[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Friends Forever #22 Storytime
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /mlp/ - My Little Pony

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 101
File: cover.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
cover.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
Friends Forever #22 is out on iTunes.

Previous comics can be found here:
https://yp1.yayponies.no/book.php
>>
File: img_2.jpg (1 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_2.jpg
1 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325129
>>
File: img_4.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_4.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325142
There was a blank page for img_3 for some reason, but the comic looked complete when I double checked it so it should all still be here.
>>
>>25325150
Why is Fosgitt still employed
>>
File: img_5.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_5.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325150
>>
File: img_6.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_6.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325159
>>
>>25325155
Cause faggots like you don't buy any comics anyway, so they don't lose profit because of you disliking a comic.
>>
File: img_7.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_7.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325164
>>
File: img_8.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_8.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325174
>>
>>25325174
I want to cumple in Pinkie's cherpumple
>>
File: img_9.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_9.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325179
>>
>>25325159
JUST
>>
File: 1280px-Cherpumple1.jpg (199 KB, 1280x1065) Image search: [Google]
1280px-Cherpumple1.jpg
199 KB, 1280x1065
>>25325174
That's a real dessert
http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2010/11/09/what-is-the-cherpumple/
>>
Adowable ponieses
>>
>>25325150
One less page for this comic? Pure laziness.
>>
File: img_10.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_10.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325187
>>
>>25325187
god this art style is grating on the eyes
>>
File: img_11.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_11.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325198

>>25325197
Actually it seems like the same number as usual. There was likely just an extra blank page put in accidentally.
>>
>>25325206
I find iTunes' fuzzy compression bullshit more irritating than the art.
>>
File: img_12.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_12.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325208
>>
>>25325155
I don't know. All of his ponies look like they're in constant pain being on two legs and Celestia's head disgusts me.
>>
File: img_13.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_13.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325213
>>
why do they all look like pigs?
>>
>>25325230
The comic is a mirror.
>>
File: img_14.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_14.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325223
>>
So comics still a thing.
>>
>>25325223
overbearing Celestia is a little cute in that last panel. She's acting mildly retarded though
>>
It's so fucking weird to see a pony that has a normal human name. "Chase." Seriously?
>>
File: img_15+16.jpg (3 MB, 2800x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_15+16.jpg
3 MB, 2800x2154
>>25325234
>>
>>25325239
I have a dog named Chase.
>>
File: img_17.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_17.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325242
>>
>>25325242
Wow worst two-page spread ever
>>
>>25325239
It's Chase Palomino.
>>
>>25325242

>Too Psychedelic

Equestria has drugs?
>>
File: img_18.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_18.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325250
>>
>>25325239
>>25325250
>Party of One retread

D R O P P E D
R
O
P
P
E
D
>>
>>25325242
What the fuck is the deal with Pinkie and the Beatles?
>>
it's shit
>>
>>25325266
It's a reference.
>>
File: img_19.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_19.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325262
>>
File: img_20.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_20.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325275
>>
>>25325275
What the fuck is wrong with the proportions in the bottom left? If it's supposed to be an exaggerated scene, it doesn't work.
>>
File: longprincess.png (664 KB, 604x743) Image search: [Google]
longprincess.png
664 KB, 604x743
>>25325275
what the fuck
>>
File: img_21.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_21.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325278
>>
>>25325278
This anatomy. Dear God.
>>
>>25325282
Her neck is behind her hair... so what?
>>
File: img_22.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_22.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325286
>>
File: image.jpg (26 KB, 267x267) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
26 KB, 267x267
>>25325275
Quack
>>
File: ouch.png (1 MB, 828x616) Image search: [Google]
ouch.png
1 MB, 828x616
>>25325278
Is this one of those "I have no clue what pose it's supposed to be, just make a mess of lines" things?
>>
File: img_23.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_23.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325295
>>
File: img_24.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_24.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325299
>>
>>25325250
She went Pinkamena over this? What?
>>
0/10 terrible art
>>
>>25325304
It looks like a dick.
>>
File: img_25.jpg (2 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
img_25.jpg
2 MB, 1400x2154
>>25325304
That's all of it. Hope you enjoyed it /mlp/!

Link to archive:
http://www.mediafire.com/download/1n8qtnj1nt3mrjb/FF%2322.rar
>>
>>25325305
No, she was just talking to herself a bit.
She didn't have a breakdown.
>>
How would you rate Friends Forever #22 out of 10 /mlp/?
Would a change of artist help it that much?
>>
>>25325312
She didn't even try the cake.
>>
>>25325304
Just what she needed, a penis with her and her sister's asses on it, made for putting in your mouth.
>>
>>25325321
It's shit
>>
File: Carlos2.jpg (116 KB, 625x409) Image search: [Google]
Carlos2.jpg
116 KB, 625x409
>>25325312
Well, look like it was a very piece of cake as comic book!
>>
File: #36cvrs.jpg (2 MB, 2108x1600) Image search: [Google]
#36cvrs.jpg
2 MB, 2108x1600
Later this month we get Comic #36, continuing the 4 part Siege of the Crystal Empire arc:

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic #36
>Jeremy Whitley (w) • Andy Price (a) Andy Price (c) Sara Richard (sc)
>“Siege of the Crystal Empire” Part 3! A nefarious foe returns to full power to reclaim that which is rightfully his! Ancient mysteries will be revealed as Twilight and Cadance seek a way to stop the darkness from spreading! An epic story for the ages unfolds!
>>
File: Chase.png (46 KB, 221x324) Image search: [Google]
Chase.png
46 KB, 221x324
>>25325239
>a pony that has a normal human name.
>"Chase"

It's a fine name I tell you hwat.
>>
>>25325321
Ordinarily, I would give this a 5/10 because the story was cute and had some good moments. However, the Luna book that came out today has a very similar story that is handled much better, creates a believable backstory, and in general is just written better. So...4/10. Fosgitt really isn't improving much sadly.

>>25325336
Slight hope for this.
>>
File: 3601.jpg (195 KB, 720x960) Image search: [Google]
3601.jpg
195 KB, 720x960
>>25325336
Here's the three page preview for that.
>>
File: 3602.jpg (209 KB, 720x960) Image search: [Google]
3602.jpg
209 KB, 720x960
>>25325344
>>
>>25325238
She looks mildly retarded as well.
>>
>>25325321
4/10
The art really was just atrocious and took away from most of whatever message this was supposed to have, but at the same time it shitted up the potential for a decent story with Luna outright saying "you do think of me as an equal, as evidenced by a cake". I mean, seriously? Fucking seriously? It acts like Luna and Celestia never speak to each-other or something and Pinkie practically plays no role. Celestia could have done the exact same thing while bearing over a castle chef, and the lesson Pinkie learned is... nothing?
>>
well it wasn't insulting bad like some other issues it was also a lot of well.. nothing.
>>
File: 3603.jpg (195 KB, 720x960) Image search: [Google]
3603.jpg
195 KB, 720x960
>>25325350
>>
File: FF#23 cover for ants.jpg (87 KB, 317x480) Image search: [Google]
FF#23 cover for ants.jpg
87 KB, 317x480
>>25325336
>>25325361
Next month we get Friends Forever #23 featuring Applejack and Fluttershy:

My Little Pony: Friends Forever #23
>Ted Anderson (w) • Tony Fleecs (a) • Amy Mebberson (c) • Tony Fleecs (Subscription Variant Cover)
>Applejack and Fluttershy go camping! The serenity of nature is ruined when ponies travel from all over Equestria to catch a glimpse of the legendary Pigasus that is rumored to be in the area! Will our two ponies be able to get to bottom of the mystery... before pigs fly?
>>
>>25325275
>>25325278
TOO PSYCHEDELIC
>>
File: cover.jpg (117 KB, 962x1400) Image search: [Google]
cover.jpg
117 KB, 962x1400
>>25325366
Also the Luna book in the chapter books series came out today if any of you are interested in that:

My Little Pony: Princess Luna and the Festival of the Winter Moon
>"Princess Luna used to be the villainous Nightmare Moon. Now reformed, she's still getting used to palace life with her sister Celestia. Read more about fan-favorite character, Luna, in this original story."

http://www.mediafire.com/download/04d6brzitxi8aam/Princess+Luna+and+the+Festival+of+the+Winter+Moon.rar
>>
>>25325295
>wet and messy lesbian hugs
muh dick
>>
File: shiggy.png (112 KB, 448x377) Image search: [Google]
shiggy.png
112 KB, 448x377
>>25325366
>Written by Ted Anderson
>Drawn by Tony Fleecs

Welp, that's an easy skip.
>>
>>25325275
>>25325304
Celestia appears to have ptsd in the bottom left panels, dunno if the "artist" was going for that though.
>>
Didn't like the bipedal moments, which were prevalent, and inconsistent models. Though found a few expressions endearing at least.
>>
>>25325282
SIMBA
>>
>>25325373
Seriously guys; fucking read this. It's like a very similar story to this comic but done a thousand times better. It actually has interesting shit.
>>
File: lingam_004.jpg (113 KB, 579x850) Image search: [Google]
lingam_004.jpg
113 KB, 579x850
>>25325304
>it's a lingam
>just a fucking boring ass dome

What a shame
>>
File: RAGE.png (346 KB, 1000x563) Image search: [Google]
RAGE.png
346 KB, 1000x563
>>25325312
Did he just PHOTOSHOP a fucking whisk on that chef in the last panel?!
>>
>>25325297
Looks like a mess of legs tangled up.
>>
>>25325392
I was seriously having a hard time staying quiet while storytiming this time around.
Those poses were out of control, and that detail was just ridiculous
>>
>>25325336
>Whitlley's OC x Canon OTP saves the world electric boogaloo
I want this fandom to burn
>>
>>25325392
well actually drawing one would be too much work, clearly. Also noticed Twilight is wearing the wrong crown
>>
>>25325304
Looks like one big pile of dung. Good job Pinkie.
>>
File: 1297279355815-(n1301811445903).png (100 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
1297279355815-(n1301811445903).png
100 KB, 1024x768
>>25325392
Holy shit that's exactly what they did.
>>
>>25325399
Fosgitt did this before.
>>
>>25325392
The itunes blurriness is just making it look wired.
>>
Know what I just noticed adds to the weirdness of this art? He doesn't use any eye reflections at all. It makes them look like flat, dead eyes.
>>
>>25325350
>>25325361
Looks like Chrysalis is having second thoughts on helping Sombra. This is going to turn into a villains aiding the heroes because now a bigger threat endangers them won't it? At least until they are one shot as well just so Twi and/or Cadance can save the day.
>>
>>25325470
Well yeah, what he wants to do is completely defeating the reason why she joined up. It would be like if dictators teamed up and the senior partner in it wanted to nuke a country that was the whole point the junior partner joined up to begin with.
>>
>>25325373
I'm liking this so far.
>>
>>25325299
is that really a bunch of shitty OC's or are they references to pop culture I'm missing?
>>
>>25325445
Don't you defend him
>>
>>25325535
also, holy shit there's actually a cooked turkey on that banquet table. Which pony is eating meat??
>>
This comic is shit

SHIT
>>
>>25325548
>there's actually a cooked turkey on that banquet table
It's right next to alcohol too. This artist is ridiculous.
>>
>>25325559
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
I don't understand Fosgitt. I like a lot of his other art and most of it's clean and consistent. Why does he shit all over when he's making these comics? The weird poses, the inconsistent proportions, the lazy details...Just...Why?
>>
>>25325645
Apparently, Katie Cook and Andy Price defend him from any possible criticrism or backlash from IDW's staff.
>>
>>25325299
God fucking damn it
I'm listening to Luna voice as Friendship is Withcraft for no reason
>>
>>25325304
"Go eat a dick"
Someone should edit that.
>>
>>25325661
lol wut, why are you lying?
>>
>>25325155
The sketching themselves are whimsical and actually rather decent. It's the coloring that's godawful and shitty.
>>
>>25325486
And they just showed Sombra is powerless following one-shotting the princesses (for some reason) and Hope is a purely support type.

If Sombra turns her down here, WHAT is stopping Chrysalis from siccing her entire army on them again?

Hope's plan sucks and she sucks.
>>
>>25325715
Hope is incredibly dumb. I still wonder what her goal is. Be Sombra's queen while he rules over a kingdom of Umbrum eternally, I guess?
>>
File: ss (2015-11-03 at 10.08.49).png (105 KB, 291x239) Image search: [Google]
ss (2015-11-03 at 10.08.49).png
105 KB, 291x239
>>25325392
Is it just me or... http://www.clipartpanda.com/clipart_images/black-cooking-whisk-47160245

I mean... It's not just me right?
>>
>>25325722
They should've just fucked in front of Cadence and Twilight when he got revived and pulled out and shot his load into the princesses eyes. And then captured them while their eyes were stinging.
>>
>>25325350
For fuck's sake

SHE'S STANDING RIGHT THERE WITH THE BAG HOLDING THE CRYSTAL HEART. RIGHT NEXT TO THE CAGE.

Those bars are wide as a mile, why doesn't she hold Hope down and have Rarity or someone air-lift the Heart out, vaporize Sombra / heal Twilight's horn and be done with this nonsense? Fluttershy knows it's in that bag because she recognized the one Will came in with.

But fuck it that'd make too much sense, wouldn't it?
>>
>>25325749
No it's not. That is definitely it.
>>
>>25325760
I mean holy shit. I can't believe it, it's literally like 30 images or so down on a google search for 'whisk'
>>
>>25325778
It's a whole new level of not giving a shit.
>>
File: kek.png (297 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
kek.png
297 KB, 1280x720
>>25325749
JESUS FUCKING CHRIST
>>
>>25325778
The other cutie marks appear to be literally copy-pasted too, so corner-cutting to save a minute of work is a staple of this, it seems.

Heck, Celestia's looks like it wasn't even positioned correctly when it was pasted on. Probably the reason why every attempt is made not to make the marks visible using wings and poses.
>>25325223
>>
>>25325801
Bobby Curnow will say it's just a misunderstanding.
>>
>>25325749
That's literally the first result for cooking whisk clipart.

It looks so damn obvious too.
>>
File: ss (2015-11-03 at 10.08.49).png (79 KB, 291x239) Image search: [Google]
ss (2015-11-03 at 10.08.49).png
79 KB, 291x239
>>25325749
Literally 25 seconds.

I mean holy shit nigger this guy is a professional, what the fuck.
>>
>>25325749
You know that if that's a non-free clipart he CAN be sued for stealing someone else's intellectual property?
>>
>>25325754
how can one man be this autistic, holy shit
>>
>>25325840
>"Permission is granted to temporarily download one copy of the materials (information or software) on Clipart Panda's web site for personal, non-commercial transitory viewing only. This is the grant of a license, not a transfer of title, and under this license you may not:

modify or copy the materials;
use the materials for any commercial purpose, or for any public display (commercial or non-commercial);"
>>
File: middle pinger.jpg (28 KB, 141x168) Image search: [Google]
middle pinger.jpg
28 KB, 141x168
> filename
>>
>>25325866
...wat?
>>
File: images (15).jpg (14 KB, 219x311) Image search: [Google]
images (15).jpg
14 KB, 219x311
>>25325129
>Celestia as Chairman Kaga

Fuckimg beautiful
>>
>>25325866
Oh you just misquoted me and were aiming for >>25325842

And holy shit that is hilarious. Quick alert the authorities.
>>
>>25325877
That means Fosgitt stole clipart not meant to be used for commercial purposes.

This is a serious fuckup from both him and Bobby Curnow, as he is the one who approved this comic.
>>
File: not so smart.gif (904 KB, 500x347) Image search: [Google]
not so smart.gif
904 KB, 500x347
>>25325897
>>25325866
>>25325749
>>25325392

Literal art theft. Of something as simple as a fucking WHISK as a cutie mark. Holy shit my sides are gone.

Fosgitt needs to go, fucking hell. I can barely breathe right now.

OVER A FUCKING WHISK.
>>
File: whisk.png (132 KB, 564x468) Image search: [Google]
whisk.png
132 KB, 564x468
>>25325897
I wonder if they'll actually get flak for it. I mean, it's a super minor detail, but it's pretty a solid no no in any professional industry.
>>
File: kek.jpg (138 KB, 758x966) Image search: [Google]
kek.jpg
138 KB, 758x966
Welcome to IDW quality.

>>25325935
It's art theft, plain and simple. If it were a public domain thing it would be fine, but it's not.
>>
>>25325924
Just goes to show that Fosgitt is the laziest of cunts. Even worse than Fleecs.
>>
>>25325164
>luna's accomplishments over centuries
Great resume, be on the Moon for the last millenium and return promising eternal night.
>>
>>25325964
Maybe she's referring to the work that Luna did before being banished, which not getting recognition for helped fuel the Nightmare Moon change?
>>
File: 1411666850754.png (1 MB, 773x942) Image search: [Google]
1411666850754.png
1 MB, 773x942
>>25325299
>roasted turkey on table
>>
THIS COMIC IS SHIT

SHIT

S H I T
H
I
T
>>
File: IDW QUALITY.jpg (89 KB, 363x461) Image search: [Google]
IDW QUALITY.jpg
89 KB, 363x461
>>25325645
I dunno.
Bobby must know, yet he keeps his mouth shut for some reason.

It is a mystery.
>>
File: 1404099974292.png (285 KB, 550x550) Image search: [Google]
1404099974292.png
285 KB, 550x550
>>25325262
>dat bottom right panel
>>
Stolen whisk and crap compression aside, all of the cutie marks look like shitty copypasta of poorly resized raster images.

And this pose, jesus:
>>25325297

The ability to be a lazy fuck with an employer that'll rubber stamp whatever comes across their desk? Goddamn, Is IDW hiring?
>>
>>25325754
The heart needs to be recharged first dumb ass.
It was stolen the day BEFORE the crystal faire, aka BEFORE it got recharged.
>>
File: celestiaponktemplate.jpg (274 KB, 744x1305) Image search: [Google]
celestiaponktemplate.jpg
274 KB, 744x1305
>>25325262
Alright, do your worst
>>
File: 1446622584815.jpg (271 KB, 744x1305) Image search: [Google]
1446622584815.jpg
271 KB, 744x1305
>>25326309
77 trillion hours
>>
>>25325304
How phallic.
>>
>>25325312
I know Luna is smaller than Celestia, but she looks like a normal sized pony here.
>>
File: straw.png (104 KB, 218x224) Image search: [Google]
straw.png
104 KB, 218x224
>>25325297
Do i have cross-eyes or is that her neck?
>>
>>25325177
On /co/, we don't post in story times until they're complete, eh.
>>
>>25326600
a portion of her neck is being hidden by mane
>>
>>25325262
Ah Molestia, I knew you wouldn't abandon us in our time of need.
>>
File: 3yearsofphotoshopmadethis.png (1 MB, 744x1305) Image search: [Google]
3yearsofphotoshopmadethis.png
1 MB, 744x1305
>>25326309
On the sidenote, Celestia have detachable limbs.
That or this "professional" artist" just don't give a fuck.
>>
>>25325304
>>25325311
>>25326382
I know, it's glorious!
>>
>>25325350
>>25325361
Looks like we have us some dissension in the ranks.
King vs Queen fight, this gonna be good.
>>
File: lazy.png (2 MB, 1287x859) Image search: [Google]
lazy.png
2 MB, 1287x859
>>
>>25326612
On /co/, does anyone story time a comic with art as pure garbage as this? Seriously, this shit burns my fucking eyes. And these >>25325935 >>25325948
IDW should be embarrassed to have their name on this.
>>
File: atleastyoutried.png (3 MB, 1400x2154) Image search: [Google]
atleastyoutried.png
3 MB, 1400x2154
All too easy this issue. Why does cooking + Pinkie Pie = fucking disaster in IDW's comics?

(See the even more loathesome Pinkie/AJ comic for worse, but where the fuck is Curnow and why isn't he killing fuckups like this before they get to final layouts and heaven help us, publication?)

My opinion on what Jay should do next, in comicshoop form:
>>
>>25325361

Coloring glitch there on Radiant, who suddenly turns blacker than black in the bottom panel.

Though it's kinda cute in a dark elf meets unicorn way.
>>
File: CelestiaTriggered.jpg (109 KB, 809x412) Image search: [Google]
CelestiaTriggered.jpg
109 KB, 809x412
>>25325378
Yeah, I see it too. Celestia literally does have PTSD over Luna's banishment though.
>>
>>25325187
I was honestly expecting of the writer to do a Ramsay joke or a complete reference of it.
>>
>>25325239
It's not so weird since other ponies have verbs for names as well.
>>
>>25325251
Why would it? It's practically the best thing in the comic.
>>
>>25325299
Wine AND Turkey? Canterlot confirmed carnivorous drunks.
>>
>>25325312
>>25325321

I'll give it a 5/10.

The setting and story was a nice touch, as it shows more sisterly bonds that's four years late and such. She and Pinkie's scenes were nicely done, and the one pagers and spreadpagers were one of the better looking parts of the comic.

The bad bits was that the comic was a bit boring, both in dialogue and in length. Normally I have nothing bad to feel for Fogsitt's art since I'm probably one of the few who doesn't mind it at all, but in a lot of the panels, the art was all over the place, mostly noticable in the hind legs, head size and >>25325296, >>25325278 and >>25325159. The art is cheery, but I can see why it would turn some people off especially when viewed zoomed in. This >>25325749 though is unacceptable and just really lazy. I mean really, a copy paste for a small butt mark? Really?

Also adding, the look of the last cake was extremely underwhelming. Yes, I expected something simple, but I didn't expect it to be THAT boring.
>>
>>25325749
>>25325924
IDW and Jay Fosgitt twitter time?
>>
>>25327792
Someone should
>>
File: 2mininpaint.png (492 KB, 751x619) Image search: [Google]
2mininpaint.png
492 KB, 751x619
2 min in paint and I don`t know how to draw. A pro can't do it right?
>>
Has anyone tweeted IDW staff about the photoshopping or the comic in general?
>>
>>25326272
>>
File: 1443560218095.gif (3 MB, 260x195) Image search: [Google]
1443560218095.gif
3 MB, 260x195
>>25325749
>>
>>25327495

5/10? I would see it as much lower. a 2/10

The idea was ok, and the reasoning of the characters is good. But the dialogue is terrible written and dumb down many things. The art while cute, here and there, it's terrible in big doses with many stupid and weird anatomy here and there. Plus the Photoshop pasting of the cutie marks and if you include the stolen whisk clipart, shows how much that artist cares. IDW should fire that guy, or give him only cover art duties, and only on those weird variants.

My comment for this comic is what Luna is saying.
>>
Same anon >>25328101

I just had an idea, you know what would be much better? Celestia going to Pinkie, trying to learn to bake a cake because she wanted to have a small celebration after the banquet. We still have Pinkie shenanigans, Celestia having the same reason but making it more personal, a better moment between those 2 sisters, because right now is like Celestia was bored to bake, so she hired another pony to make a cake for her sister.
>>
File: comic_edit.jpg (179 KB, 744x926) Image search: [Google]
comic_edit.jpg
179 KB, 744x926
>>25326309
>>
>>25327919
I don't have a Twitter. Someone please reveal his clipart theft and question him and IDW with the pics >>25325948
And
>>25325935 made. Please I need this.
>>
>>25325299

To celebrate your birthday we invited in every random freak, weirdo and loonie we could find on the streets.
>>
File: lefthoof.png (981 KB, 744x926) Image search: [Google]
lefthoof.png
981 KB, 744x926
>>25326309
The art is shitty on this comic
>>
File: 1446622584815.jpg (229 KB, 741x772) Image search: [Google]
1446622584815.jpg
229 KB, 741x772
>>25328364
Methinks somebody's getting unwarranted money for shite final product.
>>
>>25328485
Redlining Fosgitt would be a Herculean task. What's weird is that none of his non pony art is this bad. He just gives no fucks about it.
>>
It's an odd feeling that for once I'm looking forward more to the main series than the FFs. Not by much, but still.
>>
>>25328527
Next FF means more shit art and stories. Understandable.
>>
>>25328509
I think he's just not considering that he's supposed to actually draw (miniature) horses, not humanoid sorta generic cartoon creature.
>>
>>25328577
There's a stylization limit that was passed. These look like humans in pony costumes.
>>
File: 1015077.gif (2 MB, 480x270) Image search: [Google]
1015077.gif
2 MB, 480x270
>>25328364
Maybe her left hoof is incredible long?
>>
Anyone contacted IDW over clipart theft?
>>
File: 005.jpg (970 KB, 1040x1600) Image search: [Google]
005.jpg
970 KB, 1040x1600
>>25325187
>Ramsay

Already done.
>>
>>25326680
they look like pigs
>>
>>25328793

He looks cute.
>>
>>25325312
>>25325321
Beside the art, it would've been an okay but mediocre issue.

And I actually like the basics of Fosgitt's style, but if he can't even draw consistently and keeps putting in human poses and stock clipart cutie marks...

It was just bad.
>>
File: molly time.jpg (442 KB, 744x1305) Image search: [Google]
molly time.jpg
442 KB, 744x1305
>>
File: idwanker.png (226 KB, 423x601) Image search: [Google]
idwanker.png
226 KB, 423x601
>>25327495
>>
File: legs2.png (985 KB, 741x772) Image search: [Google]
legs2.png
985 KB, 741x772
>>25328485
Look at the part under her armour, is it fat?
>>
>>25325321
I think it's a bit autistic to constantly bitch about "too much human poses" in a cartoon, and that very well translates to comics here. Don't get me wrong, a lot of the anatomy in this comic was completely fucked but not because it was "too human"; moreso that certain actions did not translate well and made limbs look awkward.

Further more, holy fucking shit the immediate knee-jerk reaction toward a clipart cutiemark. Seriously? I laughed at that, because I took into consideration that just maybe it was intended as a gag. But in the interest of fairness, yeah sure it would help if somebody tweeted them to find out what the deal was.

Overall I'd give it a 7/10. Comfy and safe story bogged down by questionable art design choices.

>>25329017
I don't have image editing software, but I think that and the patch just south east of it under the wing was supposed to be her foreleg.
>>
>>25329036
Oh hai, it's you again.

Came back from more after yesterday's lastest failed derailment attempts, eh?
>>
File: SmugTwi.png (469 KB, 3000x3254) Image search: [Google]
SmugTwi.png
469 KB, 3000x3254
>>25329094
Just stopped by to participate in open discussion and sharing my opinion freely. :^)
If -that's- what's considered thread derailment, then I know I'm doing something right.
>>
>>25329152
Haha, it IS you again.

Please, keep telling everyone how this is pure gold and how we are all autistic for not agreeing with you.
I'm preeeety sure that will help to boost the comic's sales and save Fosgitt's ass.
>>
File: Keep sucking.png (815 KB, 1099x821) Image search: [Google]
Keep sucking.png
815 KB, 1099x821
>>25329255
>7/10 is pure gold
>Criticized the disjointed awkward art
>>
>>25329302
7/10 is above average. Do you think this comic was above average?
>>
>>25329036
There's a limit to how disjointed the art can be, don't you think?
>>
http://www.equestriadaily.com/2015/11/mlp-friends-forever-22-released-today.html#idc-container

And the shilling show goes on...

>>25329302
7/10 means it was 70% good.
>>
>>25325242
I'm digging the Yellow Submarine cake there.

Also, did she just wrap a bunch of books together and call it a cake? Or is it just a cake that looks exactly like a bunch of books wrapped together?
>>
>>25329335
Who the fuck is this Silver Quill guy?
>>
File: wtfair.png (794 KB, 1092x1073) Image search: [Google]
wtfair.png
794 KB, 1092x1073
>>
>>25325159
Holy shit this Celestia just disgust me. Fostgitt cant draw for shit.
>>
>>25325179
>Pinkie/Celestia Friends Forever team up
>Celestia leave Pinkie after 7 pages
>>
>>25329373
The way that she's sitting...

ew
>>
>>25329353
A self proclaimed "reviewer" and self appointed Internet SuperStar who's on Equestria Daily's shilling payroll.
>>
>>25329313
>>25329335
I'm using the American measurement where 70% is about average. Whatever the case, yes for me the positives outweighed the negatives and I felt this comic was about average/slightly above average.

>>25329323
Did not break my immersion excessively, but then I'm not judging it solely on the art and I liked the story.
>>
File: shillshill.png (187 KB, 614x382) Image search: [Google]
shillshill.png
187 KB, 614x382
>>
>>25329406
Why exactly this comic deserves an above average rating?
Please explain it without using personal preferences and subjective claims, as you are trying to apply your own rating as something everyone should accept.
>>
>>25329353
>>25329399
I wouldn't really call SQ an obvious shill. If an issue has problems he'll always mention them. At the very least he's a step up from people like DrForrester who I've never seen dislike any issue.
>>
>>25325297
I have no fucking idea where are her forelegs
>>
>>25325299
Oh yay, a fucking reference to Three Stooges. Is sooooooo original, no one ever made this reference before!
>>
>>25329350
I just assumed it was a lot of fondant. Pic related is a cake.
>>
>>25329434
Even when he's criticrizing something, he always sugarcoats it while downplays the flaws and overblows the positive aspects.

Shill it is.
>>
File: FFFF.png (80 KB, 326x293) Image search: [Google]
FFFF.png
80 KB, 326x293
>>25329421
>Please explain it without using personal preferences and subjective claims, as you are trying to apply your own rating as something everyone should accept.
Are you being serious right now? Are you literally saying I need to define my interpretation of this comic in an objective manner, insinuating that I am somehow telling others they have to agree with me, and then insist that my -personal- opinion is somehow objectively wrong by implying I should give it the same rating everyone else is giving it? Because not liking Fostgitt's artstyle totally isn't personal taste, and believing there should never be human poses is in no way subjective at all?
>>
>>25325312
>>25325321
I think it's time to stop making those Story Time threads, anon. Put this episode behind us and forget about mlp comics. I completely lost any interest in it and i was the one who used to defend Reflections.
>>
>>25329468
Go back to Equestria Daily if you can't stomach the idea of somebody disagreeing with you.
>>
https://twitter.com/JayPFosgitt

He hasn't said jack about the stolen clipart.
>>
File: this is you.jpg (59 KB, 325x295) Image search: [Google]
this is you.jpg
59 KB, 325x295
>>25329468
>>
>>25325373
I don't care about Luna so nah.

Also the Dsicord book had not any influnece over the series, so it's as pointless as the comics. The only reason to read it is to find any clues for future episodes since Berrow already seen the scripts when writing these books.
>>
>>25325282
KILL THEM PINKIE
KILL THEM ALL
>>
>>25329522
Fair enough. I like the books and comics cause I enjoy the cute little things I can get from them. Any of the other things are a bonus.
Plus I like how they pull from each other. Even if the show's probably never going to take from either of them.
>>
File: haha oh wow.png (125 KB, 639x350) Image search: [Google]
haha oh wow.png
125 KB, 639x350
>>25329492
>>25329521
Typical response, as would be expected.
>>
File: What a bait.png (41 KB, 593x489) Image search: [Google]
What a bait.png
41 KB, 593x489
>>25329409
>>
>>25329492
Actually, you know what? Your response is especially hilarious considering the reaction -I'm- getting because I'm disagreeing with people.
>>
File: the cold truth.jpg (26 KB, 369x231) Image search: [Google]
the cold truth.jpg
26 KB, 369x231
>>25329546
>>
>>25329541
I've always enjoyed the chapter books. I mean they're meh to decent in quality but it's fun reading them.
>>
>>25329556
i can use reaction images too!
>>
>>25329541
Book are not canon and without any art. So is literally like buying a generic story from fimfiction.
>>
>>25325142
I hate The new art style. It's like artyl on drugs. Celestia's head looks awful.
>>
File: Bend over.png (403 KB, 664x792) Image search: [Google]
Bend over.png
403 KB, 664x792
>>25329564
>>25329569
>He selects from his reaction folder yet another "clever" image
>Fingers a tremble from the frayed nerves that somebody would dare disrupt his comfort zone
>He tries doing the captcha, but the anxiety causes slip-ups and he keeps needing to redo them
>Finally getting it right, he hits the post button
>His voice cracks as he squeals out a reluctant giggle, the image upload percentage climbing upward building his anticipation
>The post submits, he wipes the profuse grease and sweat from his brow and gives a sheepish grin
>"T-that'll teach that bully to invade my safe space!" he declares aloud to the dark and empty room, but tentatively as he is unsure of his victory.
>>
>>25329589
It's more canon and in continuity than the comics because it's written by a show writer who gets scripts in advance.
>>
>>25329606
Hey. Play nice with other Anons Anon.
>>
>>25329606
:3
>>
>>25329628
Are you stupid or really can't see he's samefagging so he could pretend he's winning an internet discussion against some random 4channer?
>>
>>25329628
Just a bit of banter, m8. Hav'n a giggle with fellow anons pokin' a bit of fun, no harm intended :^)

>>25329636
Luv yu bby <3
>>
>>25329409
All shilling aside, he's right about that one. Comical expressions is one thing Fosgitt does right.
>>
>>25329649
>using the term 4channer

You are not from here.

Return to where you came from Outsider.
>>
This artist is like the liefeld of the pony universe. And on 4 legs is his Achilles heel.
>>
>>25329709
No anon, he's just a discount atryl wannabe.
>>
>>25329673
Nice damage control: exposing yourself on your samefagging but using the "wrong" wording so you could try convince everryone to dismiss the samefagging claim.

Talking, arguing and defending yourself: you are a very special case of a forever alone guy.
>>
>>25325321
3/10
The art was terrible and the dialogue forced and retarded towards the end. Plot was a nice concept but could have been handled better.

The problems were too significant for me to enjoy it.
>>
What a fucking shit comic, story is bullshit, the art is absolute shite and then the artist is so lazy he photoshops clipart into it instead of drawing
Does Hasbro simply not have any QA to screen and filter this garbage or what, Jesus Christ.
>>
>>25325948
I knew something looked incredibly off about that. Holy shit.
>>
>>25325321
eh/10
>>
File: I did it all, adagio.gif (846 KB, 600x412) Image search: [Google]
I did it all, adagio.gif
846 KB, 600x412
>>25325312
>>25325392
>>25325749
>>25325924
Are you fucking kidding me?
I'm sorry, but is this fucking reality right now?
I'm probably overeating right now, but did they seriously use some non commercial vector of a fucking whisk picture to put it on the flank of Chase as his fucking cutie mark?!?
Is this fucking mean we actually have a legit prove to make a change for the IDW comics of MLP for fucking really?
Again, excuse me if I type like a faggot, but my mind is destroyed right now by this absolute nonprofessionalism, this is a new level of fucked up.
I can only legitimately see people do it for a homework in the University when they are at last minute, and again...
>>
>>25331530
>I'm probably overeating right now
I know what you meant to type but I still kek'd. Seriously though I'm just as upset as you and I think he needs to be confronted about this.
>>
Awful artist is awful. If they want to draw walking on two legs go back to humans or furries.
>>
HQ rips

http://tu____sfiles._____net/q70mazv6ah1s
>>
>>25332429
Pass on the bad art.
>>
>>25325749
Absolutely disgusting.
>>
>>25325373
Oh shit, it has Tiberius in it!
>>
>>25333810
She also has two owls.
>>
>>25333810
Also Luna understands manticore, a reference to the Journal of Two Sisters.
>>
Bemp
>>
>>25325373
According to this book, she met her 2 batpony guards when she settled a dispute when she was a young princess.

So those guards of hers are 1000+ years old which I guess makes sense if they're supposed to be vampire analogs.
>>
>>25334262
Or they hibernated or something.
>>
>>25332429
thank
>>
>>25334262
Or they know the secret to longevity- shoving carrots up your asshole every day.

Or they know bullshit magic like Radiant Hope/Mirror Sombra/whatever other bullshit OC survives thousands of years and several generations without actually aging a day.
>>
File: 1444088318498.jpg (87 KB, 900x846) Image search: [Google]
1444088318498.jpg
87 KB, 900x846
>>25331530
>I'm probably overeating right now

then put down the goddamn fork there, porkins
>>
>>25336729
This. The characters ARE horses. Stop drawing them as midget humans.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 101

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.