[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Christ it's nearly impossible to find trades o Steph's
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 24
File: Batgirl_Rising.jpg (127 KB, 450x696) Image search: [Google]
Batgirl_Rising.jpg
127 KB, 450x696
Christ it's nearly impossible to find trades o Steph's Batgirl run. Most of them run upwards of $50, which seems really weird for a series that's only been gone for 4 years.

Is there a reason DC refuses to reprint them?
>>
>>78500631
Because n52 Barbara is superior. People have hated Steph since she was that try-hard wannabe Spoiler. Then she got the Bat-Mantle? Fuck that shit, hate intensifies for an annoying character.
>>
>>78500631
Is coming dc is reprinting cass first.
>>
File: 1432084823169.jpg (13 KB, 228x238) Image search: [Google]
1432084823169.jpg
13 KB, 228x238
>>78500699
>n52 Barbara is superior
>>
>>78500768
DC announced reprinting Cass a while ago, have they given any indication that they're reprinting Steph?
>>
>>78500798
If the trade sells maybe they will reprint brian q run.
>>
>>78500798
nope

I'll be surprised if they don't though, they reintroduced Steph in the new 52 already and they are clearly willing to acknowledge that Batgirls other than Babs existed since they're reprinting Cass's book
>>
>>78500777
Prove me wrong. Her run had good art, action, and asskicking. She was a fuckin female Batman. Total badass.
>>
>>78500631

Wait a few years. The same thing happened to Cassandra's trades. Now we're finally getting a reprint. So give or take another eight years given DC's trade policy.
>>
>>78501378
The New52 run?

I liked it, and I liked the tone of it. Kinda bugs me that Babsgirl seemed to change so drastically for the burnside stuff, which I think would have better suited Stephs character.

>But Steph was based on younger Barbara

yeah, younger Barbara without many years of character development.
>>
Cass and Steph are the only real Batgirls. Barbara is boring as fuck when she's not Oracle.
>>
The agenda is pretty obvious. They didn't even let Miller use Steph in the Smallville comic, it had to be Babs.
>>
File: sad cass.jpg.png (86 KB, 240x198) Image search: [Google]
sad cass.jpg.png
86 KB, 240x198
>>78500699
Your shit opinions make Cass sad...
>>
>>78500915
They're reprinting Dixon's Robin, where Steph was a major supporting character as Spoiler. There's very little demand to reprint a recent Stephgirl series that got cancelled due to poor sales. Cass is getting a reprint due to the demand as a fan favorite character, her being back in B&R Eternal and the series being over ten years old. War Games is far more like,y to get a reprint than Steph's short run as Batgirl
>>
>>78502453
Like getting shot? Babs never maintained a solo title pre flashpoint. Her biggest accomplishments were getting shot and making dumb blondes run around doing her bidding.
>>
When are they going to reprint Denny O'Neil's Question run?
>>
>>78505900
Steph series didn't get cancelled, it ended like all the other series. Also, Steph had a two year run, longer than any pre-flashpoint Barb series.
>>
is this run any good? can someone story time it
>>
>>78501853
DC changed policy, in part because people mistakenly compare the current Batgirl run to prior runs and in part because of the Nu52 flopping hard. Steph trades will probably come about in five or six years, giving two trades of Batgirl released a year.
>>
>>78502453
uh oh, Simonefag detected....
>>
File: p11_6 copy.jpg (324 KB, 1000x1492) Image search: [Google]
p11_6 copy.jpg
324 KB, 1000x1492
>>78506229
no, but I will share some highlights...
>>
File: p11_7 copy.jpg (162 KB, 504x746) Image search: [Google]
p11_7 copy.jpg
162 KB, 504x746
>>78506282
>>
File: p11_8 copy.jpg (149 KB, 504x749) Image search: [Google]
p11_8 copy.jpg
149 KB, 504x749
>>78506297
>>
>>78506254
It sucks that we'll have to wait so long. The Stephanie Brown Batgirl run was ~25 issues, there's no reason that wouldn't fit in a single book

>>78505900
A reprint of War Games just came out
>>
>>78506254

Well given what they put in the Cassandra trades (if they include Fresh Blood, and the Superboy X-over, along with Secret Files & Origins One-Shot) give or take five years indeed.
>>
File: p11_8 copy.jpg (133 KB, 497x738) Image search: [Google]
p11_8 copy.jpg
133 KB, 497x738
>>78506297
and the shot...
>>
>>78505985

Now that's a good question.
>>
File: p11_10 copy.jpg (141 KB, 504x745) Image search: [Google]
p11_10 copy.jpg
141 KB, 504x745
>>78506356
All the knives, Alfred?
>>
>>78506366
They already did about ten years ago, I think?
>>
File: p11_17 copy.jpg (153 KB, 540x806) Image search: [Google]
p11_17 copy.jpg
153 KB, 540x806
>>78506372
>>
File: p11_18 copy.jpg (143 KB, 540x788) Image search: [Google]
p11_18 copy.jpg
143 KB, 540x788
>>78506422
>>
>>78506393

Seven years ago and they're about as expensive as a Stephanie Brown Batgirl trade.
>>
>>78500699
Miller's run was everything New52 Babs wants to be.
>>
File: DC4.jpg (25 KB, 297x420) Image search: [Google]
DC4.jpg
25 KB, 297x420
>>78500631
>I can finally use this
Man, I loved her run as Batgirl.
>>
>>78506422
>>78506372
>>78506427
The death of Steph and Damian's bantering was the greatest tragedy of the New 52.
>>
>>78506199
It didn't even end properly, it got Nu52'd.
>>
File: p18_4 copy.jpg (333 KB, 1000x1536) Image search: [Google]
p18_4 copy.jpg
333 KB, 1000x1536
>>
>>78506549
cute
>>
File: BatgirlEnding.jpg (46 KB, 466x647) Image search: [Google]
BatgirlEnding.jpg
46 KB, 466x647
>>78506590
It at least got an emotional ending instead of just stopping like a lot of other series
>>
File: p12_7 copy.jpg (207 KB, 576x913) Image search: [Google]
p12_7 copy.jpg
207 KB, 576x913
>>78506557
it really humanized him
>>
File: p12_8 copy.jpg (152 KB, 540x797) Image search: [Google]
p12_8 copy.jpg
152 KB, 540x797
>>78506700
>>
File: p12_9 copy.jpg (144 KB, 540x861) Image search: [Google]
p12_9 copy.jpg
144 KB, 540x861
>>78506731
>>
File: p12_10 copy.jpg (169 KB, 540x843) Image search: [Google]
p12_10 copy.jpg
169 KB, 540x843
>>78506753
>>
File: p30_13 copy.jpg (235 KB, 540x809) Image search: [Google]
p30_13 copy.jpg
235 KB, 540x809
>>78506648
but there was gonna be more
>>
>>78505985

If we'd even get Question Quaterly reprinted.
>>
>>78506886
>Stargirl
Remember when JSA was good?
>>
>>78500699
>People have hated Steph since she was that try-hard wannabe Spoiler.

What? People liked Spoiler, people hated the bullshit surrounding her death and rebirth and her then turning into Batgirl for no fucking reason, that completely took away everything that was endearing about her when she suddenly was being pushed as hypercompetent because lol, time jump training, with tonally off art making the early issues seem like Steph was a psychopath because the story was going for a slightly looney toons effect but the realistic art didn't convey that at all.

And it only got worse when Brian Q. Miller's run kept trying to put all the blame for War Games on Bruce, instead of, you know, ignoring it because it was shit. I mean for fucks sake, there's an entire issue where Steph blatantly tells Bruce she wasn't responsible for anything and you're suppose to applaud for her complete sociopathic view of what happened in War Games.
>>
>>78507173
>she suddenly was being pushed as hypercompetent
When was this?
>>
So should I sell my Steph Brown tpbs now and make some money or should I wait a bit longer?
>>
>>78507225

Depends. Wait and maybe she'll show up on some random show, cartoon, Arkham game, or movie and it might increase. But wait another year or two and it will increase just more until a trade re-release.
>>
>>78507349
Do you think a Rocksteady batgirl would be more likely to be Cassie or Steph? Discounting the fact that it would definitely just be babs again.
>>
File: p26_14 copy-1.jpg (1 MB, 1000x1508) Image search: [Google]
p26_14 copy-1.jpg
1 MB, 1000x1508
>>78507173
She was training with Cass so it would make sense that she got better, and she wasn't "hypercompetent" as Batgirl, she was just better than she used to be which would make sense with training. She was still kind of impulsive and didn't really think things through like pic relayed or when she fucking dislocated her shoulder running away from the police. The most impressive thing she did was reacting and kicking a gun out of someone's hand from a couple feet away, but then the next page you find out it wasn't even loaded.
She got better but she wasn't nearly as good as you're implying.
>>
>>78507554
>so it would make sense that she got better

But the whole appeal of Steph was that she was never going to be as good as the rest. She was the underdog. When she gets the cowl, she stepped into the hypercompetency territory where she could fight Gotham freaks on her own and win.
>>
>lol it's all your fault Bruce
>oh btw you have no say in whether or not I represent your symbol

I hate this bitch. She makes the idea that fighting crime in Gotham is a serious issue a joke. The robins live and train rigorously under Bruce every day for years before they are ready to stand on their own, but apparently girl power and a couple of self-defense seminars is enough for her. She's a bimbo who never thinks or has shown any sense of discipline but somehow everyone likes her and she always comes out on top.

I'm willing to be her fandom has serious overlap with Harley Quinn's.
>>
>>78507684
Did you forget when Bruce fired her from being Robin and ordered Cassandra not to talk to her because of her incompetence and disobedience? Or how in her very first appearance Batman told her to go home and let him deal with cluemaster, and then she was almost killed because she didn't listen to him?

She was very incompetent and the batfamily aside from Tim and Cass tolerated her more than accepted her. She had to get better and only then did Bruce allow her to stay batgirl. Hell the issue you just posted was a setup by Bruce to test her competency. Had she failed I doubt he would have allowed her to be batgirl
>>
File: BWTRHBatgirl_1.jpg (185 KB, 1092x599) Image search: [Google]
BWTRHBatgirl_1.jpg
185 KB, 1092x599
>>78507893
Her being fired was good. Her dying was good. She was absolutely incompetent and it made no sense that Bruce gave her ANY chance at all. It had meaning, it showed that you can't just be a bat-member because you just feel like it and fight crime treating it like playtime and not have to dedicate your life to it.

It all changed thanks to fan mandate. It made it all Bruce's fault. She was a perfect flower who was wronged by big bad Batman. She could take out entire groups of men in their prime who were twice her weight and armed as easily at Batman without nearly a fraction of the training, thought, and time he put into it. All while quipping. It's doesn't deserve any recognition in the Batman mythos because it all it does is serve to water down the accomplishments and hard work of the others.
>>
Editors literally hate Stephanie, there's really not much else to say. They hated her fans and that went on to just hate for the character in general. There's stories about how writers were explicitly told they weren't allowed to use her in the New 52 for anything, and when someone snuck her into a panel and Editorial found out they colored her hair red and turned it into a Barbara cameo.
>>
>>78500631
Just buy the singles on ebay.
>>
>>78508321
DC editorial was absolute garbage for YEARS, only ending something like 18 months ago.

Too bad they didn't use Convergence as an excuse to erase some of the bullshit, but at least Steph's back, and appearing pretty consistently in her best identity.

Things are pretty dire for Cass, though. Babs too, to a much lesser extent.
Of course with Catwoman changing hands (clearly her book being good again was such a drastic change that it frightened everyone at DC) Steph may need to find a new home.
>>
File: p15_18 copy-1.jpg (1 MB, 1000x1496) Image search: [Google]
p15_18 copy-1.jpg
1 MB, 1000x1496
>>78508295
Except she did train, and she's no where near batman's level. I don't know where you're getting her competency from. She had her fuck ups in her time as batgirl and it was clear throughout that she was still the weakest member of the batfamily. She still had a ways to go, and you're overexaggerating her skill level.
>>
File: Batgirl50.jpg (131 KB, 600x910) Image search: [Google]
Batgirl50.jpg
131 KB, 600x910
>>78508588
>but at least Steph's back
Yeah but it would appear she's getting sent to Fletcher's Batgirl.
>>
>>78508652
Well at least she gets to be drawn by Babs Tarr.

But man, the relationship between Stephanie and a Barbara who is barely older than her does absolutely nothing for me.
>>
>>78508644
She only made mistakes about as much as Nightwing. It always works out anyway.

She receives some half-assed training from Batman for like a week and some from a cripple who never really had any arduous training either and she's able to take out Scarecrow, Livewire, etc. People who have given Supes and Bats problems.

Trying to say she didn't receive a huge powerboost in order to please her fans is idiotic, because it was obvious.

And you seem to be forgetting the fact that she's a self-pitying, patronizing bitch who loved to throw blame on others, but she got away with it because she smiled and made childish jokes. Nobody ever seemed to call her out on it because she was special and somehow "earned" the title of Batgirl.

Also, in order for her to become Batgirl they had Cass just give up and relinquish it for no real reason. Absolute bullshit.
>>
File: p20_15 copy-2-1.jpg (690 KB, 857x840) Image search: [Google]
p20_15 copy-2-1.jpg
690 KB, 857x840
>>78508831
She got lucky with Livewire because her suit was insulated, and kyptonions are weak to electricity.
I'm not saying she didn't get a power boost, but it's not as big as you're saying it is. She did have some training, but it's clear not nearly enough as the others. She dislocated her shoulder jumping between buildings and someone fucking died because of her screw up as seen in >>78508644
You're acting like she was one shotting everyone. When a lot of her big fights she had help from others, like Supergirl, Batman & Robin and that detective that followed her around.

I don't know when she was ever patronizing, and she did take responsibility for war games. Tim called her out on not taking it seriously multiple times, Cass once knocked her out because she was a liability in a fight. And she did earn the title because she proved herself capable multiple times and she passed Bruce's test.

Being upset that Cass' spot as batgirl was replaced is understandable, but you're way overexagerating her skill level.
Thread replies: 64
Thread images: 24

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.