I'm sure people will disagree, but that's kinda what the thread is for.
Make alterations, add channels, make a list of /his/ preferred historia channels, based on accuracy, information and interestingness.
>>1214603
What are the top ones called?
>>1214612
in order.
Historia Civilis, Lindy Beige.
Where is HH? I know it's a bit of a meme podcast but it's very well researched and a great introduction to the topics he discusses
Also, just wondering why you put The Great War at good tier. Is it because they don't go into much depth? I personally love their Out of the Trenches and Where Were They episodes.
>>1214615
I agree on Historia Civilis, I just wish he'd make some more videos
The /his/ YT king obviously
>>1214629
It's a podcast right? Is it on youtube?
>>1214603
label them or else that is completely useless
Lindy "the way that Trojan laced his sandals in Troy is not historical" Beige
>>1214640
Oh I'm sorry, I thought it was just /his/ related content in general. Never mind my incompetence then
Sargon of Akkad is god tier
>>1214657
He doesn't talk half as much about history as he talks about current events.
>>1214603
Switch Lindy and Matt around, lindy has sprouted to much unsourced and incorrect bullshit.
>>1214644
uh huh, source?
>>1214660
I disagree, Lindy has spouted a lot of unsourced stuff, but it has always been blatant that it was not meant to be stated as fact. Lindy is good at making clear when he's talking consensus in the field and when he's just shooting a hypothesis out there for discussion. I believe that matt is neither more knowledgeable, nor is he as entertaining.
>>1214657
Sargon of Akkad is shit tier when he talks on current events and absolute wretched bile tier when he talks on history.
>>1214637
>>1214647
Have you tried out their self-produced Alain du Button-approved porn?
You know, for more philosophical wanking (not that all of TSOL-material isn't, but in this case, literally).
>>1214647
Hardcore History is objectively better than ERB, CC, or EH
Stop memeing
>>1214667
>uh, huh, source?
it was joke, you autist
>>1214693
idgi.
Is there any of these that covers WW2?
>>1214647
Why is TGW borderline, also, just checked out Lindy Beige's channel and it's like GoT and Dr Who stuff, what gives?
Lindybeige is probably around decent level. He's not an expert in anything, has zero formal education on most of the topics he speaks on, and rarely ever cites any sources (might not matter ultimately but I thought it should be pointed out). There's a few things he gets wrong and a couple videos are absolutely atrocious, but there are a couple other videos that I personally like. Example of his misinformation, on one of several incorrect information in his 3-minute video "A point about bows" he says you can't have a more powerful bow because power is entirely dependent on the man but that's simply not true because you can have improvements of design that make the bow faster regardless of weight, i.e. more powerful.
Fixed
>>1214760
>Real Crusades History
>good tier
May as well chuck some afrocentrist channels in while we're at it
>>1214732
because the image wasn't made by a qualified historian, but a guy who wanted to put on his favourite channels
>>1214774
>sources his shit
What faith are you?
>>1214779
>sources his shit
and?
Oh and I'm a Sunni Seljuk from 1099; that's the sole reason why I don't think a youtube channel is very good. In case your wondering, I'm also a cultural marxist intent on destroying the west.
>>1214790
>Oh and I'm a Sunni Seljuk from 1099; that's the sole reason why I don't think a youtube channel is very good. In case your wondering, I'm also a cultural marxist intent on destroying the west.
You can drop the sarcasm you faggot, or are you being serious.
>>1214737
I'd like to rescind my statement; Lindybeige should actually be shit tier.
>>1214795
Oh I'm being serious. I am actually a Seljuk from 1099.
>>1214803
>I am actually a Seljuk from 1099.
Don't lie you fag.
>>1214723
But the comment you're responding to is inaccurate.
>>1214807
I dunno man I think he's telling the truth.
>>1214813
I think he's a lying atheist who reaps off the back of people who defended the land
THE ABSOLUTE BEST, NO MEMES, WANNA ACTUALLY FUCKING LEARN SOMETHING? WATCH THIS GUY
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmmMFJIKfsSLNVxA55Kt42Q
>>1214817
I think IT'S POLITICAL CORRECTNESS GONE MAD THE BANKERS THE BONUSES
>>1214823
>supporting heresy
Anon why you gotta do this?
>>1214826
Because slaanesh is a qt
>>1214818
>yet another channel about Greece and Rome and the Middle Ages
ugh I'm so tired of this stereotypical white male history I can't even. where is the African history? where is the Asian history?
>>1214833
>wanting to be a fucktoy for a God
>or a fucktoy for Dark Eldar
No, stop that.
>>1214835
>white male history
Did greece and rome fail because there were no women?
>>1214774
Never seen one person who dislikes his channel because they found a flaw in his evidence, it's always because they don't like the truth.
>>1214647
Lindybeige above Schola Gladiatoria? Do you just not care about HEMA or are you actually that retarded?
>>1214923
I don't see the weaponry discussion as necessarily the most interesting. I also don't believe lindy is generally as wrong as people claim.
>>1214927
So you're saying it's totally your subjective opinion (I don't like + I believe) and I shouldn't bother discussing it, right?
Seems totally pointless to do a chart based this, but hey it's your time.
>>1214667
>Consensus
Linthorax was glued
Pikemen never fought each other in melee combat
Horses don't charge people
>>1214942
No, I believe based on evidence/lack of evidence. And as stated in the OP, these are encouraged to be altered if you disagree, it's supposed to be /his/ list, not mine, I just took the first step.
>>1214954
>Linthorax was glued
>Pikemen never fought each other in melee combat
>Horses don't charge people
all of them blatantly stated as being hypothesis against the general belief in the videos.
>>1214818
this
>>1214970
How so? I watched those videos ages ago and I seem to recall that he said something along the lines of: Some people believe, quite wrongly, that X happened. Haha no they are not right pikemen fighting each other would be suicidal and therefore they didn't do it.
He doesn't even seem to adres where this idea came from nor what sources people use to defend to consensus.
Whats wrong with Skallagrim?
>>1214994
His accent and audience I think.
>>1214884
>falling for the bait
>>1214603
I don't there's a single god-tier history channel, and if there is, Lindy doesn't belong up there.
>>1214603
Seriously why does everyone here seem to hate cc?Please explain.
>>1214657
Sargon has a history channel where he reads historical texts. Cant remember its name though
>>1214657
Angry neckbeard whose "epic points" take hours to be made
literally shitty teetering alt right memer too scared to go full /pol/
>>1215092
Yeah I don't get it either. It's by definition not meant to be a detailed and nuanced look into history - it's literally just giving you a very brief overview of time periods for the sake of quick digestion.
>>1214672
lewd
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCK09g6gYGMvU-0x1VCF1hgA
Mil history channel is ok. Tends to only use one source but pretty decent.
>>1215092
It's mainly the liberal bias and distortion of facts to suit said bias.
>>1215107
It's called Ancient recitations.
His audiobooks of the communist manifesto and the prince are great.
I liked that video about the crusades that he made but i don't know too much about the crusades so i don't know how accurate it was.
>>1215110
> He thought this was decent bait
>>1214657
cuckold of mossad is a literal male that can say "My wife's child"
>>1215171
But he's correct, Sargon is a faggot.
>>1214884
That bait wasn't even enticing. You'd never last as a fish
>>1214657
the problem with sargon is that he preches to the choir, and the kind of people he tends to respond to are the type of people who just plug their ears with their fingers and screm "lalalala I cant hear you shitlord!", thus, nobody gains anything by watching his content
but I will say that he shines when he analyses people, like that black homo who makes videos, Steve Shives, Melissa Click and the black kid who shut down Milo´s talk
what about metatron and knight errant?
>>1214603
Good list, but you should change two things. The Great War should not be so low, and john green should get his own tier below shit tier.
>>1215149
Cool. Can anyone bring examples?
I like crash course. Sometimes its a little too liberal revisionist, but having grown up in a very conservative environment with a eurocentristic view on history, its a good separate point of view.
>>1214603
>Real Crusades History is good
Said no historian ever
Nobody mentioned History Buffs? It's a youtube channel where this guy grades historical movies on both drama/acting ect but also on the authenticity of the film. I'm not expert, but he tends to give an even handed view of history, and calls out historical revisionism when it's just there to appeal to modern sensibilities.
>>1215317
What is your faith?
Why is everyone rating The Great War and Real Crusaded History so low? Are they inaccurate?
I've just started The Great War and was going to Real Crusades after...
>>1215327
Cuckolds who hate Europe and want it to fall to Islam anon. That's why.
>>1215327
There are many muslims on here
>>1215327
they're fucking retarded fucking lefty cucks.
Sure, they may be "educated", but all that says to me is that they're bluepilled and brainwashed.
For example, just look at all the students supporting Bernie cuck Sanders.
>>1215327
The Great War is good. Real Crusades History isn't actually history, it's just ideology pushing.
>>1215342
>he isn't a fucking Catholic
>he's a fucking Muslim
>>1215342
no it's not.
You're just bluepilled and retarded, in other words, shut up you're wrong cuck.
>>1215342
>ERB
Why is that even on there? ERB has like no goal of actually educating people, it's like complaining that Danger 5 mislead you on WWII.
>>1214657
Lmao!
What the fuck just happened to this thread?
ITT: Lefties blown. the. fuck. out.
>>1215389
Us /pol/lacks BTFO'd some lefty numales who tried to derail discussion with their anti-west bullshit.
>>1215396
This is what Christianity watered down to, a fucking alt right shilling
>>1215384
How do you feel about the Pope.
>>1215403
Christianity has always been on the alternative right you shill
>>1215344
>there's literally only two religious beliefs in this world
mcfucking kill yourself
>>1215389
Muslims. It's always the Muslims.
>>1215396
It's so nice to see the impotent rage of the scum of society, knowing you will never provoke any reaction other than laughter.
You are a bigger joke than Black Hebrews.
i dont even know that what happened in this thread was trolling or legitimate retardation
>>1215409
>supporting Islam
>>1215416
>not supporting the one truth faith revealed to man by Allah through his prophet, Muhammad(pbuh)
Do you want to suffer the lake of fire, kaffir?
>>1215413
t. butthurt
>>1215422
>>1215426
Look all around you.
We're winning.
We will win.
Your women are mixing with black men.
Your laws mean nothing anymore, cultural relativism is the law. Marxism is the law. Degeneracy is the law.
We won.
We have made slaves out of you.
>>1215448
>We
>>1215429
That is some incredibly facetious bullshit
>>1215452
Some of us are Jewish, some of us are yellow, black, brown and yes, even some white people realise we are working towards improving mankind. You will not stop History's tide, the Flood which will purge this world.
>>1215458
>BTFO
>>1215464
JIDF pls
>>1215465
Trump is just a mere toy to us. As is Hilary, as is Sanders.
All of you shall be working on our tea plantations.
>>1215465
It saddens me to think you're more than likely genuine in these beliefs.
>>1214603
where is filthyfrank?
>>1215471
Jebediah, it's better if they find out for themselves, the surprise will be grander.
>>1215485
>jebediah
Good Chap ;)
I entirely doubt the anglo has anything to do with this B)
>>1215429
Random stripes and points
Thats not how you spell chi xi digamma
(ΧΞϜ)
>>1215662
There really is no point in you lying, satanist
>>1215378
>>1215465
Ayy you faggot white supremacist are no better then SJWs. You're both are failures who us resort to conspiracies against you group as an excuse for the fact that your are wastes of air who will never amount to anything in life. ZOG = Patriarchy you fucking insecure faggots. Is the only thing you've ever accomplished in life being white? If so, Then you should kill your fucking self like adolf did when he realized his ideology was doomed to fail.
>>1215327
Its really not bad and it goes into more depth than most documentarys on the subject. They don't portray one side as the good guys as much which is rare for some reason
>>1215378
>>1215365
>>1215390
>>1215410
>>1215448
>>1215452
>>1215736
>Is the only thing you've ever accomplished in life being white?
Also not being a cuyck, so at least two things here.