Help me moo
Where would you place Adele and Amy Whinehouse ?
Newsom sounds like a dying goat, though.
>>60319063
Adele = ok
Amy = good
Julia Holter belongs in god
Move Joanna down
Move Julia up
>>60319120
juliafags pls go
St. Vincent should be under ok
FUCK
OFF
WAIFUTARDS
Reply to this post if you want the mods to force all Western pop threads into a general just like KPOP since its the same shit.
Can anyone name the God tier for a pleb like me (besides Bjork and Newsom)?
>>60319116
amy = GOD
Adele = good,
Jewberg = grimes = ok
Lavren = shitty
>>60319152
>>60319128
plebs pls go
>>60319171
>liking the greatest living songwriter under 40 over some hacky dream pop waifu makes me a pleb
ok kid
jesus christ you people have awful taste in female musicians
>>60319204
>doesn't post his taste
hmm, ok den
>>60319204
well my favorite female musician is ariel pink
>>60319128
>not liking Julia Holter
I saw her live last month and it was easily one of the best shows I've seen all year. She is an excellent singer and performer, her band also kills it.
You're probably a butthurt Joannafag who's disappointed that Divers was good at best and not a masterpiece like you wanted where as HYIMW was the masterpiece you wanted Divers to be.
>>60319226
don't samefag, it's sad
>>60319063
you have shit taste in female singers fool.
adele: below shit
amy: ok
>>60319232
christine lavin, nina hagen, tara cross, nicola hitchcock, anneke van giersbergen, mariee sioux, christina kubisch, ursola bogner, evi vine, suzanne vega, zoe boekbinder, gillian welch
>>60319247
I'm a huge Newsom fan and Divers is my personal favourite album from her.
>>60319189
You can argue songwriting abilities all day long but OP made a thread about vocals and Julia has a much better voice than Joanna.
>>60319247
Stop projecting, HYIMW was a 7. This "my waifu > your waifu" thing is pathetic
>>60319144
It's about singing dumbass
No one's even posting their pictures and there's a reason I didnt add memes like Sky or Charli
>>60319247
>HYIMW
>masterpiece
>sellout album
>masterpiece
kekerino
>>60319267
>Lavren
>not chaotic evil
>>60319298
But is it more patrician?
>>60319285
I've never wanted to shit on someones taste more. But I have no idea who any of those people are, and I have no interest in looking any of them up.
>>60319299
It's definitely an 8 at worst. I'd say Divers is a 6 to a 7.
>>60319301
HYIMW is hardly Julia selling out. I don't understand how you might think this. It is no poppier than the poppiest of tracks from LCS.
>>60319295
I'm sorry to hear that you are in denial.
>>60319332
you don't know who suzanne vega is, at the very least? get off my board retard
>>60319344
>I'm sorry to hear that you are in denial.
>>60319301
you're right man we need some titty pics in here, shit. It's been 30 replies in a thread about women musics I havent seen even ONE titty.
Who's top right?
>missing
>>60319365
Coincidentally that was my face when I read that Divers is his favorite Newsom release.
Where is Sufjan?
>>60319360
he's not >>60319232
>>60319353
>implying soofy belongs in there with all those disgusting women
get my husbando out of there u sicko
>>60319385
reddit-tier
>>60319360
You only need to know one Vega and he's a dude.
DAILY REMINDER GRIMES IS A GODDESS WITH A BEAUTIFUL VOICE
Art Angels is amazing fuck you op
>>60319408
Great post btw.
>>60319389
you don't know that
>>60319425
you too faggot
>>60319433
Thanks.
>>60319430
Yeah I do, I'm >>60319232
>>60319462
fuck off this bord then retard
>>60319506
rude
>>60319385
Why? It might be because it's new to me and I've listened to the other three literally hundreds of times, but I still don't think it's a weak release at all. Maybe not as spectacular as Ys, but definitely still a contender for her best; and I think you could competently argue for any one of her albums taking the top spot.
>>60319525
>>60319525
>>60319525
>>60319525
>>60319563
I never said it was weak. Just not as good as the others.
>>60319575
It's better than MEM
St Vinny has chops, she's just fucking pretentious.
>>60319631
[citation needed]
>>60319410
>need
neo-/mu/
Why are you guys so stubborn about music taste? You realize it's subjective right? I mean sure you can roughly rank a singers value by their range of pitch and tone but it seems like you guys think your opinions are infallible and jesus fuck it's pretentious.
>>60319631
She comes off as a try hard sometimes, but more often than not ahe seems like a genuine person.
>>60319575
>Just not as good as the others
Well that's what I mean by weak in this context. I think it's just as good as her other albums. Maybe you need to listen to it more, I wasn't super impressed on my first play through either, but that's also been true for me with every Joanna Newsom album.
>>60319660
yes genuinely pretentious
>>60319657
/mu/ is a place where people with mild opinions out-pretentious each other for fun and/or spite
>>60319611
Everyone hates on MEM (relatively to the other albums), but I really think it has a lot of her best songs (CCCC, PPP, Bridges and Balloons, etc), and the delivery on MEM and Ys won't ever be replicated so it's really valuable for that as well.
>Jonanne Newsom
Overrated. And Adele should be top tier. And Bjork shouldn't be on it if we want to consider debut in 21st century only, she had an album out in the 70s.
And thingy should be on here. Angel Olsons. Her voice is great and no it's not just because of the incredible breasts.
>>60319690
hella fucking epic
see >>60319642
>>60319657
Juliafags on suicide watch.
>>60319063
Liz Harris is great
>>60319708
MEM is one of my favorite albums but Divers is way better arranged and the songwriting is vastly more mature
>>60319721
hue
>>60319657
because when I am right and you are wrong you must be destroyed.
such is life
>>60319692
god that's fucking gay. Can't we just share music and discuss it at a rational level?
>>60319725
I literally don't know who julia is.
>>60319749
All her vocals are really soft and quiet though
I wish she'd do one song where she fucking wrecks her voice
>>60319760
Music taste is one of the most subjective things that exists.
>>60319692
yes
>>60319063
>no Joni
>>60319786
Julia Ecstatics. She made a great album this year.
>>60319786
>just share music and discuss it at a rational level
hahaha
So are they all supposed to be white?
>>60319850
I can't wait for some autistic /pol/tard to take this b8
>>60319874
great argument
Put Fiona on there you melon.
>>60319721
>Adele
She literally has NO range. And all of her music is about encountering men from her past. People like her because her lyrics are shallow and easy to empathize with.
>>60319892
b-but m-muh pop
>>60319846
God man it really sucks. 4chan has so much potential to be great without a faggy reddit points system, heavy moderation and open discussion yet just like /pol/ you guys seem to ruin it with a circlejerk that ends up being between two very similar viewpoints arguing. Don't any of you like blues and rock music?
>>60319813
yes, that's why I have to subjective my dingdong into your throat to prove that I am better than you.
>>60319892
She has a decent ranges and a well refined tone. Just because she's pop doesn't mean she sucks.
i just don't understand the appeal of adele. i really dig winehouse though
>>60319971
Her music is definitely boring, but adele does have a good voice. That's really difficult to argue from a technical standpoint.
>>60319926
You have no idea what you're talking about.
We're talking about primarily male topics on a primarily male music board, and you expect this not to turn into a circlejerk? You ma'am, need to go outside more. Find some dudes. Talk to them. Is it not like bouncing rubber off a wall? Yes, welcome.
>>60319950
I'm not really saying that, but what I mean is that a lot of people are giving her more credit than she deserves as a singer. While I agree her breath control is good and her lower register belts sound good too, I don't think she's much better than many other pop singers who have much more exciting music that tends to mask their vocal talent (ie. Sia)
>>60320019
>You ma'am, need to go outside more. Find some dudes. Talk to them.
this is the funniest thing I've ever read on 4chan
Where's Celine Dion?
>>60320019
>We're talking about primarily male topics
>Where would you place Adele and Amy Whinehouse
>>60320019
Where in gods name did you get the idea that I'm female? You guys are largely circlejerking about obscure genres and indie bullshit
>>60320076
in the trash where she belongs
Where is FKA Twigs
>>60320110
I just assumed because you weren't circlejerking that you had no dick.
>>60320179
probably drowning like the mouthbreather she is
>>60320180
Somewhere watching a live stream of a coalmine while eating spiders
>>60320179
as much as i love twigs she fucking sucks at singing her vocals are so weak and shaky just watch some of her live vids
>God tier
SVE
PJ Harvey
Joanna Newsom
>Good
Julia Holter
St. Vincent
Jànéllè Mônàé
Amy
>Ok
Adele
FKA Twigs
>Shit
Grimeth
who else
>>60320424
>PJ Harvey
I don't believe she is eligible for this list. If you are one of the best of 20th Century too you don't need to be on this list. Otherwise you could just stick Erykah Badu on here too.
I would add Jessie Ware but her voice is weak. And Florence's voice can be really shit too. I'd add Lykke Li but those are for waifu related reasons.
>>60320250
Yikes that was meant for
>>60320179
>>60319285
>no one can criticize my taste if it's obscure enough
>Christine Lavin
solo RYM ratings: 14, band: 4
>Tara Cross
RYM ratings: 29
>Nicola Hitchcock
Solo RYM ratings: 9, band: 109
>Christina Kubisch
RYM ratings: 43
>Ursola Bogner
RYM ratings: 78
>Evi Vine
Solo RYM Ratings: 4, band: 101
>Zoe Boekbinder
Solo RYM ratings: 16, band: 37
>>60319285
word
THE LIST STARTS AND ENDS WITH JONI MITCHELL and STEVE NICKS FROM FLEETWOODMAC
god: Susanne Sundfor.
>>60319419
fuck off pleb
>>60319063
Joanna is a godtier songwtiter but not singer. Not that singing is that important or else we'd all be listening to Beyonce or Celine Dion or something
