Sgt. Pepper > Pet Sounds
but
Wouldn't it be Nice > all of Sgt. Pepper
discuss
>>60479753
Not even the best track
A Day in the Life >>> All of Pet Sounds > Rest of Sgt. Peppers
desu senpai
>>60479753
Pet Sounds > anything the Beatles did
Wouldn't it be nice isn't even the best track
Let It Be > *
>>60479796
>Pet Sounds > anything the Beatles did
This.
sorry, wrong party, do you plebs know where the good album party is at?
>>60480041
The Velvet Underground & Nico > Pet Sounds > Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
highway 61 revisited > pet sounds/Sgt pepper
>>60479753
Pet Sounds > Sgt. Pepper
BUT
A Day in the Life > all of Pet Sounds (except God Only Knows)
>>60480126
Dylan is a better lyricist than Wilson/Asher and McCartney/Lennon but Wilson is a much better composer than Dylan.
Pet sounds is better than Sgt. Pepper
But Abbey Road and Revolver are both better than Pet Sounds
>>60480041
You showed up at the right place, senpai. You might want to change your costume though...
>>60480170
>Abbey Road
>better than Sgt. Pepper and Pet Sounds
>>60480195
It's better than Sgt. Pepper, but not Pet Sounds
>>60480195
"Abbey Road isn't the GOAT Beatles album" is the ultimate Beatles meme
>>60480237
The second half is a stellar medley, but the fist half is just garbage they all got out before their solo careers started.
There isn't a single decent song on the first half.
>>60479753
MBDTF>Petsounds>>>>>>>Beatles
>>60480286
0/10 bait senpai.
>>60479753
SOMETIMES
I
FEEL
VERY
SAD
>>60480286
TPAB>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>sgt pepper>pet sounds>MBDTF
>>60480264
>come together
>something
>oh! Darling!
Octopus's Garden is cute for the ringo element and I think I want You is great but I can see why some may not like it
I'll give you Maxwell's Silver Hammer, but to me it's such a distinctly Beatles song that I love it
>>60480323
Know that the dust has settled we can all agree TPAB is meme trash right
I had friends on Facebook unironically writing multiple paragraphs about how it was the greatest album of all time
>>60480041
>>60480126
>>60480170
>>60480286
lol
>>60479753
beatles had better singles and shit but never made something that works as good as an album as pet sounds, sgt.peppers is the only one that comes close, but i feel like they are really different albums and comparing them makes no sense.
maybe something like pet sounds vs abbey road would be more appropiate but still, nah.
pet sounds would win anyways
pet sounds > sgt.peppers >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> shit >>> abbey road
>>60479753
>Wouldn't it be Nice > all of Sgt. Pepper
top kek, mate
>>60480374
>>60480427
epic gif bro
>>60480491
/thread
>still talking about those two fossils when the superior album has already been made
kek'in hard
>>60480566
what the hell is that mess?
>>60480612
>one direction tago mago
what the hell is that mess?
>>60480639
the greatest album of the new generation
>>60480684
but that would be >>60480566
you dummy, dont you see the dubs?
>>60479753
We all have opinions that come up when listening to music, very good.
>>60480612
>>60480566
>>60480041
Banana > Sgt Pepper > Pet Sounds
but
Beatles > TVU > Bitch Boys
>>60480863
>Banana
made me laugh for some reason
>>60480003
Only contrarians think this
What's with all the talk about Pet Sounds, Sgt Pepper's and TVU&N on /mu/ recently? Can we just accept they're all influential and wonderful albums and move the fuck on?
>>60479753
Just picked up a copy of Surf's Up at the local thrift store for 99 cents. Perfect condition. Today was a good day
>>60481390
>Can we just accept they're all influential and wonderful albums and move the fuck on?
nope
3 albums enter
1 album leave
Let's not forget that this all started after Brian heard Rubber Soul. (Most likely the U.S. version)
>>60480041
Most overrated album of all time.
>>60480612
>2015
>people unironically listening to Radiohead.
ishiggydiggy
>>60481536
>you know what website you're on?
>>60480566
This is accurate
>>60481582
Appearently one inhibited by a bunch of pretentious faggots without ears.
I give Pet Sounds and Smile Sessions a listen and really liked them.
At what point, if any, do their albums start getting bad?
>>60481688
The further out you get from that point in either direction, they decline in quality. They don't have much that's totally irredeemable.
>>60481688
after smiley smile
sunflower has its moments but thats it tbqh
>>60481688
They go back an forth. Surf's up has some brilliant tracks.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46IQu0yuJzU
