1. Post a comic.
2. Others say "approved" to the comic that they want on the list.
3. I will poll the results and rank them.
>>78131832
overrated
>>78131869
approved
Inb4 a bunch of indie garbage nobody fucking reads
>>78131832
Top lists are for faggots.
>>78132552
Approved
>>78132552
Tippets of keks. Denied.
>>78132718
Denied, typical Morrison garbage.
Year 100 for sure
>>78132718
Approved. It should probably just be Multiversity since it was the GOAT event.
Heathcliff
>>78132552
Approved
>>78132934
I feel like something TinTin related needs to be on here.
>>78132994
Approved
>>78132718
This isn't even close to Morrison's best work. Denied.
>>78133061
Underrated classic exploring deep philosophical concepts. Approved.
>>78132552
>>78132718
>top 100 of ALL TIME
Nein.
Think more like Sandman.
>>78133155
waifufaggotry, rejected, doesn't deserve to be on the list
I propose Dilbert
>>78131832
Kingdom Bum
>>78132552
Approved 4 lyfe
Outburts of Everett True
>>78132552
Well this thread went to shit with waifufags awfully quick
>>78133454
If you go over the waifu shit it's still a good book. It's really comfy and relatable
>>78133375
approved
>>78133483
It is in no way shape or form one of the top 100 books of all time.
Just cause you are a teenage girl that can relate to it doesn't make it god tier.
>>78132718
Approved.
>>78133619
Just because you dislike it dosent mean it's shit, all the people approving g it proves that
>>78132552
This. Approved
>>78131869
approved
Marvel Knights: Spider-Man
>>78133759
approved
American Splendor
>>78133676
>All the ppl
It was like 3 waifufags. I didn't even say I disliked it, it just doesn't belong on the top 100.
When did this place go so down hill? I should probably just go with the rest of the oldfags.
>>78133606
Approved, most definitely
Flex Mentallo?
>>78133834
The world is changing , nothing you can do about it.
>>78133061
I mean, who DOESN'T LOVE a visit from the garbage ape?
APPROVED
>>78133884
The world changing has nothing to do with shit taste.
>>78132552
Approved for sure
>>78133805
Approved
>>78133914
So thousands of people have shit taste?
>>78132552
Approved
>>78133949
Yes. Yes they do. Again the book is in no way bad but it doesn't deserve to be in the top 100. Not even close.
If you wanna shill Marvel say Silver Surfer Requim.
If you wanna shill a female book say Birds of Prey.
>>78134068
approved
>>78133443
All 3 comics here should be approved
most heroic superhero, most dramatic slice of life drama, and most horrifying cosmic horror
>>78132552
Of course approved
>>78133375
top 10
>>78134119
APPROVED
So there seems to be some pretty terrible nominations so let's narrow this down. You can't nominate anything unless you've actually read 100 comics.
>>78134182
I've read over 700 Heathcliff strips. I can still nominate comics. Your rules can't stop the best stuff from finding a way to the list no matter how hard you try
What about this one, niggas?
>>78134206
ha, good one
>>78134217
I got no problems with Heathcliff home slice.
Nolan's Plane Scene
>>78134206
denied, but top kek
>>78133416
approved
Just picking this issue as a representative of the series as a whole.
>>78134249
HAHAHA fucking no.
>>78134284
Why the fuck not?
>>78134284
Approved of course, in my opinion its Moore's best
>>78134284
approved of course
>>78134330
Approved
>>78134162
>top 10
What about this "top 10"?
>>78134311
absosulte bullshit central mystery>MAPONE
>>78134330
Is this board just like over ran with entry level plebs now? Thanks MCU
>>78134365
Nigga fuck you. Twist was fucking great.
Morrison's Doom Patrol
>>78134255
Since there technically is a comic of it, APPROVED.
>>78134433
Approved
>>78134424
so many great DD stories and you pick that one.
hell, even Bendis has done better with the character, his whole run is one long story
>thread overrun by heathcliffags
oh well, the cause is not lost yet. I propose Garfield
>>78134460
>Even Bendis
That reminds me.
Ultimate Spider-Man. Shit was GOAT al the way up until Pete died.
>>78134460
Becuase it's breddy fucking gud. I like it, sir and you should stick it up to yo ass
ancient El Santo comic where he uses a jetpack
Geoff Johns' JSA run
>>78132934
The Spirit's moon adventure was better.
coming soon in english
>>78134371
>posts alias
>entry level pleb because netflix mcu apparently
>posts punisher
alright
>>78134628
Are you trying to imply Punisher Max wasn't god tier and Alias isn't meh who cares tier? Cause you'd be wrong.
Something by Dave Cooper
>>78134673
he's implying that complaining about "pleb tier/ tv-movie tastes" in the same post in which The Punisher is suggested is a mixed message at best.
Look at that list of credits.
LOOK!
>>78134628
Dude Alias is pretty mediocre. It's not even Bendis' best work.
top 10 cape shit no particular order
>has to be from an ongoing monthly title
Miller's Daredevil
Simonson's Thor
Lee/Ditko Spiderman
Lee/Kirby Fantastic Four
Gerber's Defenders
Robinson's Starman
Ennis' Punisher
Wolfman's Teen Titans
Beck's Captain Marvel
Shooter's Harbinger
Top 10 non cape shit
Bark's Donald Duck
Sim's Cerebus
Kurtzman's Mad
Gaiman's Sandman
Moore's Swamp Thing
Kanigher/Kubert's Enemy Ace
Smith's Bone
Ellis' Transmetropolitan
Thomas' Conan the Barbarian
Hernandez Bros' Love and Rockets
and there you have it, my top 20 comics I would place inside a time capsule for future generations to read
might be shit but fuck it
>>78134708
Again are you implying that Punisher Max is in any way pleb tier?
You haven't fucking read it then.
>>78134581
I keep wondering if I should buy it or wait for a storytime.
>>78134768
yeah, i realize that. i actually like ultimate spidey more than anything in terms of bendis, but i liked alias for what it was.
>>78134805
I was gonna buy it but Amazon has been saying that it's not in stock for weeks.
Suspicious, suspicious indeed.
>>78134805
If you're tempted don't look at this:
https://www.instagram.com/p/-R_JY4naB5/
>>78134581
>soon
it's already out
>>78134714
jesus you people really do exist.
I read the first ~20 issues as they were coming out. It's great. If Punisher at all deserves to be on the list, the Ennis Max material is what should represent it. I don't disagree.
But if you're gonna get on to someone for a SEEMINGLY pleb-tier choice, and then use IT GOT MOVIE as a reason, maybe don't also suggest one of the handful of Marvel properties THAT ALSO HAS A FUCKING MOVIE
>>78134782
this list need more >>78134909
>>78134952
fuuuuck that was meant for >>78134801
>>78134714
I meant to say something else to you. "Look at the content!" is a stronger argument.
What about The Death Ray by Daniel Clowes?
>>78134952
But Punisher Max is also good while Alias is mediocre at best.
>>78134855
Wow, that looks needless. I'm actually less tempted now, thanks!
>>78135156
approved
>>78134407
approved
>>78135156
Honestly anything with Quitely should be on this list.
>>78135314
Except Jupiter's Legacy.
>>78135429
Oh yes. Also
>>78135429
approved
>>78135156
hell yes
![634f717a4fa988b6b5392e4961922706[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/OSYHPfd.jpg "634f717a4fa988b6b5392e4961922706[1].jpg")
>>78134068
Denied.
Specifically this issue.
>>78135618
>Judge Dredd
If I could pick only one story to approve, it would definitely be America
>>78135147
totaly aprove
>>78135933
Approved
>>78132552
Approved
>>78135692
Good choice
>>78135658
This the one where the Crisis erases his wife?
>>78133818
Approved
>>78134068
Approved
>>78134246
Which do Anon's prefer, Eisner's Spirit or his GN's? If the latter, which one?
>>78134723
Seth Fisher, what a singular m/s talent, RIP. But, I couldn't approve on this basis alone, personally.
My choice off the top of my head for being one of the first autobio comics, the first comic (or any other publication, to my knowledge) to deal with OCD (before it existed as a medical diagnosis!) and also because it is definitely "Art" with a capital "A"--pure, untrammelled, visually refined self-expression. Was gonna post the original floppy but the McSweeney's facsimile edition reprint is so much better
>>78136291
yep
Pick a fuckin' issue
>itt: /co/ reveals that its just made up of a bunch of casuals
Or under water welder
Prophets
>>78136421
It's Prophet anon but yesh.
![madman_ac_08[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/88ERYXI.jpg "madman_ac_08[1].jpg")
![daytripper_09_0001[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/lS5urDN.jpg "daytripper_09_0001[1].jpg")
![Rocketeer_Adventure_Magazine_1[1].png](https://i.imgur.com/CVOYJ0j.png "Rocketeer_Adventure_Magazine_1[1].png")
1- Fun Home by my idol Bechdel thank you for exposing your shitlord dad
2- Ms Marvel
3- Babsgirl
4- Whatever book has Carol Danvers
5- Harley Quinn
![Top-10-comics-5[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/BZgEcu0.jpg "Top-10-comics-5[1].jpg")
![241825[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/vcNMsvx.jpg "241825[1].jpg")
>>78132718
Multiversity is to comics as ASS is to superman. Definitely approved.
![743519-maxx044[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/GDtBzXn.jpg "743519-maxx044[1].jpg")
>>78136344
seconded
>>78136816
best BR comic??
>>78137431
>BR
?
>>78137456
brazilian
Cmon brehs
>>78131832
>>78131869
>>78132552
Nothing but garbage and trolling so far.
>>78137489
Ah. IMO it is, but mesmo is also breddy good.
>>78132718
Approved. Best single issue of the year except MAYBE some of Archie vs. Predator and the first and last issues of Godzilla In Hell.
>>78137090
I'm glad someone posted this. Approved.
>>78137527
>watchmen
>trolling
leave
>>78134581
Approved
>>78134499
Approved
>>78134407
Approved
>>78134352
Approved
>>78137144
Great comic and I love Darrow (and Miller up 'til DKR2) but no way top 100. How come no one talks about the almost contemporaneous Give Me Liberty on here? Not that I'd put that in the top 100, either.
>>78137351
Is it really that good? I mean, I've only read about five issues and whilst I know he's a great cartoonist his art just really turns me off. You prefer this over the Alex stuff, yeah?
>>78134782
>Gerber's Defenders
Far from his best work.
>Robinson's Starman
Not on the same level as the rest of the list.
>Shooter's Harbinger
The fuck?
>Top 10 non cape shit
Enemy Ace isn't on that level and Sandman is the most overrated comic ever.
DeCarlo/Doyle Archie should be on there. Rosa's Duck comics should as well. I'd also recommend Hitman. Planetary probably deserves consideration. As does Busiek's Conan.
This thread is FULL of fucking children who don't know what would actually deserve to be on a list like this.
Little Nemo in Slumberland
>>78136842
Approve as long as we're only talking about the original run.
>>78137709
>I'd also recommend Hitman
That was a lot for you to have typed out just for bait.
>>78137578
>liking Watchmen
>le tipping le gentlesir's le fedora
>>78137578
Being contrarian is a way of life
>>78137723
See, >>78136888
You dumb fuck
>>78137883
Wow, worst post of 2015 contender right here
>>78137883
I'm sorry, did you have anything to say about the actual comic or are you just going to keep making yourself look like a fucking child?
>>78137883
You spazzed the fuck out man.
>>78137060
Except the part about having co0nsistently good art.
And consistently good stories.
Well, I'm making my own list and might try even writing short reasons I believe they deserve to be on it.
>>78138029
Kek what. Every single issue of Multiversity was amazing. Which one did you dislike?
>In before Pax
Don't do it anon.
>>78138068
>anything involving Grant Morrison
>amazing
lol
>>78138068
Holy kek, I don't frequent /co/ anymore but are there seriously people on here that pretend Pax is bad?
S M H
>>78138095
>ASS issue 10
>not better than any indiean comic ever made
>>78138131
Pax isn't bad but it's overrated due to the structure. The story itself wasn't great but it was fun to piece it together.
>>78137690
I've read more bacchus then I have Alec, but yeah I dig it more. Campbell's best work artistically IMO
>>78138248
Okay, I'll give it a go then, Anon. Read about half The Complete Alex in bits and bobs over the years then got a copy outta the library and read the whole thing. Very good, varied art. I DID like his art in From Hell A LOT for some reason....I saw a great Bacchus double-page splash advertisement in the back of an old Cerebus which was fucking brilliant.....I just kind of take issue with the idea that a sketchy or "uncontrolled"-looking line is somehow more "expressive" than a measured, controlled one (not that Campbell has EVER made that claim to my knowledge but a fair few of his admirers and "comics lit. 101" types have done). But, yeah, great, great cartoonist, undoubtedly, even though he's not my usual cup of tea.
Keep posting indiefags, I'm discovering some interesting looking comics with this thread.
![jason-covers-02[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/tvZ9vTz.jpg "jason-covers-02[1].jpg")
>>78138766
>>78138766
check out Jason's full body of work
![usagibw[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/7hhCgXb.jpg "usagibw[1].jpg")
![91hsjgUvI6L[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/jVssTPZ.jpg "91hsjgUvI6L[1].jpg")
![contract_trilogy_cv_300[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/hTNDhgh.jpg "contract_trilogy_cv_300[1].jpg")
my fave
>>78134206
Well, if this was a lit of 100 comics that /co/ users should reed.....
![Sandman_Mystery_Theatre_29[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/40Q3B7s.jpg "Sandman_Mystery_Theatre_29[1].jpg")
>>78134539
Approved
>>78132552
>>78132718
>>78132934
>>78133375
>>78133626
>>78133880
>>78134050
>>78134284
>>78134330
>>78134433
>>78134480
>>78135156
>>78139020
Approved.
>>78133061
Approved?
>>78139202
wow, your taste is really basic.
>>78139349
Well, I guess I'm sorry. I don't have money nor time to read everything.
>>78139406
no hate, just try to read stuff outside Mavel or DiC or their imprints. you'll look back and be glad you did, trust me
>>78132552
Approved
>>78139484
I do read some Image. Saga, Copperhead, East of West, Manhattan Projects but none of them was posted but Sandman is my favorite comic and I did not see it in the thread so that's what I posted.
Might as well post this while I'm at it.
>>78138961
>>78139020
Fur faggotry
>>78138961
>>78139118
Approved
>>78138060
That cartoon was sweet
>>78137709
You can't put everything in. I tried to stick to shut that heavily influenced other creators and revolutized comic book medium in some small way. Something that can teach other how to do comics properly
Enemy Ace might not be as flashy as the other books or even the better known of Kubert's works like Sgt Rock but Ace was a game changer. Take a look at the vertical paneling and layouts used to convey dogfight in the air. Get use of space and they're beautiful to look at. If you think about it he was an antihero during the counterculture movement and he was based on a German war hero. Pretty ballsy stuff and even if the creators didn't intend for the comic to come of as anti war, the readers did pick up these themes as the creators were vets. Kurtzman had some great war stories too.
Plantery was thought about I swear. I just didn't pull the trigger, love the lore but it terms of actual craft Ellis' Athuority was a game changer, made the whole industry notice the wide panel motif and it's stuck everyone is using it still to this day.
I like Busiek's Conan and it be overall better than Roy's Conan the Barbarian ongoing but that can't beat Savage Sword of Conan.
Kungpow.jpeg
>I implore to reconsidure
Reread the Defenders. I like Man-Thing better but Defenders is just as good as any cape comic and still retaining that Gerber touch
I agree with everything else. I tended to side with the more influential run that's why Rosa didn't make it as Bark's Duck influenced everyone see Raiders of the Lost Arc.
I like the X'ed out series a little more but this is still overly amazing.
>>78139202
After reading all of the Sandman and then having the extreme pleasure of Overture - I must say, it was a very beautiful experience.
nominating Strangers in Paradise by Terry Moore
>>78133626
approved
>>78134782
approving Love and Rockets
>>78133818
approving although I've only read Our Cancer Year and the Quitter which are only technically part of American Splendor
>>78131832
>>78132718
>>78133375
>>78133805
>>78133882
>>78134480
>>78134499
>>78134524
>>78135147
>>78135505
>>78135658
>>78135933
>>78137523
>>78139118
>>78139202
Approved.
>>78139610
There are more than three publishers, farn.
If Sandman is your favorite then you should read Cerebus the Aardvark. While working on Sandman, Neil Gaiman said that Dave Sim is a better creator than Neil Gaiman.
>>78140021
Denied faggot.
>>78137060
People who can't tell the difference between the medium and a genre shouldn't be permitted to post on this board.
The Adventures of Luther Arkwright
>>78140094
Pretty sure he was referring with the medium because of all the different ways Morrison messes with the comic itself, like the paneling and being able to read it forward or backwards and what not.
>>78139970
Yeah, I know. They're just kinda harder to get into, for obvious reasons.
Thanks for the recommendation, I'll look into it!
>>78133375
>>78134480
>>78133805
Without a doubt
>>78133626
>>78132552
>>78133880
Approved, if only for influence
>>78134768
Alias was good, but had too much "Bendisness". I approve Ultimate Spider-Man tho.
For The Man Who Has Everything
>>78140318
Agreed! Also "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow".
>>78137299
most certainly approved
>>78140318
For a sec, I thought that said "Anal Superman"
>and Supes face with Mongul behind him...
>>78140355
Agreed
My nomination is Daredevil: Born Again
>>78140036
Approved. Definitely approved.
>>78139750
>>78139202
>>78139046
>>78138875
>>78137523
>>78137299
>>78136917
>>78136421
>>78135156
>>78135147
>>78134499
>>78134433
>>78134352
>>78134119
>>78134050
>>78133882
>>78133805
>>78133759
>>78132994
>>78132718
Approved
>>78134768
>>78134480
>>78134330
>>78134249
>>78133626
>>78132552
>>78131869
>>78131880
Denied
Nominating a /co/ favorite, Stardust
>>78140536
>Denied
I agree with all you denied except Kingdom Come.
I think its too significant.
how many nominations do we have so far and how many of those are approved by at least one anon?
>>78140687
He's right, it might not even be a top 5 Waid story.
>>78140674
>Approving fur faggotry
Kill yourself
>>78140718
Uh, no. You are both wrong.
>>78140718
Its literally the only comic Waid has made that's worth anything.
>>78140718
This is where I was coming from, maybe it is just personal taste. Kingdom Come's the only one on the list I wouldn't really mind being there, but the others are actually just run-of-the-mill genre stuff or the Unfunnies. At least Kingdom Come tries to be something better even if I think it failed.
>>78140762
>>78140806
The only good part is the art and Justice is a better Ross story anyway. Please don't be a pleb.
>>78140959
You're the only pleb in this discussion.
This deserved to keep going. Still bummed it didn't.
>>78138908
Approved, definitely. I like Why Are You Doing This and Left Bank Gang. He's kinda the Swedish Hal Hartley of comix.
>>78139020
Kind of goes without saying (no dis intended!), woulda posted but last time someone posted it they got that "greedy jew" pic with a "good goy" comment. But, yeah, approved, OBVIOUSLY.
>>78139046
Approved
>>78136888
Approved but not without DeBeck's Barney Google, Krazy Kat, Peanuts and Gasoline Alley.
>>78136917
It's great, it's on my shelf, Pope is an ace cartoonist but....storywise he's not so strong. I think 100% is better, maybe?
>>78136970
Bechdel is your idol?! Cool. Check out Phoebe Gloeckner, Debbie Drechsler, Carol Tyler, Krystine Kryttyre, Dori Seda and Julie Doucet for some amazing, stomach-churningly amazing, female autobio (female cartoonists just do autobio better and I'll fight anyone who says otherwise!) comix.
>>78139750
He's no writer....the Big Baby stuff is better in my humble opinion.....still, an amazing achievement that I'd probably stick in the top 80's. I reckon.
>>78139845
Started off as a Jaime Hernandez L & R rip, soon became it's own thing, approved for me. Anyone reading Rachel Rising?! It's really fucking good.
Why our those books "only technically" AS? It says "American Splendor on the cover of OCY, doesn't it (don't think it does on the Quitter, though--you may have a point...)?! Unsung Hero is FUCKING DOPE.
>>78140115
YES
>>78140489
C'mon...really?
>>78140959
Alex Toss would kill his own family to be able to paint and draw like Steve Rude....he goes to bed at night, thinking: "HOW DOES THE DUDE ACHIEVE SUCH REALISM....WITHOUT GETTING HIS FRIENDS TO COSPLAY FOR HIM?!?!" Yup, I know the Dudue does draw from life....but his comics are all from his boundless imagination. Which leads me to my second nomination, who gives a fuck if I'm disqualified: Nexus Omnibus 1
>>78141468
I can't believe I just typo'd "The Dude" as "The Dudedue". I'll get my coat.
REMINDER, AGAIN:
http://putlocker.is/watch-rude-dude-online-free-putlocker.html
