The Mountain Goats > Neutral Milk Hotel
Honestly, true.
agreed
mountain goats thread bump
100% agreed, and I fucking love NMH.
Favorite Album? Favorite Song?
>>61143171
>Favorite Album
All Hail West Texas
>Favorite Song
Going to Spain or Riches and Wonders
NMH has 15 good songs, they're not hard to top
Ok, John Green.
>>61143041
I totally agree with you m8.
But also..
Everything else>The Mountain Goats > Neutral Milk Hotel
>>61143260
which 15? isn't 15 songs their entire discography?
Anyone else think this is better than Sunset Tree?
>>61143756
I don't know if it's better because I fucking love Sunset Tree but I also really really like CCTTST
>>61143756
Didn't come up in Google image search, what is this?
>>61145102
That's Come, Come to the Sunset Tree. It's basically the acoustic version of The Sunset Tree but there are some lyrical changes and a song that isn't on the regular version.
>>61146382
Can't believe I missed out on this, will listen immediately
bump
>>61143332
john green likes nmh too, a character goes to a nmh concert in one of his books
more like neutral GOAT hotel amirite
>>61143756
I like this version of You or Your Memory better than the album version desu senpai.
>>61143041
>Best Album
All Hail West Texas
>Best Song
Objectively, it's The Best Ever Death Metal Band In Denton. Personally, it's Quito.
I must say, the Mountain Goats have got to be the least controversial band on /mu/. Everybody on here seems to either really love them or be totally ambivalent.
>>61143260
I like them quite a bit and while I would say they have more than 15 solidly good songs, I have to admit they have a lot of filler songs, annoying ditties and absolute crap.
>>61143539
They probably have several hundred songs in their discography.
>>61143171
>Favorite Album
Hot Garden Stomp
>Favorite Song
Shadow Song
>>61143041
Now THATS contrarian
