Finals Edition.
ITT:
>We discuss Current, Finished and Upcoming CYOAs.
>Give advice on CYOAs
>Pitch ideas
>Get critique
>Trade art
>Shitpost
List of stories: https://www.anonpone.com/
Read this advice first:
https://www.anonpone.com/advice
http://www.tgchan.org/wiki/Advice
>What day is best?
http://strawpoll.me/10160199
>What time is best?
http://strawpoll.me/10160202
>What genre are you interested in?
http://strawpoll.me/10160203
>What if I cannot into art?
http://strawpoll.me/10160205
>What race would you play?
http://strawpoll.me/10160997
Remember: theres a reason that quest isn't up right now
Last Thread: >>27337368 → #
>>27374197
Big
Bug
Butt
Oops
Actual previous thread >>27350576
>>27374197
>>27374210
>nips will never finish the lily lewd
>nips will never make the butt comparisons
>we will never get with best fire waifu
>>27374234
Never is a long time anon.https://i.gyazo.com/fed72a801966c2288acc24b52d5f7b37.png
>>27374234
>Hero is making nips finish the lily lewd
Why must all the good ones be taken away from us
>>27374234
Nips has been gone for a while.
>>27374245
I'm having trouble deciphering what's happening in that fourth panel.
>>27374278
she's hotdogging him and his dick just ground against her clit.
Which CYOA is objectively the worst?
>>27374269
School's been taking a lot of time from me. It's almost over anon. I'm actually really excited to be able to come back to questing.I know my quests aren't the best, but you guys are great, and I owe a lot to you all. So now that I'm going to be able to come back to this is a great feeling.
>>27374291
Yours
>>27374307
>I know my quests aren't the best
Your quests are what got me into CYOA and I still consider them the best out therenow that Cutie Clash is dead
>>27374291
Your favorite one.
My drivers are trying their absolute hardest to fuck me, gimme a bit.
>>27374307
>I know my quests aren't the best
It's sweet that you think that.
>>27374307
I second >>27374336
>>27374336
>GCuck into Nipcuck
wew
>>27374336
His art is certainly the best.
The writing though?
>>27374379
Can you blame them, sexy?
>>27374416
His writing's alright, but he's got setting autism.
Lurker has it too in his own way.
>>27374379
Why don't you let them? are you already in a relationship? Are they unattractive?
>>27374447
>setting autism
I don't know how long this term has been around, but it's fucking perfect. I have never heard a better word for whatever the fuck it is that Nips has.
>>27374498
>>27374447
it's true. I'm trying to make it not as >deepest as i can with what's been done
>>27374630
This is so dumb I can't bring myself to call it porn.
>>27374307
I'm just glad you still enjoy it.
>Cursequest fell off the board.
H-he'll be back, right?
Will he stay dead for a week again?
>>27374645
What if I told you there's an entire mop head inside that filly.
>>27374630
Whispen finally loses her cool
>>27374664
>filly
>>27374664
>filly
Guess again.
>>27374664
>filly
>>27374664
Psker pls
>>27374773
>psker being aware of alchemy art
Unlikely.
>>27374787
I took it more as being unaware of Hijacker art/fanart :^)
Session would've started an hour ago had my computer decided not to work, so a short session tonight.
>>27374930
>>27374291
Any of Bath's edge-quests.
>>27375421
IWTCIAS
>>27375421
So that's chemist, geneticist, xenobiologist, kinesiologist, security guy, and bureaucrat, right?
>>27375457
Me too, kinda.
>>27375421
i like acid base
>>27375469
that's right.
>security guy
>guy
hue
>>27375421
>2nd wind a cute
New horsebando(?) incoming
vote for tired science horse name pls
http://www.strawpoll.me/10226327
>>27375421
>Acceptable Losses
His parents must've hated him.
>>27375708
>crystal beaker
Should have corrected that to Vial, Beaker, or Flask
>>27375709
>I don't think your son will survive
>Well, okay. An acceptable loss.
>>27376023
He knew the risks.
Lol don' b gay
What are the little things that make a CYOA better?
>>27376269
Threads not dying prematurely would be nice.
>>27376269
players discussing about the world and their plans for the characters
>>27374787
https://derpiboo.ru/1147534
Active threads
Crystal Symphony: >>27344969
Dirty Work: >>27363917
Hype Quest: >>27317068
Custos Luna: >>27357752
FOE: >>27336570
War in the North: >>27314942
Across the Ocean: >>27372434
Coltquest: >>27341283
Spicyquest: >>27362094
Pocket Watch: >>27280887
Miracle: >>27359835
Unnamed: >>27362199
SIM: >>27303978
DITA: >>27360978
Boatquest: >>27293282
>>27376889
>no vampony
It's literally only quest I play
>>27375708
>acid base
I like this one. Follows the pony naming pattern and is immediately recognizable as a chemistry name since it's something most people learn in high school.
>methylene blue
I like this one even more. Still follows the pony name pattern but now we're talking advanced chemistry. Also my favorite microscopy stain.
>crystal beaker
Eh, okay. Not quite as good as the other two, but okay.
>>27375421
How many of them are blue/red?
>>27376976
All of them. Even the zeb.
>>27376988
Blue/gray and red/black?
>>27375708
The first two gave me chemistry stuff when I googled them and crystal beaker gave me bongs.
>>27375708
I gonna ignore the context of this, since while a pony name is always context based, there are quite a few occasions when a pony's name is used outside of the context of said pony's cutie mark.
You should try to come up with names that are not this specific.
>acid base
>acid
It hurts to touch, dissolves matter, and stinks. Perfect name for a pony!
>methylene blue
Methylene alone seems like a good enough name for a pony, as it sounds similar enough to normal names, the blue overloads it.
Still, try to say Methylene three times without feeling like a dumb ass.
>crystal beaker
I guess it's okay. Beaker sounds kinda strange.
>>27376962
Fuck off Doxel.
>>27377125
However, reacting acid and base together usually makes a salt and water.
HCl(aq)+NaOH(aq)->NaCl(aq)+H2O(l)
is a simple one you'll probably recognize.
>>27377141
First of all for this to fully work everyone would have to call the pony by her full name which nearly never happens.
Secondly, this is not a chemistry book, this is a pony.
Let me guess your favorite mane6 is Festivity Scheduler?
>>27374447
>setting autism
>>27377179
I don't think I get the connection you're trying to make. You just made up a completely unrelated name and made an assumption about me.
Assholish sarcasm doesn't get points across well.
>>27377232
u don't get points across well
I want to bully Treads again.
I can't believe Inept is fucking dead.
F
>>27377409
>No one will ever billy Treads again.
She's gone, Anon.
Its time we move on and pick a new poner to billy.
>>27377125
>name opinions
I tried your experiment and said Methylene three times, but I didn't feel like a dumbass. If you are worried about the name being a bit too over-the-top, she could always just go by Methylene. I also think that Acid Base could still work as a name too, because not all acids are as harmful as you're implying, although I do understand the point you were trying to make about the connotations someone would perceive in the name "acid". Again though, she could just go by Base. She doesn't need to go by the whole name. I agree with you about Crystal Beaker.
>fuck off
Will do.
Alchemy returns.
>>27377662
>>27377512
Second base ;)
>>27377512
Call her dihydrogen monoxide.
>>27375708
Everyone gonna call her Methy
Quests where you are the villain?
>>27378034
Super
>>27378046
He probably meant a competent villain.
>>27378034
Shooting Stars, you're trying to stop gods from unleashing their holy wrath on the unclean populous to reign in a era of peace.
>>27378034
There was that brief GC quest where the MC was learning mind control.
>>27378169
>Brief GC quest
They were all brief anon.
>>27378158
>>27378034
Players don't like going full evil, usually.
Which loner were you totally wrong about after their first impression on you. How did they change?
>>27378249
*poner* god I hate phones.
>>27378219
One ingame day
Symphony is now "find husband" quest.
>>27378343
As if anyone will get with a sapient rock that sounds like a demon.
>>27378343
Finally ready to not be a dead virgin huh?
>>27378249
Bottlecap. I thought he was bland and had no flaws at first. Turns out that his surface mildness hides an inner core of stupidly courageous helpfulness and the lack of any ability to evaluate the consequences of his actions.
>>27378438
Bonus session on monday
>>27376461
This, to be honest.
>>27378355
y-yeah, who'd do that?
>>27378471
>>27378355
Obviously, they're r-right.
>>27378249
Emerald Jewel. I thought he was another horny foal in the same vein as Foal Quest. But then we discovered the nature of his past and the potential mental issues he's loaded with. The mysteries with his mother and amulet. His desire for revenge...
Also he's fairly brave and is willing to risk himself to protect the friendships he's made so far.
Far more interesting than just another horny foal in a lewd quest.
>>27378534
to bad you guys play him as nothing but a horny foal in lewd quest.
>>27378555
Have you played recently?
>>27378570
No, because it's garbage.
>>27378588
Well the boat stuff is done and now we are in a Lich's compound where we have learned that the amulet houses a demon which we have become bound to.
>>27378555
>to bad you guys play him as nothing but a horny foal in lewd quest.
Do you have any suggestions on how to play him then?
>>27378622
So how many times did you getbonedby the lich huh?
>>27378622
Don't forget to mention that the Lich is a QM reference, and possible a self insert of ficfic. Because you know QMs are Liches, am a right guys.Not every QM is Lich tier.
>>27378649
>So how many times did you get boned by the lich huh?
None at all. Though he almost killed us...
>>27378667
>Though he almost killed us...
I'm sure a ruined anus can do that.
>>27374197
What pone has fallen into the abyss/black hole of No updates?
>>27378829
As I opened the reply box, I realized I couldn't even remember Puppy's real name anymore
>>27378829
>>27378871
Honeydrop.
And while we're on the topic I just saw the Alchemy OP. It honest to goodness made me cry. Alch, could you please edit that pic to where she has green eyes and a horn? Please?
War in the North continues:
>>27378940
>>27378829
LOSTAt least it means the spiders can't get her.
>>27378933
>>27378996
Goodbye Honeydrop. Go have a happy ending for me.
>>27379047NotCanon:^)
What are your opinions on Equestrian Dungeon?
>>27379069
Smug indiference
>>27379061but it is canon. there is even a picture. checkmate:^)
>>27379061
I don't even care, I'm getting closure from it. Fuck... why am I so tore up from this?
A meme a day keeps the QM away
>>27379116
Because you know that you will never properly save her in her own universe.
>>27379117
when in doubt, blame the players:^)
>>27379174
That's just rude. QM without players is nothing. Players without QM will simply find a new one.
>>27379187
But what happens when the players run out of QMs?
If a player becomes a QM, is he still a player?
...no wait, don't answer that.
>>27374210
>>27379268
I'm a player who's also a QM :^)
>>27379187
Only players can be cuck anons, don't you forget that
>>27379396
SOON BROTHER
>>27379396
Remove kebab from Constantinople
>>27379396
>Deus Vult
Urban 2 confirmed
>>27379465
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umDr0mPuyQc
>>27379473
Urban 2: Shade strikes back
How about a a Shadow of The Colossus type quest?
>>27379721
TITAN
>>27378628
Get Joyride or Ruby to start pegging him with footballs when he's not looking until he becomes a fucking pro-reciever or starts getting really tough.
>>27379762
I think pelting would of been a better word, unless you mean actually shoving a football up his butt.
>>27379721
How about a a Shadow of The Colossus type quest except instead of Colossi you're trying to find the perfect spots to pleasure big mares?
>>27379784
Sounds about right for CQ players.
>tfw you get a great CYOA idea while you are in the middle of running another one.
>>27379785
You mean big mares have different pleasure points?
>>27379895
Post it so someone can steal it
>>27379923
Yeah no, it's too good of an idea.
>>27379933
Come on.... we might not be trustworthy, but we are lazy, ain't no one gonna steel it.
>>27379933
Just call dibs bro.
>>27380174
You can't call dibs on a spaceship!
>>27379949
Your waifu is ______!
>>27380464
Not real....
>>27380464
a whore
>>27360978
The bar is once again, open.I forgot to post an announcement or whatever edition
>>27380464
adorable
>>27380464
A husbando
>>27317068
pls subscribe
>>27377422
>implying
I'm not going to be dead until my CYOA's stop getting players and die and I leave in shamefor another website for four months.
Anyway, pick a game.https://youtu.be/u-TmJsWglE8
>>27380838
Since she said please, Juicy.
>>27380838
Origami!
>>27380838
i pick juice.
>>27380838
>for another website for four months
I still hate you forever for that.
>>27380838
paper pony
>>27377141
Since acid + base = salt + water, that could be a hint that she'sreally salty
>>27380838
Papermint pone.
>>27380464
A failed abortion
>>27380464
a mistake
>>27380838
>the sad look
>the please sign
>Everyone tells you that the game has been paused for months.
>The QM lowers his head in grief
Inept why you do this. I've got tomorrow and the next day off.
It's time to continue. Give me like 20 minutes to contact ya on skype. We'll discuss more there.
>>27380880
Look, I'm sorry, but >>27379187 is right. A QM without players either leaves for greener pastures or diesof a broken heart.
>>27380867
>>27380868
>>27380875
>>27380884
>>27381091
Juicy isn't the CYOA, it's the name of the original QM.
That being said, Paper Pony now continues!
>>27381199>>27381182
If you want to take over, by all means go ahead.
>>27381231
You did have players though, and the pastures you left us for were just as dead. The only reason I'm mad at all is because you didn't even tell the players you had that you were moving.
>>27381281
Stop acting so entitled. Players leave without saying a word, so QMs have every right to just leave if they don't feel like continuing anymore, too. They have no obligations to tell the players if they feel like they're an ungrateful bunch of pricks.
>>27381231
I'd never break your heart bby
>>27381231
Forgot the pic.
>>27381281Four CYOA's, Anon. Every single one of them was dead. DEAD-dead. 'Zero players at all' dead. The takeaway from that is pretty clear.
>>27381350
She's gonna hit holiday, fuck.
>>27381350
It's always heartbreaking to see a dead CYOA.
>>27381317
The players aren't providing content that other people care about. No one will really give a shit or even notice if a single player leaves unless they're a primary participant, but if the QM leaves the entire thing is fucked. I have every right to be mad.
>>27381487
Check your privilege.
>>27381497
BACK THE FUCK OFF?!?!?
Resuming Miracle: Books boogaloo.
>>27381507
Don't disappear again. I bet you're lurking the Paper Pone thread right now. Anons are ripping hard on you right now but I believe in you.please...
>>27381612
He's not even running the quest anymore, who gives a shit if he's still around.
>>27381612
It's over, anon.
>>27381563
No one cares
Hijug
Hijumbojet
Higigu
Higger
>>27382014
N-no...
Hijimbo
>>27382019
GLASSED
L
A
S
S
E
D
Hijustrungenequestalready
Inept.
REMEBER WHEN YOUR FAVORITE QUEST DIED?
IT WAS ME ANON. ME.
>>27382223
S P E E D F O R C E
>>27382223
I might run a quest soon
>>27382452
Oooh~!
Tell me what it is?
>>27382452
Cool. What's the concept?
>>27382463
It's a cutequetria quest, i will run it in 5 hours.
>>27382452
That's neat.
>5 hours left
>>27382487
>4 hours and 56 minutes left
>>27382474
>4am est
>starting a new quest
>>27382474
That's really an awful starting time.
>>27382487
>le raised fist.png.meme
So what CYOAs are you playing?
>>27383255
The ones I like.
>>27383255
Dirty work, friendship is- cuddle m- vamp- Hype quest, cuckquest
>>27382487
>3 hours 43 minutes left.
>>27383540
Fuck off.
>>27383540
Reminder that hype kills quests.
>>27383552
Thats why Raven had to take away his tufts.
>>27383255
Torn between desperately wanting to finish catching up on Dirty Work so I can play it and not wanting to finish it too quickly so I have something to read on the train.
What stories would you tell or read to CYOA ponies.
>>27384115
11-54IF IT WERE STILL ACTIVE
>>27383902
Where are you up to?
>>27384115
I have no mouth and I must scream.
>>27383902
Breakfast of Champions seems appropriate.
>>27384304
Thread 11
>>27384346
I don't follow?
!Brushie
>>27384474
>SWC is animating now
qt Basil gifs here I come
!bully
>>27384523
Please specify someone to bully, you idiot.
>>27384533
!bully inept
>>27384523
Who the fuck are you, literally no one important
>>27384533
!bully everyone
>>27384542
Go back to ponychan, Inept.
>>27384556
>Everyone here
>being a /cyoa/cuck.
>>27384579
!bully Choosie
>>27384608
Screw you, Anon.
!bully Choosie
!bully wolvan
!bully Amm
>>27384474
amazing
>>27384662
>Brickway
>>27384115
I would read Oliver Twist to Honeydrop.
>>27384236
Why would you read that to a CYOA pone, you cruel person!?
>>27384616
this choosie is an imposter. She'd have said "Fuck you Anon."
>>27383610
he'll get them back right?
>>27384474
Adorable dicehorse.
So what quests are you following that isn't up right now? Do you wanna talk about them?
>>27386054
JAD died because no one was awake/free to bump it.
It was just getting interesting too, we were playing good cop/bad cop with Celestia and her bigot changeling assassin.
Oh, and there were strippers.
What ifall CYOAs played in the same universe/same placebut at different times and maybe different cities or continentsHow would you sort each quest in time and space?
>>27386133
It logically can't all happen in the same universe.
>>27386133
This is my favorite theory. It really doesn't work, but it's fun to try
>>27386137
How so? And then just sort the ones that would work in the same universe
>>27386147
Becausea few of them are confirmed to take place in alternate universes/timelines :^)
On a serious note it would be because eventually you would run into inconsistencies, especially with how many CYOAs there are. This should have been evident.
>>27386054
Lost
NE
Sam Quest
>>27376893
>>27383506
Hey, I just got back from my trip to Tejas. I should be able to get a thread up tonight, depending on a few things.
>>27386147
Because you'll run into inconsistencies everywhere. Take any random feature of a setting. Technology, for example.
Urban has modern technology. Dirty work exists at a state of technology around the first World War. Tinepone has tech at roughly the same level as the show. 11-54 has tech that doesn't exist yet.
It just doesn't work.
>>27386250
Urban also takes place about a hundred years in the future
There aren't enough sonbandos and daughterfus in cyoa.
The last few brushie pics got me in the mood.
>>27386586
sparkle sparkle
I did this over eleven hours ago but here's my brushie contribution.
Choosie a ugly horse
>>27386606
wow rude
>>27386250
>>27386187
That is why I was also saying different time periods
>>27386586
>>27386677
Oh Spicy, how silly thou art.
>>27386677
choosie a cute
>>27386677
Her hair is really dark
