[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
He was actually pretty based CSA wanted to turn America into
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 37
Thread images: 7
File: image.jpg (37 KB, 384x384) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
37 KB, 384x384
He was actually pretty based

CSA wanted to turn America into an English spesking Brazil
>>
CSA was the most idiotic thing. Practically none of the seceding states held any referendum, and the couple that did had massive, MASSIVE voter intimidation. The CSA had to draft like crazy just to fight, because few wanted to fight that ridiculous war waged purely for slave owners (who were a tiny fraction of the Southern population), and the North didn't have to follow suit to keep up until years later, which would be the first time in history the U.S. used the draft.

Abraham Lincoln was absolutely based. Shame his family didn't blossom into a dynasty.
>>
>>1284242
>Abraham Lincoln was absolutely based. Shame his family didn't blossom into a dynasty.
Monarchism is the most un-American thing in the universe.
>>
>>1284242
>North didn't have to follow suit to keep up until years later

Both sides started drafting in 1862, fuckhead.
>>
>>1284281
Political dynasties are pretty American though
>>
File: image.jpg (40 KB, 297x420) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
40 KB, 297x420
>>1284242
The Union drafted more people than the Confederate States

Almost all white folks in the North did not support the Civil War nor the Union, most people didn't care about slaves, just Rabbi Lincoln
>>
>>1284292
The Union act only authorized state draft for states who failed quota, the Confederate act drafted everyone between 18 and 35 (exempting anyone who owned twenty or more slaves), extended to 17 and 50 by 1864. The union didn't pass such an act until 1863.
>>
File: df.jpg (50 KB, 850x400) Image search: [Google]
df.jpg
50 KB, 850x400
>>1284324
The South didn't just get fussy over having slavery, they seceded because the North wouldn't support slavery. For instance, one of their non-ngeociaable demands in the days leading up to the secession, was that all Northern states would compel return of escaped slaves. This, however, fell short of their main demand, which was that there be an amendment to the Constitution recognizing slavery.

The CSA were traitors. The United States was built on treason against the king (pic related), and the CSA managed to go further and commit treason against the abstract nation that took the king's place.
>>
>>1284333
So? Given the difference in available manpower between them, it's amazing the North needed a draft at all, let alone so soon after the South started doing it.
>>
>>1284359
The South drafted every able bodied male who didn't own a ton of slaves. Sure they had a smaller population, but that's still an awful lot of manpower to combat with purely volunteers
>>
>>1284350
>treason against the king
That's not treason.
That's glory.
>>
>>1284393
That's objectively treason. Just because you find treason glorious, does not preclude it being treason.
>>
>>1284396
Your posts are treason to serious discussion.
>>
>>1284393
Still treason though.
>>
IMO Reconstruction didn't go nearly far enough. The Radical Republicans were totally right to treat the South as a breakaway province, and even then they were too kind.

White southerners should have been forced to pay a portion of their income to the federal government for a hundred years to pay for the Civil War. They should have been forced to retake oaths of loyalty to the union, and every Southern soldier should have been branded in the aftermath of the surrender at Appomattox. They should have been conscripted into chain gangs and forced to rebuild both Southern and Northern cities.

Basically they should have been knuckled under. They should have been treated like the conquered people they were. Northerners should have treated Southerners like the British treated the Irish. They should have been stooped and broken, made into a whipped and conquered people. Maybe if they had been, America wouldn't be such a mess these days.
>>
>>1284502
I've always fantasized about a southern version of the IRA. Almost makes me wish your proposition came to pass.
>>
>>1284193
Too bad he died before he was able to get the majority of Africans to repatriate to Africa(or anywhere but here) as he desperately wanted.

Maybe JW Booth's most vicious act in retaliation for the war was to curse America with free blacks for all time.

>import 400,000
>now are 40,000,000
And what a joy they are.
>>
>>1284502
Yes lets treat the south exactly how Germany was treated post WWI, since that turned out wonderful.
>>
>>1284502
>South, PLEASE rebel again and take this universal justification too
>>
>>1284575
So that they elect a nutcase who leads them to another war with the North, where they lose again but this time get blasted back into the stone age and permanently shamed from ever thinking the Confederacy or slavery was a good idea ever again?

Germany had to burn for it to be reborn and is now the pinnacle of European democracy and capitalism. Shame the South has yet to accomplish much past the Confederacy aside from College Football dynasties, barbecue and hilariously backward living caricatures. The North was too soft.
>>
File: 55.png (65 KB, 500x391) Image search: [Google]
55.png
65 KB, 500x391
>>1284609
Merkel please, it's too early to be b8posting
>>
>>1284542
The plan would've had super big issues.
Vast majority of Blacks did not want to leave and wanted to be equal citizens along with the colonization pilot projects being a total failure.

Stating another conflict is not a good idea especially one that turns you into the bad guy.
>>
>>1284650
Should have put more effort in educating and integrating blacks instead of subjecting them to Jim Crow segregation and institutional racism for 100 years. But you already made up your mind, blacks are inherently inferior so why bother making them respectable members of society? Revisionists and racist apologists say this shit when they damn well know they did not do a damn to stop it so they look back and say "why haven't the blacks progressed?" Slavery and segregation reaped what it sowed.
>>
File: sherman goes wee wee.png (75 KB, 356x293) Image search: [Google]
sherman goes wee wee.png
75 KB, 356x293
>>1284583
And get to fry dixie twice? I'll take these odds
>>
>>1284502

With malice toward none and charity for all, dickhead.

>>1284609

because a few hundred thousand more deaths in a guerilla war over cultural practices would totally be worth it? Racism was thoroughly woven not just into Southern culture but American culture as a whole, and it had support from the scientific community at the time.
>>
>>1284609
>Germany had to burn for it to be reborn and is now the pinnacle of European democracy and capitalism.

Gonna have to troll harder than that shit son.
>>
>>1284671
You don't seem to understand that the North dictated how the Gov'ts of the south were run post civil war, but did little to nothing to help blacks to ensure that they would be given an equal standing post reconstruction.


The fact is the North as a whole was only slightly less racist in its polices with black people than the southerners were at the time.
>>
>>1284406
>le no arguments answer
>>
File: draft-riot-no-draft-7.16.13[1].jpg (309 KB, 749x653) Image search: [Google]
draft-riot-no-draft-7.16.13[1].jpg
309 KB, 749x653
Remember kids, it's not slavery if they're drafted FOB immigrants!

http://picosong.com/ZDnL
>>
>>1284193
How was he "pretty based"? What he did was the definition of going with the flow.
>>
>>1284242
Where did you read this? It isn't correct, so I'm curious as to what your source is.
>>
>>1284350
They seceded because they didn't have the North's support in expanding slavery. Do you know how many letters there are written by Lincoln condoning slavery, or at least saying, "No senpai we won't touch your slaves just come with us"?
>>
>>1284242
>a bunch of poor peasant farmers would die just to see rich people have slaves
wew
>>
>>1284350
>The CSA were traitors. The United States was built on treason against the king (pic related), and the CSA managed to go further and commit treason against the abstract nation that took the king's place.

All revolutions are illegitimate until force and time makes it so. The Cuban exiles in Florida may still be salty, but at this point the Cuban government is legitimate, so that's that.
>>
>>1284755
But even being slightly less racist made all the difference. Northern Blacks are noticeably more educated and wealthier than Blacks in the Southern US.

The South fucked up hard by enforcing Jim Crow bullshit instead of just integrating the slave populace as best they could have.
>>
>>1284324
>Almost all white folks in the North did not support the Civil War nor the Union, most people didn't care about slaves, just Rabbi Lincoln

baseless claim because the Republican Party was founded on the Abandonment of the Whig Party and Free Soil Party (Which anti slavery was a huge platform for them) and placed for John C Fremont AKA The Pathfinder in 1856 who carried a majority of the Northern Vote and lost only because of the Know-nothing Party splitting the vote. His platform in 1856 "Free Soil, Free Men, and Fremont." It is self evident that the initial founding of the Republican Party was anti-slavery. This Northern Carry again happened in 1860.

John C Fremont established the first emancipation of Slaves in the West in 1860/61.

John Bigelow, Nathaniel P. Banks, and Henery Wilson were also advocates of anti-slavery.

As for support for the Civil War in the North, in the early years recruitment was easy like all wars with an established Casus Belli (Or perceived if you're a southernboo) but like all war as it edges on War Exhaustion becomes a real thing as prevalent in Vietnam, WW II, Iraq War 2.0, Afghanistan War, Rhodesian Bush War,French-Algerian War, War of the 3rd Coalition etc.

This war exhaustion lead to draft riots in Ohio and Pennsylvania. In order to make quota, one can easily say the Emancipation Proclamation was used to boost recruitment numbers by adding blacks to the recruitment list.

>tl:dr

you're an ignorant faggot who needs to read more.
>>
File: riots-01[1].jpg (123 KB, 600x515) Image search: [Google]
riots-01[1].jpg
123 KB, 600x515
>>1287017

>but like all war as it edges on War Exhaustion

Are you really going to call the largest race riot in US history the result of mere "war fatigue?"
Thread replies: 37
Thread images: 7

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.