And to start us off here is this fucking disgrace
>>8907372
The face of fattychan after a hike in the woods.
>>8907949
being black would actually be 100x more convenient than batman having to fill his eye holes in with makeup.
>>8907949
Crazy eyes Harley
>>8907959
>looks at upper half
>what's wrong with this besides the nose ring?
>scrolls down
>oh sweet succotash why
>>8907959
>trash behind her on the floor by the room
amazing
>>8908302
what the fuck are her boobs
>>8908510
>>8908302
Whats with her right leg?
>>8908514
>>8908209
stop ruining my son with your awful cosplay
>>8908941
the makeup and wig are great, but whatever she used to make that armor is fucking abysmal. I bet it took a lot of time and money, and it ended up being worthless.
>>8908975
I'm fucking scared of the girl's shop
>>8908516
The cape is covering part of it. I saw it for a second too, though, I get ya.
>>8908975
Uncanny valley.
Hey at least some of the people actually tried. Those who really tried I applaud them. If you are saying their cosplays are horrible only because they are fat are dicks. Concentrate on the costumes and not the person wearing it. I think the two girls wearing costume from the hunger games (?) Look adorable.
>>8909293
>concentrate on the costumes
like katniss' massive seam and terrible choice for the black fabric, as well as bad makeup? And how the white piece is supposed to go all the way to the other side of her waist but only covers her chest partially?
Or maybe Effie's ill fitting dress and bra showing? Or even the sad cardboard support for the butterflies?
>>8908518
The costumes aren't terrible but why the fuck wouldn't you wear some nude tights?
>>8909311
Like I said they tried which means they did they could. Did I say they were the best or 100% accurate? No I didnt. I'm just saying good for them for at least trying and on hard costumes too. It's a learning process give them a break. As is I think they look cute. Also I have only seen parts of the first movie in the hunger game series so I don't know what the costumes look like. These girls look like they are having fun and have confidence in themselves (which I also include in judging a costume.) I'm sure your first few costumes weren't spot on. Sorry not trying to be a bitch. Just try to stick up for two girls who I don't believe should be on the list. Sorry for my attitude or if it seemed like I was rude just speaking my opinion.
>>8909359
Lmao either you're new here or bait. I'm not saying "it HSOULD BE PERFETC OMDGF" but they are not good no matter what you say. "They tried" doesnt make it accurate."They did what they could" doesnt mean its good. It is obviously a bit of a vendetta post but that doesnt give them a free pass for mistakes
I think cgl could use a critique thread. An actual critique thread not "it's fucking awful" or "the cosplayer is fucking ugly" as critique. How does one improve when "it's fucking awful" is all you get?
>>8909359
Part of this thread is a bit mean-spirited, but honestly I browse these threads to learn from other people's mistakes. One of the first things I do when I decide to cosplay something is look at what other cosplayers did wrong/right.
>>8909451
There are self-post and WIP progress threads were people can give critique.
get fucking dunked onnnnn
The featured cosplays on amino never fail to disappoint.
>>8909572
Dying
That wig looks like it's trying to run away.
>>8908975
Funny how those pictures were liked and shared by everyone today only to have it posted here. That's cosplayers for you.
>>8909595
I don't think it's the same people
I know who you're talking aboot though.
We can point out exact flaws on bad cosplays. Is fugly one reason usually? Yes. They should try harder.
>>8908358
Plastic
>>8908209
I'm already so sick of miraculous ladybug shit
>>8908302
her titties gonna pop
>>8909821
If the implants don't first.
>>8909738
ignoring basically everything else, i actually don't mind the shape of that rose wig. either she only has a talent for wig styling or she commissioned it
>>8908513
Someone explain what is wrong here because I can live with BD having shiny fabric
I'm not a star wars fan but I'm enjoying cringefest of crossovers that are being shat out
>>8909996
I kind of wish she had used velvet or a less shiny satin.
>>8909870
kek
>>8910088
Is this.... A sith lord gijinka of an Umbreon?
At that point why not just dress up as your own OC Sith Lord?
>>8909879
The idea is there, but the execution needs work. Some of those curls look bad. I also feel so bad for these girls that don't have good strapless bras.
So grim >< and super cringy
>>8910618
why don't people cosplay for their body types FFS
>>8909572
didnt know eggman did cosplay!
>>8910618
this girl is one step away from a nip slip and i hope she's prepared bcos im not
I don't think any of these are bad. You're just a bad person.
The leafa is actually pretty good considering
That cosplay is pretty good considering it's a bigger girl I mean it could be ALOT worse. Yeah they look pretty out of breath but it's not to bad compared to the anime. That's just my opinion.
>>8910655
learn how to reply to posts samefag
>>8910645
>>8910649
>>8910655
lern to quote, samenewfag
>You're just a bad person.
>implying we're all one person
>kek
>>8910645
>>8908975
Ok, these have clearly been airbrushed to cartoon levels, but the basic costumes are good.
>>8910645
Welcome newfriend
>>8910698
Not that hard to wear a shirt, jeans and furry gear.
>i say that but wait for the horrendous zoo cosplays to appear
>>8909996
Do you not see those shiny converse peeking out?
>>8907372
Weird. This threads are supposed to be bait to post hightest girl, but you guys are actually posting bad cosplay, and worse, a lot of them not even related to vidya
>>8911295
pretty shitty way to bait for something when you're going the complete opposite direction with the first post
>>8909738
You're apart of the cosplay sale group on Facebook aren't you?
>>8907372
Disgrace? How so?
Doesn't look that bad to me.
This is just a fat-shaming thread!
this is probably more bad photography but... the absurdity of this entire photo is making me crack up like the dickens
>>8911342
Yep
>>8911631
I get what they're going for but that's...bad.
>>8909595
That "face" will haunt my nightmares.
>>8911631
Hajime's wig (left) is super bad, but overall the cosplays aren't terrible. But I'm pretty sure everyone who saw this has a seizure looking at it
This is supposed to be a closet cosplay of Jack Frost. What the actual fuck are they trying to achive? It was one of those 'say a character and I'll make a closet cosplay of it!' but they didn't even bother at all! JFC
>>8908975
Should be in the bad shoop thread.
DESUDESU
>>8912313
... What? There's litteraly nothing that indicates that this could be Jack frost? Wtf
Idk what is even going on with the "hair"
This is super sonico apparently.
>>8912313
It just looks like a bad selfie
Why must attention whores slutify even the most covered cosplays? It would've been more inpressive with the full outfit. Also that prosthetic needs some work.
>>8913006
She's also touching part of the lightsaber blade to her stomach, which somehow makes me more mad than the outfit.
>>8912827
>>8912884
She looks familiar.. Do you have more pictures?
>>8908975
>>8913193
what wrong with her arm?
>>8912881
I witnessed this in person anon and the drills were fabric. She competed in craftsmanship and it seemed like she was a beginner.(atleast she competed in novice catagory) She'll probably improve.
>>8910618
Ravioli
>>8913410
Is she supposed to look like a gay gremlin?
>>8908302
ew those fishlips
>>8912884
>No headphones
That's like the one rule of Sonico
>>8913006
Dear God that prosthetic is terrible
>>8910666
This kid's face is gonna haunt me.
i was getting really frustrated at the costume i'm currently working on so i came to this thread and i feel like i have been given new life, thanks cgl.
>slave junko
just.. why
Why would you not even wear dance tights?
>>8914121
>slave junko
>she's also black
>>8914121
Makes me wonder what goes through their mind when they decide to do mashups especially poorly ones like this. Frozen or slave anything in particular....
Man, this is my question. I understand not having a good cosplay because of time/skill, but I honestly do not get people like >>8914121, >>8910011
who have botched paint jobs, raw ends, uneven cuts or other things that you can easily go back in and fix, but don't bother.
Maybe, I'm just a perfectionist, but if I saw a part of my cosplay that looked like that I'd immediately go back in and touch it up. >>8914121 particularly kills me because the paint on her bra is SO EASILY FIXABLE and she just lets it be gross and uneven.
bad cosplay, bad photography
>>8914251
>what goes through their minds when they decide to do mashups
What is going to get the most people to look at me? How do I combine the two biggest band wagon cosplays?
Do intentionally bad cosplays count?
Fucking hell though that is just miraculous
>>8910649
> doesn't fit properly
> unflattering and makes her look alot bigger
> make up looks to be awful
> bad pose but points for trying with the location
>>8914368
dear god
>>8914386
i think this is bad even though it's trying to be 'funny' and people wonder why there is a distinction of "black x y and z" characters. ugh.
>>8910011
omg is this asherbee
From Naka-Kon 2016... Stuff of nightmares. :(
>>8909573
war muh dargums
>>8915042
bb you know it is
>>8915046
>essentially free hug shirt
jesus fuck
mini dump, some shockers on fb
>>8915290
>>8915295
>>8915301
>>8915304
end mini dump
>>8915290
Man the harpoons
>>8915326
Atleast the cosplay actually fits though.
>>8914368
9000 HOURS IN MS PAINT
>>8915160
>im needy
Its so much worse than just a free hugs shirt. Why god why
>>8914121
hi hina
Also from Naka
>>8915352
>Narutard at the left
>>8912827
that armpit hair
>>8914794
Why would you paint a bodysuit instead of buying one...
does this consider as bad?
>>8915369
it's a dude.
>>8915402
fucking crossdressing sissies I swear...
>>8914368
I would love something like this of my friends and I for wallpaper/lock screen, its brilliant!
>>8914339
For Asherbee in particular, the reason is that she completely lacks any talent at all for costuming and/or crafting. Literally everything she makes looks like complete shit a 5-year-old would be ashamed of, but she thinks it looks great. The others, I can't say.
>>8915401
nah
>>8914368
>>8915401
That's actually the only good America I've seen.
>>8915793
I think that's the only dude America I've seen!
>>8916012
It's not a joke. She posted saying it was a crossover with one of her loli friends.
What the actual fuck. Fatty Venus, shitty put together Mars, jupiters face (Need I say more?).
>>8916038
>not even talking about tuxedo mask
Venus looks decent even though she's fat, especially compared to some of the others here
>>8916038
Other than the mars I think they look fine? (Apart from the odd shiney skirt)
Tuxedo mask was probably just put together last minute.
I'm feeling a vendetta~
>>8916038
Venus is probably the best one there. The others are yeah, bad.
But man that Tuxedo Mask fucking christ did he put that together in 5 minutes?
>>8916038
theyre arent even that bad, but mercurys pure lack of shoes is off throwing.
>>8916038
>they look decent, vendetta?
>open picture
>lol nevermind
>>8916038
Is no one going to point out the shitty Mercury? Vendetta-Chan is that you
>>8916393
I know this cosplayer (actually a few of them in the pic), she has a medical condition + can't wear certain shoes for long periods of time. Wasn't at this con with her but assume she had to take them off
>>8916038
Hate to burst your bubble but "fatty Venus" and Jupiter look like the best ones compared to the lanky Moon with the bad buns, or that fucking Tuxedo. How are you gonna call the Venus fat when the Mercury is also fat AND worse by far? Mars looks terrible in both costume and wig.
>>8909455
No one could compare to Cardcaptor Will.
>>8916038
is that Beckii Cruel as Sailor Moon?
>>8916038
Hi jazz
>>8916531
As somebody who has been posted on here before, all you're doing by informing your friends is making them feel bad. How necessary is it to know strangers say things behind your back? Does it really make a person's life better to know, or does it just make them feel sick and upset?
>>8916531
I think you need to take a good look at yourself before you attempt to start a feud over nothing.
>>8916531
ok thats nice and all but i can guarantee that we dont care
>>8916531
It would have been better to keep your "informing" of your friends off 4chan. You don't need to tell everybody you're confronting them.
>>8915304
That's the look of a man doing it for his girlfriend and regretting every step into public he takes.
>>8916531
Sindy, get your ass out of here
no one really cares that you "infirmed" them (it's spelt informed btw}
everyone is sick of your shit you anorexic crack whore
>>8916531
go take off your panties in public again sindy
>>8916543
this
>>8916634
meth panty
>>8916531
Newfags if your friends get posted the best thing you can do is ignore it. Do not come in here tripfagging to start shit.
Grossly overweight hogs here
>>8916859
Jeez, I can smell your vendetta from here
>>8916531
You do realize only mods can ban people right? And they dont give a fuck about "fights"
>>8916870
They're undeniably shitty cosplays anon.
>>8916870
>ill fitting everything
>party city wigs
>overweight
Vendetta = jealousy. Nothing will ever be jealous of those cows honey.
Who fed Ashe?
>>8916995
The photoshop effects are awful, and she could use some work on her makeup, but I wouldn't call this bad. The costume itself seems to look pretty decent. If you're only problem with this is that she has a heavy set face, then you don't really understand what bad cosplay is.
>>8916038
This has already been picked apart, but I keep finding new awfulness!
Moon's glove cuffs aren't attached to anything.
Mars' skirt looks like it's starting to fray, and I am fairly certain her tiara is made of craft foam. Not even painted. Just yellow craft foam stuck to her forehead.
I feel so bad for that Venus, being stuck with this group.
>>8911507
>Implying fat people have the energy to make good costumes
>>8916711
It looks like she has eczema...
>>8915304
madam orange
>>8915306
nigga look like sonic the hedgehog lmao
>>8916567
WATCH OUT
HE'S ARMED
>>8912313
>favorite character is a very non-human alien with a generically pretty humanoid representation
>every single decent cosplay of her is the pretty humanoid version
>tags are flooded with shitty closet cosplays for the pretty humanoid version
Never love a non-human character who doesn't just look like a human with weird colored skin or you'll be fucked forever is the lesson here.
>>8916038
Jupiter and Venus look great. No idea why you're bashing Jupiter's face, she's adorable. Mercury and Mars needed to work on their wigs, Moon's costume is disheveled, and they all needed non-satin skirts. Moon is also pretty adorable though.
Good grief, have fun with this at shutocon
>>8917457
Keeeeeek kek kek kek kek
:<
>>8917535
Why is this less than decent?
>>8917568
At a glance it looks okay... but then you notice that the gold on the armour was painted on, the fabric in front of her legs is a bright purple instead of a semi-transparent dull shade, and that she used the same thing for her gloves.
>>8916038
i want to fight mars this is so awful why would you do this
>>8917535
those jagged unfinished hems... what a wreck
+10 points if you can figure out what this even is. *hint* it's something that should never be "sexyfied"
>>8915486
That's fine, just know you have shit taste.
>>8917695
¿Tarta de fresa?
Idk how is called in english...
>>8917695
I want to guess strawberry shortcake?
Please tell me I'm wrong.
>>8917695
Green striped socks gave it away. This doesn't need to exist.
>>8917708
This is one of those things were she really needs to be fat (and have any sort of costuming skill) in order for people to even get what she's cosplaying.
>>8917876
I normally hate slutifying genderbends, but this is pretty in character for Spider. Don't really see anything wrong here.
>>8917883
I think its the fact she's chubby and doesn't look well in a bikini.
>>8917906
Person who posted the pic here and that's pretty much it. Also she was the same chick wearing the ' blow up doll rainbow dash' outfit.
black unicorn cosplay is a goldmine for cringe
>>8918197
Shitty costume aside, holy fuck does she need to clean her room. At the very least, shove shit off to the side before taking a pic.
>>8914794
I swear yesterday I had a nightmare with this pic.
I'm glad I'm not into undertale
>>8915290
UHHHHHHH THICKERRRR
>>8918213
Those are terrifying.
>>8917876
Holy fucking porridge sacks I feel so much better about my saggy tits right now. Why would you flaunt such melting mammaries??
I have such an issue with her eye makeup and the way she smiles. I know braces make it a little harder but she looks like she wants to bite my dick off D:
>>8918313
oh shit homegurl from my state, always has the same crazy smile even when her cosplay is on the ok side
>>8918313
Do you think about putting your dick in everyone's mouth, anon?
>>8918328
always, if you're going to show me some titties like that my dick will come along for the ride
>>8912881
Celeste's hair is just a style that doesn't transition well into reality. For that style I think something like this Nui would work, especially since Celeste is dressed in Gothic Lolita. (I can't actually find the cosplay I'm thinking of but this is similar. The one I'm thinking of has lighter blond wig and is Asian.)
>>8918372
>Celeste
>Gothic Lolita
Funniest comment I've seen all day, anon.
>>8918389
"Celeste wears aGothic Lolita-style outfit, consisting of a white blouse with a Peter-Pan collar, a black jacket that includes white ribbon lacing down the sleeves, fastened by a simple ribbon across her chest to show her red tie with a butterfly pattern on it and the waist of her skirt, which is many-tiered and features white lace."
Straight from the wiki my friend.
>>8918400
She's ita as fuck though
>>8918404
shes a fictional character.
>>8918404
Ita is still lolita.
>>8917914
this is lady ikari Cosplay right? She's a goldmine for this thread
>>8917568
The only that's decent is her arm armor and even then, the paint job is bad. The gold parts are all uneven.
bad photoshop. cheap kimono; something you'd find off ebay for 2$
kimono rory? what the????????? & she's wearing pants underneath? if you're going to wear a kimono, at least do it properly.
>>8918325
She has the ugliest smile I've ever seen wow
>>8918847
I cannot unsee this damn smile like holy distracting as fuck.
>>8918197
this makes me feel like i need a shower
>>8918197
Pretty sure its supposed to be pic related
>>8915295
10/10 Mr.Yan cosplay
>>8918847
Fact she has braces and tries to hide them with such a scary looking smile.
Urgh
>>8919139
It's so sad that some people are that insecure about their braces. I think they look super cute, honestly. Back on topic, I wonder why she didn't just do a closed mouth smile?
Publicly posted WIP, the axe is apparently plywood on a metal pipe. I have no idea how any of his props get certified as consafe (and yet they do - I've seen him hanging around at several crowded events with his wooden monstrosities). I get that they look visually okay and all but I'm terrified of being near him because of his giant goddamn assault weapons
Nightmare material in here
>>8919167
Oh man, I just noticed, in the comments he also says the pauldrons are 'made from an old washing machine', so more metal? I don't want to be anywhere near those spikes.
>>8919169
oh
oh no
if your fat, ugly, a nigger or poor then just don't try. End of.
>>8915357
>Narutards everywhere
>>8917799
Oh yah i know, i meant I would want it because it is so bad/tacky
>>8919167
ahaahaha im gona keepthat in mind
>>8919018
autists love each other
>>8919273
Oh my god literally fuck off you're providing more material for this thread all by yourself Jesus. Ashamed to be from the UK comm
>>8919274
well as a scot i dont realize consider myself part of the uk
and how dense are you, stating the ovbious
>>8919280
I'd say you're embarrassing Scotland, but considering Scotland has about three good cosplayers to its name, I'm not sure if that has any impact.
>>8909293
If you're unhealthy and overweight you should use your time and money getting healthy and becoming human again, not a vain attempt to dress up a turd. Fat people destroy fashion as well as just about everything else. For a boars that glorifies Japanese culture and fashion, why is this concept so hard for you to understand? Japanese people would laugh at you for ruining their fashion with your fatass.
>>8909451
Being ugly and being fat are the same in that being fat is ugly, but different because you can fix fat, but you can't fix ugly. Being fat is not acceptable/ disgusting and a sign you're lazy, being legit ugly is something you can't help and not something that should be critiqued. Being legit ugly doesn't usually Garner negative critiques, but being fat is a different story.
>>8919273
i dont even know you and you come off as 10000% annoying
>>8910622
They lack the self awareness to look in the mirrior and just say no. Lack of self awareness is also probably why they need to "dress for their bodytype" in the first place. This is what happens when people are trying too hard to be "politically correct" and not straight up tell her she's fat and should not rape my eyeballs. They never get the hint because no one says it to their faces now a days.
>>8911507
Considering today's obesity levels, every thread and every day of your life should be a fat shaming thread. Do as the Japanese do and stop sugar coating it, fatty
>>8919273
>jealous
>of this
>>8917052
You can only see her face because she doesn't want you to see her below the neck.
>>8919169
why do they look 11
