Now with a new MLP movie coming I wonder
What's your opinion on the EG movies so far?
Eg1: https://goo gl/xDHup6
Eg2: https://goo gl/VcVLte
Eg3: https://goo gl/dO0Lt0
>>27846760
EQG 1: Bad
EQG 2: Meh
EQG 3: My least favourite of the three
>>27846760
>MLP
No it isn't.
Please post EqG or full name, I have filters for a reason.
Every movie is shit.
>>27846760
That fact that Shimmer isn't in the promo for EQG 2 makes me laugh
>>27846780
This.
>>27846832
Honestly I kind of wonder if she's not selling poorly with the little girls; Hasbro seems to be in no hurry to put out toys with her.
>>27846780
This. Though I'd rate RR above average instead of meh.
Not looking forward to LOE due to them basically deciding to go "Midnight sparkle 2: electric boogaloo" for the plot and digging up FG's old shit again.
>>27846760
On a scale of enjoyment:
1: Pretty good
2: Very good
3: Pretty good
On a critic's scale:
1: 6/10
2: 7/10
3: 5/10
>>27847417
Yeah, RR was alright, I guess I'm just pretty meh about the whole franchise. The EQG movies are a bit of fun, but not very rewatchable imo, and I was actively bored halfway through the third one.
>>27847440
1. So-so
2. Better
3. WAY better
>>27847494
>>27847440
>>27846780
>not using the polls
>>27847483
Agreed. The EQG franchise has been pretty poor all around.
Unfortuantely, with Haber at the helm, I don't see it getting any better; Haber's bargain bin as a head writer.
Kind of sad, because like the premise of Humanized mane six, just the execution has been bad.
>>27847546
I'm trying to find the thread where the survey was at, but I can't find it on teh board right now.
Did it die?
>>27847546
I know the polls! where ~70% of /mlp/ either hate or don't give a fuck about EQG. Theres more to life than polls
>pic not related
>>27846760
0/4
0/4
0/4
What's the point in watching a pony movie without ponies, the worst bait and switch of the century.
>>27847602
reminder that /mlp is a TERRIBLE example of the Fandom as a whole.
Every single site that sells or rates EQG rates it VERY highly. Rotten tomatoes gives it over 70% for example.
>>27846760
EQG: meh
EQG 2: Good
EQG 3: meh
EQG 4:WHERE'S MY FUCKING DAZZLES DHX?
>>27846760
Still no dazzles. 3/10
>>27846760
1: Pure shit
2: A bit better but still shit, at least it gave us the sirens.
3: More shit, not better than 2
EG1 was flawed, but still represented the mane 6 well, and it was a nice movie.
EG2 is the master race of the 3. I cri evertim Sunset transforms
EQG3 couldn't live up to the hype of the competition, the music, or the previous movie. I still liked it, especially Sunset's arc coming full circle, but still not as good as 2.
>>27846780
/thread
>>27846780
Maximum shit taste
1 is the worst thing ever devised while 2 is only liked for the popshit, memes, and new waifus
>>27847825
>being this cynical because thinking makes a millennial's brain hurt
>>27847825
I bet you're either a twilightfag or a shimmerfag
>>27847825
what are you implying? that the third one was the least terrible of the three?
If so kill yourself multiple times.
>>27847836
Except it's literally true
1 was a total shitfest full of glaring plotholes and every fucking character was totally retarded except for Spike who for some reason was written probably the best he ever has been, but that doesn't save it from being total cancer overall
2 introduced 3 cookie cutter villains (the ebil mastur mind, the dumb one, the grumpy one) and continued to make everyone totally retarded and fuck around doing shit that isn't even remotely necessary (Twilight writing that counterspell that she eventually just gave up on and used one of Fluttershit's songs)
>>27847825
>is the worst thing ever devised
at least you kept an open mind
>>27847854
Except it is, you braindead faggot
It's the only one that doesn't entirely rely on ebin brony memes and pandering to generate interest because it has an engaging story; therefore it's the only one that's good
>>27847881
we get it, you don't like memes.Your hatred of them has made your taste poor and shit, your soul cold and unkind.
>>27847915
>I only enjoy things that go out of their way to shoehorn in fandom references rather than create narratives that have merits of their own
This mindset is why every new installment of a series these days will never live up to the original
Fuck off
>>27847868
>>27847881
there's nothing worse than someone with shit taste and opinions flaunting that shit taste and opinions like a gaudy fur coat.
>>27847941
>being this all-consumed and spergy about may mays that no one else gives a shit about or pay attention to.
The only people who notice and care about references in the show are the ones who bitch about them. The rest of us potty trained adults ignore them and move on.
Not canon
>>27847881
The third one was objectively retarded. Liking it makes you a retard.
What little I remember of it involved a dirt bike race at a high school with a large tentacle monster. While that sounds like it could be awesome in the right context, it was actually boring as fuck and totally shattered my suspension of disbelief.
>>27847978
>types up an edgy post
>takes a sip of his OJ juice box
>looks around the school lunch room
>if only these filthy plebes knew how cool I was
>hits submit
>>27846760
EqG1: meh at best
they could have done a better job if they had had more than 6 months to work on it
EqG2: much better
Sunset Shimmer character growth and the Dazzlings, "welcome to the show" is the best EqG song imo
EqG3: the games made no sense, but it was enjoyable
not a fan that they brought EqG universe Twilight into the mix, but they pulled it off well
could have been better than RR if they had kept the deleted scenes
great job on Shimmer's story arc. they just need her to reconcile with Celestia to finish it off
>>27847600
Why would I keep a thread up for a survey that ended months ago? I want to remain respectable, not turn into some attention whore with his own general.
Link to survey:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1vJacbIjMlf5g6pgwviZg1ecnKNYtDuP_oB5UoTo1Ub4/edit#responses
Link to raw data in google's version of an excel sheet:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kJHrprPG503FHQkr5ErA-aD4Db5tEVUb-Yj69CM4uCc
Pic related is data on EQG.
>>27846760
1: 2/10 At least it can only get better from here.
2: 4/10 if they improve it more I might have to begrudgingly accept that it's worthy of being canon.
3: 0/10 Oh dear god why was this greenlit and what kind of drugs did they cram down Ingram's throat before forcing him to write songs for this atrocity. I thought the first one was bad but holy shit.
>>27846780
>mainstream opinion
>>27848181
I don't mean THAT survey, i was talking about the OTHER survey done this week where People were rating the episodes and movies up to this point.
EQG 1 and 3 were very far down on the list (lower 1/4 of the list) while RR was at roughly the 50% mark.
>>27848228
>3: 0/10 Oh dear god why was this greenlit and what kind of drugs did they cram down Ingram's throat before forcing him to write songs for this atrocity. I thought the first one was bad but holy shit.
they went from McCarthy to haber; its pretty much a sure bet that it was going to be shit since they swapped out a semi-decent writer for a shit one.
Same with EQG 4.
>>27846760
Eqg1: 0/10
Eqg2: 1/10
Eqg3: 0/10
TL;DR ALL OF THEM ARE SHIT
