Trout Mask Replica shouldn't be on the /mu/core chart because the chart is supposed to be a starting point for your average pleb who just discovered /mu/.
TMR is too inacessible for someone who hasn't listened to much music.
What album should replace it? The Glow? ITCOTCK
>>60401182
>ITCOTCK
They'll just skip moonchild
>>60401182
>the chart is supposed to be a starting point for your average pleb who just discovered /mu/
>>60401182
your dumb
a
I could get my two year old nephew to touch random piano keys, transcribe it to guitar and horns in differen pieces, spam it on /mu/ and fake a good pitchfork reviews and people here would honestly think that they were intelligent for liking it and people who don't like it would be labeled as stupid.
>Kid A over OKC
>Trout Mask over any of KC's discography
>>60402166
You have awful taste and need to go back to Reddit (and then kill yourself)
>>60401182
I actually kind of agree.
Safe as Milk would be the better entry point. By that same token, we should replace Kid A with OK Computer.
>>60402130
Go back to the Beefheart thread and complain there, you pleb.
>>60402209
You know what's harder than composing music that sounds bad? Composing music that sounds good.
>anco
>kanye
>meme rap
>no the microphones
>no king crimson
>no americ anfootball
Fucking pleb chart
>>60401182
It's not supposed to be plebcore. /mu/core are the albums that get discussed ad nauseum. Fuck the plebs. Let them fend for themselves.
>>60401182
TMR is /mu/'s boku no pico
how is this so hard to understand?
>>60402275
Anco and Kanye are crucial /mu/core, unlike your whiny betarock
so that normie tier kanye album is official /mu/core just because the fucking pitchfork rating?
>>60401182
You must be new..
1) /mu/core are albums that are constantly posted on /mu/, not necessarily entry level ones.
2) That's one chart out of hundreds, there is no 'the /mu/core chart'.
3) Many of the charts DO have The Glow & ITCOTCK on them, as they already are /mu/core.
ITCOTCK belongs on that list
>>60402130
Except they played that shit perfectly live
no, its supposed to be a list of albums mu cant shut the fuck up about, in order to demonstrate how repetitive and homogenous this board and its tastes are
My favorite part about this picture is that the original has 'having a hundred fucking different ones that some people on here like has nothing to do with the concept'
and yet every time I see it posted, it's a new slightly altered version to include an album the person who posted it likes
>>60402684
the pic on the OP is the most accurate version of the chart i've seen
the old official one has Hospice, which half of the board hates by now
>>60402684
Weird,the albums we talk about the most change over time.
How unnatural.
>>60402232
Except that TMR sounds amazing after you understand it you shitlord
>>60401182
the glow for sure
If anything Phil gets on that chart I'm leaving
>No Can
>No Velvet Underground
Fuck you people.
>>60406429
I'd love to put Can on there, but they're not discussed enough honestly.
It'd also be a huge debate whether to put Tago Mago or Future Days on there.
>>60401182
revised version
can we please just gas everyone that doesn't like tmr
>>60407530
Stop posting this, Also, nice changing coltrane to davis you fucking pleb.
1. Desertshore is better
2. Not Davis' best
3. Ok. Not my favourite but understandable.
4. Good but not good enough for a top 12
5. literally who
6. literally who.
7. the early industrial stuff is better.
8. Not springsteens best
9. Not lou's best.
10. Good but nothing important.
11. Decent but nothing important
13. Not even Dylan top 3
>>60407561
Literally composed by a guy who didn't know anything about music and then transcribed to instruments. It turns out like shit and you faggots pretend you're higher beings because you like it because /mu/ and pitchfork told you to. It's really fucking hilarious actually.
>>60408563
You realise TMR is respected and treated as a masterpiece by any reputable person? Not saying that's a reason to like it, but it's hardly a unique choice for a favourite album. Go listen to C.uckye.
>>60408527
what is lou's best in ur opinion
what is dylan top 3 in ur onion
>>60407530
dadkek version*
>>60401254
is this the newest yamyam?
>>60401182
The chart isn't for people who haven't listened to any music. The chart is for people who have lurked here, and aren't familiar with the type of stuff discussed on this board.
>>60408653
>TMR is respected and treated as a masterpiece by any reputable person?
It was unique and new, it was not good. My mom literally could have composed the same song and she has no experience with making music or how it works.
>>60408728
its a meme from earlier this year
>>60408674
New York
Blonde on Blonde
Highway
John Wesley Harding
>>60408770
No she couldn't. You are proving you know nothing.
>>60408811
havent heard new york yet
blonde on blonde is GOAT-tier but havent heard other two
I think the perfect /mu/core chart would be:
>Loveless
>Giles Corey
>Kid A
>Spiderland
>MPP
>Pet Sounds
>LYSF
>Giles Corey
>American Football
>Deathconsciousness
>Giles Corey
RiL, TMS, and MBDTF are barely discussed. SftB and TMR are too inaccessible.
And of course:
>ITAOTS
>>60401182
I actually want Black Elvis/Lost In Space on this chart.
>>60408835
The guy literally didn't know anything about composing music or how it worked.
>>60408527
>Spacemen 3
>literally who
fuck off dude
>>60401182
Safe as Milk should replace it, that's a more plebby starting point for Beefheart.
>>60401182
Challenge: Create a definitive /mu/core listing, based on ubiquity on the board above all else, in 8 albums
>ITAOTS
>Kid A
>MPP
>Hospice
>The Money Store
>Loveless
>LYSF
>MBDTF
