[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
>mfw someone says that music is subjective
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music

Thread replies: 132
Thread images: 16
File: image.jpg (13 KB, 236x236) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
13 KB, 236x236
>mfw someone says that music is subjective
>>
who's that ugly mug?
>>
>>60854053
me irl
ask anything
>>
File: image.png (108 KB, 236x236) Image search: [Google]
image.png
108 KB, 236x236
>mfw someone says that music is objective
>>
>>60854033
>cropped off her tits

thefuck is WRONG WITH YOU
>>
>>60854064
what's life like having such a pig nose
>>
>>60854088
wait what
>>
>>60854088
post 'em
>>
>>60854166
i steal money from my parents
>>
>>60854088
you just can't say that and not post 'em, man
>>
File: 1448491935279.gif (557 KB, 214x188) Image search: [Google]
1448491935279.gif
557 KB, 214x188
>>60854033
>>60854166
>>60854088
>>
>>60854341
BIG
>>
>>60854446
MEATY
>>
>>60854491
FLOPPY
>>
>>60854503
TITS
>>
>>60854341
delete this
-k
>>
File: raccoon5.gif (13 KB, 139x110) Image search: [Google]
raccoon5.gif
13 KB, 139x110
"Music taste is subjective" is justified because we see that different people have different preferences.

"Music taste is objective" is, until somebody comes up with an objective way of evaluating it, completely unfounded bullshit.
>>
>>60854033
boy this chick is fucking ugly
>>
>>60854660
cocksucker detected
>>
File: farmerdog.jpg (657 KB, 813x1024) Image search: [Google]
farmerdog.jpg
657 KB, 813x1024
>mfw someone doesn't realize the course of music and art are shaped by business mogels and the elite tastemakers and not by traditional merits of "good and bad"
>>
>>60854675
yeah she's pretty fuckin hot
>>
>>60854564
ok sorry
>>
>>60854660
shut up
>>
>>60854745
thanks
-k
>>
>>60854643
>>60854033
Golden Ratio
>>
File: 1449429629333.jpg (54 KB, 299x903) Image search: [Google]
1449429629333.jpg
54 KB, 299x903
I like music
>>
>>60855007
delete this
>>
>>60855156
no
>>
>>60855234
why
>>
>>60855260
because i have no gf
>>
>>60855315
iktf
>>
>>60855555
>>
>>60855566
yo fuck
>>
>>60855566
dubs
>>
>>60855007
who is this semen demon
>>
File: nope.gif (1021 KB, 200x147) Image search: [Google]
nope.gif
1021 KB, 200x147
>>60854033
>oh look it's THIS thread again.
>>
>>60855643
kayla
>>
goddess
>>
>>60855777
OF /MU/
>>
>>60855684
>kayla
i need more info dud
>>
>>60855861
use the archive you dingus
>>
>>60855861
https://rbt.asia/mu/thread/S60678820
>>
>>60855891
>>60856136
thx ily <3
>>
File: 1449033430968.png (855 KB, 600x600) Image search: [Google]
1449033430968.png
855 KB, 600x600
stop this cyber misogyny
>>
>>60856187
qt <3
>>
File: 1394513194130.jpg (66 KB, 474x595) Image search: [Google]
1394513194130.jpg
66 KB, 474x595
cool thread
>>
>>60856691
thanks familia glad you like it
>>
File: image.jpg (57 KB, 576x800) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
57 KB, 576x800
what's going on here
>>
>>60856785
cyberbullying
>>
File: owned.jpg (68 KB, 474x595) Image search: [Google]
owned.jpg
68 KB, 474x595
>>60856735
it was a trick
>>
>>60856860
fuck you
>>
>>60854071

mf
>>
>>60856999
trips
>>
this what she look like without out make up
>>
>>60857196
delete this
>>
>>60857196
lmao
>>
>>60857196
fake
>>
>>60857264
nah senpai it real
>>
>>60857196
>tfw kayla fucked drake's shit up to unfuck her's

literally a witch
>>
>>60857281
to be fair, she's very young and fatter in that pic

there's a vine of her without makeup in which she looks pretty cute desu
>>
>>60854643
There's a difference between taste and opinion.
>>
>>60854643
>plebs actually believe this
>>
File: image.jpg (63 KB, 596x609) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
63 KB, 596x609
>>60857196
even taytay was an uggo when young
>>
where's the folderfag

dump some rare pics
>>
>>60857196
lel that's not her

I have pics of her with no makeup on but I ain't posting them. She looks completely different without makeup.
>>
>>60857868
is she cute
>>
>>60857863
I deleted it all :^)
>>
>>60857887
ehhhh
>>
>>60857953
post a pic and delete it real quick no one's gonna see it
>>
>>60857335
Yes, but the same argument applies.

>>60857505
Give me a reason not to.
>>
Yes you fucking autist, It's an entertainment medium and an art form, all of which are entirely subjective.
>>
>>60858021
lmao get a load of this guy everybody
>>
File: yesplease.jpg (42 KB, 375x500) Image search: [Google]
yesplease.jpg
42 KB, 375x500
>>60857505
Everyone has different genetic predispositions to their psychology, different experiences growing up, different genres they were exposed to while growing up, some people like things because of the instrument they play, it depends on who your friends like and listen to, it depends on how old you are, what current mood your in and what setting your listening to music in. It is literally one of the most subjective things there is and anyone calling music taste objective should probably sit in their garage with their car running.
>>
>>60857505
Oh and don't forget culture and sub-culture.
>>
mothafucka we rollin
>>
>>60857505
In fact, being unable to realize that music taste is subjective is something that people usually grow out of around the age of 20.
>>
>>60858251
and grow back into in their 30s
>>
>>60858409
Oh so you just start forgetting all these factors?>>60858084
>>
>>60857976
they're all on my PC and I'm on my phone rn so yeah get fucked
>>
>>60854033
I fucking hate that shit
>>
>>60858513
:^(
>>
Art is subjective, but music isn't art and should be treated like an objective science.
>>
>>60858605
>music isn't art
source on that
>>
>>60858637
Me. I just said it, and I'm saying it again, right now: music isn't art.
>>
>>60858654
Music is art. There, I just said it. I'll say it again. Music is art.

Whatchu gonna do about it faggot?
>>
>>60858707
You're a fucking idiot, then. Good luck living life as a total manchild.
>>
>>60858810
You're a fucking idiot, then. Good luck living life as a total manchild.
>>
>>60858836
Wow!
>>
>>60858877
Wow!
>>
>>60858810
>Music isn't art

Are you fucking retarded anon?
>>
>>60858921
Music isn't subjective - there are set rules and standards that all musicians should abide by. When these rules are broken, they are disrespecting culture and poisoning our ears.
>>
I am so fucking sick of seeing the same threads every day, why don't you think of your own fucking types of threads you embarrassing uncreative shits. This statement has been made thousands of times you useless waifu posting cunt
>>
>>60858988
So music is a form of artistic expression.
>>
>>60859045
meme
>>
>>60858988
Lmfao that's wrong. So someone who creates a beat that are somehow outside of these invisible set standards it means it's no longer music?
>>
>>60857868
WHERE ARE DEM PICS
>>
>>60859631
WHERE
>>
>>60857868
that's obviously her

same nose, same eyes, etc
>>
People think music is subjective because different music can be pleasing to the ear of different people. Anyone can make music that sounds pleasing to the ear given the time, however, only some can go about doing that in alternate ways. Music that goes about achieving a level of feeling through alternate and more complex ways to diversify itself from other songs/genres is objectively better.
>>
>>60860804
not at all

that's not her

you're wrong and I'm right
>>
>>60860987
we know it's you, kayla

don't worry tho, you're cute now <3
>>
good thread
>>
>>60854823

OK, which is better, the white album or sonatas and interludes for prepared piano?

Remember, you have to demonstrate it using nothing but one single ratio.
>>
>>60858988

Some offenders who have unambiguously broken the "rules":

Bach
Beethoven
Debussy
Duke Ellington
Charlie Parker
The Beatles
>>
>>60860907

Saying that more complex music is better music is a subjective opinion.

You happen to prefer complexity, which is hardly a defined concept in music anyways, that doesn't make it objectively anything.

Also, by your own logic Milton Babbitt is objectively the best music ever created, I fucking dare you to listen to only Babbitt for even a single day without changing your mind.
>>
music is objective

taste is not
>>
>>60862424

Did you happen to see that recent study which demonstrated how people who subscribe to pseudo philosophical sayings have a much lower intelligence on average?

I'm sure you think you're saying something here, but you aren't.
>>
>>60862424
objectively wrong
>>
>>60862529
stop projecting
>>
>>60862561

Then elaborate on your stoned drivel. How is "music" objective?
>>
File: 1429853201111.jpg (494 KB, 650x650) Image search: [Google]
1429853201111.jpg
494 KB, 650x650
this is now a freeposting thread
>>
>>60862665
OEEEPLXMDOEPWPWPS
¥¥¥¥\£\£\¥|={=]=_¥'£££&k'mkkdkskkkaoKkhbbhibhh^?89
>>
>>60862561

Did you happen to see the recent dictionary which gave a definition of the word "projecting"?

You might find it useful.
>>
>>60854033
What makes music good?
>>
>>60861542
She looks nothing like the girl in the pic for fuck's sake you stupid faggot I'm going to fucking kill you if you don't stop saying retarded shit fuck you
>>
>>60862378
Think about what I said. It has to deliver something that is pleasing through its complexity. A better word to use here would be diversity tbqh tho. For example, godspeed grew in popularity because of the way they differ from other lesser known progressive rock bands because it differs in length, content, etc. yet is still pleasing for a certain mood.
>>
File: image.jpg (96 KB, 1377x683) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
96 KB, 1377x683
>>60863087
wew
>>
>>60863607
damn...
>>
>>60863043
thats actually a pretty good question for me its probably just like really tasty riffs they make me feel good dude not op though
>>
>>60863607
lol
>>
>>60863504

You are trying to argue for the existence of objectivity and your argument is effectively that some people like things a certain way?

Most members of godspeed would literally punch you in the face for calling them "progressive rock", BTW. Also, "differs in length, content, etc..."? Did you know that every single song in recorded history differs in "content" because of what the word content means.

You honestly couldn't be saying "it's objectively better because I prefer it" any harder, it's embarrassing.

It just seems obvious to you by virtue of the fact that you aren't actually thinking the issue through. You are universalizing your own tastes, and assuming that the things you like in music are objectively the right things to like. Godspeed are memed like crazy on here, but they are overall a very niche band for people with specific interests, that makes them neither better or worse objectively.
>>
>>60863504

Unless you care to try to answer the question of why it "has" to do that, you are severely out of your depths right now.
>>
>>60863504

>godspeed are loved for how long the songs are, and what the songs consist of

Do you honestly think you're a smart person?
>>
fuck kayla
>>
>>60865393
rude
>>
>>60865443
He was stating his wishes. Fuck kayla, indeed.
>>
It is. What you're ignoring is the fact that an opinion can be wrong.
>>
>>60866944

What you're ignoring is that there is no way to determine which opinions are right and wrong.

You are welcome to present one, but you can't, because if you could you would be the toast of the academic world and be flown around to conferences and get a book deal. It would be a huge fucking deal if you actually had anything to back your claim up with, not just in the realm of musicology, but philosophy generally.

In reality, you are overestimating your own faculties on a Laotian handkerchief embroidery board, which is slightly less impressive.
>>
>>60860907
No one has ever said a painting is the best painting. That's because there is none that can be called the best. You walk into a Modern Art museum and see a painting and dismiss it. The thing with the painting is that there are different people who are going to walk by. They know things that you don't and were previously exposed to different paintings. Different life experiences, different emotions. Some people might be taken aback with how great the painting is. The painting could be anything. This analogy is pretty embarrassing lmao.

different art forms and all that etc. but, doesn't that make sense? I'm sure someone who isn't depressed or recently got over depression would love Elliott Smith as much as me.
>>
Is music subjective or objective?

Is your opinion about the matter subjective or objective?

You know what's objective?
We've been having these threads for fucking years and you're all still wankers.
Kill yourselves.
>>
>>60863607
what a ghoulish fucking cunt

her dad must be sad
>>
File: vonnegut.png (2 MB, 1622x1140) Image search: [Google]
vonnegut.png
2 MB, 1622x1140
WHERE WERE U WHEN SOME KID FROM NY MADE THE HOTTEST SPACE CLUB BANGER OF ALL TIME???!!

https://soundcloud.com/yung_vonnegut/planet-x
Thread replies: 132
Thread images: 16

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.