumma
7 Atom Heart Mother
6 Meddle
7 TDSOTM
7 WYWH
6 Animals
5 Wall
Easily better without
DSOTM > Animals > The Wall > Wish You Were Here = Atom Heart Mother
Every other album doesnt matter
>>63187972
yes!
More and Obscured By Clouds are both criminally underrated and BASICALLY you're JUST fucking idiots
>>63187895
They actually stopped being shit when Syd left.
>>63188109
Meddle matters more than the Wall.
>>63187221
Piper 8/10
Saucerful 8/10
Ummagumma 7/10
More 5/10
AHM 5/10
Meddle 10/10
Obscured 6/10
DSOTM 8/10
WYWH 9/10
Animals 10/10
The Wall 4/10
TFC, 3/10
AMLOR 3/10
DB 4/10
ER 2/10
The Final Cut and The Division Bell are both fantastic. Nobody gives viable reasons as to why it supposedly sucks. People just regurgitate what others think without giving the album's a shot.
>Which Pink Floyd album is the best?
Animals imo
>Were they better with or without Syd Barrett?
Without of course. Syd era floyd is fucking trash for the most part and only wannabe hipster faggots pretend to like it.
