one of these threads
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
You are currently reading a thread in /mu/ - Music
one of these threads
antz pls go
>>51738143
bad taste general?
>>51738143
This must be a troll, there's no way someone can rate More above Animals and Meddle. Pretty much every album you gave a 1/10 is stunning and revolutionary.
inb4 dadrock, pink floyd is a good fucking band
>>51738143
this is correct
needs updating tho
>>51738194
>stop having opinions
>>51738225
I didn't tell you to stop having opinions, I told you to stop shitposting
>>51738225
it's not even some guys opinion. it's a troll chart that gets posted in every Floyd thread
>>51738194
I prefer More to Animals, but equal to Meddle
>>51738143
If you genuinely believe The Wall and Dark Side of the Moon are 1/10s, then you're a try hard hipster.
>>51738305
better that than trying hard too to be objective about anything music
>>51738143
>one of these threads
What? an edgy contrarian opinion thread?
>>51738411
see >>51738182
I'm glad this chart riels everyone up
>>51738143
No one actually thinks this about Pink Floyd lmao
>>51739351
You'd probably enjoy Beyond Magnetic
/r/ template
>>51739670
>>51739582
almost positive I made this
>>51738143
god this is so innaccurate
>>51739599
swap wl/wh with tvu&n and we have a winner
>>51739928
s/t>Melophobia>TYHB
>>51740013
S/t started getting boring. All the songs started to blend together toward the end.
>>51740062
They all suffer from that, though
Spirit, They're Gone, Spirit, They've Vanished - God Tier
Danse Manatee - 6/10
Hollinndagain - 7/10
Campfire Songs - 10/10
Here Comes the Indian - 9/10
Sung Tongs - 9/10
Feels - 9/10
Strawberry Jam - 7/10
Merriweather Post Pavilion - 9/10
ODDSAC - 9/10
Centipede Hz - 5/10
>>51738143
The Piper At the Gates of Dawn - 4/10
A Saucerful of Secrets - 7/10
More - 6/10
Ummagumma - 5/10
Atom Heart Mother - 9/10
Meddle - 8/10
Obscured by Clouds - 7/10
The Dark Side of the Moon - 10/10
Wish You Were Here - 10/10
Animals - 9/10
The Wall - 5/10
The Final Cut - 4/10
A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 5/10
The Division Bell - 5/10
The Endless River - 6/10
>>51739599
The Velvet Underground & Nico - 10/10
White Light/White Heat - 10/10
The Velvet Underground - 10/10
Loaded - 10/10
Squeeze - 1/10
>>51740083
epidemic
>>51740082
No each song on the other albums were distinctively different. Some songs off s/t sounded alot alike to the point where I'm not sure which one I'm listening to
Yo.
>>51740083
shit taste alert
>>51740083
Sprit, Danse and Hollinndagain are a solid run of god tier albums
How can you rate Here Comes the Indian 9/10, but danse a 6? It's not like you don't like the experimentation or the soundscapes, because HCTI has all that
>>51740181
"Here Comes the Indian" did it better. I feel like it goes more places than "Danse Manatee" and overall sounds more mysterious and spooky and dreamlike.
>>51740166
Oh, shush.
>>51740288
fair enough
I hate it when people bash Danse, it's such a great album, it means so much to me.
>>51740389
>>51740419
>opinions
>these opinions
just made this
prodigy's discography
>>51739885
Nah, I made this one. But nice taste m8
Someone should do it for Buckethead's entire discog :^)
>>51740661
Invaders Must Die never gets any love. Easily better than Fat of the Land.
>>51740154
rival dealer better than s/t? maybe i should check it out
>>51740154
rival dealer were miles ahead of untrue
>>51738143
gr8 b8 m8 r8 it a 7
>>51740793
I like the first song.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTw2YvutJRA
It reminds me of thishttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwWmGzxQDY4
>>51740344
>one bad song
>worse than the first two
No
>>51740925
Wait, Eurythmics were ever good?
>>51740667
pretty much
>>51740709
>Sun-Baked Snow Cave
>2
Opinion invalid. Also, Akuma No Uta is good and all, but in no way better than Feedbacker or Altar.
>>51741065
Boris usually has good collabs but fuck Sun Baked Snow Cave.
It is awful by noise standards and by guitar music standards. It's an hour of absolutely nothing.
Stephen O'Malley is a pretty cool artist though.
>>51739379
joshua tree is also god tier
>>51741065
Nah suck my dick. That album is boring as fuck
>>51741145
You mean it's awful by YOUR standards. Which are awful. You have to be in the right frame of mind for SBSC, but it's an absolutely stellar, emotional as all fuck, piece of ambient beauty.
>>51741222
Sure, if you enjoy listening to absolutely nothing.
>>51739599
The Velvet Underground & Nico - 7/10
White Light/White Heat - 7.5/10
The Velvet Underground - 6/10
Loaded - 5/10
Squeeze - 4/10
>>51741222
No. It's a failure as an album. You're talking to someone who enjoys ambient and is usually in a mindset to enjoy such music.
>>51741256
You have an odd idea of what constitutes absolutely nothing.
>>51741221
i prefer kites, i was at one of their shows recently, amazing fucking night and band.
>>51740793
i hope thats a troll
its so bad
>>51740778
This is accurate.
Objective fact
>>51741425
How can you tell the difference between the albums?
>>51741378
Any track off IMD > any track off FotL. Prove me wrong.
>>51741483
lolwut have you even listened to mastodon or am I just being baited hard an heavy over here?
>>51741521
im not going to warrant your ignorance with a proper response, good day
>>51741053
>With Teeth
>Better than anything else
I agree that The Fragile is the best though.
>>51741808
The covers are nice. What genre is this?
>>51741840
Indie Rock/Post-Hardcore
>>51741425
But Blood Mountain is their best album.
>>51741808
This is pretty good, though I'd probably rank their first three albums up one.
I'm a huge fan of mewithoutyou though, so I dunno
>>51741840
varies. first album is post-hardcore, second album is post-hardcore with indie rock shades, third album is indie rock with post-hardcore shades (best one definitely listen if you fancy it), fourth album is folky rocky stuff, fifth album is indie rock.
the first three have kind of the shouted spoken word vocals of la dispute except they actually sing about interesting things
>>51741889
i'm a huge fan too, don't get me wrong. just trying to rate it without bias heh
>>51741856
>>51741901
I'll check them out. Should I start with the third album?
>>51741932
Brother, Sister is a classic in my book. Definitely start there.
>>51741932
definitely yes. the earlier back you go the heavier it gets, the later you go the indier it gets
>>51740083
SHIT taste
A classic one...
Boris - Akuma No Uta
Cos AVPD
oops sorry wrong thread
>>51741956
>>51741965
Fantastic album, 9/10.
Thanks bros.
>>51742286
Never understood the appeal to Rubber Soul. Eh.
How can one band go from so good to so bad in one album
>>51740154
where the fuck is kindred you stupid fucking plebian
>>51741320
My nigga
>>51741117
>feels
>god-tier
somebody here gets it.
>>51742286
Here's a better one
>>51744997
FTFY
>>51745224
uyama hiroto plz go away, ur idol iz ded, deal
Objective fact.
>>51746096
Innocence is GOAT
>>51738182
my man
>>51746128
There are a few great songs on Volta, but in general though it's just much weaker than anything she's done. It's still not that bad though, I mean, it's Björk.
>>51738143
Offical REM chart
>>51746414
>no reckoning
Haven't really listened to Prayers for the Unborn so I can't rate it.
>>51746414
UP deserves to be higher, it's fantastic.
>>51746240
>It's still not that bad though, I mean, it's Björk.
And some people wonder why people stay in Scientology.
>>51746612
Not a fan of R.E.Ms electronic music but maybe its because they were one of the greatest alt rock bands ever
>>51741022
>>51740667
>Stankonia the best album
>Speakerboxxx / The Love Below better than the first 3 albums
no
>>51746677
Not because of Björk I hope, I kind of like her.
>>51738305
>The Wall
>anything other than a steaming pile of shit
>>>/r/eddit
>>51741286
accurate enough. I'd crank STG disc 2 up a tad, buy hey: opinions.
>>51741117
so, you like Dance?
>>51741320
I'd give notm a higher score personally
>>51741887
this is truth.
for me, BM and CtS are tied for best album, due to their differences in sound, if I had to though, I'd likely rank Blood Mountain higher.
>>51747958
Not that guy but looks like he does because there are stars in the eyes but ears are bleeding because of the high frequencies of danse.
>>51741053
>Pretty Hate Machine
>bad
>The Downward Spiral
>average
>shiggy diggy doo
>>51743438
You better be fucking right about those ratings, just downloaded those two 10's based on your opinion.
>>51739351
As a Metallica album Anger may be low, but compared against their catalogue as a whole it's in a whole other class. Top quality record.
>>51750585
>that rating for fixed
lel plen
>>51750618
I re-listen to it once every few months just to check, but it will never work.
>>51750644
i understand, that stuff isnt for everyone
>>51750671
Looking again, I guess I need to add Gone Girl, once I've heard it.
Might drop Broken down to an 8 in fact, unless hearing it again convinces me otherwise. Last and HiS are the only ones I go back to now and again. Never understood everybody's fascination with Wish.
>>51750807
I agree
>>51750807
but rubber soul is the best
>>51740083
There's no way Centipede Hz is a 5. Listen to it again.
the fact that ive listened to all of these albums enough to make this is really sad
>>51741117
fucking spot on anon pls be my friend
>>51740778
Pipedreams is a 9 tho
>>51740667
>Stankonia their best album
>S/TLB better than Aquemini
Yeah, no.
>>51750876
casual
>>51746414
Dude, you missed Reckoning, and it's their best album
>>51741425
Saw them play in ATL at the tabernacle on the 7th. Last show of the tour, in their home city.
And i left halfway through their set, some frat bro stole my spot in the balcony and my friend pussed out holding it for me.
Fuck it, I was there to see Gojira open for them anyway.
>>51750585
whatd you think of the gone girl soundtrack
>>51741320
Bump NOTM to Exm and Tms and it's accurate
>>51744834
>Speaking in tunges highest rated
This nigga gets it
>>51740778
Distressor's album cover is taken from Eyes Wide Shut. That's Nicole Kidman's ass.
>>51740389
>Lift yr fist
10
>>51738143
>Ummagumma
>Complete mess of an album produced right after a major lineup change
>Even the band thinks it's a weak album
>Throw in a random live performance in an attempt to make it less shitty
>10
>>51750943
this is correct, no matter what anyone says
>>51751545
except Niggas is a 10
>>51740667
>there are people who actually believe this
>>51740925
thanks for this. been meaning to get into eurythmics for a while now.
>>51738143
nice pasta b8, OP
>>51741117
this is the chart for the ones who into them early rather than late. i like it.
>>51738143
you dont get music
/first albums are idd better but u are insane
>>51751524
agreed except I'd add 6 to Quaristice
>>51740599
agree 100%
>>51738143
hilarious
>>51751690
Quaristice is just a complete mess to me. It has two or three decent tracks, but there's also tracks like Fol3 which are just random noise.
>>51740154
S/T gets an average face
No Kindred
No vs Massive Attack
Your ratings mean nothing
>>51740083
Worst taste on /mu/?
>>51751750
I like the entire album for that exact reason. and fol3 sounds wonderful on car speakers
>>51750807
>abbey road
>God Tier
Why do people like this boring snooze-fest
>>51739599
squeeze shouldn't even be included
IMO even loaded is basically a lou reed solo album
>>51741117
Fucking awful chart.
Campfire and Feels rated too high, and CHz, Danse and STGSTV too low
>>51741320
Switch NOTM with ExM and it's accurate
>>51752082
A lou reed solo album with him not singing on half the songs
>>51738194
>Pink Floyd post-Barrett
>revolutionary
They were good and stunning at times, but revolutionary? nahhhhh
>>51746610
This has to be b8
UR is 7/10 at best
>>51752061
How can you like blood bank over self titled And Emma?
>>51738143
>animals
>2/10
plz die
>>51750948
is other albums of PatD similar to Pretty Odd or something different?
>>51752197
I like Blood Blank as much as For Emma (though For Emma is probably a bit better).
s/t is nothing special to me. It didn't feel cozy or interesting.
>>51746096
>not including selmasongs
>>51752217
no.
A Fever You Can't Sweat Out is dance-y pop punk on side A and side B is pop punk with some classical instrumentation
Vices and Virtues is just a mess.
TWTL,TRTD is top 40 style pop, the singles are pretty good though.
Side B of Fever is probably the closest to Pretty Odd, but its still pretty different :/
>>51746610
The Grimes and the Glow is an abomination of a record. Unknown Rooms is half-baked.
>>51750943
Swap NLDW and NOTM and it's prefect.
>>51742286
>>51750943
Fixed that
>>51752971
>>51750943
Fixed both of you silly geese.
>>51747398
I'm not saying they are good. DSOTM and The wall are both like 5-6/10.
>>51752971
spot on
>>51740083
Decent taste. I'm assuming most people are just buttfrustrated about the low Piper rating.
>>51753370
i wouldn't put dsotm and the wall in the same league
the wall is like 4/10
dsotm is at least a 7
>>51753263
listen to niggas on the moon more
it's become one of my favourites (behind ExM)
Aboriginal Man - 10
$ - 7
Dick pic - 8
3D - 8
niggas - 9
>>51746414
up should be much higher
>>51752027
not fixed, just my opinion
The Endless River: 6/10
its a better album than the wall
>>51750800
Can't agree with lowborn, you are right by naming vitals as the best however.
>>51751957
FUCK OFF YOU WORTHLESS FUCK I HOPE YOU DIE YOUNG! Abbey Road is godteir so SHUT THE FUCK UP!
>>51750948
Sad thruth
i dont know how to makes these so i saw this in a thread one time and its crazy close to my own opinion. id probably make How to leave town a 6
I love sufjan
>>51739698
template used
>>51741320
swap Exm with NOTM, bump GP down slightly and NLDW up slightly and it's perfect
>>51741296
>That one guy, every time the Velvet Underground is mentioned
top kek
>>51752050
my nigga
>>51751463
oh how knowledgeable you are. tell me more mister
>>51757854
what a drone
>>51757436
>he only started listening to swans in 2012 and hasn't even heard my father will guide me
>>51757872
>Narrow Stairs over Plans
>>51757884
i'll get around to everything that's missing soon
why the fuck does it matter if i started listening to them recently
>muh "i listened to swans before they were popular"
fuck off
>>51752628
OT is the shit
>>51752628
but that's wrong. every one of those should be marked as god tier. also, it's out of order.
>>51757871
why?
>>51750428
Well? How are they?
>>51757436
as far as studio albums go
Filth - 8/10
Cop - 10/10 (best 'heavy' Swans album to me)
Greed - 7.5/10
Holy Money - 8/10
Children of God - 8.5/10
White Light - 9/10
Love of Life - 6.5/10 ('Her' is one of the best Swans songs and more people need to dig it)
The Burning World - 4/10
Great Annihilator - 6.5/10
Soundtracks for the Blind - 10/10 (as are all live performances of it)
My Father will Guide Me - 7/10
The Seer - 9.5/10
To Be Kind - 8/10
Probably my favourite band which is why so many ratings will seem inflated
>>51752925
I disagree, but kekd anyway
>>51758059
>burzum not being the highest rating
>hvis lyset tar oss that high
>aske that low
>filosofem the second highest
>umskiptar lower than the prison albums
>>51758138
Not him, but I've only enjoyed his prison albums
>>51744834
speaking in tongues was always my favorite. I always thought I was weird for liking it over remain in light
>>51758138
congratulations you have opinions
>>51740709
that's some serious work there
>>51741320
basically
>>51754791
Recovery and Mmlp2 are both shit tier, get the fuck out faggot
>>51743438
None of them is above 7, dipshit
>>51738143
fuck you, meedle is cool
