Manga > anime
No exceptions
Not really fair when Vagabond has some of the best art in all of manga period.
>>142539653Usagi Drop
>>142539653
Most manga/comics in general look better than animation.
Just compare Dragon Ball's manga and anime and you will see what I mean
Manga is shit, you never know wtf is going on.
>manga without spectacular art
>random lines everywhere and huge black boxes
>can't even tell what color a characters clothes/hair are
this is never a problem in anime
>>142539853
Underage and illiterate detected.
>>142539907
>>142539853
Samefagging
Anime takes 22-24 minutes to tell the same story as a 2-3 minute read of 2 chapters.
Who the fuck watches anime anymore?
ITT: what is HxH
The source material for that was awfull m8
![[SMC] Sailor Moon SuperS - 161 (R2 DVD 480p H264 AC3)[6CAF2BDF].mkv_snapshot_07.45_[2016.03.01_00.37.16].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/VdPjzqy.jpg "[SMC] Sailor Moon SuperS - 161 (R2 DVD 480p H264 AC3)[6CAF2BDF].mkv_snapshot_07.45_[2016.03.01_00.37.16].jpg")
>no exceptions
suuure
>>142539997
>9 ips
kill yourself
I don't know man, I want my fighting scenes animated.
It's pretty obvious that the tradeoff for superior black and white art is animation, color, voice acting and music. Quality direction can also enhance the story by setting it at a very deliberate pace, while the pace of a written story is somewhat dependent on the reader.
There's no reason that anime cannot be (and sometimes is) superior to manga; it's a result of the structure of the industry and the inherent higher cost of producing animated works. But, stating that wouldn't let you start a shit-slinging war between our more gullible members.
I'm sure this will be a productive and high-quality thread. Keep up the good work, OP.
>>142539907
>this is never a problem in anime
>implying that is even a problem
manga leave more room for your imagination
hence much better experience
that why Blame!! anime never work
also art quality is much higher
>>142540087
the only reason i want some fight scene got animated is the soundseason two never
>>142540217
No like, take Bleach for instance, the art is so shit for the fighting scenes that I can't make out what's happening. I can imagine sound.
>>142540177
>>142540038best two anime of all time, not fair comparisons
>>142540217
>manga leave more room for your imagination
friendly reminder this excuse literally translates to the author was not talented enough or too lazy to convey his story properly.
>>142539653NGE
>>142540306
>Sailor Moon
>good
I guess, if you can get over Tuxedo Mask being unrecognizable without his mask on, and the fact that throwing a tiara at someone is an attack.
>>142540365
This has to be bait.
The same way characters aren't described 100% in books is the same reason characters aren't shown frame by frame actions in manga. Its not required and helps the reader by improving the flow of the work.
>>142540515
>reader has to do all the work
See >>142540365
>>142539653
>mfw baiken died and the little girl committed sudoku
>>142540259
never read bleach
never read any shounen with a never end story
>>142540365
>>142540611
it only enhance the experience
stop being a lazy tard and read something good
like pic related
>>142540416
NGE mango never have any budget problems
ep 25-26 and brain hack part in EOE never happen in the manga
every thing got better explanation
>>142540798
Bleach has already ended.
>>142539653
Source material > Later adaptations
>>142540611
Yeah, nah.
By leaving certain details out, stories can be heavily enhanced. If it's done to such a point that there can be no logical construction of the story or themes without severe speculation at every level, you're more or less correct.
If ambiguity, instead, works to enhance certain themes, characters, or story elements, it becomes less a case of making the reader do work, and more a case of involving the reader in an interactive manner; it becomes a fruitful labor that is superior to mere exposition and heavy detailing. This is especially salient in written work.
Imagine, for example, if Lain just came out and told you everything that was implied in the story, or if Gravity's Rainbow just told you all about the 00000 in completely literal terms, or if The Entertainment in Infinite Jest had a chapter of exposition dedicated to exactly what it was instead of letting you generate the idea of what the most addictive possible entertainment could be.
kaiji part 1
>>142540427
>suspension of disbelief
Why yes, I can.
>>142540217
>manga leave more room for your imagination
>the only reason i want some fight scene got animated is the sound
Imagine the sounds you fucking dipshit and stop contradicting yourself. Ultimately kill yourself.
>>142539653
This manga is flat out boring
>>142540611
Leaving some details up to the viewer's imagination improves a shitton, no matter what the medium is. Ex. Dwarf Fortress
>>142541076
>Imagine the sounds you fucking dipshit
i cann't read chinese
and most mango SFX are chinese
>>142539653
CORRECTION
Manga > Anime, very few exceptions.
>>142539653
>being this wrong
https://youtu.be/xge0HpnCGv8
>>142539653
What is gintama?
>>142541165
You're flat out retarded
>>142541376
Really though the only good thing about the anime is the music, everything else is literal shit. If anything we can be thankful that the anime exists so that people can read the manga with some sick eurobeat in the background.
>>142539653
Shoujo anime > Shoujo manga
>>142540925
>Lain
Not really the best example unless you want to invalidate your entire point or are a red herring. Can you not use pretentious shows like Lain as your only example.
>>142544000
>watching shoujo
>>142543905
No
the CG, faces, and eurobeat are what make it initial D. without those it is far less
>>142544929
>toari no kaibutsukun
>maid-sama
>akagami no shirayukihime
Your loss.
>>142545044
>not watching shows with obnoxious love triangles and male characters
I don't think i lose much here.
Maybe i'm just not girly.
>>142544968
they were both disturbing, so in a way they succeeded
Way to get flamed, but ok.
>>142539853
>wtf
>>142539653
Soul Eater.
>>142539853
Fuck off.
![[HorribleSubs] Wandering Son - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_04.40_[2011.02.19_14.00.09].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/4iOGNS1.jpg "[HorribleSubs] Wandering Son - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_04.40_[2011.02.19_14.00.09].jpg")
Manga and anime are equally good.
>>142541165
f a g g o t
This manga is fucking garbage.Totally ruined yoko
>>142549445
Whooooooooooops
>>142539851
o i'm laffin
>>142539791
Oh boy.
>>142540259
How much of that is the art itself and how much of that is the scans? Can you post an example?
A lot of the time scanlation groups use a variety of filters on the image to clean it up, but it inevitable ends up corroding or even outright omitting finer lines. Stuff like screentones are pretty heavily butchered. This probably has something to do with it.
>>142539653
Not always. For example, Aria's manga is good, but only the anime makes it into a masterpiece it is.
>>142539653
Never was a big fan of NHK, but the manga was deplorable. At least the show was bearable, and this is coming from someone who only reads manga too.
>>142550890
Original was the LN.
NHK's LN > NHK's anime >>>>>>>> NHK's manga
>>142550927
Actually good to know. is the ln a lot better. been out of things to read recently so I might give it a shot if it is
>>142550974
I think it is very good. Pretty short, too, and much more to the point.
>>142551029
Thanks anon, will give it a look
>>142540217
>Blame! anime will never work
And yet we're still getting one. As worried as I am, I can only hope at this point it'll turn out good, especially this scene. It was so fucking badass that you'd have to be a weapons-grade fuckup to ruin it.
>>142550927
It's a novel, not an LN.
>>142551273
Ah, yes. My bad.
I mostly agree. In recent years the only anime I can think of which was better than its manga adaptation was Ping Pong.
Name three manga adaptations that are better than the anime.
>>142551443
>manga adaptations
Are you talking about manga adaptations of the original anime or novel? For they are invariably trash.
>>142551443
Evangelion (arguably), Umineko and Overlord.
>>142539653
I'd say flcl is better in anime form, but that might just be because of nostalgia
Anime will never get gems like pic related
I can't agree or disagree but I do like manga more. Also, Ping Pong the Animation is godlike so nah.
haha
I agree.
>>142551466
>>142551488
Yes I meant when the anime is the original.
