>there are people on /co/ RIGHT NOW who don't think that Treasure Planet was the best movie to come out of the Disney Renaissance
>>82476330
What? You serious? What are mods even doing?
>>82476330
I was pretty average imo, not bad but not good either.
Atlantis was GOAT.
>>82476330
It's a close call between Treasure Planet and Atlantis, desu senpai
>>82476349
>>82476350
I don't get it. I don't disagree with OP?
>>82476871
Fucking idiot retard
>>82476330
It was good. Not the best.
Also
>inb4 Silver Arm Anon
>>82476330
Well, those people on /co/ would be right.
>>82477050
>Silver Arm Anon
Can we go for one. Thread. Without him.
>>82476330
It's a decent movie, but by the time I watched it I had seen Muppet Treasure Island so much that I couldn't help but compare the two. MPI is much better IMO.
If you took out the robot it would be a top tier disney movie.
>>82477503
I meant MTI, Muppet Treasure Island. MPI isn't anything.
>>82477558
This. BEN was too fucking much, ruined the gravitas of the movie
>>82477558
>>82477997
I agree whole-heartedly
>>82476330
>>82477050
>>82477161
What?
>>82477161
No.
>>82476330
I 'like' Treasure Planet (nostalgia), but it's one of those hit or miss movies Disney tried to do when they were appealing to the male demographic. Disney has the female demographic locked down, but for boys, they kept experimenting with stuff and making it EXTREME! (Hence why Tarzan looks like he's surfing on vines and Jim looks like he's wind sailing). Eventually, this all culminated with Atlantis the Lost Empire and this.
When they realized they couldn't do it, they just said "Fuck it" and bought Marvel Studios.
>>82478944
This CAN'T be real
>>82476330
Treasure Planet was awful. Great visuals and a cool setting, but most of the characters were awful, their arcs were mostly awful as well, the comic relief was literally Hunchback-tier movie-ruining and in the story was a hollow and uninspired adaptation, which was a goddamn crime when considering how much they could have done with that setting.
>>82479341
How were the arcs awful? Jim grew up, the dog guy got brave, the captain became emotionally open, and Silver gained some responsibility. Nix the le funny robot and keep Mr Arrow, and you have top tier Disney
>>82479418
>Jim grew up
He turned from a shitty stereotypical teenager into a generic disney hero. It
s development, but it's not exactly inspired.
>the dog guy got brave, the captain became emotionally open
There was no real development here. They basically just threw a switch on their personalities the moment they hit the planet.
>and Silver gained some responsibility
Silver is the only character I actually liked all through the movie. Sure he was a shitbag at times, but his arc was definitely the best one in the movie. No sudden changes because the plot calls for it, but a believable transition from a selfish shitbag to a less selfish shitbag with a heart. Arrow was decent as well but died to soon to make a lasting impression, and Amelia started off good but was reduced to a useless damsel and love interest bait after she got shot.
>>82476330
>treasure planet
>Disney Renaissance
All I can think of now when I see Treasure Planet is that one chick with the terrible Mary Sue fanart that fucked him.
>>82480444
You mean the one where there's Jane from Tarzan for no reason at all?
>>82480635
No, the self-insert one that reads like a really awkward Kingdom Hearts comic.
>>82480695
Ah, I don't know that one, luckily.
>>82476330
This exact same thread was made before (with the exact text and image).
To reiterate, Disney Renaissance is a different time period.
>>82476330
That movie hit too close to home for me.
It's one of those where I identify heavily with the MC.
Also a personal favorite.
Le Hidden Gem Syndrome: When an overall well made but obviously flawed film is a critical and/or financial failure causing its devout fanbase to defensively inflate it's quality
>>82479229
You shit talking Atlantis?
>>82476330
Treasure Planet was underwhelming shite, and the sooner you realize it the better.
It's not part of the Renaissance, even if it was Aladdin is the best.
>>82479308
You better believe it.
Titan AE >>>>> Treasure Planet > Atlantis
Muppet Treasure Island came out 8 years prior and was an infinitely better film.
>>82478944
lmaooooo
>>82481999
I thought I've seen this before lel
Is it bait, or just an actual retard?
>>82477161
You and I both know that will never happen
>>82477503
>>82477696
>that metal as fuck intro song
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tABNCSDoUSY
Thank you based Hanz Zimmer
>>82476330
It was good, but weren't nearly that good.
Silver's pretty much the saving grace of the movie along with Captain LOLcat.
>>82485195
>Realizing this was made before POTC
>Realize Hans Zimmer stole from himself
I was twelve, but it was a huge mind-bender for me.
>>82485529
Silver was underwhelming, especially when compared to Tim Curry. His relationship with Jim was never convincing.
>>82485599
Well, not every Silver can be Tim Curry's Long John Silver. He's legitimately the best version of the character, ever.
>>82485694
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nrj8EZm9ca8
>>82485195
>>82482341
Anybody realize that the Muppets nearly always strike gold with their literary adaptations? Their Christmas Carol is fantastic too. (Infinitely better than CGI'd Jim Carey)
>>82485773
I wish they'd do more literary adaptions, instead of Office-esque TV shows.
HELLOHELLOHELLO
>>82476330
>that moment when it looks like Silver is going to legit kill Hawkins for knowing too much
That was some suspenseful shit.
>>82485837
Ugh, that piece-of-shit ABC show made me want to hurl. I was EXPECTING a modern return to the classic "Muppet Show", with guests, acts and all that. The variety-show format worked, goddammit, don't mess with a good thing.
I mean, c'mon. The old version had Vincent fucking Price!
>>82478944
>at least im the guy whos always prepared for anything
my fucking sides
>>82486038
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJh9W3Gcpmo
>>82486038
it got a bit better when they came back, they clearly listened to fans a bit and fixed it
basically, the first half of the season was "The muppets tonight 2" and the second half was its own new show
>>82486151
>Animal drum battles Buddy friggin Rich
I had completely forgotten this awesomeness.
>>82476349
>>82476350
Treasure planet was GOAT, yeah OP was wrong about the movie being part of the Disney Renaissance, but it's still one of the best animated Disney movies after the Lion King.
>>82485897
Link to the best of Silver scnes?
>>82482235
>>82482198
>>82481999
>>82480397
>>82477022
>>82476349
>>82476350
>>82486932
OP here, how is it not Disney Renaissance?
No I'm not memeing, explain
>>82485860
Ben you fucking cock juggler, there were already 2 other comic relief characters, the movie didn't need a third one introduced at the last fucking act. Why the fuck were you put in, who thought it was a good idea?
>>82487443
The Disney Renaissance ended with Tarzan in 1999
Is their a Kingdom Hearts level based on it?
>>82478944
We laugh, but try to find a 4-limbed prosthesis engineer with more passion. Wonder what the crazy guy would do with a 3D printer.
>>82478944
>tfw I was in that thread
So amazing and it came out of nowhere. Sometimes you guys are alright.
>>82476330
I love silver, he is more than your Disney villain he is driven by greed but isn't evil just driven. and becomes a mentor to the kid and his voice is awesome
>>82476330
That's because, believe it or not, there people on /co/ who actually have two working brain cells, and realize that Treasure Planet wasn't part of the Renaissance
>>82476330
>only half the movie, maybe even less than half is actually really good
>B.E.N is in it
Jim and Silver's relationship is great shit for Disney movie standards, but the rest of the film falls short.
Treasure Planet? It's time.
>>82491412
>>82491423
>>82491442
you stop that
>>82491454
No.
>>82491412
>>82491457
>that fuckin gut
He's so fat, fucking christ
>this thread
>>82491473
he looks like a scarred potato from behind
>>82491166
I've actually designed and built a prosthetic mechanical knee that is on the market, but that guy is pretty nuts.
>>82491457
>>82491464
>>82491473
>>82491481
the longer I look at him without his hat the more I see Hitler hair
>>82491412
From what I remember, this lady's a teacher and she's apparently very open about her fantasy self-insert romance with a fictional obese pirate
They reproduced?
>>82491604
Shit, maybe she and the arm artist should meet up lol
>>82491412
>>82491423
>>82491442
>>82491457
>>82491464
>>82491473
>>82491481
>>82491537
>>82491552
>>82491587
>>82491600
IMPORTANT QUESTION:
Does his mechanical arm feature any... pleasure gizmos?
i don't know what it is about this guy because she's not the first one to ship their self-insert with him. there was this girl from i think the netherlands, had a brown tiger fursona and she was REALLY possessive over him. it was fucking weird.
>>82491704
From the looks of this, yes.
>>82491643
>it has a tail
huh
>>82491767
Silver got cucked by Simba
That's why he looks unhappy
>>82491827
>>82491796
That's a sentence I never thought I'd fucking read
Holy fuck...between the OP copypasta, the arm autist, and self-insert chick, is it ever EVER going to be possible to have a non-meme discussion about this movie ever again? I actually like it, and now every TP thread is just these same three subjects on loop
Oh, and the furry captain too, but no one's spammed the thread with her yet
>>82491838
>>82491880
No, the movie is ruined forever. I'm sorry you had to find out this way.
thinking about it, don't think i ever actually watched treasure planet. i know i definitely played the psx game when it came out though. i shall have to remedy the situation.
thinking more on it, i played more video game adaptations than watched movies back in the day.
those graphics looked a lot nicer in my memory hole.
maybe i actually played it on ps2?
>>82486932
It was fucking awful
>>82479229
Tarzan was fucking fantastic though. Treasure Planet was good, Atlantis...would have been better if it was longer, or had more polished execution for its big ideas.
>>82479341
>only Disney movie other than Hunchback where the villain is interesting and has a character arc
Nigga you have shit taste.
>>82485599
jesus christ I wanna bang that
>>82492007
>>82492010
>>82492055
>>82492079
>>82492089
>>82492135
>>82492519
>
>this awesome setting will never be explored ever again.
might as well post this then
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahVKiBDMBHw
>>82492800
Honestly this... I know that people bitched about there being better versions of Treasure Island, but you can't help but admire how cool their interpretation of the setting was. An almost steampunk, Age of Sail in space is such a cool idea
>>82492618
You don't like our cat waifu, son?
>>82492344
See >>82479568
Silver was good. Everything else wasn't.
>>82492918
It was definitely a great setting. I have some issues with how literally they transplanted some ideas (space pirates sailing the space ocean by using the space wind and breathing the salty space air), but the setting definitely had a lot more potential than what they did with it in the movie.
>>82494450
Completely ignoring the characters and plot, what would have made the setting better? Not memeing, genuinely curious
