Musicians that has no clear magnum opus/frequently debated
>sufjan stevens
>st. vincent
>neutral milk hotel
>anco
>bj(umlaut)rk
>arcade fire
lol i just listed random /mu/core, seriously though, they're all legit unclear
>inb4 cause they're all shit
>>60455038
NMH is obviously ITAOTS, are you kidding me? I mean, On Avery Island is good, but come on.
Arcade Fire's is probably Funeral, idk enough about the band to know for sure but I thought that was widely considered their best.
the rest I agree
all of them
Pink Floyd
>>60455097
ye but on avery island has that certain feel to it, if OAI was fewer poppy songs,then it'd probably on par with itaots
>>60455097
the suburbs and neon bible are solid albums tho
>the Paper Chase
>Ween
>Black Sabbath
>>60455097
I've heard most people say Funeral of Neon Bible
>>60455038
oh and anco
>>60455038
NMH and Arcade Fire have already had their magnum opus. The rest are good though.
I guess some other ones could be
>Joanna Newsom
>Death Grips
>David Bowie
>Swans
>>60455177
Yeah Bowie is tough. My favorite is probably Ziggy, but I love too many of them to choose an opus
I would argue that Sufjan's opus is usually argued to either be Illinois or the Age of Adz, at least on this board.
>>60455038
they actually are all shit
>not putting The Beatles on here
>>60455038
>sufjan stevens
Illinois
>st. vincent
Who gives a shit?
>neutral milk hotel
Obviously Aeroplane.
>anco
Merriweather
>bj(umlaut)rk
Homogenic
>arcade fire
The Suburbs
>>60455122
>pink floyd
Dark Side of the Moon
>>60455149
>the Paper Chase
Never heard about
>Ween
The Mollusk
>Black Sabbath
Paranoid
>>60455177
>Joanna Newsom
Ys
>Death Grips
The Money Store
>David Bowie
Ziggy
>Swans
Soundtracks for the Blind
>>60455315
>The Beatles
Sgt. Pepper
You fuckers need to try harder.
>>60455339
>>anco
>Merriweather
triggered
>>60455339
>>Ween
>The Mollusk
>>Black Sabbath
>Paranoid
See, I love both of those albums, but my favorites are The Pod, and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath
>>60455374
Even if it's not your favorite, you have to agree it's the one people will remember them by.
>>60455392
>my favorites are The Pod, and Sabbath Bloody Sabbath
This is completely irrelevant. Most of the albums I listed aren't my favorite of said artist, it's just the obvious choice for this.
>>60455420
Granted, but in that case I would have to say that Ween's would be chocolate and cheese
>>60455339
just because you can choose a favorite doesnt mean thats a magnum opus. this thread is about bands/artists with multiple critically acclaimed albums where not one can be chosen as better.
>>60455553
>>60455420
>Most of the albums I listed aren't my favorite of said artist
>>60455614
well if you think those are the magnum opus of each said artist well
>Joanna Newsom
Ys and Have One on Me are debatable
>Death Grips
The Money Store, NLDW, Jenny Death, Exmilitary are all debatable
>Bowie
Hunky Dory and Ziggy are debatable
>Swans
Children of God, SFTB, To Be Kind, and The Seer are debatable
>>60455149
i dont agree with paper chase or ween
>The Paper Chase
Now You Are One Of Us
>Ween
The Mollusk
but Black Sabbath is debatable for sure
>>60455339
>Not Revolver
>Not Low, Heroes, or Station to Station
>Not STGSTV
>Not Master of Reality
ok
>>60455688
>To Be Kind
Get the fuck out of here.
>>60455759
>implying any of those gets as frequently thrown around as my examples
People need to stop stating their personal favorites as objective fact. For this you literally just need to look at what goes down with the normies.
>>60456001
triggered
