Rate his writing /mlp/
>>25583690
On the whole, his writing varies between bad and good like anyone else.
5/10.
>>25583690
They don't call him Josh "Mediocre" Haber for nothing.
5/10
It at least got progressively better.
>>25583690
I've found hid episodes to be mostly good, but there was too much unexplained bullshit in the finale that ruined it a bit for me. And wjy didn't they bring Starlight's boyfriend back to her at the end, or have him be the one to convince her to stop her bullshit?
>>25583690
The applejack lier episode was one of the worst episodes I've seen in my life.
>>25583806
Because he wasn't the princess of friendship, duh!
>>25583690
Consistently not bad. Casle Mania and the one with Trenderhoof were a couple of the great S4 eps.
His headshot creeps me out.
>>25583824
Are you retarded? That was the second best key episode. That and you know, the conflict actually made sense.
I won't claim it's fantastic but I've enjoyed all of his episodes save for the bottom left there.
>>25583690
Surprisingly decent/10
Made up for the disaster that was EQG3. This actually ranks as the second best finale, right behind season 2's.
>>25583806
I think they're going to bring that topic up sometime in Season 6 where she encounters him again
>>25583690
All his episodes were good except for the Applejack/Rarity one, which was one of the worst of the show.
>>25583690
based/10
>>25583856
Only retarded one here is you. It was the most annoying key episode of them all. And It didn't introduce anything new at all or develop anyone other than flim/flam as being more black/white evil salesponies.
>>25583690
Castle Mania: Pretty good
Simple Ways: Some scenes are horrible others are incredibly hilarious and top tier. Hard to rate it overall
Leap of Faith: One of the better key episodes
Bloom and Gloom: The only good Apple Bloom solo episode.
Cutie Re-Mark: One of the better two parters, though not the best.
All in all he's pretty good Simple Ways is his weakest and even there there's plenty of good along with the bad.
>>25584044
>villains get redeemed
>WAAAH they need to keep some villains ebil!
>villains don't get redeemed
>WAAAH they did nothing wrong why are they acting so mean?
Shove it up your ass. The worst thing you can say about it was that it was boring. Otherwise it had one of the most believable and realistic conflicts in the show (letting a lie slip if it appears to make someone happy). No magic bullshit, just characters and their convictions.
>>25583690
>>25583824
Then you have shitty taste.
>>25583690
3/10, at best 5/10
I like all of those episodes, although I slightly preferred S4's finale to S5's but they were both real good.
>>25584139
This. #rekt
>>25584316
Mah nigga
>>25584096
>Bloom and Gloom: The only good Apple Bloom solo episode.
How would you compare it relative to the other two "Luna and the CMC" episodes?
Copypasted from FIMFiction / 10
>>25584139
It's almost like...*gasp* /mlp/ is not a hivemind and different people have different opinions on things!
>>25583690
Apart from Simple Ways I think his episodes are okay. Nothing spectacular, but still decent. 6.5/10.
>>25583690
Ok then.
>Castlemania
OK-ish.
>Trenderhoof one
Shit
>Flim flam one
Shit
>Applebloom one
Pretty good
>Today's one
Not shit, but not amazing.
>>25584467
Well it's the weakest of the 3 but that's only cause the other 2 are contenders for best episode of their respective seasons. Still I enjoyed it a lot.
>>25583690
10/10
>>25583690
S4 was hit or miss but everything he did for S5 was really great
8/10
>>25583690
It's not his writing. It's his scripts heavily modified like 6 times by Hasbro Studio executives till they completely ruined it with brony pandering.
>>25583690
He's like a metronome, swinging from good to bad without ever stopping in the middle point.
Castlevania episode could have been great.
