[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Marguerite Bennett
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 105
Thread images: 19
Why is this allowed?
>>
>>
>>81694834
>It's not heavy handed if I'm meta about it!
>>
>>81694834
>trying to make a joke about "ad nauseam"
>literally jsut repeat it with an implied "LOL I SAID NAUSEAM"
this is why you never hire school drop out, no matter how cheap.
>>
>>
File: 1431757241539.jpg (27 KB, 592x448) Image search: [Google]
1431757241539.jpg
27 KB, 592x448
>>81694834
I thought only marvel did this
>>
>>
>>81694834
>already here
nice Homestuck reference
>>
I'd make more sense if Batgirls weren't drawn like 12 year olds and you start thinking of Lisa Simpson.
>Batgirls
>none of them are Barbara, Stephanie and Cassandra
At least I don't remember. I do remember Harper Row being in comic.
>>
There are people who got upset when Bennett didn't get Wonder Woman. Thank you based Rucka.
>>
>>
Isn't this comic set in WWII? Not that people weren't always harping on about how much better the past was, but if you're going meta you should riff on the fact that literally all these people, even the progressive heroes, would have had a patriotic hatred for the Japanese.
>>
>the man across the ocean

Hue hue I wonder who that could be
>>
Isn't this the jerk writer that killed Stargirl?
>>
File: 1398555363910.jpg (228 KB, 902x421) Image search: [Google]
1398555363910.jpg
228 KB, 902x421
>bitter writer creates smarmy filler text for fight scenes
I see nothing out of the ordinary here.

>>81694861
Lucky duck, you've been dodging a lot of bullets.
>>
>>81694910
They even stopped beating Nazis and replaced them with evil zombies. Lame.
>>
>>81694861
She worked there too
>>
>>81694915
>>
File: 0987645342.jpg (14 KB, 316x202) Image search: [Google]
0987645342.jpg
14 KB, 316x202
>>81694934
>the darkest timeline
>>
>>
>>81694934
What the actual fuck is going on with the lettering here. I have no idea what order these shitty one liners are supposed to be in.
>>
Makes me want to support Trump
>>
So is this an elseworlds line? I'm not impressed at all. Look harvey was a bit bull headed but he cared about everyone. This is character assassination.
>>
>>81695026
You should see what is done to Batman.
>>
>>81695026
Its based on those Bombshell covers. Its not that good
>>
>>81695037
I thought he just didn't exist.
>>
>>81695037
Didnt they retcon the age? Or is everything still fucked? I don't know shit
>>
>>81695037
I'm afraid to ask
>>
>>81695068
That's the joke.
>>81695073
Batwoman saved his parents from Joe Chill. And Bruce is still kid, while Hal serves as pilot.
>>
>>81695026
>So is this an elseworlds line?
Yes.
>I'm not impressed at all. Look harvey was a bit bull headed but he cared about everyone. This is character assassination.
No, this is an alternate interpretation of an alternate character. Regular Harvey Dent is a different character. In this "oh look, enlightened people in the past are just like me and my friends" universe, Dent is figuratively two-faced, rather than literally two-faced. That's dull and shallow, but you can't assassinate a character that barely exists, and it's not like anybody cares to make this new Dent anything other than a target for these batgirls to swing at.
>>
>>81695041
Holy shit those covers are oozing hipster.
Glad I'm not reading this
>>
This never had any chance of being good, but it's such a waste of good designs.
>>
>>81695111
The term hipster originated from that time.
The problem is that the writers aren't writing it like it takes place in the 40s. Its a modern story with a filter slapped on.
>>
>>81695097
>>81695104
Well thanks for clarification.
I get that it's different Dents but it's pretty lame to make him seem like not-trump. Its cheap on many levels
>>
Which is the better female centered Elseworlds?

Ame-Comi Girls or Bombshells?
>>
>>81695185
Haven't read ame-comi girls but I'll still go wit dat since it came out a while before all this nonsense
>>
>>81695185
Ame-Comi was good for a while until the Trigon arc started and it all went to shit
>>
>>81694834

Does that bitch know anything other than fourth-wall breaking?
>>
>>81695158
It is cheap. It would bug me, too, but this level of execution seems like the standard for the industry so it doesn't register any offense for me anymore.
>>
>>81695097
>And Bruce is still kid, while Hal serves as pilot.
Hal is Bruce's pilot?
>>
Maggie Bens is a shitty writer

More at 11.
>>
I just passed the hate for Bennet as being the usual, "I don't like it, so the writer is shit" but god damn this is some incredibly pedestrian writing. All the dialogue reads like it's from some shitty fan fiction.

Not really surprised she was fired from DC anymore.
>>
>>81695151
That's one of my biggest issues with Bennett, she can't alter her dialogue to not sound modern at all and she has a big problem with characters all sounding the same
>>
>>81695285
>Not really surprised she was fired from DC anymore.
She wasn't fired from anything, she's still on Bombshells
>>
>>81695268
Nah, military pilot. Harley lured him to dark corner, and he hoping for quickie, followed her. She smacked him and stole his plane.
Classic Hal.
>Harley flies
>plane crashes on Ivy's house
>Ivy is killing men
>Harley goes all OH MY SEXY MAMA, LOOK AT YOUR TITTIES!
>Ivy keeps rolling eyes and acts like Harley is scum
>they two fuck off into sunset never to be seen again
>>
>>81695320
Isn't Hal British in this? There's a lot of nationality swapping
>>
>>81695158
>I get that it's different Dents but it's pretty lame to make him seem like not-trump. I
It's more like "Not-McCarthy."
>>
>>81695308
Didn't realize she was still on it. The way people were talking during the Rebirth thing with her being passed over on Wonder Woman it sounded like she wasn't working with DC at all anymore. Something about her setting up a patreon too.
>>
>>81695355
I'd have to check, but I don't remember. I remember Selina being Italian and Supergirl and Stargirl being Russian.
>>
>>81695285
This IS basically designed to be shitty AU-WWII fanfiction. It's like someone saw 'A League of their Own' for the first time and was like, what if this movie was Batman?

>>81695361
I mean, the way comic creators get paid pretty much all of them should have Patreons.
>>
>>81695320
The only thing that Bennett did right was the Harley/Ivy dynamic. Shame she dropped that plot
>>
>>81695320
Are there any men in it that arent super evil or super sexist?
>>
>>81695359
It's kind of a mix of both, "Make Gotham Golden Again" and "blah blah immigrants" is clearly a Trump reference, and the crackdown on "Batgirlist sympathizers" is clearly a McCarthy reference

>>81695361
She set up a patreon because her Marvel book was canceled for being shit and she lost the Wonder Woman gig to Rucka

>>81695391
There are some who are just dumb
>>
>>81695391
Hal wasn't really sexist, he just wanted to smooch a clown
>>
>>81695361
She's only working in Bombshells and doesn't write for Marvel at all. She needs to pay for hospital bills so her setting one up is for the best.
>>81695291
This so much. She's not subtle, tries to hard to sound like she's saying something, and all her characters are the same. There's a difference from being in sync and being clones. Her characters are clones.
>>
>>81695391
>Siren's husband mega evil
>Riddler evil
>Stargirl's dad evil
Mhm. Steve Trevor is good, and he whines about HORRORS OF WAR every panel. Constantine is good, but turned into fluffy rabbit. Can't remember Lex's alignment.
>>
>>81695415
>Constantine is good, but turned into fluffy rabbit.
A chain smoking fluffy rabbit?
>>
File: 1.jpg (698 KB, 1650x1268) Image search: [Google]
1.jpg
698 KB, 1650x1268
>>81695457
Yep.
>>
>>81695524
>Stronger than I-- no

This shit is unintentionally hilarious. This writer should attend that comic writing course DC is offering this year.
>>
>>81695565
She saw Joker's Daughter.
With piranha teeth.
>>
>>81694852
I'm glad she got booted from Wonder Woman in favor of an actual talented writer. Maybe the same can happen with all of her books.
>>
>>81694834
Because we gave women the vote.

>>81695565
She got her start because she was one of Snyder's students in the first place.
>>
>>81695601
>Because we gave women the vote.

Based Islam
>>
>>81694915
No, not the doodle!
>>
>>81694956
where are the men? where is superman and batman and the rest of the boys?
>>
File: eR76a.gif (61 KB, 664x719) Image search: [Google]
eR76a.gif
61 KB, 664x719
>>81695565
>>81695586
So there's definitely no I-no, then? Shame.
>>
>>81695615
>where are the men?
In the kitchen?
>>
>>81695615
It's WWII, they all got drafted
>>
>>81695628
Based Guitartits.
>>
>>81695185
Ame-Comi.
Ame do not take itself seriously for shit, which makes it great
>>
>>81695601
That's a little worrisome, since Snyder is teaching the class. Snyder's a decent writer, but if this is the kind of student he churns out I'm kind of afraid to see more.
>>
>>81695615
Bruce is a child so there's no Batman

Dunno about Kal, maybe his rocket got lost
>>
>>81695615
#killallmen
>>
>>81695646
so, you are telling Superman is fighting in germany and the allies still can't win in a week?
>>
>>81695524
I'm...I'm surprisingly okay with this.

Must be the hair tuft, it makes him adorable.
>>
>>81695660
Honestly, Snyder could use a few more writing lessons. He fluked into comics writing while struggling to write a novel.
>>
File: 1072366-fourth_reich_1.jpg (61 KB, 421x640) Image search: [Google]
1072366-fourth_reich_1.jpg
61 KB, 421x640
>>81695676
I imagine the Nazis must have Wunderwaffen of their own
>>
>>81695676
Why Superman doesn't fix all of Gotham's problems in a week? He could, if he wanted to.
>>
>>81695698
I almost forgot about Captain Nazi.
>>
>>81695633
what's Superman doing for breakfast?
>>81695709
we all know Batman won't let him do it, he loves the joker and the criminal life of gotham, what's he gonna do with peace? he NEEDS the criminals.
>>
>>81694834
Why are people even reading Bombshells still? It's Injustice levels of dumb insanity but without any of the moments where that dumb insanity is fun. It's just a soap box of suffering and I've seen it being recommended whole heartedly.
>>
>>81695811
>Barda
>Light
>Supergirl
>Stargirl
>WW
>Mera
>Zatanna
Yeah, I'd read it even if art was stick figures and written by Lobdell.
>>
File: 1432012334726.jpg (612 KB, 588x535) Image search: [Google]
1432012334726.jpg
612 KB, 588x535
>>81695720
How could you forget about the best villain?
>>
>>81695855
>Barda is banging Kimiyo Hoshi and not a fem Scott

I'm still mad
>>
>>81695885
>Getting mad about an alternate universe book

I don't read this shit but who gives a fuck? It has nothing to do with the canon universe anyway.
>>
File: Baroness_Blitzkrieg_2.jpg (163 KB, 324x760) Image search: [Google]
Baroness_Blitzkrieg_2.jpg
163 KB, 324x760
>>81695870
But that's not best Nazi villain.
>>
>>81695913
Because I want to see Scott and Barda as lesbians
>>
>>81695957
Go make your own shitty fan fiction like this one then.

There, problem solved.
>>
>>81696003
You seem upset, friend
>>
>>81695957
Scotia?
Eh, they avoided genderbending so far.
>>
>>81694852
What is this dialogue? Their diction is completely fucked.

>lol if u go back 2 enforcing da law and cracking down on bad business practices that also means segregation

Well gee I guess we better just let things keep getting shittier because otherwise retards will whine we want to holocaust the joker
>>
The funny part about retards whining about "make america great again" is that "making america great again" was ronald reagan's campaign slogan too
>>
>>81696204
I thought that was "Morning in America"
>>
>>81695698
>>81695870

Much as I hate to say it... I always thought that even wartime german superheroes... should still be superheroes instead of villains. They're villains because they're fighting the Justice Society or the Invaders or whatever...

But, c'mon, I wanna see just one comic where the team of nazi ubermench are saving civilians during the fire bombing of Dresden or some shit.

They should still be heroes, just on the other side...
>>
>>81696358
As logical of an idea as that is, it's impossible to do because of the horrible backlash the publisher would receive. Even more so in modern society when people are so easily offended. It'd be more trouble than its worth.
>>
>>81696358
There's something like that in Uber where you have the three Nazi battleship-class superhumans --- one is a psychopath who loves killing people, but of the other two, one is just a patriot trying to protect Germany from Hitler's stupidity and the other is a widow who wants revenge for the death of her husband during the Dresden bombing.

They're still presented as the villains of the story, just not as one-dimensionally evil as you would expect
>>
>>81695104
> a target for these batgirls to swing at.
CARLOOOOS!
>>
I would like to see a female bigot in a story, you know how rich white women use brown women as maids, but in this case as sidekicks with something slightly sinister at play. The happy and cheery acceptance they portray and seemingly push for is looking rather dishonest now.
>>
>>81696423
I'm not saying they shouldn't still be villains. They're still nazis, they just shouldn't be cartoonish one dimensional villains that like to kick puppies. Or at least not all of them.

The idea that they come off as being monsters... just chafes me the wrong way. Like Captain Nazi can't fight Captain Marvel all the time. What does he do when he doesn't? Dont' tell me he sits in his castle plotting the downfall of the Allies... there's german kittens in german trees that belong to little german girls. They're not gonna get themselves out...
>>
>>81696711
Like owner of that orphanage where Harper's brother was enslaved to build Nazi deathbots?
>>
>>81694834
She... has no idea what Harvey Dent was like before becoming Two-Face, does she?
>>
>>81695041
I like the Bombshell designs, so I was looking forward to this book. Too bad it's trash. Couldn't make it further than the third issue.
>>
>>81696848
Those German trees keep hailing. Fuck them.
>>
>>81695744
>what's Superman doing for breakfast?
beef cake
>>
>>81696076
if there were more than one joker I'd want to definetly engage in some genocide
Thread replies: 105
Thread images: 19

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.