![[FFF] Hibike! Euphonium - 05v2 [A9467CF3].mkv_snapshot_12.02_[2016.07.11_22.57.59].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/SdbyasK.jpg "[FFF] Hibike! Euphonium - 05v2 [A9467CF3].mkv_snapshot_12.02_[2016.07.11_22.57.59].jpg")
You lied to me /a/
You told me Hibike was good.
What I watched was an overdirected, melodramatic mess of a series that was as shallow as a kiddie pool.
Why is this so praised? Because of yurifags?
>>144107831
Your own fault. When was the last time KyoAnus did anything worth watching?
What the hell does "overdirected" mean?
I liked the animation and OST.
>overdirected
hibi kek
>>144107930
It doesn't feel natural. Actions, sets and everything feel like a film.
>>144108002
That's just you.
>>144107930
>>144107914
>2 characters having any conversation at all in the series
>cut to the back of Kumiko's head
>cut to outside shot of the school
>cut to the floor where only feet are visible
>cut to the instruments
>cut to eyes
>finally get a shot of the characters' faces
>shaky cam for the entirety of the scene
>conversation ends
>>144108039
Ignoring your heavy overexaggeration, would you like it better if every talking scene was framed completely flat?
>>144108039
>this is somehow a bad thing
>>144108039
Oh, so you're not used to good looking anime with actual cinematic direction?
>>144108084
>>144108097
>>144108135
Its exhausting when it happens EVERY SINGLE CONVERSATION
Hence overdirected
>>144108097
It is. It's showing off.
>>144108157
Watching so much shit anime with lazy animation and camera work has ruined your little brain.
What was her fucking problem? Anytime she was on screen I was annoyed.
That's because most anime aren't even trying to be good. At least Hibike tries. It's just a shitty medium.
>>144108212
She loved her senpai.
>>144108039
>Anime looks smart and that makes me feel unconfortable
>>144108212
I loved this show, but fuck that cunt.
>>144108172
>Being good at something is now showing off
Yeah, really we should be mad at all artists. Fucking show-offs, rubbing how good they are at making stuff.
>>144107831
>>144107831
Go back to /v/ and watch dragon ball and attack on titan faggot
>>144107914
I'm pretty sure it's the exact same complaint KyoAnifags regularly make about Shaft, he just phrased it dumber.
>>144108135
instagram filters and lens flare do not look good.
>>144108084
It's not over exaggeration. Literally go to any conversation in the series and you'll see it happen.
>>144107831
Your first mistake was listening to /a/.
not even actual yuri, just fucking bait
>>144108290
I have a feeling I know what you're talking about, but what Shaft does and and what KyoAni (particularly Yamada) does are really two different things.
Out of everything KyoAni has done that I've seen, this is the first time I felt like they did good. The show feels original and refreshing. The artistic value has a lasting impression and helps to seperate it from other "similar" anime. The characters (MC) in particular feel a lot more realistic. At first glance they seem like one-dimensional stereotypes but they aren't (for the most part). The soundtrack is great, the animation is great, and the characters can be original and relatable. Way better than Haruhi, K-ON!, and Clannad combined.
as simple as it is... expect nothing from no one. specially from the trashcan of the internet that is 4chan.
>directed by Ishihara and Yamada
>both of whom have worked in film previously (Disappearance of Haruhi, and Tamako Love Story)
>they wanted to take their experience of film to the small screen to push the medium of TV anime
>this is a bad thing
OP pls.
>>144107831
It's praised because it IS a good show.
Why is it a good show?
-Good Music:
One thing this show did that I personally praisse it for more than I can for almost every other show of it's like i''ve seen is that it just fucking let the music play during its finale, and the characters didn't explain how the music was supposed to make you feel during crucial moments. I'm looking at you Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso.
-Good directing:
Shot composition, animation, character designs, voice acting, musical production quality, writing(mostly), were all well above KyoAni's usual standard.
-Characters:
It was nice to see people actually competent at their craft, and to watch other characters get better at their craft, and struggle with competitive pressure, as well as drama to overcome their insecurities.
My favorite part of this show was how every character managed to grow in some way, especially Kumiko, and it showed through her performance and her will to actually try, and how it was all because she befriended this amazing person who inspired her, and that's a feeling I can relate to like fuck.
And well, that's my two cents. the details are neither here nor there, but I feel like the show managed to convey it's themes and character well enough for me to walk away from it feeling happy to see the characters succeed through their hardships.
And on top of that, there's more to come and im excited.
>>144108299
you're retarded.
You don't know what the fuck a lens flare is.
>>144108135
Not related to Hibike specifically, but the more cinegrids I see, the more I hate them as a concept. Contextless shots are almost never that impressive, and whether they are impressive out of context or not doesn't reflect with any real weight on the directing of the show.
>>144108304
There aren't six different shots before the speaking starts. In a reasonably long conversation there will be 2 or 3 while speaking occurs, though there are more in higher impact scenes.
>decide to try the first episode
>hdr, depth of field, and shaky cam abuse like it's an AAA video game
but I still want to rub Kumiko's chest
>>144108871
I still have no idea why some of you people think any of those techniques are bad. They all have its purpose.
>>144108971
The problem is when they get cranked all the way up to 10 instead of something more subtle. Vaseline covered windows are not appealing.
>>144109175
Why are they no appealing? What difference would it make if the background was crisp in that image?
perfection
Im still rooting for Reina to fuck sensei
>>144108039
Given a choice between this and two static talking heads with two frames of animation for the mouth movements, I'll take this.
>>144107831
>overdirected
You absolute invalid.
You meant to say "poorly directed," and everyone that watched the show agrees with you that it wasn't one of its strong points, and only morons say otherwise.
>>144109560
The direction was pretty good though
The former half has almost nothing that could be considered as good cinematic directing or cinematography.
A1, A3, C3, D2, and D3 are particularly awful shots.
>>144109560
>You meant to say "poorly directed," and everyone that watched the show agrees with you that it wasn't one of its strong points
Pretty sure it's the opposite.
>>144109609
No it fucking wasn't, especially on the second to last episode.
>>144109175
Blurring the outside of a train window isn't the same as bokeh. I'm not even sure what some of you people are complaining about.
>>144109738
But it was.
>>144107831
Euphonium was another brilliant kino delivered by none other than the gods of the industry. You need to show some fucking respect you bottom feeding shitter.
>>144109716
They're referring to the sound direction.
>>144109560
No, you're the moron here. The series was pretty well directed. Not perfect, sure, but there are no significant problems with the direction. Anyone complaining about it, it just didn't suit their tastes and they're unable to make the distinction between not suiting their tastes and actually bad.
What exactly is wrong with these scenes?
https://u.pomf.is/pxwzfz.webm
https://u.pomf.is/drevet.webm
>>144109758
Stop shitposting and misuing kino. Saying that Hibike has good direction is an insult to masters of cinematic timing and nuance like Resnais, Fellini or Wajda. I'd appreciate it if you stopped saying that. It only has relatively good direction compared to anything else from that season.
Now I have to deal with the same undeserved praise with Re:Zero and its insufferable fanbase worshipping amateur shots and pans and a godawful credits sequence. Why can't you guys just open a book, for once?
I've read every post in this thread and I still have no fucking idea what "overdirected" means.
>>144108172
>>144108157
>>144107831
>possibly the best directed seasonal series in a decade, not just in terms of composition but also in nuanced visual storytelling
>overdirected
Welcome to neo-/a/.
>>144110076
It means there was too much forced animation.
>>144110058
Smells like reddit in this post.
>>144110058
They're /tv/ crossposters
Explains literally everything about their taste
>>144110058
>Now I have to deal with the same undeserved praise with Re:Zero and its insufferable fanbase worshipping amateur shots and pans and a godawful credits sequence.
How about you leave your autism aside and just relax, you arrogant self-centered pretentious faggot? Throwing a few names you've searched on Google doesn't give you a point.
>>144108290
Bad direction?
>>144109891
>https://u.pomf.is/drevet.webm
Nothing but the voice acting in the second one was shit.
>>144110089
If there's one thing that Hibike doesn't have, its subtlety, especially visually. It's not exactly tasteful with its characters' mannerisms and facial expressions, particularly during dialogue. It's just rather cookiecutter stuff.
>>144110095
That's called having a trademark, you fucking buzzword-spouting idiot.
>>144109175
It's just steamy in there senpai
>>144109693
>implying cinematography is even the most important component of direction
>>144110153
Don't get angry simply because someone has higher standards for ""good direction.""
>>144107831
I want to be a cute girl blowing cute horns.
>>144110221
It isn't
>>144110197
>nuance
>subtlety
>same thing
>>144110099
>forced animation
Another entirely meaningless term.
I like yuri. All haters should be gassed.
>>144110235
>anime
>high standards
I bet you're gonna tell me that Akira was well-directed next.
>>144110213
Their trademark is a bunch of pointless cuts?
>>144110235
>Projecting this hard
Yet another anti-KinoAni licker bites the dust and leaves the thread with its tail between its legs
>>144110271
>can't into reading comprehension
>KyoAnus autists
Is there any way to reason with them?
>>144110197
>It's not exactly tasteful with its characters' mannerisms and facial expressions, particularly during dialogue
I honestly can't follow you with this. Give me one conversation from the show where this was the case for you.
>>144110313
>Reasoning with the truth.
>>144110124
>a board not dedicated to anime has better taste than one that is
You're damn right it explains everything.
>>144110313
I actually agree with what he says in the second paragraph (although I'm not a huge fan of that approach, honestly), but then he fucked it up.
>>144110285
>pointless cuts
I think I'm starting to understand your problem. Please, go back to whatever show you watched before Hibike. It would be to the benefit of all of us.
>>144107831
Liking Hibike is just a meme. How come you fall from it?
>>144110300
Says the brainlet that misconstrued my original post and thinks I implied anything.
>>144110285
Your main argument lies with the repetition of said cuts as you've said here >>144108157
Most shots are here to create an atmosphere and emphasize the characters' dialogues when they talk about the club and practice by showing instruments, the club room and other stuff. If you want the camera focused on the characters only, SHAFT is more up your alley.
>>144110213
I hope you're thinking of something more specific than "showing shots of different things during a discussion," because that's not exactly unique.
>>144110423
>>144110058
How can you misuse "kino"? It's like misusing baneposting, it's just a shitty, nonsense meme.
>>144109891
Was the lightsaber censor really necessary on the sheet music? Is it really that lewd?
And why is the camera shaking when they're not on a boat?
>>144110385
Feel free to tell me what the point is of all the cuts to motionless feet and eyes other than trying to look cool
>>144107831
>Why is this so praised? Because of yurifags?
Yeah that and the pic related is top tier waifu. KyoAni knows how to draw and animate them waifus.
>>144110475
What's the point of images? Just rip the audio from the video all together.
>>144110475
Don't even bother. He's going to say something vacuous like "establishing atmosphere" or something about accentuating a critical moment in character interactions. It's quite sad.
>>144108039
>faggots who know nothing about direction arguing hibike's was bad
>>144110213
>faggots who know nothing about direction arguing hibike's was good
This thread is a shit show.
>>144110546
>It's quite sad.
And somehow this guy still manages to come out on top as the biggest faggot with this cringey dig.
>>144107831
The overanimation while being melodramtic got me. Like that scene you posted there. Also, over filler word meme.
Come on anon, it is 2016.
>>144110546
By all means, tell us what "actually good direction" does, we're all ears.
>>144110475
Let me tell you something that I learned long ago. I don't recall when, but it was probably in a place called a school. There are parts of the body that are more expressive than others Feet and hands are one of them. Your saying that the cuts were to "motionless" feet is almost certainly untrue, as Yamada has for years been a fan of having her characters talk with them.
But feet and hands are nothing compared to a person's eyes. If you've ever studied film, or art, or even enjoyed the consumption of either of those things, you'd have realized the amount of attention paid to a person's or character's eyes.
These "meaningless cuts" are things that help tell the story. They're things that let you understand the characters better, even without them saying anything.
And to you, it's over direction.
>>144110691
looks like you can't read
>motionless feet
>>144110635
>unironically using the word cringey
>>144110635
>Trademark doesn't exist in direction
Fuck off. Most people do things their own way, that's what trademark is. It exists everywhere in crafts and even in your speech. Everybody uses patterns.
>>144110691
Go ahead and tell me what those legs are trying to represent
>>144110691
That webm just gave me eye cancer.
>>144110691
Not him, but please provide context, because I haven't seen this since it aired and I cannot tell a fucking thing about what those legs are supposed to be saying just from watching that.
>>144110709
What's wrong with the word "cringe"?
>>144110691
>others Feet and
>Your
>the rest of that train-wreck of a post
Your ESL teacher would be disappointed.
>>144110475
Anime is a visual medium, what exactly is wrong with doing things with it to make it look interesting? Besides, you can "say" a fair bit about what's going on, what's on characters' minds, their moods, etc with cuts like that.
>>144110691
>Hibikefags actually think that's a good webm
I feel ashamed to call myself a Kyoani fan
You want a good lower body shot that speaks volumes in half the time? Go watch Children of Men.
>>144110737
>>144110815
It's not about 'representing' anything. It's about setting the mood. Even without sound you can see the girl in the front is the one driving the conversation, meaning she's probably the most outgoing. With sound, that shot just serves to strengthen the point.
>>144110835
>>Your
This is correct, tho.
>>144107831
>You told me Hibike was good.
not really, no yuri, ecchi, comedy.
i dunno what the fuck is this show is about.
in my opinion this show sucks balls, worst kyoani show.
>>144110851
Doing things because they look cool is amateurish from a directorial standpoint and childish from a social one
>>144110866
No, why don't you post a scene and explain why and how that movie's lower body shots speak "volumes"
>>144110904
He said interesting, not cool.
>>144110835
>others Feet and
I'll admit, I missed a period, but
>Your
Looks like >>144110881 beat me to it, but yeah. If you're looking for a "You're" there, you've got some nerve calling other people ESL.
>>144110893
Are you serious this show is so simple it's about getting good and making the nationals
>>144110872
>DUDE YOU CAN TELL A LOT OF THINGS FROM PEOPLE'S FEET! IT'S A METAPHOR AND SHIT!
>OK WELL THIS ONE ISN'T REPRESENTING ANYTHING BUT THERE ARE OTHERS REALLY
>>144110893
>ESL
I guess some mysteries solve themselves.
>>144110866
I wasn't using that as an example as something good, actually. I honestly thought that was a bit much from Yamada.
However, I included it to show that it's a staple of her style.
>>144110935
but the post he replied to >>144110475 said cool.
the hibike fanbase is almost as delusional as Re:Zero's
Literally everyone agreed that it was above average at best, and that it was one of Kyoani's worst shows. KnK and Hyouka were much better directed.
hibikek is hot garbage
>>144110966
>METAPHOR
No. You are dumb.
>>144111003
So?
>>144110966
Nobody was talking about metaphors.
>>144110966
>Being this asshurt.
>>144110872
This.
If you're familiar with K-ON, you'd instantly be able to tell which character is which from that webm. So much of their character is shown through how their legs are animated in that scene.
>>144111011
>Literally everyone agreed that it was ... one of Kyoani's worst shows
Not even close, friend.
it was okthe umaku naritai scene is one of my favorite anime scenes of all time
>>144110737
>>144110815
Not him and I don't exactly know what shot this is from but
Right girl is always walking backwards while facing the others that walk in this direction. That means she enjoys being the center of attention, standing out from the others and looking at people directly.
Second to right has a rather casual walking style that gets even more casual as the webm goes on until the end where she's jumping around. She's quite the mood shifter and got relaxed through the conversation.
Left behind 's walking style is rather straight and doesn't change. She's most likely the serious and hardworking type. She also probably doesn't show much emotion.
Second to left is skipping around quite a bit. She's rather relaxed but seems a bit concerned about showing it.
>>144111128
Nice revisionism, faggot.
>>144111128
>deliberately misquoting him
jesus christ you're a faggot
>>144111011
>Literally everyone agreed that it was above average at best,
You say this like it's a bad thing.
>>144111145
>>144111171
>>144111011
>LITERALLY EVERYONE agreed that it was above average at best, AND that it was one of Kyoani's worst shows
I changed nothing.
>>144111108
> you'd instantly be able to tell which character is which from that webm
Anon, you could tell that from a fucking screencap, because they have different designs.
>>144111171
Not him, but I don't think you know what misquoting is.
>>144111216
Anon are you a professional fencer? Because you're very good at missing the point.
>>144107831
>Why is this so praised
I don't know. There were people who really liked it when it aired but recently I've been seeing such effusive praise for it. There's been a lot of "Hibike is 2015 AOTY" posts and I don't know where it's coming from.
>>144111130
You also missed the obvious metaphor with the pole with how they shift back into normal walking stances, but otherwise, good job.
>>144111035
>>144111059
You are just as retarded as him.
>>144111274
I don't know about AOTY, but Hibike was definitely a Top 5 in 2015.
>>144111289
Hey! I see you!
>>144111252
I'm just saying that you're talking as though they aren't identifiable through normal means, when they are - you wouldn't have made that point if it had been a full-body shot, because it would have been obvious who was who, and due to the differences in clothing/skin color, it was still obvious who was who.
>>144111323
yeah, it's summer, alright
>>144111315
>>144111274
It was a top contender for AOTY in 2015, it's coming from all the /a/nons who watched it and in large numbers actually voted for it to be AOTY in 2015.
I don't know which bait should I go for
>>144111385
There's only one correct answer.
Why are people so obsessed and jealous of Kyoani? Is it because they have the best animation and every other studio wants to be like them?
I have to agree. This tries way too hard to the point of distraction.
I adore great editing, unexpected cuts and scene changes. This is like a freshman liberal arts student just discovering cinematography was a thing, and overextending it.
Nothing will come close to Nodame imo, as far as music anime. If it had more budget to cut back on the audience pans it would have been one of the best.
>>144111470
KyoAni mastered the arts of eyecandy and wasting money.
Is that the point of the webm?
>>144111471
>actual, valid criticism in this thread
>JEALOUS :^)
Fucking hell, this is literally the Re:zero fanbase, at this point.
>>144111515
https://twitter.com/erkin_kawabata/status/589384655796731904
>KyoAni budgets are below average
>>144111477
The thing that separates Hibike and Nodame for me, is that Hibike just plays the music and makes it obvious who is playing better through the sound alone. Other shows like Nodame always feels the need to include voiceovers to explain when someone is playing well. It shows a lack of confidence and respect for the audience
>>144111547
>valid criticism
Where?
>>144111525
Not him, but what's good about them?
>>144111547
>implying
KyoAni has had a more rabid defense force than Re:Zero does right now since long before anyone new what Re:Zero was. Their only competition are the HxHfags and the /m/ crossboarders' devotion to G-Reco.
>>144111555
>>KyoAni budgets are below average
So? It is still a waste of money, since Phantom World's scripts are worth less than 2 pennies.
>>144111431
I'm waiting to observe those sick 5's on /g/
>>144111587
Classic Re:Zero retort.
the girls aren't even cute.
>>144111590
Not him, but the thread is dedicated to shitting on Hibike for having "overcinematography", burden of proof lies on you, retards. Go ahead and rip them appart, but provide sources, citations and if you can mathematical hypothesis on why their cinematography is bad.
>>144111315
>Top 5 in 2015.
barely
>haikyuu!! s2
>owari
>OPM
>death parade
all better
>>144108212
>>144108242
Just so you know you will be seeing alot more of her in s2. You might as well get used to the best girl.
>>144110966
>EVERYTHING IS METAPHORS
your intelligence is a metaphor :^)))))))
>>144111661
>if you can mathematical hypothesis
what did he mean by this?
>>144110999
So her style is doing things that aren't good?
>>144111695
Nice bait. Euphonium was easily better than all of those. Kyoani haters really are getting desperate.
>>144111749
>Euphonium was easily better than all of those
not really though
>>144111695
Haikyuu, OPM, and Death Parade maybe. But Owari no Seraph went downhill after episode 8 or 9. Still, top 5 in a year with over 250 shows is not bad at all, yet /a/ shits on Hibike or any other KyoAni shows like they're sub par in every regard.
>>144111735
you're retarded if you think there's no metaphorical elements in that webm
you're like a freshman that has renounced metaphors upon entering English 2 in college.
>overdirected
You mean forced direction right? You can add it to all the stale memes like forced drama and animation.
>>144111661
No one said "overcinematography" you dumb cunt, we said overdirection
>>144111749
Except it wasn't.
>>144111815
Buzzwords are buzzwords.
>>144111783
I think he meant Owarimonogatari
>>144111834
Direction and cinematography are two different things but I can see how plebeian KyoAnus lickers could use the two terms interchangeably
>>144111841
Even worse, Monogatari stopped being good a while ago.
>>144111695
>one joke man
>better than hibikek
>>144111584
Not that anon, but I think Nodame and Hibike are separated by a lot more than that. Kasai and Yamada are not similar directors.
>>144111695
OPM is worthless aside from the action animation.
>>144111841
both seraph and monogatari were better so it doesn't matter
>>144111695
>Huehuehue he kills enemies in one shot so frustrating so fun
>Good
Pick one and only one.
>>144111882
niceme.me
>>144111880
And the better direction.
>>144107914
>forced animation
>forced sound design
>forced direction
>forced drama
>forced this, forced that, FORCED FORCED FORCED
I know is hard to come up with good thread discutions when we're still waiting S2 to air, but holy shit, put some effort and stop shitposting
>>144111880
which happens to be all it needs to be better, along with better writing and sound direction
Konosuba is better than Hibike.
>>144111849
Yeah, the same way you use "forced animation" to shitpost.
>>144112029
No one other than KyoAnus lickers have mentioned "forced animation" in this thread
>>144112113
You just did in this forced post of yours.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C-AbLcsFyFY
Discuss
>>144107831
>as shallow as a kiddie pool
What's the meaning of this?
>>144112218
Lacking in depth.
>>144112345
>Lacking in depth
What did he mean by this?
>>144112345
But Eupho was loaded with depthof field.
>>144107831
This anime was great commentary on how slackers are subhuman and drag everyone around them down into mediocrity.
>>144107831
>overdirected
don't you mean forced directing?
![[Kantai] Hibike Euphonium - 11 (BD 1920x1080 FLAC) [6F9ED27C].mkv_snapshot_13.24_[2016.07.12_21.26.34].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/SXXZ7pZ.jpg "[Kantai] Hibike Euphonium - 11 (BD 1920x1080 FLAC) [6F9ED27C].mkv_snapshot_13.24_[2016.07.12_21.26.34].jpg")
>>144112614
How? The only slacker in the series that got fucked over was Natsuki and she didn't make it to the main team anyway.
>>144112664
Wheat from the chaff, Sensei knew this
>>144110313
The buy isn't even wrong. He just quoted what Ishihara himself said.
>>144107831
>overdirected
If there's a joke to be had, I must've missed it
>>144112345
And how does that translate to "as shallow as a kiddie pool"
>>144113043
>KinoAni
kill yourself
>>144113066
What's your problem? It's the perfect name for a studio as illustrious as they are.
![[Coalgirls]_Hyouka_19_(1280x720_Blu-Ray_FLAC)_[3CB7FBF7].mkv_snapshot_19.35_[2016.05.31_21.12.54].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/46VnEWw.jpg "[Coalgirls]_Hyouka_19_(1280x720_Blu-Ray_FLAC)_[3CB7FBF7].mkv_snapshot_19.35_[2016.05.31_21.12.54].jpg")
>>144113066
Maybe you don't understand, KyoAni shows are top tier as far as kinography goes, hence why I call them KinoAni
>>144111470
To be truly objective, Kyoani generally offers a good level of detail and smooth animation.
Their Anime are super saturated, but for me this is not a bad thing. Then, their stories may be good or not, and no doubt they have always a moe element quite intrusive, but aesthetically, at last, I appreciate a lot their effort.
>>144113155
>>144113111
autism
>>144113066
I thought it was clever
>>144113043
I find petite girls to be highly sexual.
>>144111730
I'm legitimately at a loss. How can anybody unironically like ribbon? She may redeem herself in the S2 but after watching S1 she literally has no redeeming values.
>>144113381
She's the villain that Kitauji deserved.
>>144107831
you know yurifag..they mad when their shipfag arent real so they want to make themselves feel better
>>144113381
She was loyal and protective of her senpai. She was wrong, but for the right reasons
>>144107831
Because of yurifags.
>>144113043
KinoAni has that magic touch, they just find a way
Do people really need to bring a Kyoanus war even when there's nothing airing being made from them? Are you guys that bored?
>>144113519
But Future is a sexual being
>>144113614
KyoAni is the most popular and divisive studio on /a/ after all.
>>144113714
They ain't that popular. Bones, Madhouse ad Trigger is way more popular.
>>144113753
None of those have as many haters and fans, at least not on /a/.
Is Hibike the litmus test for whether an anon has taste?
>>144113999
>It's just newfags regurgitating stale memes.
says the /tv/ crossposter using the word "kino" unironically
>>144114056
If you didn't think it was great, you have shit taste and you lose all credibility. It's as simple as that.
>>144114159
I agree with you.
I love it when shitposters spout nonsense and baseless opinions and then proceed to ask like they just typed the most insightful and objective criticism in the world, and then get offended when nobody replies seriously to their bullshit.
Fuck you.
>>144114513
That you replied like this means they've already won
>>144114557
It doesn't.
>>144107831
End your pathetic life. For real.
>>144107831
>You lied to me /a/
>You told me Hibike was good.
/a/ is not one faggot
>Good
lol
>If people enjoyed it, It was because of the stupid yuri bait between Kumiko and Reina.
Stop.
>>144115531
Literally the best KyoAni love story.
>>144107831
The sole reason why I like this show is because of yuri.
>>144107831
>Why is this so praised?
KyoAnifags gonna fag. You've now learned an important lesson.
I watched like two episodes of this show. It was boring. It takes everybody 5 minutes to say anything, even when they wind up saying nothing. They didn't even play the euphonium.
KyoAni has mastered two things. Overuse of eye highlighting and selling it to faggots with no taste beyond eye highlighting.
>>144108212
I really hated her at first but I really warmed up to her once she started realizing what she was doing and why it was wrong.
Ribbons a cute.
>ITT: Shitting on an anime for being pretty
>>144116635
>ITT: Shitting on an anime for being nothing but pretty
ftfy
>>144107831
KyuAnusfags and yurifags that think two girls being intimate means that there's yuri.
But yurifags don't even like this, I'm a yurifag who can see the piece of shit studio Kyoani is and I won't ever watch their shit anime for free ever again, I fucking hate getting baited
>>144117312
Same. I wished people would stop praising this for having "the best yuri relationship" but then again KyoAnusfags are quite autistic.
My only problems with Hibiki are yuribait and extremely poorly handled Shoe (if he was done better I would be fine with it; I like romance)
sadly these are enormous detriments for me, tho
As a "band" story, it's okay.
>>144111315
I think you mean Hibike is definitely #1.
I liked it but for some reason I really, really fucking hated Reina.
Ready for their next 3 masterpieces?
>>144118665
My heart is ready for all three!
>>144118626
Success breeds jealousy
Hibike is the unassailable masterpiece of KinoAni. People trying to criticize it just come across as desperate to be honest
>>144119090
More like I can see my autism in her, yet she doesn't give a fuck about getting along with other people, unlike me.
>>144108135
Kyoani have god tier shot composition and visual direction
I'm not even a kyoanifag and I can acknowledge this
>>144108212
Inside your heart, there's no heart
You fell for the Kyoani meme, they're as bad as entry level shonenshit
>>144119664
You wot m8
>>144108212
Yuuko did nothing wrong!
