Rate each /mu/core album.
chart
>>61121132
shit taste confirmed
Untrue and American Football don't deserve to be there
They aren't nearly as popular on /mu/ as albums like Pet Sounds and Soundtracks for the Blind
>>61121197
that chart was made in 2011 i think
green = like
yellow = neutral/don't care
red = dislike
>>61121228
That sounds way off considering that OK Computer and MPP were both universally considered /mu/core back then and Death Grips never got real popular here until TMS was released. This chart was probably made within the last year
>>61121132
itaots - 6
stgstv - 7
kid a - 6
spiderland - 8
loveless - 6
untrue - 6
remain in light - 7
itcotck - 8
lysf - 9
mbdtf - 5
exmil - 6
american football - 5
>>61121302
>liking shitty meme albums
>disliking all the actually good ones
>ITAOTS
4/10
>Spirit They're Gone...
3.5/10
>Kid A
8/10
>Spideland
9/10
>Loveless
9/10
>Untrue
6.5/10
>Remain in Light
5/10
>ITCOKC
8/10
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
3/10
>MBDTF
4.5/10
>Exmilitary
7/10
>American Football
6/10
>>61121335
>Scaruffi
>>61121338
>boring as sin
>>61121342
>trying to feel superior to someone over /mu/core
cute
>>61121302
post kt
>>61121349
epic bro!
>>61121388
do you have something to say or are you just going to hide behind passive-aggressiveness
>>61121433
i was complimenting you my man no need to get hotheaded
>>61121455
just leave
>>61121462
i am sorry you did not like my compliment
>ITAOTS
6/10
>Spirit They're Gone...
8/10
>Kid A
5/10
>Spiderland
7/10
>Loveless
4/10
>Untrue
6/10
>Remain in Light
7/10
>ITCOKC
7/10
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
3/10
>MBDTF
2/10
>Exmilitary
6/10
>American Football
4/10
>>61121358
The only ones there scored the same as scaruffi are spiderland and loveless you nematode.
i have better taste than all of you
>>61121493
it's OK anon, I thought it was a great compliment
objective rankings
I left only the good ones
fight me
Rate each /mu/core album.
Yall aint got shit
>>61121547
b-but you gave Loveless a 5.
Still haven't listened to Remain In Light
;^)
>>61121132
>ITAOTS
9.5/10
>STGSTV
6.5/10
>Kid A
9.7/10
>Spiderland
9.2/10
>Loveless
9.5/10
>Untrue
5/10
>Remain in Light
9.3/10
>ITCOTCK
10/10
>LYSFLATH
9.7/10
>MBDTF
7.5/10
>Exmilitary
7/10
>American Football
6.5/10
ITAOTS
>8/10
idk why this is having backlash as of late, maybe some meme kids trying to be cool?
STGSTV
>6/10
i don't even fucking care that a small outspoken group here thinks this is the best album ever made.
it has great ideas and the fact they did this shit at the age they did is pretty neat but that's about it.
Kid A
>7.5/10
OKC is better imo, i'm not that into radiohead so don't really take this to heart
Spiderland
>9/10
if STGSTV is an amazing debut album then this is christ incarnate
Loveless
>8.5/10
vacuum noises xddddd
Untrue
>8/10
i prefer his s/t, kill me
Remain in Light
>9.5/10
nothing wrong here
ITCOCK
>9/10
nothing wrong here
LYSF
>8.5/10
nothing wrong here
MBDTF
>9/10
opinion disregarded!!!!!
Exmilitary
>8/10
best three DG albums are NotM, this, and NLDW
American Football
>8/10
high school rock
You guys can be pretentious, contrarians all you want, but all those albums are great except for American Football, MBDTF, and Untrue.
>>61121871
>contrarians
>thinks 3 acclaimed albums aren't great
KAH
MAH
PO
LEECE
>>61121871
I'm with you. the only okay album is american football and thats not even that great
the only completely wrong people in this thread are people who rate Exmilitary >5
>>61121871
>calls everyone contrarians
>doesn't like mbdtf
ok lad
>>61121622
>>61121985
Triggered
>>61121906
This, holy shit
How can someone contradict themselves in such a retarded way in one fucking sentence?
>>61121342
>liking things you dont like
>not liking thing i do like
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
>ITAOTS
Never heard
>Spirit They're Gone...
Never heard
>Kid A
5
>Spiderland
6
>Loveless
4
>Untrue
10
>Remain in Light
Never heard
>ITCOKC
6
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
5
>MBDTF
0
>Exmilitary
4
>American Football
Never heard
>>61122071
wow I've never seen worse taste on this board
>Spiderland is a 6
>ITCOCK is a 6
>Has never heard Remain In Light
>Untrue is a 10
>all these low stgstv scores
I want neo /mu/ to leave
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea - 10/10
Spirit, They're Gone, Spirit, They've Vanished - 10/10
Kid A - 10/10
Spiderland - I haven't listened to it, and I'm ashamed to say that.
Loveless - 9/10
Untrue - Haven't listened.
Remain In Light - 8/10
In the Court of the Crimson King - 9/10
Lift Yr Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven - 9/10
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy - 5/10
Exmilitary - 9/10
American Football - Haven't listened.
>>61122176
the low scores are not wrong
>>61121745
>spiderland & American football both 6
are you fucking kidding?
>>61121871
nice meme but American Football, Exmilitary and STGSTV are they only objectively bad albums on the chart
>>61122186
Check out Spiderland and American football. They both took a while to grow on me but they're amazing records
Since when did Spirit They've Gone and Exmilitary replace Merriweather Post Pavilion and The Money Store?
>>61122193
ikr seems way high for two seriously dull albums
>ITAOTS
6.5
>STGSTV
8
>Kid A
8.5
>Spiderland
4
>Loveless
4
>Untrue
I have literally never heard this
>Remain in Light
8
>ITCOTKC
7.5 (overrated, not sure why anybody would listen to this over Red or Discipline)
>Skinny Fists
6
>MBDTF
1
>Exmilitary
1
>American Football
2
>>61121132
honestly a lot of /mu/-core is pretty good besides a few duds
I like to overrate
>>61122662
Loveless is a 1? Really?
>>61122434
Real /mu/core:
ITAOTS
OKC/Kid A
MPP
MBDTF
Loveless
ITCOTCK
maybe Lift yr Skinny Fists.
As good as RIL is it's not /mu/core. Everything else on there is faddish.
>giving meme gripes anything above 2
/mu/'s become such shit
my 2 cents
objectivity coming through
REAL OBJECTIVITY coming through
They're all better than the average album for sure but some land harder than others.
>>61123910
>face palm
>>61122863
what can i say, i fucking hate shoegaze
>>61121358
>>boring as sin
or i just don't really care all that much about any of those 12 albums. i do like spiderland a lot though.
>>61122062
Not my fault that they are shit, and other acclaimed albums could easily replace them to have a perfect selection of god tier entry level albums.
>MBDTF
Change it to madvilliany, Illmatic, or 36 chambers.
>Untrue
Change it to SAW I or MHTRTC
>American Football
Emo is a pretty shit genre inherently so you could either remove it completely or change it to Pinkerton, or another critically acclaimed shoegaze album like souvlaki.
Prove me wrong.
You can't because you know I'm right.
>>61123960
What don't you like about shoegaze? And what are you favourite genres?
>>61123986
>shoegaze
>good
>ever
Objective facts comin thru
>>61121132
>mfw I've never listened to any of those albmus
>>61124025
It's emo 2.0. Emo actually doesn't need to exist when shoegaze does everything it does but better.
>>61124043
why are you here
h
y
a
r
e
y
o
u
h
e
r
e
>ITAOTS
Overrated as fuck/10
>Spirit
eh
>Kid A
I used to really like this, now I think it's kind of boring
>Spiderland
Very good, should listen to it more
>Loveless
Overrated
>Untrue
Haven't listened though I want to
>Remain in Light
First few tracks are their best material, the rest is boring
>In the Court of the Crimson King
Probably the most technically 'proficient' album here. It's a classic, really.
>Lift Yr
Listened to it once or twice, it works as decent background music
>kanye/dg
Sorry I don't listen to memerap
>American Football
I won't bother listening to this.
>>61124002
i don't know, i guess i'm not a fan of the hazy pedal, drone and dense kind of stuff
i like anything psychedelic mostly, le weird avant-garde shit like captain beefheart, TVU
are the rest of them worth hearing?
>>61124313
also, anything by the Elephant 6
This is mine using scaruffi's rating system.
The following albums are the pinnacle of their respective genre:
Loveless
Skinny Fists (2nd wave)
Spiderland (1st wave)
ITCOTCK
If you are honestly giving these albums bad scores than you don't even appreciate that kind of music in the first place.
All the other albums are at least a 6
>>61124403
5 isn't 'garbage' by his standards, it's a mediocre album.
5 is the average score for a music piece. If something gets a 6, it means it's better than average.
>>61124468
AF are the pinnacle of emo.
>>61124317
yeah kid a, but im bias as a radiohead fan
>>61121985
ITAOTS - 8
STGSTV - 5.5
Kid A - 7
Spiderland - 8
Loveless - 4
Untrue - 5
Remain in Light - 5
ITCOTCK - 10
Lift Your Skinny Fists - 9
MBDTF - 10
Exmilitary - 6.5
American Football - 5
i would say they all fit the closest definition of "objectively" good but not stuff i enjoy, and certainly overrated.
>>61123836
nice
>>61124621
i was like "omg marry me" until i saw the zero to american football.
you need to listen to it again i guess, it's that good.
How to spot faggots: everyone who rates American football below 6
>ITAOTS
9/10
>Spirit They're Gone...
haven't listened/10
>Kid A
8/10
>Spideland
8/10
>Loveless
7/10
>Untrue
6/10
>Remain in Light
7/10
>ITCOKC
5/10
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
7/10
>MBDTF
3/10
>Exmilitary
7/10
>American Football
8/10
>>61121580
You left Spiderland out.
am I too liberal or shit taste?
>>61124711
but only 19 years old men unsure about their sexual orientation like emo
Aeroplane: 9
Spirit: Haven't listened; can't say
Kid A: 5. Could never get through it, but it didn't ever seem atrocious
Loveless: Can't say
Untrue: 6
Remain in Light: 6
Crimson: 10. One of my favorite albums ever
Skinny fists: 7
Kanye: 4
Meme grips: 6
Football: 7
>>61122434
Aeroplane- 8/10
RIL- 7/10
Kid A- 8/10
Spiderland- 5/10
Loveless- 6/10
MPP- 10/10
Pet Sounds- 8/10
SFTB- don't know enough, won't comment on what I don't know
MBDTF- 5/10
TMS- 7/10
TMR- also don't know much
sorry /mu/, you know its true
>>61124283
>>61124188
>>61122431
Only acceptable ratings
>>61124283
>>61126101
My bad. Didn't mean to tag you.
Please give LYSTFAH a few more listens before you reenter this thread. Thanks.
>ITAOTS
6/10
>Spirit They're Gone...
8/10
>Kid A
7/10
>Spideland
8/10
>Loveless
6/10
>Untrue
5/10
>Remain in Light
7/10
>ITCOKC
8/10
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
7/10
>MBDTF
5/10
>Exmilitary
8/10
>American Football
5/10
6
haven't listened
haven't listened
9
haven't listened
4
6
9
6
6
8
haven't listened
>>61124706
>retarded frog posters like emo
kek. Makes a lot of sense.
>>61121132
>ITAOTS
5
>STGSTV
Listened only once, bad memories but i was sick and barely gave it attention
>Kid A
Never listened to
>Spiderlad
8
>Loveless
8
>Untrue
7
>RiL
Never listened to
>Court
9
>MBDTF
Never listened to, would probably not like it desu
>Deaf grapes
6 maybe idk
>American football
6.5
The Death Grips albums are the only shit albums on either chart lets be honest
In order: 9, 8.5, 7.5, 7, 7.5, 7, 5.5, 7, 9, 6.5, 3, 7
>>61126354
Made it easier to read
>ITAOTS
9
>STGSTV
8.5
>Kid A
7.5
>Spiderlad
7
>Loveless
7.5
>Untrue
7
>RiL
5.5
>ITCoTCK
7
>MBDTF
6.5
>Death Grips
3
>American football
7
>>61126425
Oh and
>LYSF
9
>>61122434
NMH - 9/10
Talking Heads - 5/10
Radiohead - 7/10
Slint - 8/10
Mbv - 6/10
Anco -Don´t listen to garbage f a m
TBB - 4/10
Swans - 7
GYBE - 6 (F# A# is better)
Kanye - 2/10
DG - 8/10 (Exmilitary way better)
le trout album of patrish - Lusty/10
>>61121132
>ITAOTS
7/10
>STGSTV
8/10
>Kid A
6/10
>Spiderland
9/10
>Loveless
7/10
>Untrue
6/10
>Remain In Light
8/10
>ITCOTCK
7/10
>LYSF
7/10
>MBDTF
6/10
>Ex Military
6/10
>American Football
6/10
Loveless and Spiderland are 10s, the rest are under 7
>>61121139
ITAOTS: 8
STGSTV: 5
Kid A: 6
Spiderland: 7
Loveless: 7
Untrue: 6
Remain in Light: 5
ITCOTCK: 6
LYSF: 8.5
MBDTF: 7
XM: 6
AF: 5
>>61122434
ITAOTS - 5/10
RiL - 3/10
Kid A - 3/10
Loveless - 2/10
MPP - 1/10
Pet Sounds - 6/10
SftB - 1/10
LYSF - 3/10
MBDTF - 7/10
TMS - 10/10
TMR - 0/10
>>61122369
good taste senpai
>>61121132
Ask a 40 year old man anything
STGSTV isn't /mu/core btw
The correct chart. American Football is trash, shouldn't even be on here.
>>61121871
You're a fucking idiot
Shittiest thread I've seen in a while. Good job you fucking idiots.
this thread embodies the sewage that is /mu/
>>61121132
ITAOTS - 9/10
STGSTV - 6.5/10
Kid A - 8/10
Spiderland - 10/10
Loveless - 9/10
Untrue - Never listened.
Remain in Light - 6/10
ITCOTCK - Never listened.
Lift Your Skinny Fists - 9/10
MBDTF - No interest in hip hop.
Exmilitary - See above.
American Football - 5/10
>>61121302
Thanks for letting us know which color meant which
insult my objectively superior taste
>>61121132
I haven't been on /mu/ in 4 years. How did so much dogshit get added to /mu/core?
American Football? Death Grips? Are you guys fucking kidding me.
>>61122071
>ITAOTS never heard
Holy shit. Has it stopped being a meme? Can I like it again?
in the aeroplane over the sea
8/10
Spirit They're Gone, Spirit
4/10
Kid A
6/10
Spiderland
7/10
Loveless
6/10
Untrue
4/10
lift yr skinny fists
7/10
My beautiful dark
5/10
exmilitary
7/10
You can tell who is white and or smokes cigarettes by the scores they give lmao.
>tfw the only one left who likes American Football
reminder that if MBDTF isn't a 10/10 on your list your list is wrong.
>>61129604
Never meant and honestly are so good, but they're an exception.
>>61130168
Every song sounds the same wtf are you talking about?
>>61129604
Oh look. Another faggot frog poster cares about emo. This is just too funny.
Is it a meme to dislike LYSF now?
Sure, F#A# is better, but LYSF is still by all means a fantastic album.
>>61122434
I haven't heard most of these albums here. I should probably get on that. Only albums here I have listened to in full here are MBDTF and TMS...
ITAOTS: 10
STGSTV: 10
Kid A: 8
Spiderland: 5
Loveless: 5
Untrue: 6
Remain In Light: 8.5
havent heard ITCOTCK yet
LYSF: 8
MBDTF: 4
ExMil: 6
Americ anFootball: 9
>ITAOTS
9
>STGSTV
6
>KID A
FUCKING 0
>SPIDERLAND
HAVEN'T LISTENED
>LOVELESS
7
>UNTRUE
8
>REMAIN IN LIGHT
HAVEN't LISTENED
>ITCOCK
8
>SKINNY FISTS
8
>MBDTF
9
>EXMILITARY
9
>AMERICAN FOOTBALL
9
>>61122662
this might be the worst opinion itt
>ITAOTS
7.5/10
>Spirit They're Gone...
Not heard because MPP is the worst album I've ever sat through. I hear it's more noisy and raw though, so I might get around to it one day.
>Kid A
7/10
>Spideland
3/10
>Loveless
4.5/10
>Untrue
6/10
>Remain in Light
6/10
>ITCOKC
8/10
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
8/10
>MBDTF
5/10
>Exmilitary
5.5/10
>American Football
1.5/10
>ITAOTS
10/10
>Spirit They're Gone...
9.5/10
>Kid A
8/10
>Spideland
8.5/10
>Loveless
8/10
>Untrue
6/10
>Remain in Light
7/10
>ITCOKC
8/10
>Lift Yr. Skinny Fists...
8/10
>MBDTF
6.5/10
>Exmilitary
6/10
>American Football
6.5/10
>>61132462
I like it, but definitely listen to ITCOTCK senpai
>>61121613
good rate. listen to king crimson though. great stuff you're missing out
>>61122264
I've never seen worse taste
>All these people giving STGSTV the lowest score
I guarantee you these are people who hate Animal Collective because
>meme band
Or some shitty argument like that
>>61121613
>passing lysf off as a meme
when/where
>>61134052
lmao is this the only defense AnCo fags have for their shit taste?
yeah, fuck you, couldn't be bothered to listen to the rest
in my opinion
>>61121132
>implying I've listened to them all
>meme
6
>spirit
7
>kid a
5
>spidermeme
9
>loveless
8
>untrue
5
>remain in light
8
>in the cock
8, possibly 9
>skinny fists
7
>mbdtf
8
>exmilitary
haven't listened
>murcan football
7
>>61135797
>there are plebs this bad posting on /mu/ daily
>>61121132
8,10,10,9,8,9
7,6,9,5,5,6
>ITAOTS
6.5/10
>STGSTV
7/10
>Kid A
7.5/10
>Spiderland
9/10
>Loveless
9/10
>Untrue
7/10
>Remain in Light
8.5/10
>ITCOTCK
8/10
>LYSFLATH
7.5/10
>MBDTF
5/10
>Exmilitary
5.5/10
>American Football
5/10
>>61121132
Holy fucking pleb
>ITAOTS
8
>STGSTV
7
>Kid A
9
>Spiderland
9.5
>Loveless
6
>Untrue
5.5
>RIL
8
>ITCOCK
8.5
>GYBE
3
>MBDTF
7.5
>ExMil
7.5
>American Football
3
>>61122434
Per Sounds is easily one of the most talked about album on this board. Needs to be on the chart
>all those low scores for STGSTV
Have we reached the point where /mu/ is made up of teenagers with underdeveloped taste who can't get past the first song on an album?
>>61135938
>you HAVE to listen to ALL meme albums
