[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
WSJD - Shokugeki no Souma
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 83
Thread images: 31
File: 65.jpg (263 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
65.jpg
263 KB, 784x1145
I think I don't like this manga anymore.

Boku no Hero Academia >>142195525
>>
File: 66.jpg (317 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
66.jpg
317 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 67.jpg (283 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
67.jpg
283 KB, 784x1145
>>
Last chapter ended with Erina coming to Souma's room right? I'm not paying that much attention anymore, let's see when I ultimately forget about it.
>>
File: 68.jpg (276 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
68.jpg
276 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 69.jpg (321 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
69.jpg
321 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 70.jpg (329 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
70.jpg
329 KB, 784x1145
>>
I watched a bit of the anime. It looks like SAO but with cooking. Does it get better?
>>
File: 71.jpg (323 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
71.jpg
323 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 72.jpg (292 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
72.jpg
292 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 73.jpg (262 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
73.jpg
262 KB, 784x1145
>>
>>142196336
they living together now?
>>
File: 74.jpg (327 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
74.jpg
327 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 75.jpg (306 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
75.jpg
306 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 76.jpg (300 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
76.jpg
300 KB, 784x1145
>>142196461
It's not like that at all, but whatever.

It is a good series, then it becomes a slog. The anime hasn't gotten to where it becomes a slog, and that drop off point is very sudden.
>>
File: 77.jpg (315 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
77.jpg
315 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 78.jpg (266 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
78.jpg
266 KB, 784x1145
>>
>>142196716
So Azami never once cooked for her or his cooking is shit? Believable.
>>
File: 79.jpg (297 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
79.jpg
297 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 80.jpg (342 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
80.jpg
342 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 81.jpg (267 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
81.jpg
267 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 82.jpg (277 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
82.jpg
277 KB, 784x1145
>>
File: 83.jpg (302 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
83.jpg
302 KB, 784x1145
WSJD Shokugeki no Souma 168 DDL: http://www32.zippyshare.com/v/5U6zcPDR/file.html

I've identified one big issue I have with Shokugeki no Souma that applies to the entire series: there's virtually no breathing room.

>arc ends
Cooking battle
>mini arc ends
Cooking battle
>ends
>Cooking with kids or something whatever

We don't get time to see characters relaxing very often, we don't see characters outside of PSD except for during cooking scenes and such, it's extremely difficult to get invested in the cast. I find it really, really hard to care about anything, Souma included and he's the character we see the most.

I know it's a cooking manga, so cooking, but it gets tiring and it feels like the characters aren't real because all they seem to care about is cooking. You can say ">complaining about realism in (this) manga" but suspension of disbelief can go a long way.

Whatever.
>>
>>142196213
>>142196940
World Trigger >>142196945
>>
>>142196940
shounen cooking
>>
I'll give it one more chapter. If he makes a trademark Yukihira horrible dish I'll continue reading.
>>
>>142196940
MEGUMIFAGS ON SUICIDE WATCH
>>
>>142196601
CUUTE
>>
>>142196213
>>142196940
NEW Takuan and Batsu's Daily Demon Diary >>142197931
>>
>>142196940
>We don't get time to see characters relaxing very often, we don't see characters outside of PSD except for during cooking scenes and such, it's extremely difficult to get invested in the cast. I find it really, really hard to care about anything, Souma included and he's the character we see the most.

you know where ALL OF THAT IS?

side material
>>
>>142198007
I am disgusted.
>>
>>142198154
buy it all goy!
>>
>>142196213
Has something happened recently in the manga?

I think it was probably around 5-6ish months ago I was still actively in the threads and everybody was excited for the new scans and the threads were huge. Haven't kept up with it for a long time, though. The art is too good for anything to have spoiled this in that time, right?
>>
Great chapter
>>
>>142198007
LN translations never again.
>>
just hang in there anon, it would get better.
>>
>>142198783
A big bad was introduced and he's fucking horrible. He made the manga overly serious and changed the entire vibe and format of the manga. It honestly fucking sucks right now, and there are a lot of problems with it.
>>
File: JUST.jpg (815 KB, 1020x1143) Image search: [Google]
JUST.jpg
815 KB, 1020x1143
>>142198978
Pic related.
>>
>>142196940
>I've identified one big issue I have with Shokugeki no Souma that applies to the entire series: there's virtually no breathing room.
Way the go slowpoke.
>>
>>142198978

That.
>>
>>142196213
>>142196940
Kimetsu no Yaiba >>142199172
>>
>>142198783
People hate based Azami.
>>
A big event is coming right, it's going to be daijobu. R-right?
>>
>>142196768
This was before Azami I think.
>>
>>142199389
That's precisely why it won't be alright.

Things will only be alright when things go back to normal.
>>
>>142196940
MEGLOOGUMMY FAGS ON DEATH ROW.
>>
>>142196899
>I came to your room before I knew what I was doing.
where's this doujin
>>
Azami is funny
>>
Megumi still best girl and will win Soumabowl
>>
File: 1419134855914.jpg (11 KB, 480x480) Image search: [Google]
1419134855914.jpg
11 KB, 480x480
>people think that Soumabowl is even winnable at this state

we got to get him out of cooking autism before he ever begins to notice girl's feelings
>>
>>142196638
So this is when they were arranging the marriage?
>>
>>142196585
She runaway from her mansion and started to live in polar star few months ago
>>
>>142196213
>>142196336
Mehgloomyfags on suicide watch
>>
>>142202628
>implying anyone but Erina ever had a chance
>>
>>142202628

They failed to protect her smile
>>
File: backstory bros.jpg (99 KB, 1054x224) Image search: [Google]
backstory bros.jpg
99 KB, 1054x224
Who's responsible for this poorly written fanfiction? Or is there actual side material that supports this?
>>
>>142198978
Shitty new editor
>>
>>142203053
that fucking pose
>>
>>142203286
Azami was introduced before the new editor
>>
>>142196940
I actually liked this chapter a lot. It feels like Erina is an actual character now, instead of a caricature. Having her admit she's lost is great. I'm ready for Souma's HEALING dishes.
>>
>>142196213
I stopped liking it the moment edge dad entered.
>>
>>142198978
Even as it was happening no one liked it. We hadn't even gotten to see the other Elite 10 in action before this blindsided us and the first thing we found out was that they were traitors.
The Azami administration jumped the shark hard. Even fucking Tsukasa is a letdown.
>>
>>142196940
>cooking manga
>tired of cooking

Suspension of disbelief is a meme directly related to the lack of SoL, I'd guess.
>>
>>142198783
Erina is melting and she is right now alone with Souma in his room.

And he's about to give her the famous Yukihira dish
>>
File: muhqueen.jpg (952 KB, 1280x1292) Image search: [Google]
muhqueen.jpg
952 KB, 1280x1292
>>142203053
>>142202694
>>142196336
>>142196585
>>142202539
I fucking go away from /a/ for a few months to focus on college and come back to Erina STILL btfoing mehgloomy and her fags

Have you fucking worshiped Erina-sama today?
>>
>>142204995
None of those posts are even mehgloomyfags aside from the one guy who posted her(probably) you dumb shipper.
The forced rivalry is just annoying at this point. The threads aren't that active anymore to facilitate shitposting.
>>
File: 1436537583941.jpg (145 KB, 631x613) Image search: [Google]
1436537583941.jpg
145 KB, 631x613
>>142205110

t.mehgloomyfag
>>
>>142205177
>t.
Fuck off shitposter.
>>
>Hype up the ELITE 10's to be much greater than Souma
>10 chapters later Souma BTFO out of one
>It was so garbage the author had to use the NO 1 to set things right again
>>
File: 1463073626353.jpg (170 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
1463073626353.jpg
170 KB, 1920x1080
>>142205177
Why did I even expect you to read.
>>
File: 1436537275407.png (89 KB, 424x424) Image search: [Google]
1436537275407.png
89 KB, 424x424
>>142205312
Y-you're not upset are you mehgloomyfag?
>>
File: 1463132592919.jpg (14 KB, 405x605) Image search: [Google]
1463132592919.jpg
14 KB, 405x605
>>142205395
>trying to falseflag
>>
>>142198978
I enjoyed his over the top chunni antics at the start but yeah.
Ruins arc we are in(moon festival), screws up dynamic only into autumn, sets us into a path not needed, etc
>>
>>142204768
basically, give me something other than cooking so that when cooking happens I really give a shit
>>
>>142196940
RIP MEGFAGS
>>
>>142196940
Thanks again Vizanon, like >>142198007 said it's all in the LNs and shit, which to everyone here is ridiculous but from WSJ's perspective it makes perfect sense.

Kids have low retention rates and they probably think that they need to keep up the 'action' (Naturally I don't agree seeing as cooking is barely more action than SOL but hey their POV) and they think the SOL lovers are all older, who will fork out the cash for the side material.
>>
>>142196213
I dropped it after Eizan lost because Souma said 'ur a feget' and used ketchup. Did he dick Erina yet?
>>
>>142208458
you're right, just wish it wasn't like this

You can get away with SoL/development in WSJ manga (see World Trigger, for example), but it's not going to be as popular. It's risky.
>>
File: skelet pepsi.gif (900 KB, 480x480) Image search: [Google]
skelet pepsi.gif
900 KB, 480x480
>>142202628
>>142205177
>>142205515
are you guys saying who is the best girl for Souma or just who you like best?

Because if you are defending the ship you are pretty much protecting your cuck fantasy.
>>
>>142208586
It's a bit different for World Trigger anon, because WT has real action. Like action action. So the spikes basically keep up retention kinda like a roller coaster ya know? It's why One Piece is so successful despite having a lot of non-combat scenes and just randumb silliness.

But Shokugeki? It's a series that's carried by Tosh's porn art, and other than having cute chibis like Alice making faces at times, the direction has clearly been to be 'cool'. It's hard to be cool to the young readers if you slow down the pace and not battle for a few chapters because even during battle the kids apparently aren't all that impressed (I believe if you check the WSJ ranking threads it usually reflects that the non-Soma male cooking battles get jack shit rankings) so they are probably scared.

Ironically enough, it'd probably go over better if they just stopped having so many guys take part at the top and have girls like Meat/Megumi slowly become top contenders, but with the way the story is written that's not possible in the near future.

TL;DR WSJ seems to want to push Shokugeki as a serious cooking manga to a much larger degree than what their readers want (mostly just want tits and ass duh).
>>
>>142210299
They did seem to like Azami's introduction at least, so I don't actually know what the kids want.
>>
>>142210748
Cause Azami appeared cool (to them). At least before everything else happened. This might be presumptuous of me to say, but for Shokugeki there's only so much you can change cooking before kids get a bit bored of it.

Even with real fighting action in manga, authors regularly rely on things such as time skips and power escalation in order to keep interest on non RomCom/SOL/comedy/etc series, but Shokugeki isn't aiming to be those things, it's aiming to be a 'battle shonen' first, while the Romcom/SOL/comedy come second just like battle shonen do.

I mean people really liked Kurokiba at first, remember the first tournament? Even guys on /a/ liked him to an extent, mainly cause he was an angry kid with an otter build and sharp teeth. Not saying they hate him now but it's nowhere near before once the hype died down.

I guess hype is all that matters if you're not fan service, but that's mainly due to Tosh's drawing skills at making everyone look bad ass.
>>
File: 1444400864790.jpg (163 KB, 656x896) Image search: [Google]
1444400864790.jpg
163 KB, 656x896
Thread replies: 83
Thread images: 31

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.