[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Glorious Celts>Stupid Romans
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /his/ - History & Humanities

Thread replies: 80
Thread images: 16
File: image.jpg (176 KB, 640x980) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
176 KB, 640x980
Glorious Celts>Stupid Romans
>>
>>1087275
Type that in your own alphabet you forest cuck.
>>
>>1087277

>romans invented the phoenician alphabet
>>
>>1087275
>amazing warriors
>lost to the Romans
>somehow still better warriors?
>>
File: facebag.jpg (99 KB, 768x576) Image search: [Google]
facebag.jpg
99 KB, 768x576
>>1087275
This sounds weird but I always see Celts as a Tolkien-esque race of magical people (think elves) that died or slowly lost their magical quality, being absorbed by the (human) Roman populace. Probably because there's not much history written about them and they seem generally enigmatic.

Anybody else have this autistic outlook on a group of people in the past?
>>
>>1087364
Romans were soldiers, Celts were warriors.
>>
I'm no we wuz, but the modern perception that Celts were "nordic looking" is a misconception. I'm no anthropologist but it's actually sensible to believe they were more, shall I say middle eastern looking, for lack of a better description.

I know the modern day Brits want to play the we wuz celts n shiet, but it's not so.
>>
>>1087378
pretty sure Tolkien did
>>
>>1087384
I thought Brits preferred the we wuz Germanics line of thought
>>
File: FU6GNV5.jpg (25 KB, 290x387) Image search: [Google]
FU6GNV5.jpg
25 KB, 290x387
>>1087384
Welsh and Irish people can be dark as hell sometimes.
>>
>>1087384
Britain's perception of celts came from picts from the beginnings of their history and the legends of Aurthur and Bodica

though I'm pretty sure the Briton Celts, Gaelic Celts, and Iberian Celts had really different cultures
>>
>>1087384
Oh look, revisionist bullshit.

>>1087394
Because celts intermingled with ancient iberians to a certain extent. That's where the term Black Irish comes from, but even these people are mostly pale as fuck that dude in your photograph looks like he spent too long under the sun or in a tanning bed.
>>
>>1087313
Phoenician alphabet loosely inspired the Greek alphabet, which was further changed to represent the modern Latin/Romanized alphabet we use today.

Try again.

>>1087275
Celts got the shit kicked out of them by everyone, they were awful warriors.
>>
>>1087384
Celtics were often described as being fair skinned and tall, Germanics as red heads or blondes. Same with the Iranics for that matter.
>>
>>1087450
>Celtics were often described as being fair skinned and tall
[citation needed]
>>
>>1087439
>Got the shit kicked out of them
What is:
Viratius
Boudica
Brennen
>>
>>1087465

>Boudica

>lel let me attack half garrisoned towns and civilians
>oh shit that's a real army
>oh no i lost
>oh and look i lost AND i had the entire supply train with me at the battle

Boudica was a net negative for the celts.
>>
>>1087465
>Boudica
>attacked defenseless towns and slaughtered Roman colonials; mainly unarmed men, women, and children
>burned townships and villages allied with the Romans in a petty vendetta for revenge

>>1087461
>Celtics weren't fair skinned and tall
[citation needed]
>>
>>1087378
That's retarded. t. celt. It's ridiculous the amount of English and Germans who fetishise celtic culture like this.
>>
>>1087275
>tfw you learned it was pronounced kelt not selt
>>
>>1087523
>all the anglo kids who said I was pronouncing it wrong when I was saying kelt
>>
>>1087384
>it's actually sensible to believe they were more, shall I say middle eastern looking

LOL
O
L
>>
File: alphabets.png (145 KB, 212x640) Image search: [Google]
alphabets.png
145 KB, 212x640
>>1087439
>Phoenician alphabet loosely inspired the Greek alphabet
>>
>>1087465

>Boudica
>>
File: UNDEFEATED.jpg (49 KB, 800x665) Image search: [Google]
UNDEFEATED.jpg
49 KB, 800x665
>>1087275
They still are.
>>
File: 1449459070256.jpg (389 KB, 2048x1756) Image search: [Google]
1449459070256.jpg
389 KB, 2048x1756
>>1087523
>>
>>1087531
Yeah, thanks for proving my point?
>>
File: 1403609107970.jpg (259 KB, 596x727) Image search: [Google]
1403609107970.jpg
259 KB, 596x727
>>1087523
>mfw my normalfag friends have no idea what I'm talking about when I utter the word [kaisar]
>>
>>1087558
The greek alphabet is a form of the pheonician, the latin alphabet is a form of the greek alphabet
>>
>>1087601
Latin is considerably different in morphology alone, so no saying its a "form" of Greek alphabet is retarded.
>>
>>1087537
Then why is Gaelic a dying language?
>>
>>1087394
Yet the guy has blue eyes something in which many anglos do not have
>>
>>1087522
>t. celt

you mean
>t.American with 1/8th Welsh ancestry
>>
>>1087465
>Boudica
>literally only famous for being female
She lost too
>>
>>1087694
Because making an entire country re-learn a language that is already the global language out of pure nationalism is absolutely retarded.
>>
>>1087694
>Then why is Gaelic a dying language?
Scottish Gaelic is dying but Irish is growing. Scots are cucks though, so no surprises there.
>>
>>1087740
Nah I'm from Ireland. I didn't know Americans claimed Welsh ancestry
>>
Reminder that the Celts were cucks as their religion actively encouraged wife sharing.
>>
>>1087859
Scottish are more closely related to the English then the Irish in the first place.
>>
File: jamin-brennus.jpg (156 KB, 470x594) Image search: [Google]
jamin-brennus.jpg
156 KB, 470x594
>>1087877
>Reminder that the Celts were cucks as their religion actively encouraged wife sharing.
Reminder that Romans were cucks because their wives got GAULED
>>
File: wales.jpg (59 KB, 640x447) Image search: [Google]
wales.jpg
59 KB, 640x447
>>1087859
Welsh is still spoken by around 20 percent of the population if thats the best celtic nations can do
Gaelic is fucked.
>>
>>1087870
They don't. Nobody wants to claim Welsh ancestry, it's more of a fact of life.
>>
>>1087905
>>1087859
>>1087694
Irish has seen a minor increase in the number of speakers (both in daily use and those identifying as competent) from the last census, I'm sure this census will show another increase.
>>
>>1087870
>>1087907
Eh, we'll claim anything if we go autistic enough.
>>
>>1087900
Then Celts got cucked by Romans even harder as they were conquered.
>>
>>1087859
>wanting to break off with no plans for separate currency, defense, or really anything.
>but muh bagpipes
>muh kilts
>muh freedom
>>
Why do anti-English and Irishfags claim that the English aren't Celtic?
>>
>>1088404
Because the Angles, Saxons, Danes and Normans weren't Celts.
>>
>>1088409
So what? Isn't the majority of Saxon/Germanic influence largely isolated to Southern England? And most English are still genetically Celtic.
>>
>>1088416
There's more to culture than just blood. The Irish still have at least -some- Gaelic culture (their form of English is structured differently, they play Gaelic sports), the English have a more distinct culture. I wouldn't have put them in a Celtic or Germanic group at this point.
>>
>>1087900
Why didn't Neptune save them?
>>
>>1088424
The Irish were heavily influenced by the Norse too for example. Either way, the English are still primarily a Celtic people. Just as the French are as well.
>>
>>1088434
>The Irish were heavily influenced by the Norse too for example.
The Norse were more affected (see: Norse-Gaels) than the Gaels themselves were. Up until the Plantations, the Gaels had managed to subsume several groups into their culture.

>Either way, the English are still primarily a Celtic people. Just as the French are as well.
The French are more Mediterranean than they are Celtic.
>>
>>1088451
The Mediterranean is a region, not a racial or ethnic group. The modern French language itself still retains something over 200+ Gaelic words that survived the language transition from Vulgar Latin, for example.

And genetically and anthropologically they are largely despite mixing with Romans and the Franks, still Celtic.
>>
File: 00052435 (1).jpg (64 KB, 333x500) Image search: [Google]
00052435 (1).jpg
64 KB, 333x500
>>1088359
literally you

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OLAewTVmkAU
>>
>>1088416
>genetically Celtic.
no such thing. Celtic is a cultural term and England is not one of the 6 celtic countries.
>>
>>1088434
Really most people on the British Isles are primarily pre-celt. The distinction is usually culture and language and the evil anglo suppressed every celtic language it could. The celtic nations have a very peculiar sort of English, but it's English. That basically leaves culture and the English have entirely divorced themselves from the celtic label. Before we could look up genetic lineage the English insisted they were 100% germanic, they want nothing to do with celtic identity.
>>
>>1088501
Regardless of your definition of "culture", the overwhelming majority of English are genetically closer to pre-Germanized Celtics on the Isles then Germanics themselves, even after said assimilation.
>>
>>1088501
>Really most people on the British Isles are primarily pre-celt.
Debatable. Pre-La Tene, definitely but it's very unclear what language the first IE settlers spoke and most Y-DNA in the Celt Belt is R1-b. Mt-DNA is more difficult to place
>>
>>1088531
right, but I think we're looking at "celticness" culturally. Nobody gives a shit about minute differeces in genetic markers, especially when we're dealing with "races" who are really phenotypically similar..
>>
>>1087380
Soldiers tend to beat warriors
>>
File: 1461938130593.jpg (9 KB, 228x227) Image search: [Google]
1461938130593.jpg
9 KB, 228x227
>>1087523
People actually haven't always pronounced it like this?
>>
>>1088539
I had read that it was a sort of "proto-basque" but yes the history is really murky. The takeaway is that there aren't any real sharp differences genetically between any group on the british isles. I mean there might be a little extra germanic here and there but by and large it's a big soup that all tastes the same.

My point being the genetics don't really play much of a part in celtic identity. It's more complicated and nebulous.
>>
>>1088569
>My point being the genetics don't really play much of a part in celtic identity. It's more complicated and nebulous.
you're right. People talking about "Celtic genes" is my pet peeve
>>
>>1088560
Blame sports.

Boston's NBA team calls themselves the seltics.
>>
>>1087465
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Watling_Street
>>
File: 12345.png (832 KB, 956x958) Image search: [Google]
12345.png
832 KB, 956x958
>>1087275

> historian
> favoritism
>>
File: c3b (1).jpg (31 KB, 456x320) Image search: [Google]
c3b (1).jpg
31 KB, 456x320
>>1088359
>Wanting a divorce with no separate plans for living arrangements, finance, childcare or literally anything.
>but muh Marital fidelity
>muh dignity
>muh self-respect
>>
File: celts.gif (17 KB, 578x382) Image search: [Google]
celts.gif
17 KB, 578x382
Celts a shit, enjoy being confined to the coasts of the Atlantic.
>>
>>1087384
>we wuz
>to actual Celts
Would you really tell a Welshman or Irishman that they're larping?
>>
>>1087384
Why the fuck would Celts be middle eastern looking? They originated in the Halstatt culture in modern day Germany
>>
>>1087694
Rekt
>>
>>1088482
This
>>
>>1090979

I will thanks, enjoy your jihad
>>
>>1088560
"selt" was the sole pronounciation until the mid-19th century when some Irishfags started complaining about. I have no idea why they insisted so much on using the classical Latin pronounciation when "celt" was never a Celtic word and the Celts never called themselves anything like it.
>>
File: download (4).jpg (9 KB, 218x160) Image search: [Google]
download (4).jpg
9 KB, 218x160
>>1091006
>he isn't a New World Anglo
>>
>>1090979
Woah
So my family has celtic ancestry?
Nice
>>
>>1091020
That's for you to look into, maps can't say much considering the ebb and flow of different folk and cultures. What's your surname? That's the go-to to rally see what you ought to identify with.
>>
>>1087275
>>1087378
Do the Celts here specifically refer to the Gauls?
>>
No Celts were repulsive savages.
Thread replies: 80
Thread images: 16

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.