[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
West tree academy of heroes thread
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Thread replies: 97
Thread images: 17
File: page-e2.png (185 KB, 764x974) Image search: [Google]
page-e2.png
185 KB, 764x974
Chapter 13 just wrapped up, some plot is building up with the dark guild and stuff.

Discuss the comic.
>>
I am discussing the comic

I am now ending my discussion

I know this isn't my personal blog but I hope you enjoyed my rant.
>>
Porn when?
>>
>>77823974
There's quite a lot on paheal
>>
File: page-281.png (164 KB, 764x974) Image search: [Google]
page-281.png
164 KB, 764x974
>>77823702
I keep wanting to read this, but it's admittedly low on my list of things to keep up with.
>>
File: page-191.png (249 KB, 1090x1389) Image search: [Google]
page-191.png
249 KB, 1090x1389
>>77824545
My point being, I have no idea what's been going on.
>>
>>77824586
Chozen scociety is battling to stop the dark guild, and something with an evil leaf guy.

At least, that's what I'm getting from it.
>>
File: 289750948.png (86 KB, 600x600) Image search: [Google]
289750948.png
86 KB, 600x600
What gender is this little faggot?
>>
File: theventurebros05[1].jpg (32 KB, 482x288) Image search: [Google]
theventurebros05[1].jpg
32 KB, 482x288
>>77825690
if it's brown, go to town
>>
>>77825690
Nigger gender
>>
I want to rape Angel.
>>
So what's this comic about exactly?
>>
>>77829894
Teenagers learning how to be heroes in a hero academy.

And you know, teenage hormones.
>>
File: _20151122_023339.jpg (11 KB, 176x171) Image search: [Google]
_20151122_023339.jpg
11 KB, 176x171
>>77830356
>hormones

Does every webcomic nowadays have to be about hormonally charged children?
Anyway, I like how your style isn't rigid.
>>
>>77830869
i certainly think there aren't enough about hormonal teenagers being fun 80s style hormonal teenagers (or 50s style hormonal teenagers as seen in 80s films)
but modern shit? fuuuck no.
>>
File: 1421180361978.jpg (12 KB, 300x300) Image search: [Google]
1421180361978.jpg
12 KB, 300x300
>>77831104
ColdFusion? Is that you?
>>
>>77831104
I dunno, It hasn't really treated it as serious.

Like when Jack realized when he was a bisexual, it was played off as a joke.
>>
>>77831157
maybe
>>
>>77831830
Nothing should be treated seriously, least of all that shit. Last thing the webcomic world needs.
Besides isn't it more of a "Stupid sexy Flanders" situation? With a possible Lee Lemon scenario, depending on what it turns out 'Beth is packing
>>
>>77831889
Yeah, It's a pretty complex and really sexually confusing situation.
>>
>nothing should be treated seriously

Who the fuck told you that?

You're webcomic is what you make it. Seriousness and all. Gunnerkrigg Court is a prime example of drama working without comedy. No only is it extremely popular, but it's extremely popular on /co/ of all fucking places.
>>
>>77832261
>Who the fuck told you that?
john cleese
>>
>>77832490
John Cleese sounds like a hack. I mean I'm sure he's had a bunch of successful comics on his own but that sounds like the wrong mindset to have.
>>
>>77832261
Well, there's some serious parts in the story, like that one section in chapter 11 with SD and Angel About Angel's mental disability.
>>
>>77832582
snicker
to be fair though what he was saying wasn't 'never take things seriously' but 'never demand seriousness of others if they would rather be silly' because silly is creative, and creativity solves problems.
He cheekily advised "if you're a supervisor and you want a workplace devoid of any fresh new ideas: do the following" and basically instructed them on how to crush all humor and independent thought with a climate of solemn seriousness.
the german audience didn't seem to get that it was a joke

in particular he doesnt see the value in treating death as a deathly serious thing. better to joke around about it and you might think up a way to improve your own life or avoid the same problems that led to that death. or at least enjoy the life they used to have, taking full advantage of it
>>
File: KIMG0028.jpg (2 MB, 3264x2448) Image search: [Google]
KIMG0028.jpg
2 MB, 3264x2448
Why is he so perfect?
>>
File: page 46.png (1 MB, 1090x1380) Image search: [Google]
page 46.png
1 MB, 1090x1380
Two dicks.

Also, The site has snow coming down on it now, cool!
>>
I'm just here for the slime/water girls.
>>
>>77833192
>he isn't here for SD's SD.
>>
>>77833088
shit that is cool
if i was better at coding, and my site wasn't done by automation, i'd totally fucking put that shit up on the pages that take place in winter
>>
File: page 28.png (978 KB, 1090x1389) Image search: [Google]
page 28.png
978 KB, 1090x1389
>>77833192
Would you let her give you the dildo glove?
>>
>>77833373
i cant find oil-hair nep as hot as i found lemonade-hair nep. not sure what that is. maybe piss fetish.
>>
>>77833373
Am I the only one who doesn't want to fuck any of the characters? I just want to see where the story goes..
>>
>>77833373
Maybe
>>
>>77833822
eh.. there's character-interaction to be sure. that's enjoyable. But story? I haven't picked up on much yet
>>
>>77834067
Exactly. Make some more. That's the best part in my opinion. Yeah tits and fan-service is fine and all but I need a good narrative to really get off.

I mean I draw lewd but it's specifically for that audience. When I draw comics I wanna do something else yknow? I dunno. He's doing good so far. I don't wanna sound like a fag.
>>
>>77834415
well shit i like your lewdness and dewd's lewddewdness for some of the same reasons, it's all delightfully trashy and vulgar, feeling equal parts modern day and centuries-old ribaldry
>>
Post more best character

It's Annabelle btw
>>
Oh hey, a guest page.

>Good thing Sd's new hat will protect him from the snow falling down on the site!
>>
>>77836638
>that hat

RUINED
>>
>>77836638
never before has it been so easy to imagine him sounding like the guy from china IL
>>
>>77836733
Good thing he does in the animations
>>
File: must resist.jpg (23 KB, 235x270) Image search: [Google]
must resist.jpg
23 KB, 235x270
>>77836638
>>
File: Video_003_0001.jpg (21 KB, 624x352) Image search: [Google]
Video_003_0001.jpg
21 KB, 624x352
>>77836638
>>77836733
>tch, again?! Alright but this is the last time, Pony

Oh god it fits so well
>>
>>77836638
>>77836733
>>77837229
If I have time tomorrow, (and if this thread is still up) I'll do a vacaroo of this comic.
>>
The real problem with West Tree is that its' very obvious that Dewd is having ideas for like 2 future chapters for every page he draws.

It feels like things never get proper focus or attention because he's thinking so much faster than he's writing and always trying to move ahead to his newest thing.
>>
>>77839774
This honestly

I mean its nice to write out a story, and anticipate it and everything like that

but it feels like he's trying to rush to that point and kind of forgets the little details that made the first few parts of this comic enjoyable.
>>
Real question, why does this comic get so much Rule34 compared to all the other no-name /co/ made comics in the webcomic thread?
>>
>>77839834

I don't know, He ask him for porn?

Or people just like him.
>>
Dewd you need some tough love. Learn to construct bodies with 3D shapes already.
>>
>>77839834
I was wondering that too. He's got a lot of regular fanart as well.
>>
>>77839774
Just dropping in real quick.

Make that, like, 20 chapters ahead.

But anyways, are you guys saying I should take some more pages to explain stuff, like exposition dumps or something.
>>
Your comic has a fanbase here? I'm impressed.
>>
Annabump.
>>
>>77842113
Fanbase is a loose term

I'd say people who frequent the HYW general that actually bother to read the comic whenever he posts it, which is everyday.
>>
>>77839834
two things i think
a) shit's sexy in a real unrestrained kinda way
b) being on /co/, we're used to looking at less than appealing art styles and interpreting them better. I like westtree 34 for the same reason I enjoy Loud House 34
>>
>>77844984
Pretty much.
I feel little shame in saying that I can fap to >>77824586.
>>
>>77845025
I was hooked when too-long-torso-Annabeth was rolling around in mud wearin naught but a pair of daisy dukes, and proclaiming that she (oh god let it be she) liked being dirty
>>
I'm just proud of /co/ that this hasnt turned into a mindless hatefest of a thread
>>
File: 1398896209472.jpg (37 KB, 240x240) Image search: [Google]
1398896209472.jpg
37 KB, 240x240
>Dewd's comic gets its own thread while mine doesn't
>>
>>77846899
well there are certain major disadvantages to having a comic with fucking hundreds of strips, yknow? I certainly know firsthand.
this is one of the few advantages our type of comic has. there's a lot to talk about
>>
>>77846899
I know that feel. Still, there's something very charming about a literally who getting their own thread and discussion. I have seen dewd's comic in the webcomic creation threads and they're not bad. I mean yeah they're mediocre but they're different too. Couple that with the lewdness of it and you have a fanbase. Albeit small.
With that said, 4chan is probably the most toxic place to advertise your comic on. Not even for the constructive criticism thing but for the general cynicism this website has so don't feel bad if you don't get a thread.
>>
Where's the site?
>>
>>77847885
http://freakanimes.info/westtree/
>>
Dewd should storytime it. The whole comic.
>>
>>77848907
YES PLEASE
>>
>>77848907
Why? They already linked the website. And the comic is fuckhuge.
>>
>>77841566
Not so much exposition dumps, since the exposition dump pages you already have are full of things that have never come up before or since which makes them especially jarring (and uninteresting).

Just like, give time to let plotpoints breathe and slow down. You have to think about how things really appear to an outsider who doesn't know what's in your head. Thinking of things in 20 chapter paces means that the audience sees an idea for all of one or two pages before the comic moves on. Such as Pony/Angel's rapidly changing appearance
>>
>>77848907
Probably on christmas.
>>
>>77849443
thinking about how the audience sees things is a really tough and important thing. I've recently been wondering if my story might have been a bit unsatisfying, because I basically did Back to the Future except saving the mom's life, and i didnt show it happening when it had been accomplished because it was far off, and it had already been shown in flashback when they met her
except that was 12 years ago
but i just can't find an interesting way to show it, it was offscreen for a reason
>>
>>77849443
>rapidly changing appearance
Ah well Dewd was having a lot of trouble keeping appearances consistent because he kept getting new idears, kept on fixing mistakes, getting better at drawing, plus he kept modifying people so they wouldn't look like ripoffs. It's a wonder you can tell who anyone is, but he's trying. It's kinda like when you binge Red Dwarf and YEARS go on in between seasons and people look quite different or the rules of the setting vary like mad
>>
>>77849643
>>77849443
>>77849643

I would actually like to drag El Goonish Shive into the picture for a minute, that one had crappy art for like, two years, and the characters appearences changed alot, and it switches color to black and white to this day.

Not to mention the plot does change around alot. But It's still considered by most (Including me) a very fun story.

Anyways, I feel like if I slow down my story will start to drag on, It's already 300+ pages and chapter 13 was a little over 50. And were hardly a sixth of the way through the story.

But yeah, the Pony/Angel change was something that needed to happen FAST so people could forget about it, It's kinda like what happened to Rick and Morty.
>>
>>77849766
in any case, you have a long way to improve, so of COURSE it's going to look different as you improve because you're improving so damned quickly. Consistency is for professionals, best to chuck that out if it gets in the way of anything.
>>
>>77849766
I think it's more akin to Dexter's Laboratory where the show style was dramatically changed half way through the shows run. That was, of course, due to the swapping of lead animators. However, in your comic, you chose to change the designs because of artistic liberties, i.e. whatever your reason may be. Which is fine, yeah, I mean I wasn't complaining beforehand but I have seen others complain about it and.. to be completely honest? Yeah I think they kind of have a point. It's really jarring to the audience because of how sudden the change was. Other people may get confused about which character is which and others may be even more confused because a couple of characters were changed but not others. It's fine if you want to change the artstyle but it's a weird feeling for the audience. It's a sudden shift in perspective because the audience who loved how the old Dexter's Lab looked now has to like this new look of Dexter's Lab. You can't expect people to keep liking it but yeah most people do and do give in because they just wanted some more Dexter. I feel really silly comparing something as bug as Dexter to West Tree but I hope you get what i'm trying to say.

Now reboots on the other hand I have no qualms with. Since.. it's a reboot. No shit it's gonna look different. Kind of like Ben 10.
>>
File: 1445413188888.gif (951 KB, 500x384) Image search: [Google]
1445413188888.gif
951 KB, 500x384
>>77850102
>bug

Anyway, all I was trying to say is, just do whatever the fuck you want boyo. It's your comic. Just don't expect people to accept your ideas as quickly as you do.
>>
>>77846899
Dewd is unrestrained, creative energy, for better or worse. While many artists sturggle with perfectionism or their inability to match what's in their head, Dewd just forges ahead at a constant, quantity over quality pace.

The comic goes on straight from imagination to page, however nonsensical, tonally inappropriate, or derivative it may be (no offense). It has a very loose, work-in-progress, "retcon-it-later" approach to story crafting.

Dewd's work is flawed, sure, but it's flawed because he has TOO MUCH of an unfiltered quality that most artists here find themselves in short supply of.

And that's why West Tree is appealing to me, at least.

That said , don't interpret what I said as an excuse not to fix anything. Listen to this guy >>77839870 and take some more time with your composition.
>>
It's about as bad as It Hurts
>>
>>77850314
>hating on It Hurts

faggot
>>
>>77850248
Imagine if dewd had an older brother like the kid that wrote axe cop
we would have a masterpiece on our hands
>>
>>77850543
No one could draw that fast and still be good.
>>
>>77851496
fair enough but the axe cop guy never drew enough
>>
File: westtree fancomic.jpg (265 KB, 900x1440) Image search: [Google]
westtree fancomic.jpg
265 KB, 900x1440
>>77836638
I did you one just now!
spent fucking ages trying to get a crayon brush and it still doesnt look right. but I did learn that I can load up brush presets!
>>
>>77852459
Oh sweet!

This is probably gonna be on the site tomorrow.

Alt text: This girl is gonna be the next ZONE, she even drew them naked!
>>
>>77852631
hahahaha tops.
Did you get a bunch of other submissions? because if not, better to pace the guest week out than only give that other guy one day
>>
>>77852732
I should be getting anouther one tonight, but if I don't then it'll only be three this week, it's cool.

What's not cool is losing a whole page of line art due to my computer restarting which happened right now.

It stuff like that, that's making me have this guest comic week.
>>
>>77836638
You guys wanna hear some useless facts about this page? Yeah, ya do!
>I started on this page three months ago and worked on it when i had free time. Which was very little.
>Also I googled 'fluffy Canada hat' to find reference for SD's hat.
>My favorite character is Annabeth. Least favorite is Skippy. The character I am most like is Sarah.
>>77836836
This is my favorite panel.
>Pony is wearing a rare matching granny panty set.
>I've drawn 34 of Jack, Neptunia and Annabeth

>>77836681
Yeah, I always imagined is as that kind of hat. I was totes wrong but that is how I'm gonna keep drawing SD. Apparently, he wears a knitted beanie hat or something.
>>
>>77853854
I always took it for a motorcycle helmet or some variation thereof..
>>
>>77853926
that's the fun of .. naive art. you get to interpret it however you want
hopefully that also goes for the contents of certain characters' pants
>>
>>77853854
He wears a beanie? I thought it was a helmet. Wow, I thought SD was cool but I guess not.
>>
holy shit, I haven't visited /co/ in a while

Last time I saw Dewd, his comic was universally hated on HYW thread except for a few loyal fans which everyone assumed was Dewd samefagging.

And now he has his own thread where everyone actually likes the bad art

my have times changed...

I just don't understand you, 4chan. You always manage to surprise me, given how anal your standards usually are
>>
>>77857968
actually HYW is still like that every 10 threads or so
some anon recently was like 'for secret santa we should storytime each others' comics' and dewd was like 'yeah that'd be great' i was thinking 'oh.. oh no let's not do that.. it'll only invite a bunch of hateboulders onto their head' and yet sure enough someone here has felt like throwin the dewd an attentionbone and everyone's been quite civil.
>>
You did it Dewd, I always knew you would make it! *manly tears*
>>
>>77858147
Dewd was the one that made the thread.
You can check for samefagging you know.

Anyway, I don't think the comic is that bad. I mean we always have Dumbing of Age threads and that comic is horrendous.
>>
>>77858890
nobody believes that myth
and even if that were true it'd be an even greater sign of /co/ being love
>>
>>77859126
Google, my friend.
>>
I've started reading this Stones of Anarchy comic lately. It's another with pretty crummy art but really engaging humor that somehow gets me in and caring about these characters that I can't even tell what they are
I guess it's kinda like cartoons vs anime sometimes.
>>
>>77850543
This could be a western One Punch Man and we just don't know it.
Thread replies: 97
Thread images: 17

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.