Who would win in a fight, if Saitama fought Popeye who had access to more than one can of spinach?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8p_SABG3SPk
Video shows that Popeye would be eager to start shit with a Jap. Given both of their absurd invulnerability and immense power who would win?
>>81546132
Why the fuck are we still having these threads? Saitama wins. SAITAMA ALWAYS FUCKING WINS. He can kill ANYTHING IN ONE FUCKING PUNCH. He is so comicly overpowered that it is joke his show revolves around ONE PUNCH MAN. People will try to over think this shit so much, bring mind control shit into it and all that bullshit, but the fact is, if he gets ONE punch on whoever, whoever he decides to fuck up dies I don't even watch or read his shit, I just know enough about him that he kills ANYTHING, any FUCKING thing he can punch. This thread is pointless, so just fucking STOP. SAITAMA WINS IN ONE PUNCH.
>>81547052
Droopy would fuck him up
>>81547052
>he can kill ANYTHING IN ONE FUCKING PUNCH
Apart from the time he couldn't.
Christ One Punch Meme fans are even worse than dbztards.
Speaking of, Goku would tear Saitama a new hole. So would Superman.
>>81547052Power Man
>>81547052
I dunno man. Popeye's pretty badass.
>>81547052
>Physical fighter with no resistance to magic
>Who is Dr. Strange
>Who is Zatanna
>Who is Raven
>Who is any fucking multi-dimensional spell caster
>>81547052
You forget that Popeye gets bonuses against slapping a jap.
>>81546132
Saitama. Popeye only has raw strength and healing spinach.
Saitama gives zero fucks about these things, his whole point is absurd overpowered strength.
Saitama's not even that hard to beat since he has several key weaknesses. He needs to breath. He can't fly. He's not immune to telekinesis, just highly resistant. He has no known immunity to mind control. Etc. Hell, he would have lost one of his major fights except he hit the moon instead of going into deep space.
Saitama is easy to beat, as long as you aren't trying to use raw strength against him. Fight smarter, not harder.
>>81547052
>What is Boros?
>>81546132
one with the worst karma loses
Saitama is a better person than Popeye
>>81547052
>>81547102
>being this dense
Fact is, saitama is fast as crap and if he touches you, you're dead. No second try. Even if you're god in a physical body your face is gonna twist and distort in a very funny manner that'll only mark your fall. At this point it's not even a fanboy fight on who would win. The plot of one punch man barely revolves around actual fights and challenges at this point. Seriously. It's the animu strongest of all the animu strongest characters, and that's a lot.
>>81548038
these people aren't even putting in effort to bait anymore
Bait used to mean something
>Joke character where the joke is "he's a boring invincible hero who can beat anyone easily"
>Semi-serious comedy character whose "gimmick" is being very strong
I mean... it's pretty obvious, right?
>>81548137
yeah, Popeye clearly wins
>>81547212
>He needs to breath. He can't fly. He's not immune to telekinesis, just highly resistant. He has no known immunity to mind control.
So does he have any sort of energy sttacks because from the sounds of it Martian Manhuter has this guy beat. Just go intangible and mind fuck him
>>81546132
Popeye has feats. Saitama doesn't.
>>81546132
>Popeye vs Anime
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYRPvz-LV-k&nohtml5
Oh, I think we ALL know who'll come out on top...
>>81547102
So you're stupid and can't understand him wanting a climatic battle?
>>81546132
Saitama kills Popeye with the first punch, Popeye for the first time eats two can's of spinach. Their fists collide, the universe caught between them dies.
Popeye grabs a bucket of paint containing stars and throws one to Saitama, yelling at him to "gets to work" as the two gods remake everything.
>>81547052
Popeye isn't using strength. He's reality warping with his fists.
I believe Popeye is an elder god dreaming it is a man. Why do you think one eye is always closed? This "man" learned "Spinach makes you strong" so it does, but it was never bound by this reality so it's definition of strong ignores physics.
>>81548933
if you want a climactic battle you don't go to 'I always win' characters. You pit, say, Luke Cage vs Red Hood, or Yosodomy Sam vs Kraven the Hunter
>>81549874
>if popeye opened his 2nd eye the world would blasted into oblivion
Popeye has the toonforce.
It depends entirely on what animation his biceps get after he eats the spinach. I mean, is he rocking battleships, anvils, or howitzers?
>>81547739
I really don't see how Saitama can match Spinach lusted Popeye. He literally warps reality with his fists.
> so many stupid people here
>>81547052 is right. Saitama power is, especifically, he wins. You can put fucking Godman against him, he will win. Because that's the perk of his entire show: he is unable to lose.
>>81547052
>I don't even watch or read his shit
So you don't even know what you're talking about. Good to know.I don't watch it either but at least I'm not writing a retarded rant about it.
>>81550774
You and that other guy are fucking retards.
Saitama is just a really strong guy in a world of weaker characters. His "serious punch" is a planetary level force at best. Even if he wasn't going all out with that punch, he at least put effort into it suggesting his actual limit isn't that much greater.
He doesn't even come close to what Popeye can achieve, which is pretty much blatant toonforce reality warping given the nature of his show.
>>81546132
If Popeye instigates the fight, he will lose. If Saitama does instead, Popeye will win. Simple as that.
>>81551505
The only correct anon in this thread. ToonForce works against instigators as noted in almost every cartoon ever. So if Popeye starts it for whatever reason he gets one punched into oblivion. But if saitama starts it for whatever reason, which I don't think he ever started a fight in his anime, he loses.
>>81547739
I'm convinced.
>>81547161
You can toss him around like a doll but it won't do any damage to him.
>>81551217
>His "serious punch" is a planetary level force at best.
According to the creator, his actual serious punch would be powerful enough to destroy the entire universe.
>>81550051
Atom bombs.
>>81551907
That doesnt make any sense. He's purely physical strength. How can a physical impact on such a small scale, no matter how strong, destroy a universe?
>>81547052
http://dc.wikia.com/wiki/Category:Immortality
http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Category:Immortals
Is spinach even good?
>>81552243
No
So much that the spinach industry had to bulid a Popeye statue for him helping them to lie to children
>>81547052
Anon is not wrong. Popeye has a lose condition (running out of spinach), Saitama doesn't have one that we know of.
>>81552243
Spinach is only good when it is converted to a curry or a dip.
Saitama's gimmick is yhat he always wins. He might be able to get some entertainment out of this fight, but he is literally unstoppable and will win regardless.
>>81552243
if you prepare it with any modicum of culinary skill rather than just boiling it in water like a caveman like you american hipsters like to do with all your vegetables
>>81546132
Whoever has the most cartoon physics.
Well, Popeye knows the satisfaction of a good scrap, so he already wins in my opinion.
>>81551907
Gonna need a source bud
>>81552830
>Saitama's gimmick is yhat he always wins
No, his gimmick is that's he's surpassed the human form's limit's, which in his universe gives him bullshit power.
Always winning is just a byproduct of that.
>>81546132
>that warship
holy fuck
>>81546132
>>81547052
>>81552830
Funny. Popeyes gimmick is that after he eats spinach, he alawys wins. And while Saitama has strenght and some speed, Popeye has strenght, speed and straight up reality breaking feats. >>81547739 Popeye can fly, he is immune to magic, capable of resurrecting, capable of punching the animator, and capable of transforming things with his fists. Saitama is not on his level.
>>81547161
He has magic resistance tho, the one time he let a psychic attack him it didn't do any damage to him.
>>81547052
Are Saitamafags really this delusional?
>>81553383
No, we've seen resistance to psychic powers, specifically telekinesis, not magic. They aren't really the same thing.
>>81553429
What makes you think he wouldn't be resistant to magic as well?
>>81552243
Certainly not when it's coming out of a can.
>>81552304
only a nephew of popeye would say that.
>>81553468
In Saitama-verse, psychic powers involve psychic waves, they're something you can block/alter to mess psychic attacks up.
I'm guessing that Saitama is gonna be like Superman in regards to magic, no special resistance.
Regardless, there's nothing to prove one way or another whether or not Saitama would be affect by magic.
>>81552304
I fell for the spinach meme as a kid and ate it every day for years. Now I'm a 6'3" bodybuilder. Popeye was right all along.
>>81546132
Both Popeye and Saitama are joke characters. Popeye character isn't that he can defeat anybody while Saitama character is. This just seems like a stupid battle. Given they were in a fight and not in some kind of contest, Saitama would win but if it were a contest, the winner is likely Popeye as that's what the funniest course of action would be.
>>81547102
>Not understanding writing.
Your the one worse than DBZtards.
Saitama is literally Powerman but in anime.
That's the point.
>>81553754
Yeah but Popeye is powerman before powerman was a fucking thing.
>>81550051
A picture of Saitama
>>81553838
/co/ seems a little to biased to judge this. They say it's okay for comic characters to do this but when manga characters do this, it's all wrong.
>>81553567
I'm not even certain magic, or rather your brand of magic is even a thing in One-Punch's universe.
If anything implies the existence of your kind of magic, it's prophesies, and its pretty well established in the story that Saitama is basically beyond the scope of prophecies to the point where they cannot register his existence and he ends up breaking them.
Again, you're right, it's not confirmed either way.
But the only reason Superman is vulnerable to magic, is because they wanted to tell stories with tension.
The entire point of One-Punch Man is that there is no tension. If there was, he would cease being Saitama, because the entire point of his life, is to find someone who can challenge him, which has not really happened. It would basically be the ending of the series if someone showed up and gave stimulation to his existence, like he did to Boros.
>>81551217
> being this retarded
Saitama power is not a fucking punch you inbred idiot. Saitama power is that he doesn't have limits, ergo he is invincible.
You shouldn't try to talk about characters you don't have a fucking clue about.
>>81552148
>That doesnt make any sense.
That's the point.
>>81552148
> That doesnt make any sense.
Yes, and running 10km per day allows you to run at lightspeed.
>>81547052
What about guys like Thanos who can warp reality n shit? Or Squirrel Girl? Or guys like Bugs Bunny and Droopy?
>>81552148
>That doesnt make any sense.
That's the fucking point saitama runs on LOLIWIN physics
>>81547102
Saitama would punch superman so hard it would tear a rip in the fabric of space.
and for the sake of the plot there would be kryptonite and superman loses
>>81554475
Saitama cannot lose. The maximum close you could get is using a character whose perk is 'he cannot lose' to ensure a stalemate.
Bugs Bunny and Droopy already lose before. Squirrel Girl could bring a stalemate... but she already died in a comic which shows she isn't invincible. I guess that depends if that comic was 'canon'. If not... then yes, if she never lose in any of her comics she could bring a stalemate.
>>81552982
Show me this culinary skill that makes spinach good then. You can't can't you? Fucking europoors. Talk wrong get bombed.
>>81553889
>a fucking attosecond
>>81554801
>A fucking attosecond
>Zoom uses this power to passive-agressively bully 6 year old Barry Allen
>>81554559
Couldn't guys like Thanos and Mr. Mxyzptlk easily erase him from existence though?
Could spinached Popeye defeat Giorno Giovanna with Gold Experience Requiem?
>>81554895
Is it funny or is it funnier to see Saitama punching his way back to existence?
>>81547102
>So would Superman.
Would superman have to stop holding back?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cl_5UwS57X8
Saitama would fuck his shit up.
>>81554952
I think so - he's punched out animators before, I'm sure he could target Gold Experience Requiem.
Is OPM /co/'s favorite anime?
>>81552243
It's pretty good when it is prepared properly. You know, like most other foods.
>>81552830
His gimmick is that he's so strong that he doesnt lose, not that he specifically always wins.
>>81553361
This. Saitama can't lose? Popeye punches him and he turns into Bluto.
There, now he can lose.
>>81553230
The sad thing is that the limiters only apply to fights. Outside of being able to one shot anyone if he's serious about it, Saitama's other areas are really lacking. His 'disciple' is the one that covered his rent before they moved into City A(?), he has a terrible sense of direction and timing, and he sort of half-asses everything else in life.
He can't even defeat King in a kusoge fighter.
>>81559062
Saitama wouldnt even flinch as Popeyes punches ineffectively, unaware that life isn't a cartoon.
>>81559101
Yeah - Saitama's a pretty tragic character. I'd consider Popeye to be the winner by default, because he can feel genuinely happy and fulfilled in and by his work.
>>81559101
That's kind of the point, he can barely maintain his life and can't relate to other people all for a power that doesn't make him happy.
>>81554952
As much as people rag on King Crimson, I'm more confused as to how GER even works?
>>81559153
Except both of them are cartoons.
Saitama gets turned into something that can lose if he gets punched, which he will be.
>>81559252
No, Saitama is anime, not cartoon. There's a difference.
>>81559252
If we're operating by cartoon logic then Saitama is a being wholly uneffected by such an attack as his strength trumps reality to begin with. I'm not making this up, he literally kills God because he is that omnipotent. Popeye is finished.
Popeye has astronomically better feats then anything saitama has ever done.
Just as an example.
>Saitama splits the atmosphere.((his best feat))
>Popeye shatters the moon.((not his best feat))
Why is this even a discussion?
>>81559101
>>81559200
That entire monologue Saitama had before he fought the Subterraneans kinda hit me in the feels. I wish the series concentrated a bit more on Saitama having an existential crisis in addition to everyone reacting to his immense strength. Kinda says something when the only time he's ever cried out during battle is when his favorite jacket got ripped apart.
>>81547212
Pope ye can lunch people through time and change the climate and time.
>>81556652
>all that city destruction
Oh shit, don't tell the Man of Steel detractors.
>>81549938
>Yosodomy
>>81559244
I think it prevents "cause" and nullifies it
>>81560207
baited hard holy fuck
>>81553313
That's really nifty. I'm saving that.
I mean, it's inaccurate as all hell... Saitama is TRYING! Completely out of character. Still, really nifty.
>>81558719
OPM is this /co/mmunist's favourite cape comic. Anime is good but not my favourite.
>>81558719
OPM has a lot of appeal because it parodies cliches found in cape fiction so I'd say yes.
>>81552148
You are asking this, and you read comics about a man that outrun everything, and another man dress like a bat and outsmart everything.
>>81552243
spinach soup is fucking excellent
>Weeaboos seriously think Saitama can beat Popeye
They're more pathetic than I thought.
>Nerds thinking Popeye can beat Saitama
They're more pathetic than i thought.
>Dorks thinking they can take my quarters
>>81558719
No, this is.
>>81546132
I'm pretty sure this guy can beat them both with a wave of his hand.
>>81552392
>Saitama doesn't have one that we know of
Range.
He has to punch the enemy, right?
Don't let Saitama get close. Anyone who can fly and has a ranged attack should win without too much effort.
>>81547739
This really should've just ended the conversation.
>>81559297
>there's a difference
>>81556652
I always found it funny that arguably the weakest version of Superman is the one who gives this speech.
>>81570568
He killed that one guy by throwing a pebble at him in that filler, so not really.
>>81570496
I'm pretty sure this guy can beat him with a wave of his hand.
>>81570747
Then be faster than him, or attack from out of his line of sight.
Also
>filler
kek
>>81570774
Can we just skip the formalities?
>>81559244
"Fuck you, you didn't do it" power, nullifies actions, nullifies will to fight and so on. And it's completely automatic, Giorno doesn't even need to do anything.
>>81570793
That might be kind of tough, considering he's faster than his world's fastest speedster.
Not even a big OPM fan or anything, but yeah the entire premise is that he's supposed to be OP as fuck.
>118 / 16 / 75 / 1
Everyone in this thread please consider suicide
>>81546132
Never watched OPM, but is there any reason it's become the new Kill la Kill, with extreme popularity and I'm presuming violent absurdity?
Should I pick it up when I get a chance?
>>81570793
>be faster than him
Impossible
>attack from out of his line of sight
He's hyperaware of his surroundings, that's like trying to get the drop on Dr. Manhattan.
>>81570774
I'm surprised The Mask is never brought up in any of these "who would win" threads.
You would think the people who are all over the "who's the strongest character in fiction" arguments would consider the completely indestructible being with cartoon physics/subjective reality.
>>81570909
The writing's nothing special, but the art is very pleasant on the eyes and it's just a pretty enjoyable read in general.
That, and Mumen Rider is the hero we all deserve.
>>81570844
I don't know, can we?
>>81547052
GER Giorno Giovanna is still one step ahead. Serious reply, not even cartoon physics can defeat GER.
>>81570909
As someone who doesn't really watch much anime, I found it enjoyable. Just remember that it's a comedy more than an action showalthough the action it does have tends to be really solid.
>>81570906
Consider this dick
>>81570979
It's because he lost toHollywood.
Going by the canon, Saitama's power is basically limitless. He can be about as strong as a trillion Popeyes if he wants to.
If spinached Popeye has any conceivable limit, Saitama wins without a doubt. If not, then it's a stalemate between the two.
>>81571157
>jaime kennedy
>2005
>>81571157
God that movie was such garbage
>>81559391
Breaking out of the cartoon and beating up the cartoonist>beating a god in your own universe.
Popeye can, based on his own series, go outside the cartoon and beat up the writer/artist/animator, so by that logic, he'd just go outside the comic and have One write that he wins.
Both characters are so overpowered and toonforce-heavy that you can't really say "Saitama wins because his deal is that he doesn't lose" when Popeye with Spinach is the exact same(only with way more impressive feats).
At that point, you go by the feats, and Popeye decimates Saitama on that particular front.
>>81559297
Yeah, anime is japanese cartoons, that's the difference.
>Saitama cs Popeye
>Popeye eats enough spinach to gain the power of two Atom Bombs
>Saitama runs up to him fast as fuck
>he reaches the distance to punch Popeye
>Popeye quickly lays the hands on him
>one, two like it's 1945
USA beats Japan again
>>81570979
The only thing that can beat The Mask is guilt tripping the wearer, so there's that.
>popeye puts on the mask
>>81571641
>Popeye can, based on his own series, go outside the cartoon and beat up the writer/artist/animator, so by that logic, he'd just go outside the comic and have One write that he wins.
I'm sure if OPM was a gag manga with little to no continuity, Saitama could do the same (but he doesn't need to, that's the point).
>Both characters are so overpowered and toonforce-heavy that you can't really say "Saitama wins because his deal is that he doesn't lose" when Popeye with Spinach is the exact same(only with way more impressive feats).
It's not the same though. Popeye's gimmick was that whatever he did was ineffective before eating the spinach whereas Saitama is either wholly uninvested in fighting or intentionally fighting at his opponents level to humor them. Popeye needs a powerup as opposed to Saitama being as strong as he needs,
An actual fight between the two adhering to both their established rules at the same time would go like this: Popeye starts a fight with Saitama and gets obliterated in one punch. He eats a can of spinach and then gets back into the fight and gives Saitama a good fight until Saitama decides to get serious and destroys him again in one punch. Repeat for every can of spinach Popeye has.
>At that point, you go by the feats, and Popeye decimates Saitama on that particular front.
And again, if OPM was a gag manga with no continuity in the same vein as Popeye, then there's nothing stopping him from performing the feats described. Every such feat in OPM is to show how Saitama is not a hero. Pic related, he stops a meteor at the last second and is utterly unphased to the collateral damage it caused. Saitama split the sky from Baros's planet splitting wave but there was no reason he couldn't have used it at the start of his fight.
TL';DR The feats are incomparable because Popeye is a cartoon that doesn't show the ramifications of dragging the moon closer whereas OPM is.
>>81571641
>Popeye can, based on his own series, go outside the cartoon and beat up the writer/artist/animator, so by that logic, he'd just go outside the comic and have One write that he wins.
>Fight starts.
>Popeye downs spinach, gets punched across a square.
>Popeye downs another can of spinach, gets punched across the city.
>Popeye downs a third can of spinach, gets punched across the continent.
>Popeye adjusts his hat, toots on his pipe and crawls out of the comic, incoherently makes angry noises at ONE, to which ONE just starts nodding insitently
>Popeye crawls back into the frame, gets a new can of super spinach drawn in his hand, which he downs and punches OPM
>OPM stands there for like 5 seconds, slighty bent, then kicks Popeye into space
>Popeye reaches out of the frame and grabs ONE by the shit, to which ONE just shrugs and puts up his arms. He can't do nothing.
>Popeye looks at the camera, shrugs at his disappointed fans and then pulls ONE in the comic as they fly together off into deep space
>"I yam what I yam and that's all that I yam." starts playing.
>>81572780
>grabs ONE by the shit
There was supposed to be an r in there somewhere.
>>81572346
He only wins in one punch due to not having a strong enough enemy, not because his superpower is winning in one punch
>>81547052
>>81548038
>>81572913
As stated multiple times in this thread, his potential is limitless. He is strong enough that one punch is all he needs, he even has a distaste for martial arts because he knows he doesn't need it.
>He only wins in one punch due to not having a strong enough enemy
He can't help that most of the monsters he comes across are unable to take his weakest punch except for two cases. Baros and Garou were capable of trading blows (obviously ineffective on their part) until he got serious and then ended with one punch anyway.
His superpower isn't winning in one punch, it's that he's so incomprehensibly strong that's all he needs. And it's not portrayed as a good thing either, Saitama feels no excitement in his life at all because every fight is an anticlimax.
>>81572346
No, the manga goes out of it's way to show why Saitama is a true hero. He does what he thinks is right and no other opinions matter. If anything, he's a more modern superman done correctly. One not affected by question of if he should do the right thing, but one affected by the apathy that comes with such a burden of power
>>81572346
But once Popeye has eaten the spinach, he also is as strong as he needs so it's more of a case of >>81551505
>>81573203
I know all of that. But simply saying that people within his canon dont match to his power, so everyone else in every other canon will die in one punch as well is not really good logic.
The idea that everyone he's beat so far is too weak for him doesnt mean "he wins because his power is winning"
It's not like Squirrel Girl where it's literally her power, his winning is just a side effect of his strength.
> Implying Saitama could beat Superman Thought Robot
>>81546132
The joke of OPM is that Saitama always wins.
Even someone stupid powerful like Popeye w/ Spinach will lose to Saitama because it's funnier that way.
>>81573790
Saitama vs Droopy.
Who wins?
>>81546132
Popeye.
Saitama can only destroy.
Popeye can do all kinds of Randy shit on Spinach. Shift continents, build monoliths, and I'm pretty sure he flew at one point.
>>81551217
It was a normal punch from his "serious" series.
>>81549874
>I believe Popeye is an elder god dreaming it is a man.
Something happened out on the open sea. Men died. A thing died. Something in the shape of a man came back, wanting only to forget. But they won't let him just be a man, live a peaceful life. Men and things keep coming for him. Striking at him through anything he tries to build, through a woman who somehow loves him, and literally, in the face. But they can't keep coming forever. Every time it happens, everyone forgets what happened afterwards, and it will never happen that way again. He just has to keep trying to find the life he wants. He has to keep a hold on his determination. Take from the universe what he earned by living this long.
>>81573300
He obviously develops more into a traditional hero as the story progresses but the beginning made clear that he was a half assed hero in character as well.
>Backstory is literally "I was bored of being a salaryman. So I'll be a hero"
>Is so out of touch that he doesn't know that he inadvertently created the Heroes Association, let alone know what it is.
>Always shows up late to most monster attacks, defeating them after the damage is done
>States multiple times that he's doing it for himself, not for others.
Yeah he had some other redeemable qualities but the manga was clearly showing that he was a boring hero and at the same time, barely a hero at all.
>>81552148
>How can a physical impact on such a small scale, no matter how strong, destroy a universe?
Because it's funnier that way.
>>81573818
Is it a fight or is Saitama just trying to get that fucker out of his house?
>>81546132
Better question:
Donald Duck vs Hulk.
>>81573944
wait a sec, where did the nails come from?
>>81546132
You do realize Saitama wants a challenge, so even if you can fight him he wins that's all he wants. You literally can't beat him cause he'll ether beat you like nothing or you give him what he wants a fight. God you people are fucking retarded it's a joke you're suppose to laugh at it not over analyse it Jesus Christ!
>>81574077
He dreamt that the three went up and a coffin came down.
In a dream, you don't think of how it happens. It just does.
The nails came from his soul.
>>81573561
>But once Popeye has eaten the spinach, he also is as strong as he needs
OPM also parodies the cliche of "Now that i've revealed my trump card, the tide of the fight has changed." This was his reaction to Boros going Super Saiyan. >>81572912 Shows him completely unaffected by his attacks.
The fight would still go in Saitama's favor because the nature of his series is that whenever someone reveals a higher power, Saitama simply holds less back and still demolishes them. In this case, Popeye would get strong enough to to exceed Saitama's current strength and toss him around for a while until Saitama gets bored and then beats him again. This would happen every time and since Saitama has no limits, it's more of a question of how much spinach Popeye has.
Saitama's abilities run on the rule of whatever is funniest. Matched up against Superman or Goku or anyone that huge fuckin' nerds actually care about winning he'll easily one-shot, but I think Popeye would be a worthy opponent ONLY IF preceded by a one-shot fight against Goku or Superman.
>>81547102:^)
>>81573691
Exactly this. I don't know why it assumed that because he is the strongest in his universe that means he can beat anyone from any universe
>>81572161
>Frank puts on the mask.
>>81574268
And if he's in Popeye's series? Where if someone proves to be a threat, he eats spinach and wins?
>>81573944
>that filename
>>81574035
Saitama owes Droopy $40.
>>81574631
It's true. My downstairs neighbor in college lost a qt gf because he spent too much time playing mincraft.
WHEN WILL YOU FAGS LEARN
THAT SAITAMA IS NOT MEANT TO BE INCLUDED IN POWERLEVEL DISCUSSIONS
HIS QUIRK IS THAT HE'LL ALWAYS WIN BECAUSE. HE'S. A. GAG. CHARACTER
PLEASE STOP
>>81551733
>ToonForce works against instigators as noted in almost every cartoon ever.
Stop being wrong...bugs bunny, woody woodpecker and fucking Jerry have episodes that they are the instigados an win
>>81574961
But it's a discussion of bullshit level.
>>81574446
because they want Saitama's meme to be in tact
>>81574961
>he hasnt read the thread at all
>>81571077
>putting daffy against bugs bunny
Fucking retard
>>81573691
>But simply saying that people within his canon dont match to his power, so everyone else in every other canon will die in one punch as well is not really good logic.
That's really the point of this thread. How do we know how cartoon characters like Popeye fare in another universe? The only thing that makes this interesting (as opposed to more asinine Goku vs Superman debates) is that OPM makes a point out of subverting cliches.
>The idea that everyone he's beat so far is too weak for him doesnt mean "he wins because his power is winning"
What's the difference though? The point of his character is that feasibly everyone is too weak that the two are one and the same. Saitama is basically an invincible hero in every sense of the term, his power isn't winning but it might as well be.
>It's not like Squirrel Girl where it's literally her power, his winning is just a side effect of his strength.
That's the comedy of it as well. At one point, the universe's strongest telepath tries to grab him but gets an aneurysm from the attempt. Saitama feels bad enough in response that he lets him do it, despite his strength not logically related towards any psychic resistance. It's not hard to imagine that this invincibility would apply to everything else.
>>81574617
You're missing the point if you think it's an either-or scenario as by that logic, any crossover fight would be lopsided if by playing by one character's rules.
The difference is that Saitama and Popeye are gimmick characters, so there's no need to compare power levels. We just need to examine whose gimmick would work better and Saitama's is superior because Popeye's resembles the kind Saitama parodies. Popeye's spinach is like a second wind trump card that gives him what he needs to do what he wants whereas Saitama's trump card is simply holding back his infinite strength as much as he needs to until he doesn't care.
>>81574936
bullshit
>>81575231
There is a very real difference between always winning and never losing.
Here, saying his power is winning when it isnt is giving Saitama a reason to win in a fight with someone who has comparable strength, for no real reason.
I do agree with the second part though. Which now makes me think that a better discussion would be Saitama vs Pucca. I havent watched the series but from what Ive read, it's similar to OPM, where the plots are just the other characters fighting long enough for Pucca to arrive and destroy them, with no perceived limits. and her feats are also pretty meme-worthy. Once she spun a normal jump rope so fast that it transported her to another dimension.
How much more bullshit can Saitama and Popeye achieve if they had some hotpot together?
>>81573790
Huh, I guess that does make the Eds really OP, huh
>>81554177
The same guy who can't beat a mosquito and got hurt by a cat? You're the retarded one here, moron.
It's clear that Saitama can lose when it is funny for him to do so. A comical character like Popeye or Bugs would fuck him up.
>>81575877
>Pucca
Man, she was some bullshit.
>>81576538
he wasn't fighting the mosquito and the cat though.
>>81546132
This actually has me curious. Has anyone even so much as HURT Popeye on Spinach?
Even once?
Even come close?
>>81576582
now I regret not watching it desu
>>81547052
NO LIMITS FALLACY
FUCK THE NLF
>>81546132
>>81547052
>>81547102
>>81547212
>>81547739
>>81553883
this is the funniest thing I've read on /co/ in a long, long time.
>all these serious responses
Guys, saitama is a gag character. He exists purely to poke fun at shounen manga and his entire gimmick revolves around the fact that powerlevels are fucking retarded. The moment you start any "saitama vs x" argument means you've already lost, because you're the exact kind of autist ONE openly mocks
>>81550774
Saitama hasn't even fought a multiverse level beingyet
>>81551907
It's just a dumb rumor
>>81577136
He's a gag character but so is Popeye. That's the point. You cant say "generic response instantly blurted out at the mention of Saitama fighting someone" when this is obviously different than the usual question.
>>81574961
Who would win Power-Man vs Saitama?
>>81577459
Power-Man is fan fiction
>>81577506
in many ways, everything is fan fiction
>>81577459
They're the same person.
>>81577399
The point isn't which gag character is stronger, it's that pitting two gag characters against each other is fucking retarded. To put genuine thought into the combat of fictional characters removed from their own universes is stupid, and ultimately futile. Go ask the creator of the character, and they could just say 'okay now my character has a super punch which beats anything regardless of circumstance'. All of a sudden, any point you could've made is rendered moot. That's what saitama represents, and why people who engage in these arguments involving OPM demonstrate the epitome of irony: that even considering the message ONE is trying to express, stupid people are still willing to waste their time bickering over nonsense just for the satisfaction of winning an empty argument
>>81577821
wrong
>>81547052
This, I can't believe people are this autistic trying to scale a joke character who is literally anime power man who wins cause fuck you
No amount of 500 sentence essays of how strong your character is is gonna change that, fucking power level fags need to kill themselves
>>81577905
Who wins George Costanza vs Saitama
>>81577821
The only people in the thread taking this seriously are the people mad at the discussion.
Everyone here (except a few Saitamafags) knows there's no real winner. It's just entertaining to discuss. Rendered better by the fact that it's finally an argument where the other person's feats give them a real chance
>>81577960
>The only people in the thread taking this seriously are the people mad at the discussion.
like this fag here >>81577905
>>81577960
How is it entertaining to discuss something everyone already knows the answer to?
>>81546132
I've said it before and i'll say it now, Bill and Ted could easily defeat Saitama by going back in time and beat him up as a kid.
>>81554559
What has SG died in other than Marvel Universe vs The Avengers?
>>81577998
>thinking anyone could take this shit seriously
>thinking there is any discussion to be had here
This shit is boku vs superfag level of hilariously stupid and it's even more autistic if your doing this shit ironically
>>81577944
George still has hair
>>81546132
Saitama is a gag character whose fights and feats are all linked either to comic relief or to parody (which in no way makes it flawless or immune to critic and following some of the very tropes it makes fun of) shonen and as the title implies, one punch stuff.
Popeye is a character whose very concept is "once he eats spinach, he wins" couple with "he always finds a way to get his spinach". hell the universe pretty much bends itself to allow Popeye to get his green steroids when he needs them. once the theme song starts playing it's over, it's not even worth discussing, no matter how horribly the odds are stacked against him, Popeye ha already won. he could punch the fucking Big Bang away.
besides, Saitama is bound t a bigger extent by the "physical laws" of his universe, whereas in Popeye the very universe, aka the animation itself shifts and bends in popeye's favor.
Popeye would literally punch Saitama into last week.
Saitama would then be greatful since he could then go to the sale he missed.
>>81552148
Imagine anything, regardless of mass, going several times the speed of light.
Say, 1000x the speed of light.
Anything going that fast (which Satiama would undoubtedly be able to accomplish, the man's a fucking mantis shrimp) would most definitely be catastrophic to the fabric of space and time, and possibly, make the very universe uninhabitable.
>>81577960
You're telling me people aren't taking this discussion seriously when >>81578246
>>81578281
these responses exist?
>>81578166
>the discussion here doesnt exist because I dont like it
>>81578026
Literally every debate ever? It's not about being right, it's about defending the side you decided to defend
>>81578352
They're giving serious answers, but nobody here is angrily typing away at thier keyboards, desperate to actually convince the other side of thier idiocy or any of that shit.
They're taking the discussion seriously in the vein of logically answering the question, but not in the way of this actually mattering much outside this dumb thread
>>81578373
So people are arguing for things they don't even believe are true? That's pretty autistic
>>81578475
But why bother taking the discussion seriously at all when it's not even your opinion, according to >>81578373
>>81552243
Spinach is great. Lettuce is it's retarded cousin
>>81578487
It beats arguing with anons on 4chan
Jesus Christus Why are weebs so retarded? Always winning (or rather being unable to lose) is not Saitalma's power or 'thing'. Is the plot of the story.
In any case, that would mean that even Superman would beat OPM as long as the fight is being published in a Superman comic because at the end he is always set to win, even if he is beaten down or it takes 12 issues he will win.
Also OPM is not a gag manga, is a comedy/action manga and at most a parody of other Shonen.
I'm more curious about how the fight would even get started.
>>81559434
because that wasn't his best feat. it was his "serious punch" in that he wanted to make Boros feel better. He was massively holding back when he did that punch.
>>81578639
Shenanigans at the SuperMarket. Last can of Spinach. Popeye and Saitama both need it.
I don't have the math chops for it, but I'd love for someone to calculate the amount of force needed to jump from the moon to earth with a travel time of 10 seconds.
>>81574961
I just noticed Hexus in the MLP strip.
funny
>>81578183
>>81578072
>Bill and Ted
>Beating up Saitama instead of taking him to the mall to play some wicked arcade and like, totally jam out
Bogus, man.
>>81574961
The Tick could beat Saitama.
He's nigh-invulnerable.
Interesting Idea, but I don't think we'd ever have a true winner. The cartoon would end on the funniest note, probably after the final punch does a sonic boom that blasts both of them into unconsciousness.
>>81580573
Probably.
My money's on the fight being about something silly like >>81578883
>Middle of the Fight
>Saitama accidentally tears his suit, and change starts falling out his pocket
>He calls for a time out to collect his money, but as he's picking the change up, he suddenly realizes that a few yens are all he has, because he forgot his wallet at home
>Saitama concedes defeat to Popeye since he can't pay for the spinach without his wallet, who then proudly scoffs, toots his pipe and walks over to the register, only to pull out the empty insides of his pockets, suddenly realizing that when just before the fight he gave Wimpy a few bucks so he'd go away, he actually gave him all the money he had on himself
>Nobody wins
>>81580772
I like the way you think, anon. I'd love to see that happen.
Gag characters don't work in VS fights, unless it's someone like Deadpool who's just goofy but still 'real'.
>>81579592
I love it
Could PopEye defeat WinMan? Keep in mind, WinMan's superpower is winning at everything, including losing if a loss counts as a win.
>>81546132
Sairtama would win, but I have a feeling he would just go with Popoye and buy him a can of spinach. On sale.
>popeye fags btfo
>>81559297
>People are really this dense.
"Anime" is literally just an east-monkey term for Animation.
The term you're looking for is an "Eastern aesthetics", as that is the stylistic difference between them.
That aesthetic is your overly complicated storylines and large eyed complex you got going on, by the by.
>>81574961
All this guy needs is an enemy that nullifies all physical contact and this guy loses. A guy who never loses can only be beaten by a guy who can't possibly lose.
Fuck it, give him that and all of this guy's powers, as well as making that fucker a lazy neckbeard . Ultimate power with no drive to use it, BOOM hire me Anime!
>>81583655
[triggered]
>>81579592
this is great, I remember that episode too
Who wins in a battle between Saitama and Blue-gloved Saitama? Or Popeye with no shirt and has spinach vs Popeye with a shirt and has spinach?
>>81558719
Pretty sure that's JoJo's.
>>81584194
Popeye. He is actually funny. Saitama is less than meme.
Popeye of course. Saitama run on anime "realistic" logic where Popeye run on cartoon logic. You can do something that realistically would have Popeye be a puddle of blood but with cartoon logic he will be flat as a pancake then just pop right back up as if nothing happened.
Saitama does have his limits it just no one came even close to them. He is just that overpowered. Popeye is only human but if he had a single can of spinach already he may as well be Saitama levels of superhuman just more down to Earth (as in better control and not blasting holes in mountains) and with the added cartoon logic of having his arms gain the weight of a ship's anchor and such. Add more cans to that and there is no telling how crazy things can get.I wrote all of this just to piss off OPM "fans" that didn't even know the series existed til the anime.Ed with a rock in his shoe would be even better than Popeye.
>>81580824
They work, you just have to not get autistic about who supposedly should win based on powerlevel/feats.
>>81576676
I'm almost sure he's eaten spinach, then his opponent somehow ate spinach, and he had to run away to eat way more spinach before winning.
>>81578183
>>81577944
But George never wins unless his opponent always loses.
>>81547739
If you think about it, Popeye is like Golden Age One Punch Man. After ingesting spinach, it only takes one punch for him to stop and/or transmogrify anything he hits.
>>81581061
>If you know you're going to win, why do you keep trying?
>>81585686
"Saitama's limitless power is stronger that Popeye's limitless power"
I bet those replies are all you.
>>81570979
the mask is like Alucard. he lost in his own book to a guy, once. Who was just too badass in his own right.
why are you guys so obsessed on who's the most powerful fictional character?
I bet Saitama can't even put a scratch on Bluto
>>81549856
This is probably the most accurate reply yet
>>81584450
>Saitama does have his limits
The webcomic made it absolutely clear that he is literally limitless in power.
>>81587558
We're not taking about the webcomic
>>81546132
Cancer
>Can absorb blunt force impacts
Nice punches, fuckers.
>>81559244
GER is the equivalent of hitting a kid on the playground with a NERF dart, telling him you got him, and he just says "NUH UH" and keeps playing.
