Can we talk about fight scenes? Like how shitty RWBY's fights are?
>>83208249
>RWBY
Holy shit, is that shit still relevant? How did it even ever get popular? /co/ could make better shit with just four anons and a drawfag.
>>83208249
Oh shit wrong wrong webm.
>>83208279
>RWBYfags will call this """""""""good action""""""""
>>83208268
Waifus.
That's literally the only reason RWBY has a following.
>>83208249
Aren't you that same fag who reposts this same webm in every RWBY thread on /v/? Why are you so obsessed with this show?
>>83208325
I don't think I've ever actually posted in /v/.
>>83208268
>/co/ could make better shit with just four anons and a drawfag.
"Better" isn't the wrong part of this, "could make" is. Remember Avian Adventures?
>>83208279
I've seen mediocre SFM animator do a better job than that.
>>83208268
the only place that hates it is 4chan
>>83208581
show me
>>83208879
4chan hates everything, personally i think its jealousy.
>I could make shit too...I just don't have the money or resources, but man it is so much better, you know in my head.
ok way do you prole hate this show even the prole that like it knows it has problems
>>83208879
That could be because we don't immediately suck the cock off of everything that gets popular in nerd culture.
>>83208933
>"Y-your just jealous hater!"
Pretty sure you have to be 18 to post on this board
>>83208954
so your response in to make the same thread over and over
>>83208959
you seem upset
>>83208895
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3FHKq9O3uak
>>83208268
I scrolled past the general for a long time before some of the fanart made me take a second look, which I spent viewing whatever the hell passes for a fight scene in that show. It's like watching a PS2 game, no fucking thanks. Do like the fanart though.
>>83208968
Yes because clearly I'm the op and the only person respond in this thread, faggot.
>>83208996
wow ok hot head
>>83208988
good i like ps2 games
>>83208974
Nope not upset but a little disappointed that you think "they're just jealous" isn't a fucking retarded way to justify why people don't like thisshittyshow
>>83209105
how can one show trigger you people so bad holy shit
>>83209073
I would watch a Jak movie animated on the PS2 before giving RWBY another look, at least Daxter was funny.
>>83209135
The most extreme reaction itt is yours, champ.
>>83209146
what are you talking about and best girl
>>83208959
>>83209105
>>83209146
Poor guy forty years old and still flipping bugers at Micky D's.
Come on man Go download Poser, Blender, or the million other free 3d software and show us this better show of yours
>>83209186
That fallacy is older than you are.
>>83208986
>>83209212
Plus what if said guy enjoys flipping burgers? What if that's all he ever wanted to do? Not really an effective insult then, is it? "Good job finding your dream career, faggot!" Not much sting to it, is there?
>>83209212
Not really a fallacy when the second comment in this thread is the "could make a better thing" statement.
>>83209255
Unless they are a fat slobby Italian that is no ones dream
![Symphogear GX - 01 [A9903EC2].mkv_snapshot_05.21_[2016.01.22_16.05.13].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/gS2PKY2.jpg "Symphogear GX - 01 [A9903EC2].mkv_snapshot_05.21_[2016.01.22_16.05.13].jpg")
How the hell did this shit get popular?
RWBY I mean. Symphogear is honestly pretty sweet
>>83209172
Jak and Dax is never coming back, while I guess R&C did last longer and tried to reboot themselves but ended up crashing at the box office.
>>83209291
people like it how is that so hard to get your small mind around
>>83209312
Because every element of it is terrible.
>>83209281
you tried
>>83209261
Yeah, it is.
>>83209298
i still have hope and the R&C game sold really well so thats a good thing
SYMPHOGEAAAAAAAAHHHHH
Now go back to /m/a/u/ geahfag
>>83209312
that doesn't really answer the question. Im asking for quantifiable measures of quality. This is good because X
>>83209281
Loads of people enjoy cooking. Among them, there are doubtless some that specialize in cooking hamburgers. Like Bob Belcher, but real.
>>83209312
How hard is it to understand that you got my cock in your ass and that your tastes will forever be shit, and by forever I mean forever.
Ever.
Your tastes fucking suck and you like a show that's fast food equivalent of anime show.
Even newgrounds flashes are better produced than the trite peice of shite that is RWBY.
>>83209348
nice opinion
>>83209291
Release stuff to an already established fanbase generally helps. Have things be mildly entertaining at least, also helps.
For me I like the show, I can see it's faults but this isn't disney so who gives a shit if it has some shitty animation, weird dialog, and questionable writing choices. As long as Pyrrah comes back it's all good.
Plus RvB is the king of shitty popular things everything else is gold in comparison.
>>83209363
wow all this mad
>>83209360
Point proven
>>83209378
this i know the show has problems but i still like it i just dont get all the hate
>>83209348
Don't make Bell look like she agrees with you, she loves ugly shit.
>>83209363
Relax anon, we both know it's shit and we both know hundreds of anons will continue to slurp it up, getting mad doesn't make us happier does it?
>>83209368
Why in the fuck do this lady's eyes switch sides? Is that on purpose, or an error? I'm not sure which is worse.
>>83209349
It looks really fucking cool and I'm considering buying it when I got a chance, despite me not having a PS$, so...
I really, realllllyy, truly do wish to see R&C come back again. It's amazing how Insomniac keeps re-inventing the same old formula despite that it's basically a collecathon game with games and still make it feel fresh and new.
Seriously, hats off to Insomniac for sticking to this series for so long even though it probably doesn't sell out megabucks like a certain Naughty Dog is currently doing.
It's great, seriously.
>>83209395
no its her power
>>83209393
Probably wannabee Roger Eberts that think something has to make them question everything they know or it's not worth their time. You know, joyless faggots that can't accept that people have fun in ways that they do not.
>>83209383
>Lol, you're mad so that invalidates this whole arguement!
@011 was a hell of a year, huh? I remember when I had an online girlfriend that would actually say this shit to me and baka.
You must really enjoy your memes now, don't ya kid?
>>83209397
yea i love it
>>83209395
>Why in the fuck do this lady's eyes switch sides? Is that on purpose, or an error? I'm not sure which is worse.
It was one, now it's the other.
>>83209408
Swappable heterochromia? Neat I guess, but not all that useful seeming.
>>83209409
>wannabee Roger Eberts
He's dead, isn't he?We all want to be him now
>>83209422
this guy no need to be mad guy
>>83209424
Did you see the movie? Was it good?
>>83209444
How's highschool kid? Do you enjoy your shitposting while people outside in your real life continue to keep on ignoring you?
>>83209446
no i didnt see it so i might get it on dvd or something
>>83209409
>Hur durr you just hate fun
you know if you people spent less time bitching about the detractors and more time actually sharing the shows good points you might not look like twats
>>83209444
>>83209466
Any chance of you two finding somewhere else to fuck?
>>83209466
nice projecting
>>83209435
Siskel is the one that died. Ebert just got jaw cancer, and proceeded to ignore that sign that God wanted him to shut the fuck up.
>>83209444
You need to be 18 or older to post.
>>83209476
Yeah, I think I might rent it at a redbox, don't know if I'll buy it. It looks like it got terrible reviews.
>>83209488
no im going to fuck you
>>83209490
Nice meme, shitposter.
>>83209496
WOW, whats that the fifth "you're a child post"
>>83209492
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roger_Ebert
>2013
He's gone too, anon.
>>83209487
Not going to waste my time, because as I said, it's not your specific brand of fun, so you aren't going to enjoy it, regardless of what I or anyone else says about it. You hate it because you want to hate it. Clearly the show is not for you.
>>83209500
Meh, nothing better to do
>>83209518
Huh, so he is. Never paid much attention to him or his friend because I try to form my own opinions about things.
>>83209492
>Ebert just got jaw cancer, and proceeded to ignore that sign that God wanted him to shut the fuck up.
Another week, another dark KEK.
Slowly I can feel the humanity spilling from the diminishing presence of my sides.
>>83209516
I don't hate the show, but people can hate what they want. The thread just wants to know why you like it.
>>83209498
yea the reviews were bad made me angry
>>83209534
>still has some of his humanity left
>>83209519
>Not going to waste my time,
Yeah I thought as much. It's always the same song and dance with you people
>>83209545
I still want to see it. I'll be honest, R&C's humor died on me after I grew out of the age o 14. The future series are pretty funny, but the original trilogy doesn't really bring much laughter out of me, but it does bring out a smile from me.
Btw those screenshots you're posting are pretty fucking sexy. I love the disney quality Insomniac has brought to the games now.
>>83209557
na all he needs to do is remember the lat 3 numbers works for me
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2lKNhSU-YUA
>>83209586
yea man the game looks so good
Christ, what a cancerous fanbase. Can't you RWBY fags just accept that your show looks like ass, is written like ass and you probably just watch it for the ass? Waifubait shows are hardly a new thing here, so why not just accept it for what it is?
People who typically like RWBY express interest in shit like Naruto and other garbage. Leave the mentally handicapped alone.
>>83209609
whay do you give a shit
>>83209612
nice joke
>>83209609
It's weird, I'm not above watching a garbage-plot for nice animation and cute grils, but every webm I open from RWBY just destroys any chance of me wanting to give it a shot. If it was exactly the same thing, only actually drawn, I'd probably watch it even though it was still shit, because at least it'd be pretty shit.
>>83209671
way dont you try and watch it for yourself and find out
>>83209577
>It's always the same song and dance with you people
Just curious, do you have to run an obstacle course at the fun police academy?
>>83209690
Because every frame of that webm and every other from this show hurts to look at, everything is so stilted and wrong-looking.
>>83209710
well ti dont know what to tell you watch it or dont i dont give a shit
>>83209710
And? We still like it, stop trying to ruin our fun. Do any of us come to your house while you're having a tea party and slap your dick out of your mom's mouth, then scream about how you're enjoying the wrong things?
>>83209710
I bet you love South Park with its top quality animation though, right?
>>83209729
Stupid Emerald. I'm still mad.
>>83209746
>We still like it, stop trying to ruin our fun.
That anon made no such attempt. He commented on his reasons for not bringing himself to watch the show.
>Do any of us come to your house while you're having a tea party and slap your dick out of your mom's mouth, then scream about how you're enjoying the wrong things?
???
This is a thread specifically about the failings of choreography in shows like RWBY. You're literally in here right now obstructing that discussion because it does not agree with you.
>>83209760
South Park doesn't come across as some weeb's Naruto fanfic.
>>83209690
I did and it reminded me of poorly dubbed anime. The voice acting quality is the biggest thing pushing me away. Roosterteeth got lots of money, can't they hire better people?
>>83209771
that did
vic mignogna
yuri lowenthal
laura bailey
Elizabeth Maxwell
Jen Taylor
>>83209769
No, just a pair of manchildren cashing in on buzz words and popculture. Furthermore, i didn't mention the writing, I mentioned the animation. South Park is the lowest of the low in regards to that.
>>83209760
No, but that was certainly an attempt.
>>83209769
>>83209822
Yuri did a voice? Who?
>>83209830
>if I can just get one of them to say they like SP, then I've GOT 'EM!
anon why are you doing this to yourself
>>83209837
mercury
>>83209841
Just pointing out that crappy animation is found everywhere, hell at this point Family Guy has better animation that South Park
>>83209830
I'm pretty sure rwby is the lowest of the low m8
:^)
>>83209854
Really? Doesn't sound like his Sasuke voice at all, which is what most studios hire him to do.
>>83209870
thay got him to do it after the other guy left
>>83209859
No, that would be your pic.
>>83209910
Please stop embarrassing yourself.
its bad enough that you like rwby.
>>83209936
wow so mad
>This whole thread
Jesus, RWBY fans are really defensive and yet none of them can actually refute the criticisms.
>>83209936
Sorry I don't like your shallow as fuck shitty mecha genre deconstruction anime.
>>83208249
I don't really see what's the problem is.
The action is perfectly readable and there's impact. Even without the sound, you feel the power of the blows.
>>83209970
your favorite show is shit
>>83209855
>Just pointing out that crappy animation is found everywhere
Why? We all know that, but we're not talking about other shit shows, we're talking about this shit show.
>>83209971
>mecha genre deconstruction
Hopefully this is the dumbest post you've made.
>>83208279
The transition between the 2 characters is jarring and it's lacking a bit of impact, but it's smooth and more detailed that a lot of cartoon.
>>83210051
That's what Eva is. A deconstruction of the mecha genre, super robots in particular.
>>83209970
Not a single one of them has given any reason for us to watch so far, only shit on other anons and get very frustrated very quickly.
One of them has posted "u mad" more than once already in response to criticism, it's like we traveled 8 years back in time here.
>>83209186
>"This guy doesn't like my favorite webshow? Better go on a rant about what a burger flipping loser he is"
Christ.
>>83210079
You know it's true because anime blogs say it
>>83210081
i dont shit if you watch it or not im just here to laugh and shitpost
>>83210112
You're certainly accomplishing one out of two there, anon.
>>83210079
>>83210093
Serious question: Is it though? I've heard many people talk about it that way but I also hear people saying that that's bullshit.
>>83210137
I think it's a show about damaged kids being used to fight unknowable monsters using slightly better-known monsters, and the interactions of the characters as they go through some shit.
I don't know what a 'deconstruction of mecha genre' would look like, or even describe, it just comes off as a lofty term that some people like to use to seem/feel smart.
>>83210137
Yes(?), because deconstructions are supposed to show the downsides/"reality" of the situation to tear down the premise. In that sense Eva is a deconstruction because it shows the psychological impact of putting the responsibility of thousands of lives on the shoulders of an emotionally compromised teenager. This strongly contrasts with a lot of giant mech series that mostly focus on how cool piloting a mech is and also gloss over the stress/responsibility that comes with being a "savior" figure.
>>83210184
I guess you could say it's like a mecha with more "realistic" characters i.e. Shinji isn't the brave, young protaginast but instead a scared kid with daddy issues.
>>83210237
Yeah that's what I figured, yet I've had arguments with people who adamantly argue against that.
>>83210237
Doesn't that just make it better-written?
Like, is a really good Superman comic automatically a 'deconstruction of superheros' if they write elements normally ignored or hand-waved?
>>83210246
That's fair I think, even for all the shit people give him for being a bitch, I don't know how much better I could've handled a quarter of that shit at 14.
>>83210237
Well, most super robot show protagonists tend not to be emotionally compromised. Gai Shishioh for example, came to terms with the loss of his body, because he always wanted to serve mankind. He realized that as mankind's strongest cyborg he could do that better than he ever could have as an astronaut. I still find it weird that his english VA was the same guy that does Dean Venture's voice.
>>83210280
do it i want to see it fucking do it
>>83210302
>>83210280
>Doesn't that just make it better-written?
Better is entirely a matter of opinion in this case.
>>83210237
>This strongly contrasts with a lot of giant mech series that mostly focus on how cool piloting a mech is and also gloss over the stress/responsibility that comes with being a "savior" figure
Gundam and Ideon, two of its biggest influences, did that more than decade before Eva.
>>83210311
i dont even know what we are talking about any more
>>83208268
>Holy shit, is that shit still relevant?
The fanbase continues to exist and support the company/series so RT has no reason to stop producing it.
>How did it even ever get popular?
RT already had an established fanbase, so did Monty Oum, the show's creator. When the fans heard they, RT/Monty, were coming out with something new they went to see what it was and found that they liked it because it fit their tastes. Additional fans were drawn in by the waifus/fights which, while not very good, were decent enough. After the third season things are looking better writing-wise and the animation is going to move to a better program, so now it's gone from "fun but shit" to "OK-ish".
>/co/ could make better shit with just four anons and a drawfag.
Potentially yes, but until a pilot for a competing show by Four Anons and A Drawfag Studios comes out the point is moot.
>>83208954
Ever think things are popular in nerd culture because nerds like them?
>>83210322
You forgot one.
How does someone watch this without feeling embarassed?
>>83210444
Symphogear or RWBY? Same answer for both, by not giving a shit.
>>83210444
>trips of truth
>>83210444
Same way first-timers watchmlp, too drunk to care anymore
>>83210464
Maybe you should give a shit. I don't think you need to watch artful or things that challenge you all the time (or even most of the time), but why demean yourself by wasting your time on RWBY?
>>83210444
I was ashamed at first but Ive come to love this shitty ahow with its shitty writting and terrible dialogue.
You come to accept and expect it, Anon. But it feela homely. Like a crap kids show made by red vs blue.
>>83210488
Maybe I should, but I don't. I enjoy it, so I watch it.
>>83210488
way give a shit what some Anonymous fucker in the internet thinks are you one of those betas that's scared to play games in public so the cool kids will like you
>>83210488
Cute girls fighting is my fetish.
>>83210444
watching RWBY is one of the least embarrassing things it's audience does
>>83210507
I never 'got' red vs blue, was never a halo player and I feel like I just sort of watched that whole thing drive right past me while I did other stuff.
>>83208974
>>83209020
>>83209135
>>83209186
>>83209312
>>83209383
>>83209409
>>83209444
>>83209500
>>83209690
>>83209729
>>83209746
>>83210378
>>83210322
I wish Tomino would occasionally slip back into Kill em' All mode.
>>83208249
Even tho I bought Symphogear figs and love the look even I can admit that it is also mostly piss. All the punch for punch no drawbacks makes me cringe super hard. It's just that RWBY is made of that same thing it's like a better animated stick video you used to watch on ebaums. Yuck.
>>83209746
>stop trying to ruin our fun
>>83210611
rick and morty opinion discarded
>>83210644
Does that make this post a Fight Club opinion then? Or are you just wrong?
>>83210674
>>83210237
>deconstructions are supposed to show the downsides/"reality" of the situation to tear down the premise.
That's not what deconstruction means at all. Are you one of those people who think Monogatari and Madoka are "deconstructions" too?
>>83210727
Apology accepted, just be better next time, and not for me, but for yourself.
>>83210775
It's the definition that I know and most common one I've seen, so those 2 count in that regard. What definition are you going by and how do those 2 not count?
>>83210863
a deconstruction takes apart a work or genre and attempts to articulate all the different ways it can be interpreted
meanwhile Motogatari is a critique while Madoka is a subversion
>>83208268
RWBY has RT built in extremely large fanbase who basically eat anything up
Since Monty died Burnie has been doing his best to suck it dry with a 2nd Chibi show and like 3 games.
>>83210904
I guess I agree with you on them not being deconstructions, but I still wanna say that they have elements of deconstruction in them (i.e. the Witches being violently shown as actual threats).
>>83211098
>elements of deconstruction in them
>the Witches being violently shown as actual threats
Just stop. How does that even make sense?
>>83208249
>
May need to see a doctor about your shit eyesight
>>83208249
>>83208279
No pls go back to Symphogear, it's better.
>>83208279
This is actually very good; especially for an amateur. What's killing RWBY's choreography is the camera work. The camera work is sterile, and it takes away so much impact.
If you took, say, Mad Max Fury Road's music and made the camera almost as completely fixed like in RWBY, it would be one of the most dull and boring things you would ever watch.
That said, I don't watch RWBY BECAUSE of the camera work. Like, you would THINK Monty would get someone to help work on the camera angles or something.
>>83210923
>like 3 games
>only 1 game being made
>>83209363
He never said that he liked it you fucking idiot. He just said that people liked it.
>>83214532
>Like, you would THINK Monty would get someone to help work on the camera angles or something.
Not really his department anymore, considering he is dead.
I agree with your point though, if your camera work is poor then your audience will have difficulty engaging with the scene, regardless of how cool the choreography is.
>>83216874
Exactly. I've recently watched the first episode, and most of the cringe for me is the camera work and how it starts off like a teenager's wet dream of a story they wrote after watching the animes. But once I was able to convince myself to stop judging it like a 'professional' series you'd see on TV, I'm able to look past it and actually see the charm of the show.
Not to the level many do, but, I get it.
>>83216952
The bright side is that it basically does start at the very bottom and has gradually been improving on almost all fronts since then.
It's sort of like you encounter something that first looks like hardened shit, but over time you see glints of something that might be a gemstone if you polish it enough.
Personally I'm hoping it will maintain it's popularity and become legitimately good in it's own right. It could influence a trend, as there's not many successful independent animated action series in the west at the moment (there aren't even many successful animated actions series at all in the west currently) and if it does I'd prefer the trend to be for good quality content.
>>83208268
Why would you reply to your own thread?
>>83208279
Is there some glaring issue I'm missing? This looks better than 50% of jap shit and 100% of American shit.
>>83218320
Taste evidently
>>83218591
If you don't know why you hate it then why do you?
>>83218609
Because its limp and flaccid.
Nothing looks like it has an ounce of weight to it and is basically just animu flailing.
>>83218737
But it's still fairly smooth and well choreographed. What current American cartoon would you compare it unfavorably to?
>>83218320
How far does your head need to be stuck up your ass to think that looks good? Get over yourself. It looks like shit. I don't care if you like it, but the animation looks like garbage. The only American show that Rwby is better than is the Power Puff Girls reboot.
>>83219492
Dude, you're pathetic. All I did was said it looks fine, and that sends you into an autistic rage. You can't even refute this post >>83219492
Why do you care so much that people like something you don't?
>>83219732
Sorry, I meant you can't refute this >>83218802.
>>83219732
I will be the first on telling you that I hate that show just based in the animu look that the characters have and even I agree that the animation looks good.
I get it, /co/ is filled with buthurt people that want to hate everything so it doesn't matter trying to bring lame shit like ''logic''
>>83208315
> Waifus
That, and the music is great in the cheesiest way possible.
>>83219732
>>83218320
It doesn't flow very well. It looks like it's a good fight scene that's unfinished, like it was stopped right before the final tweaks could be put in. The characters movements are jerky and weightless. The camera randomly moving around doesn't help. More interesting camera angles could be helpful, or at least camera movements that are more in sync with the impacts of the blows.
It's a well choreographed sight and I do think it looks cool, but it also just looks unfinished. It has a lot of the same flaws as RWBY's non-action scenes, just to a less noticeable extent because there's so much movement going on to distract you.
>>83208279
That looks like an entertainingly over the top fight scene though.
Why did RWBY continue when Monty Oum died?
>>83219947
No anon, you are meant to only like weaboo shit like the OP webm with characters that look like shit and ''muh pedo baiting bullshit''
>>83219941
Monty was all about getting the point across than doing final tweaks so that could explain a lot
>>83220013
It makes RT money and they had things somewhat planned for volume 3 so better to keep it going for now, make more money and invest into new IP so another one can take off.
Afterwards they can end RWBY or keep it going but I don't see it ending till maybe volume 5 or 8
>>83220013
I think all but the voice acting was finished for season 3.
I could be wrong though.
>>83220190
I think they started animating volume 3 after his death as stated in Shane's letter
>>83219863
I actually think that everything about the show is bad except for the fight scenes, and in volume 3 the fights aren't great either. But /co/ is just full of morons who can't handle the idea that something they're supposed to hate might have some good qualities.
>>83219899
If you can't even explain your own opinions then you're an idiot.
>>83219941
Thank you, I can see where you're coming from.
>>83217139
I felt season 2 was by far the worst so far
But yeah, a lot of elements of the show that aren't actually the show are appealing
>all this criticism over the animation
Funny enough, NOBODY has provided any examples of Western media from the same time period that's superior.
It's a piece of shit, but the only piece of shit animated better than anything else on the market right now.
>>83220317
>this thread has been up for over 10 hours
The fact that you stay and defend this shit is beyond me. You must have some form of autism.
>>83209186
Their is no shame in honest work kiddo, try again.
>>83220408
For certain values of "better", sure.
>>83220408
The only thing this show has better animation than is the PPG reboot, which another Anon already mentioned. I couldn't care less about the plot, waifus, or any of the other elements in the show, but if you seriously think the animation in this is good then you have some issues. The animation alone is the only reason I won't touch this.
>>83209446
I saw it in theatres.
Complaints
>Drek only existed to have a twist
>Spent too little time developing characters, setting, etc.
I'm sure other people had more issues, but these were the biggest for me. Ratchet and Quark easily got the most screentime and development, leaving Clank and the majority of the supporting cast out in the cold quite often, especially the other members of the Rangers, I don't even remember their names.
I'd give it a 6/10.
>>83220524
Why the actual fuck are you legitimately comparing a fucking small time independent project made by nothing but amateurs to professional works made by experienced people who have been in the fucking field for decades?
You sound EXACTLY like those obnoxious faggots who compare sundance films to major theatrical releases. In fact, I'm willing to bet you are.
Stop treating this like it's a mainstream well funded 20 man team job made by professionals and get your head out of your ass. Let people enjoy something and quit being a fucking pissbaby because all you're used to seeing is major production results from the fucking 90s that had budgets comparable to major theatrical releases.
>>83220025
RWBY is the definition of weebshit.
>>83220408
Tron: Uprising and Motorcity.
I believe an important factor in making an effective fight scene is weight. There has to be a sense of weight behind the movements. The floaty balet style of fight scenes got popular because of Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon and Matrix. Within the context of those movies they were awesome, but the style doesn't really translate well outside of those specific settings.
>>83219492
>>83220524
>people actually defending NuPPG animation
>>83220694
>Why the actual fuck are you legitimately comparing a fucking small time independent project made by nothing but amateurs to professional works made by experienced people who have been in the fucking field for decades?
see
>>83220408
>Funny enough, NOBODY has provided any examples of Western media from the same time period that's superior.
Talk shit get hit.
>>83220839
>Defending nuPPG
>What is reading comprehension
I'm saying Rwby has better animation than nuPPG, but that's the only thing in America it's better than, you illiterate fuck.
>>83220694
>Why the actual fuck are you legitimately comparing a fucking small time independent project made by nothing but amateurs to professional works made by experienced people who have been in the fucking field for decades?
Because the person I replied to asked me to.
See >>83220408
Proof that this thread is nothing more than bait. The mods should tear this thread down.
>>83209378
>As long as Pyrrah comes back it's all good.
Wanting the worst possible outcome
>>83208279
meh, it's pretty good for MMD
>>83221075
I dont know if it's a fair comparsion as one is 2D and the other is 3D animation.
Unless PPG is now 3D or something
You ain't wrong though as I'm struggling to think of any western 3d animated show. Maybe something from nerd corp but that's canadian...
>>83220409
What? My only posts were
>>83218320
>>83218609
>>83219732
>>83220317
I can't believe how much of an idiot you are.
>>83221706
Sure buddy.
>>83221075
So you genuinely think that the mainstream shit like Adventure Time, TTG and Steven Universe is better than this? It's made on a shoestring budget and only one person on the team even knew what he was doing but it's still way better than that shit.
You're so butthurt that people like this show that you've gone completely delusional. Why does it make you so angry?
>>83220271
I forgot Shane's letter was a thing. A friend who follows Rooster Teeth outside of RWBY told me about it. RWBY is the only RT series I care about. Yeah, RWBY is flawed as hell, but eh. I like what I like. I could do without the rest of the fan base, desu.
>>83221933
How long have you been here? You're not OP, are you?
>>83221936
>Adventure Time
Compared to Rwby, it's a masterpiece.
>TTG
Fuck, I forgot that was a thing. Nah, TTG is shit.
>SU
I don't follow SU. But yeah, animation wise it's still better than Rwby.
There's a reason Rwby is on /trash/ friend.
>>83221976
>You're not OP, are you?
No, because I actually have a life. I can't spend my every waking moment on 4chan.
>>83210563
Source?
>>83222143
>No, because I actually have a life.
Dude, you've spent the last few hours insulting strangers on the internet because you're enraged that they like a cartoon you dislike. You don't have a life.
>>83222278
First post I made was an hour ago. Nice try though.
>>83222270
Overlord
>>83222462
Sure buddy.
Can I just like the show or do I need to always justify my tastes?
>>83221964
Shrug no worries man, you're aware that it's flaw and its okay to like it.
I've met people who refused to see any flaws in it and any kind of critism was met with "it's that style"
>>83222547
ebin
>>83222505
Sigh
>watch Overlord for a few episodes
>think "hey this is a pretty interesting idea"
>suddenly several episodes about him as an adventurer that end up not mattering at all
>look it up
>realize it's based on a light novel
>realize the show is going to end with no resolution of any kind and the main plot won't move forward at all
Why do I keep falling for this
>>83222733
Yeah, it was pretty bad. Watched the whole, the ending was pretty boring.
>>83222733
I read summaries of the rest of the series just because I wanted to know what happens... as of the latest book, he apparently still hasn't met anyone from the old game and it's basically just become "nice guy pretending to be evil guy while minions go about their business" with no real intention of moving the plot forward.
So his whole plan to make the name of his guild famous in hopes of attracting other players who might also be stuck has been completely forgotten. Apparently he also has shown no interest in finding out why any of this even happened to begin with.
To be perfectly honest I understand that in terms of presentation, yeah RWBY has had some shit animation but it's also had some decent moments, and you have to take into account that it's also done independently without an massive budget or time.
I would just say if you want to watch it watch, if you don't then don't. If you don't know then just watch like the first three or so episodes and figure it out yourself. You like it or you don't. I'm not gonna sit here and try to convince you to watch if you don't want to be convinced.
I like it, so I watch it.
>>83222860
I dont know what summaries you are reading man. In the last book he took over a country and killed I think 70000 men from the army of another country himself, which itself was an attempt to draw out any other players that might be hiding there.
>>83219863
> /co/ is filled with buthurt people that want to hate everything so it doesn't matter trying to bring lame shit like ''logic''
Says the guy who claims to hate a show because of how it looks.
>>83222969
>In the last book he took over a country and killed I think 70000 men from the army of another country himself, which itself was an attempt to draw out any other players that might be hiding there.
I must've missed that one. Either way, the plot's still not advancing if we're on book 8 or 9 and he's still doing the "w-well maybe if I do this someone from the old game will show up?" thing with no results.
>>83208279
Are those gunchucks? What the hell happens in this show?
Anyone who honestly thinks RWBY has genuinely good animation is full of shit. I know people who are fans of the show yet can still admit that the animation is garbageinb4 "what have you made" and "I doubt you could do better"
>>83209970
okay, I'm not the biggest RWBY fan but I'll gladly reute your criticisms. What exactly are they?
>>83223128
It doesn't take itself too seriously.
Plus who doesn't love over the top weapons every once in a while? As long as they don't try to pretend it could ever work in reality I'm fine with it.I'm also a huge ancient and medieval combat nerd. Not a professional historian and I've barely done mock fencing, but I'm pretty confident in my ability to point out bullshit and I still enjoy the combat.
>>83223108
People from the game probably wont show up. They seem to pop up every couple hundred years or so so most of the rest that did show up probably died of old age. You get hints about them sometimes though, like the minotaur sage that tried to invent shit from the real world but didnt know how they worked and the descendants of player characters being way stronger than the natives.
He killed a giant evil tree from the game once though.
>>83220013
blood sacrifice made the show better
>>83220408
Literally, unironically scooby doo.
And it's proper animation as opposed to basically a shitty videogame cutscene you can't skip.
>>83223462
Is shaggy a secret badass that just has a crippling fear of the supernatural or something?
>>83223555
Yeah, the webm was him being hypnotized to have no fear of anything, but not being afraid of things doesn't suddenly make you a badass fighter so that's on him.
He also apparently races motorcycles too.
>>83223462
If you think that this is more technical than say https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-hLjX5pZv48 you are retarded. But for comparisons sake one of Ruby's critical flaws is that it's a 3D show that's animated like a 2D show. RWBY would look much better if it took a page from pokemon.
>And it's proper animation as opposed to basically a shitty videogame cutscene you can't skip.
Never got the anti CG craze. waaaaah it's not what I grew up with waaaaah. kinda sad.
>>83208249
One of the things I liked about Symphogear is that Hibiki HAD to learn how to fight before she started to pull the karate moves. It was a nice detail.
>>83223625
That was a surprisingly good Scooby-Doo movie.
>>83223757
CG can be fine but a lot of it is really just not good. Not that guy but you really cant argue that RWBY isnt badly animated. Not that the guys doing it have the resources to do it well but still.
>>83223757
God, that looks like such shit. The voice acting for the one with the scythe was really bad too. The guy with the cane wasn't so bad.
>>83223913
Gotta have some stones to fight people with lightsabers with an axe.
>>83223848
It'll slowly get better seeing how the main people making it shit before (monty himself) isn't involved anymore.
Hopefully animation won't be as stiffed as he is now
>>83224004
Guy's hopped up on Force steroids, basically
>>83223913
>The voice acting for the one with the scythe was really bad too.
In their defense, the budget is so low that they have to get Rooster Teeth staffers to do the voices.
But yeah, the voice acting is bad and Ruby sounds like a grown woman trying to sound like a congested little girl.
>>83223848
>CG can be fine but a lot of it is really just not good.
What makes a lot of it "not good". CG is superior to 2D on every front to the point that most of the 2D in existence has to integrate it to not be obsolete.
>Not that guy but you really cant argue that RWBY isnt badly animated.
I told you it's using a flawed animation technique by imitating anime. It's not beautiful but it's not objectively bad. Just flawed.
>>83223913
That was some very well placed and totally valid criticism. Truly a patrician of the arts.
>>83224155
>What makes a lot of it "not good"
The fact that its being done by a bunch of amateurs without much experience and probably not great tools for one thing.
>>83224150
The newest season started getting some professional VAs involved (most of the main cast is sadly still the same), and it apparently caused some butthurt behind the scenes.
>>83209854
>that one flashback to when Salem first met him
>she shows up at the house and finds it burning down
>Mercury hobbles over with his fucked up legs
>"YEEEAAAH! WHO WON THE LOTTERY? I DID!
>>83224252
Only butthurt one is Shane from what it sounds like
>>83224233
>without much experience and probably not great tools for one thing.
amateurishly done also looks terrible. your point?
>>83224331
It makes it not good because the people animating it arent good at it.
