[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why do people on here compare cartoons to anime so much? Over
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 85
Thread images: 11
File: image.png (439 KB, 1136x640) Image search: [Google]
image.png
439 KB, 1136x640
Why do people on here compare cartoons to anime so much?

Over the past few weeks I've seen about three threads about comparing anime to cartoons. They're completely two different mediums and in my opinion Cartoons are superior. With cartoons you have a lot more freedom and better animation while in anime you can only make moeshit or never have a show that lasts past 12 episodes.

Why do people compare these two?
>>
Mods gonna ban you for talking shit bout anime boi.
>>
ANIME IS CARTOONS.
THEY ARE LITERALLY JUST CARTOONS WITH A SPECIFIC STYLE.
>>
Low hanging fruit.
>>
>>83728221
Apples and Oranges
Same medium, but different
They're both good in their own ways
>>
Pretending modern cartoons are better is getting sad
>>
>>83728221
I enjoy both but Cartoon fans in general are much less cancerous than anime fans.
>>
>>83728221
>With cartoons you have a lot more freedom and better animation while in anime you can only make moeshit or never have a show that lasts past 12 episodes.

You're acting like cartoons don't have sets of restrictions or problems with them either. Just to name a few.
>Can't be an adult cartoon without being an absurd comedy.
>Can't be over 11 minutes without requiring large amounts of studio funding.
>Animation studios themselves are poor as fuck compared to the anime industry.
>Cartoon seasons are almost never consistent in scheduling leading to several things if a show is deemed unpopular which includes hiatuses, schedule meddling or even cancellation.
>Executive meddling up the ass.
>>
>>83728485
Hardly.
>Bronies
>Su-males
>Pre-SU adventure time fans
>>
>>83728505
Delete this
>>
>With cartoons you have a lot more freedom and better animation

HAH

thread closed people, this guy knows it

I was being sarcastic though
>>
>>83728221
Because modern cartoons are becoming increasingly animesque
>>
Because cartoons are really lagging behind? I'm sorry, I seriously think Anime might be better right now.
>>
>>83728221
Because modern cartoons, at least americans ones, are becoming increasingly animesque.
>>
>>83728221
>two different mediums
Your the problem
There exactly the same fucking thing and the sooner society realises that the sooner we can have a higher quality of animation in general
>>
is it true that a popular steven universe tumblr guy was one of the victims in flodia?
>>
>>83729530
Hardly. Early 00s the animesque style was everywhere, but now its definitely fallen out of vogue.
>>
>>83729633
>SU Fans
>social life
Seems unlikely
>>
>They're completely two different mediums
that's weeb talk
gb2gaia
>>
>>83729633
Are gay dudes even into SU?
>>
File: 1464461043415.gif (267 KB, 400x310) Image search: [Google]
1464461043415.gif
267 KB, 400x310
>>83728221
>They're completely two different mediums
Let's be real here. They're both the same and they both have the same amount of potential. They're nothing more than drawings that move.
You can get the exact same fucking story from both mediums. Some might say
>b-but anime is different because of the culture and styles
Yeah because only the West and Japan make moving drawings, huh? China's cartoons don't count as something else and neither does France. The whole argument that "anime is different" is just something that weebs made up to feel like a special snowflake when they try to explain to their friends and family that they watch fucking cartoons. I'm a fucking weeb and even I can see how cancerous we are.

TL:Dr: Just enjoy your moving pictures you faggots
>>
>>83728221
I wanna fuck peridot so bad.
>>
>>83728221
shitposting and stealth refugees
>>
>>83728221
They are both the same exact thing except one originates in a specific country and hence is a reflection of a different style/country. There's nothing stopping anime from having the feel and style of a western cartoon, and vice-versa. There are no actual differences unless you discriminate animation based on point of origin.
>>
>>83728221
>With cartoons you have a lot more freedom
I guess it is compared to anime but like >>83728505 said it has too problems
>>
>>83729789

this. forgot the bait threads but basically this
>>
>>83729748
>gaia
Is that even alive anymore? Do people still use it.
>>
>>83729766
Gay here, yes. The gayest guy I know loves SU and his favorite Gem is Sugilite because she's voiced by Nicki Minaj
>>
>>83728221
Anime is too sexist for me to get into. It demoralizes women to the point where they're nothing more than sex objects for men to ogle at. I will never support a medium when females are just turned into sex objects.
>>
>>83730082
Tumblr pls
>>
>>83730161
Degenerate manbaby please
>>
>>83728221
for discussions, because we're on 4chan where we discuss things.

Cartoons and anime are very similar in a broad sense too, so it's common for them to be discussed together.
>>
>>83729155
No
>>
>>83728221
American cartoons don't even pretend to be deep, at least in anime you can pretend to make serious political arguments without joking
>>
>>83728221
>Why do people on here compare cartoons to anime so much?

Maybe because they're literally and actually the same medium two separate ways?

The two are entirely comparable. Anyone who thinks they're not is deluded.
>>
Oh booy i can just feel the 500+ replies right now. /co/ is so easily baited its hysterical.
>>
>>83731848
>Truth is bait now
>>
File: 1430028345482.png (2 MB, 1448x1462) Image search: [Google]
1430028345482.png
2 MB, 1448x1462
>>83728221
>>83731886
> still salty from that previous thread(s) where some /a/non dumped a bunch of webms that aren't 12 episode moeshit and /co/ was like n-no we have good stuff that aren't old Disneys too! while posting less than 10 examples.
>>
But SU look like a handdrawing cartoon that magical moving around on tv screen anon
For me is no different desu
>>
>>83728221
>Why do people on here compare cartoons to anime so much?
>Proceeds to compare cartoons to anime
>>
>>83732015
Kek, what thread was that? Is it in the archive
>>
>>83731848
I can't wait for the "pandering doesn't exist" guy to come and leave a good 200 replies himself.
>>
>>83728221
>They're completely two different mediums
They are literally the exact same medium.
>>
>>83728221
You know what I just noticed? Peridots voice actress was also that assistant chick in the velvet room of Persona 3
>>
>>83733121
This.

And it's LITERALLY-literally. Not figuratively-literally. They are two different words used to describe works in the medium of animation.
>>
>>83730082
Jesus christ. Nobody likes a preachy jerk. You sound no better than an old christian group of women trying to push prohibition.
>>
>>83730082
Let's just get this out of the way...

>Cartoons are too sexist for me to get into. They demoralize women to the point where they're nothing more than sex objects for men to ogle at. I will never support a medium when females are just turned into sex objects.

>Movies are too sexist for me to get into. They demoralize women to the point where they're nothing more than sex objects for men to ogle at. I will never support a medium when females are just turned into sex objects.

>Live action is too sexist for me to get into. It demoralizes women to the point where they're nothing more than sex objects for men to ogle at. I will never support a medium when females are just turned into sex objects.

>Comics are too sexist for me to get into. They demoralize women to the point where they're nothing more than sex objects for men to ogle at. I will never support a medium when females are just turned into sex objects.

>Renaissance art is too sexist for me to get into. It demoralizes women to the point where they're nothing more than sex objects for men to ogle at. I will never support a medium when females are just turned into sex objects.
>>
File: It angers.jpg (91 KB, 1440x1080) Image search: [Google]
It angers.jpg
91 KB, 1440x1080
>>83733208
I used to work with guy who would get super pissed if you said they were the same

He would always say they were different because "cartoons are meant for children"
>>
>>83728419
This. Yet, fans with inferior or superior complex will shove their pride and ego everywhere to make themselves superior.
>>
>>83734152
>Cartoons are for children
What is Simpson, family guy, south park, superjail, ugly american, and mr. pickles? Did your boss even know what he said?
>>
>>83728221
Anime is just Japanese Cartoons with a lot more variety and depth.
>>
>>83734050

fanservice is a thing that came directly from anime, the japs make entire shows based around the premise of "big breasted/flat chested /loli/MILF/readhead/tsundere/kuudere girl conveniently falls/bumps/accidentaly kisses/walks out of the shower/her top falls off/air lifts skirt into boy protagonist"

so yeah, anime, and more specifically japan, is the biggest source of it
>>
>>83734709
Don't get me wrong, most anime sucks - just like most examples of most popular media suck. But you shouldn't skip the good shows because of the shitty ones, especially when you can filter out 90% of the shit by skipping anything with the word harem anywhere near it.
>>
>>83734895
not to mention the new guys can just avoid/ignore the extremely aggressive fans.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mQScjlXbBE

I know it is collegehumor and is meant to be a parody, but this is surprisingly valid.
>>
Everything has to be console warz now. Liking something isn't about enjoying that thing, it's about shitting on everything else to prove your thing is better.
>>
>>83735136
pretty much. however, I think your statement apply more accurately on fans that are either extremely unconfident or extremely arrogant. In nutshell, those fans will attack/insult others to protect themselves because of their ignorances.
>>
File: 1460168433639.png (165 KB, 500x375) Image search: [Google]
1460168433639.png
165 KB, 500x375
>"Why do people compare cartoons to anime!?!?!"
>Posts pic of a show that's trying to be as anime as possible (and failing)
>>
>>83734709
Because Betty Boop didn't exist
>>
>>83734586
>mr. pickles

There's no way that show isn't aimed specifically at 14 year-old boys.
>>
>>83728221
I'm reporting you to the internet police for liking both.
That's against the law.
>>
>>83729155
Hello
>>
Literally the same medium only with different audience expectations and marketing focus.
>>
>>83728221
Why do people make shitty threads and start them with Shitven Universe images even though they have nothing to do with it, as if the catalog isnt full enough of these terrible Sugar character """"""designs"""""
>>
>>83738347
oh, silly me, forgot to mention happy tree friends, this thing is brutal.
>>
Its been a long time since anime has has seen the likes of cowboy bebop, ghost in the shell, akira, or evangelion. Anime has been largely stagnating and cartoons have started getting ballsy with their writing lately. That's why there are stupid comparisons.
>>
>>83738653
>cartoons have started getting ballsy with their writing lately.

?
>>
>>83728221
Well considering action cartoons are dead in the west, Japan pretty much wins by default.
>>
>>83728317
>THEY ARE LITERALLY CARTOONS WITH A SPECIFIC STYLE
Not really.
>>83728221
>western shows have less restrictions
I don't know how you can think this when there only two target audiences.
>>
Anime is Chinese Cartoons
>>
File: latest[1].jpg (104 KB, 300x250) Image search: [Google]
latest[1].jpg
104 KB, 300x250
>>83731721
Anime don't even pretend to be deep, at least in american cartoons you can pretend to make serious political arguments without joking
>>
>>83734895
>skipping anything with the word harem
Some harem shows are quilty pleasures for me like monster musume.
>>
are you sure youre not the individual whose been making those threads
>>
>>83737136
SU is the poorman's anime. The show is basically non-stop anime references or homages.
>>
File: 1465472842355.gif (4 MB, 1249x653) Image search: [Google]
1465472842355.gif
4 MB, 1249x653
>>83728221
>Cartoons
>more freedom
>better animation
>Steven Universe picture

End yourself
>>
File: 1463604980667.jpg (87 KB, 523x456) Image search: [Google]
1463604980667.jpg
87 KB, 523x456
>>83728221
>Why do people compare these two?
>They're two different mediums we shouldn't compare them
>Guys let's not compare them
>BTW Cartoons are better than anime and here's why...
>>
File: 1457727467780.jpg (11 KB, 480x360) Image search: [Google]
1457727467780.jpg
11 KB, 480x360
>>83734485
Anime v Cartoons
xbox v playstation
Consoles v PC
Fantasy v Sci-Fi
Action v Romance
SU v SvtFoE
>>
>They're completely two different mediums
No, no they aren't.

Artistic styles, cultural differences, and tropes may create vast differences between the two categories, but they are exactly the same medium, that being animated cartoon.
>>
File: 1465258952772.jpg (11 KB, 298x292) Image search: [Google]
1465258952772.jpg
11 KB, 298x292
>>83733128
Maybe you should check IMDB first before making claims.
>>
>>83728317
Not even that. They're literally cartoons from a specific country.
>>
>They're completely two different mediums

Literally the exact same shit.
>>
File: you worry me anon.png (30 KB, 125x175) Image search: [Google]
you worry me anon.png
30 KB, 125x175
>>83728221
>They're completely two different mediums

How retarded do you have to be to actually say something like this?
>>
>>83738653
I agree anime is mostly shit these days, but cartoons are literally just imitating anime. We've gone from most cartoons being garbage story wise to moderately okay like SU, but they're still knock offs.
>>
>>83728221
Neck yourself please
>>
>>83728221
Why do people compare anime and cartoons as if they were two different things. Animes are cartoons. Just from Japan.
Quit being a fuckwad OP.
>>
>>83741615
>mostly shit these days
It has always been shit with some good stuff. 90s and 80s werent any better times.
Thread replies: 85
Thread images: 11

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.