[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
So I've seen 6 episodes of this and so far they've
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 92
File: image.jpg (216 KB, 590x334) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
216 KB, 590x334
So I've seen 6 episodes of this and so far they've
>cut out Gon's backstory with Kite
>removed an entire stage of the Hunter Exam
>censored every instance of blood and violence
>rushed through the story
>hired a shitty music composer and director
>made the colors and character designs look fucking terrible
Why do people say this is better than the 1999 version and manga again? Have they just not seen or read it?
>>
Report and ignore.
>>
File: 129 (2).jpg (659 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
129 (2).jpg
659 KB, 1019x1528
> Have they just not seen or read it?

Yes.
>>
>>141366783
>Why do people say this is better than the 1999 version and manga again?
Go into a HxH thread and you'll find people constantly saying the opposite.

Otherwise it's because 2011 is new and slick looking, people think 99 looks out dated and the manga is scribbles. They are wrong, obviously.
>>
>>141367184
>the manga is scribbles. They are wrong, obviously
But this is true.
>>
>>141366783
Stop this meme fag
>>
File: masterpiece.png (3 MB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
masterpiece.png
3 MB, 1920x1080
>>141366783
>>cut out Gon's backstory with Kite
it's in Chimera Ant
>>removed an entire stage of the Hunter Exam
It was boring shit where the characters cook eggs, thank god
>>censored every instance of blood and violence
To keep out the edgy Naruto crowd, thank god
>>rushed through the story
It's called a consistent pacing with the manga newfag
>>hired a shitty music composer and director
The music compositions are god tier and the director respected the material
>>made the colors and character designs look fucking terrible
Get your eyes checked
>>
>>141367273
This meme is almost as funny as the "2011 is good" one.
>>
File: 018.jpg (24 KB, 625x626) Image search: [Google]
018.jpg
24 KB, 625x626
>>141367321
>>
>>141367273
That's only in the magazine, they've been known to literally publish just the drawings from the name and not the final copy because it's better than nothing. Togashi actually pushes out completed drawings for the collected volumes and they're fucking beautiful.
>>
>>141367348
Pic related IS from the volumes newfag
>>
>>141367408

Only chapter with that kind of art and it fits the abstract nature of it which is probably the reason it's the only one.
>>
>>141367273
It's objectively wrong and anyone who's read the tanks knows this. Togashi published scribbles for a certain period of time when his hand was injured, but they were redrawn for the tanks. It was 7 sequential volumes worth out of 33 total, only one chapter wasn't fixed.

The rest ranges from average to great (by weekly standards) and is given a boost in quality by Togashi's paneling and composition.
>>
File: 1342974441154.gif (983 KB, 370x278) Image search: [Google]
1342974441154.gif
983 KB, 370x278
>>141367298
>that pic

Everytime I see it.
>>
File: s006-007.jpg (509 KB, 1740x1270) Image search: [Google]
s006-007.jpg
509 KB, 1740x1270
>>141367408
>1 chapter out of 350
You sure showed us
>>
File: image (1).jpg (2 MB, 2037x3056) Image search: [Google]
image (1).jpg
2 MB, 2037x3056
>>141367348
Pretty sure there's still a lot of scribbles in the tanks tho.
>>
I dont understand why hxh threads are so cancerous if the anime (99) and manga is so good?
>>
File: 62.jpg (487 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
62.jpg
487 KB, 1019x1528
You really have to think hard of scenes they didn't butcher in 11.
>>
File: 1355718741089.png (477 KB, 1654x1248) Image search: [Google]
1355718741089.png
477 KB, 1654x1248
>>141367408
That's the exception that makes the rule.
Magazine scribbles get redrawn in volumes newfag.
>>
>>141367524

That's not a scribble you fucking moron. Do you only read berserk. And yes that not a question since I know you do.
>>
File: image (2).jpg (1 MB, 2037x3056) Image search: [Google]
image (2).jpg
1 MB, 2037x3056
>it's a meme
>>
>>141367544
Because of deluded 99 fags like him >>141367595
>>
File: bravo madhouse.jpg (126 KB, 852x478) Image search: [Google]
bravo madhouse.jpg
126 KB, 852x478
>>141367298
>it's in Chimera Ant
No it's not, it's like 3 seconds and they actually even changed the story and downplayed Kite and Gon's relationship.
>It was boring shit
Subjective and irrelevant, it's still cut content. Don't use pacing as an excuse because they also added random filler on the boat about the sailor.
>To keep out the edgy Naruto crowd
Are you actually defending censorship? Did you think the sparkles blood was good too?
>The music compositions are god tier
They're average with some great ones in Yorkshin and CA. Sadly they didn't know how to use them most of the time so they ruined it.
>the director respected the material
Clearly not, it's one of the blandest Madhouse adaptation and they've made a lot of shitty ones.
>Get your eyes checked
It's true, they all look lanky and like their hair is made out of plastic. They also made the faces longer and the chins pointier and it looks fucking awful.

>masterpiece.png
It's a copy pasted manga panel and the tail is clipping through the background.

It's shit.
>>
I dont understand why hxh threads are so cancerous if the anime (2011) and manga is so good?
>>
>>141367663

I want to shoot the director.
>>
>>141367668
Reddit and MAL flocked to 2011 like flies to shit. It really got bad since the last couple of years though.
>>
>>141367632
So his art is just shit? Glad we cleared that out.
>>
File: 1444284107914.png (38 KB, 261x274) Image search: [Google]
1444284107914.png
38 KB, 261x274
I'm not here to shitpost, I just want to express my love for Kurapika. Kurapika is the cutest, smartest, kindest, and most best boy ever. That is all.
>>
>>141367741
r/hunterxhunter isn't bad tho.
>>
File: 177 (2).jpg (586 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
177 (2).jpg
586 KB, 1019x1528
>>141367652

Really loved this scene in the anime.
>>
File: hisoka.jpg (399 KB, 1488x2096) Image search: [Google]
hisoka.jpg
399 KB, 1488x2096
>>141367668
>>
>>141367408
>>141367298
>newfag
Don't use a word if you don't know what it means.
You're just showing your own newfaggotry.
>>
File: vtgqphC.jpg (86 KB, 680x989) Image search: [Google]
vtgqphC.jpg
86 KB, 680x989
>>141367787
>>
File: 1443531195830.png (4 KB, 135x134) Image search: [Google]
1443531195830.png
4 KB, 135x134
>>141367800
What was his power's name again?
>>
File: t002.jpg (323 KB, 869x1241) Image search: [Google]
t002.jpg
323 KB, 869x1241
>>141367524
>>141367764
Anyone can cherrypick you huge faggot.
>>
>>141367757

Both anime are shit newfriend, read the manga.
>>
File: ..jpg (2 MB, 2037x3056) Image search: [Google]
..jpg
2 MB, 2037x3056
Based outsourced scribbles.
>>
>>141367877
Read the manga.
>>
>>141367764

It isn't, at all.
>>
>>141366783
Are you waiting for next chapter doing this thread or you really are a faggot?
>>
>reading this instead of just watching 2011
kek
>>
>>141367898

I think he heard the first time.
>>
>>141367885
That looks pretty good though, definitely beats the ugly purple/white effect they used in that scene.
>>
>>141367967
My nen restriction requires a second time though.
>>
>>141367790
>getting butthurt about one or two unimportant lines of dialogue omitted
The cherrypicking and mental gymnastics you guys have to go through to find something against 2011 really tells a lot about how great it is.
>>
>>141367885

You might think this is bad if you didn't understand art at all.
>>
>>141368026
Lol exactly
When questioned about how 2011 sucks their best argument is "they removed cooking eggs" and "muh gore"

Based Madhouse
>>
>>141367298
>ruining togashi's brilliant page with their retarded tail clipping and not even fixing it for the BD
Embarrassing.
>>
File: 108.jpg (706 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
108.jpg
706 KB, 1019x1528
>>141368026

It's very important for his character but obviously the fujoshits wanted a kid friendly killua.
>>
>>141368077
The tail clipping is intentional to show how Meruem was physically becoming overwhelmed by Netero's spirit, newfag.
>>
>>141368139
READ
THE
MANGA
>>
>>141368104
>gorefag thinks he understands Killua's character
go back to >>>/b/
>>
>>141368074
>maybe i can just ignore all the other arguments and add "muh" in front of a strawman
I don't understand why 2011fags try so hard to convince themselves their mediocre adaptation isn't shit. It can't be nostalgia since it only ended a couple of years ago, so what is it? Was it your gateway anime or something?
I really can't understand that delusion.
>>
>>141367764
There's nothing shit about that art. It's light on detail, that's it, and it's clearly for the sake of atmosphere and emphasis.

>>141367632
You can really tell that people who bitch about Togashi's art don't read much manga. They've probably read Berserk and Vagabond and expect everything to be on that level, and that detail is the best gauge of art quality.
>>
I recently have watched a lot of HxH threads in /a/, even more than dbz, OP and loly threads. Is this anime so popular? I've never watched before..
>>
>>141368196
Madhouse's 2011 adaptation has been met with near universal critical acclaim. While the series as a whole has received widespread praise,[133][134] the Chimera Ant arc in particular has been often singled out. In addition to being met with rave reviews, the arc has generated considerable discussion and analysis of its themes, symbols, characters and structure throughout and in the aftermath of its run. The arc is commonly viewed as a deconstruction of shōnen and action anime;[135][136] other readings have focused on supposed symbolic parallels with Buddhism[137][138] and nuclear war. Nick Creamer compared the arc to a “war drama”. In a lengthy essay, Creamer read the arc as a study of, and in the end a simultaneous critique and defense of human nature.[139]

Much of the writing surrounding the arc focuses on its villain, the Chimera Ant King. Largely echoing Creamer’s conclusion, Luke Halliday, in an examination of the character, describes his story as “an exploration into what it means to be human.”[140] In the piece, Halliday describes the King's development as “one of the most interesting and captivating in anime . . . [the King's] journey is simply unforgettable” and states his own belief that the arc “will go down as one of the greatest stories told in anime”.

Nick Creamer held similar sentiments, writing “the show’s fantastic aesthetics elevate it above almost everything out there – in direction, in sound design, in pacing, in animation, in basically every relevant aesthetic metric, Hunter x Hunter triumphs. That it’s been maintaining this level of quality for well over a hundred episodes is nothing short of astonishing.”[141]
>>
>>141368227
No, fuck off.
>>
File: 78.jpg (2 MB, 2037x1528) Image search: [Google]
78.jpg
2 MB, 2037x1528
>>141368195

I think you should be in bed or rewatching 4kidz wan piss.
>>
>>141368227
Yes you can watch the anime on Crunchyroll
>>
>>141368217
I don't care what anyone says, Berserk's art is stiff and the composition is usually cluttered and messy as fuck.
>>
>>141368238
>trying to make a copypasta out of a wikipedia article
This is like the bottom level of attempting to force memes.
>>
>>141368301

Details are something that even amateurs can pick on so usually most mainstream praised art works are detail based.
>>
>>141368272
I think you should be on >>>/b/ jerking off to a gore thread
>>
File: Bungee_Gum.gif (2 MB, 500x281) Image search: [Google]
Bungee_Gum.gif
2 MB, 500x281
>>141367835
The one with the properties of both, rubber and gum
>>
File: 1462575481225.png (435 KB, 950x551) Image search: [Google]
1462575481225.png
435 KB, 950x551
>>141368450
Chrollo is dead.
>>
>>141368227
Watch the 1999 version, anon. It's worth it.

>>141368280
>crunchyroll
kek
>>
>>141366783
>hired a shitty music composer and director
NO, fuck you
>>
File: 183.jpg (861 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
183.jpg
861 KB, 1019x1528
>>141368383

Sometimes violence has a point my christian friend.
>>
File: tumblr_inline_nk3qittOjm1rwyesj.png (225 KB, 500x282) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_inline_nk3qittOjm1rwyesj.png
225 KB, 500x282
>>141368518
No chance in hell
>>
>defending censorship and watered down content
You can't make this shit up, 2011fags are this delusional.
>>
>>141368238
This has now become a copypasta hasn't it?

The sad thing is that there are fags who actively believe it.
>>
>>141368602
2011fags are tumbliberals.
>>
File: tumblr_o6advbUilT1u550qbo1_500.gif (277 KB, 500x281) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_o6advbUilT1u550qbo1_500.gif
277 KB, 500x281
>>141368602
>>141368606
>>
>>141368606
No, it's just one faggot spamming it since the other thread. Report, filter and hide.
>>
>>141367638
>>141367885
Fucking hell, stop valuing polish over effect. It's not smooth and shiny looking because it's meant to create an impression instead. Eg, the page with Welfin is supposed to convey his stress and paranoia, therefore it has rough lines and excessive text to show his frantic mental process. His face is divided into multiple panels and there's no background to keep focus on the fact that we're hearing what's going on in his head, and it feels tense and claustrophic as a result.

I feel stupid just typing such a babby level analysis but if you don't understand what I'm saying you're beyond help. The page with the king is even more obvious with the effect it's going for.
>>
>>141366783
I still don't understand how anyone can bitch about faithfulness to the manga, then turn around and praise 1999. People who are manga purists and hate both adaptations I at least get, but 99fags preaching this are downright hypocritical.
>>
File: 41.jpg (653 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
41.jpg
653 KB, 1019x1528
>>141368602

But my mom doesn't let me watch violent shows!
>>
File: CanaryManga.jpg (49 KB, 460x391) Image search: [Google]
CanaryManga.jpg
49 KB, 460x391
>>141368635
>implying the manga doesnt have homosexual, black, and transsexual characters
Togashi is a tumblrite face it
>>
>>141368653
I'm pretty sure those are just people pointing out that 2011 isn't exactly faithful either, i don't see any bitching about it.
>>
>>141368636

Don't ruin sakamoto for me faggot.
>>
File: Berserk_v13_p120-121.png (728 KB, 2498x1800) Image search: [Google]
Berserk_v13_p120-121.png
728 KB, 2498x1800
>>141368301
>>
>>141368740
Are you even in the same thread I am?
>>
>>141368653

At least 99 when it deviated tried something new, something different. Instead of just removing things or watering things down without any clear direction other than to make it more kid friendly which is what 11 did.
>>
>>141368799
>>
File: 1461823784131.jpg (57 KB, 598x356) Image search: [Google]
1461823784131.jpg
57 KB, 598x356
Why are these threads so shitty when the series is so good
>>
>>141368854
nostalgiafags shitting up the threads with their memes and poor quality screenshots
>>
>>141368854
Because of obnoxious fans who have a warped view of the world where they think everyone else is the problem.
>>
>>141368854
It's nearly summer and 2011 attracted a lot of underage posters.
>>
>>141368774
Too bad everything went to the shitter after golden age arc.
>>
>>141368854

Yeah the manga is good. Popular with teenagers and mediocre anime is the problem.
>>
>>141368947
That's not true, it went to shit after Schierke was introduced.
>>
>>141368900
Actually hxh threads used to be just fine until 2011 anime started.

Plus most of the oldfags got sick of the 2011 newfags and left for good, so contrary to popular belief by 2011fags, there's very little in the way of nostalgia to be had in HxH threads.
>>
>>141368854
99 or 2011?
>>
>>141369008
Yeah it did get bad after 2011. Not because of the people who saw the new anime though, because of the nostalgia fags who just have to shove their gay pretentious opinions down everyone's throats.
>>
>>141366783
Fucking toonami fags
>>
>>141369008
Why do new anime adaptations attract leddit?
>>
>>141369008
I wouldn't even give a shit but 2011fags started the "2011 is a faithful adaptation of the story/characters" meme and shoved it down the throats of everyone.
>>
>>141369226
typical 2011 fag
>>
>>141369226
I want r/hunterxhunter to fuck off.
>>
File: 902515631.jpg (57 KB, 1016x356) Image search: [Google]
902515631.jpg
57 KB, 1016x356
>>
>>141367668

It's not good though. Naruto chunin exam is vastly superior to hxh
>>
>>141369245
It is factually a faithful adaptation. Read the manga.
>>
>>141369316
Left is how he looks in the manga newfag. Read the fucking manga
>>
>>141369339
Case in point.
>>
>>141369324
It's a carbon copy of the hunter exam and the Sasugay subplot alone makes it shit.
>>
Kurapika is the most retardedly broken character on HxH.
I hope he dies in a brutal way.
>>
>>141369339
Don't bother arguing with them. They seriously believe that a couple minorly altered scenes over 100-something episodes means the characters come across completely differently.
>>
>>141369397
The 1999 anime had poor direction with the story. The filler was horrible and you'll probably be bored as fuck watching the first 10 episodes. I would say the 1999 anime is 40% faithful while the 2011 anime is about 85% more faithful.....So yeah watch the 2011 anime it's easier and better to watch.
>>
>>141369419
>it's a 2011fag who doesn't know what emperor time does post
>>
>>141369452
typical cancerous pikafag
>>
>>141366783
Try watching more than 6 episodes and you'll get why. The amount of blood and violence you love goes up drastically in the later arcs, and the only really big issue is how the sound direction is consistently shit.
>>
File: 195.jpg (564 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
195.jpg
564 KB, 1019x1528
>It's "let's butcher another chapter" episode.
>>
>>141369452
>kurapika becomes invencible when angry
Literally crawling in my skin

Also, they did a whole infodump about emperor time on the fight with Uvogin.

What a fucking shit character
>>
>>141369482
Pikafags are becoming the new Killuafags.

>my husbando is sooo cute u guys! hes sooo perfect
>no he isnt edgy see he held a child omg! so perfect
>>
>>141369509
>franklin's bullets bounce off the people like rubber
embarrassing
>>
>>141369489
>The amount of blood and violence you love goes up drastically in the later arcs
Does it? Most of it is censored, even when Kite loses his arm there's censorship and the scene of Pitou gutting that one guy is removed entirely.
>>
>>141369530
>becomes invencible
Confirmed for retard who hasn't read the manga. Even in enhancement it doesn't make his as effective as a transmuter could be.
>>
>>141369376
Yes and that's a good example of why panel by panel adaptations are horrible.
>>
File: 133.jpg (531 KB, 1019x1528) Image search: [Google]
133.jpg
531 KB, 1019x1528
>>141369556

Worst thing is they always use as much camera tricks as possible to make it kid friendly.
Any impact they might have is drown out.
>>
File: Kanzai_table.png (5 KB, 128x128) Image search: [Google]
Kanzai_table.png
5 KB, 128x128
>>141369530
>>141369581
Do you know how to make a post without spouting memes?
Also, how is saying he doesn't have a family to a guy who was threatening it edgy?
>>
>>141369376
He never looked that exaggerated in the manga though and he only looked similar to that in the exam.
>>
>>141369651
no the manga is shit too

panel by panel adaptations of good manga are acceptable, look at one punch man
>>
File: 1459389174721.png (227 KB, 696x480) Image search: [Google]
1459389174721.png
227 KB, 696x480
>it's another 99 vs. 2011 dick waving thread

Hunterfags are almost as bad as Fatefags at this point.
>>
>>141369715
(You)
>>
>>141369692
>OPMtards
Literally the most cancerous faggots on this board after narutards.
Also it was a shit adaptation, nice way to show your garbage taste.
>>
>>141366783
JESUS CHRIST SON OF A BITCH YOU'VE WATCHED 6 EPISODES OUT OF 150 AND YOU THINK YOU'RE ENTITLED TO HAVE AN OPINION

DON'T FUCKING WATCH IT GO FUCK YOUR MOTHER HOLY SHIT
>>
>>141369581
>>141369681
Jesus, they are talking about the mafia family.
>>
File: 1460853834899.jpg (134 KB, 960x960) Image search: [Google]
1460853834899.jpg
134 KB, 960x960
>tfw no Greed Island VR game
>>
>>141369822
11fags can't into context.
>>
>>141369847
That line is in 2011 retard. Read the manga.
>>
>>141369618
>implying I haven't read the manga just because I insulted kurapika
He is a fucking walking cliché with no other purpose rather than killing interesting characters.
Is there any point to give him 100% power on every nen skill when enraged? The fights are literally getting mad because 'they killed muh family' and using your overpowered skills that you got from LITERALLY NOWHERE.
>stoic and serious as fuck
>edgy
>sad background
>everything he says is right

I don't understand pikafags
>>
>>141369876
They can't into comprehension either apparently.
>>
1999 anime > 2011 up until York Shin
If you disagree you have shit taste.
>>
>Whole beginning of the CA arc is ruined by the shitty direction and censorship

All I wanted was good CA arc out of 11 and when they butchered Election Arc too it was a final nail in the coffin.
>>
Has there ever been a comfier opening?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CzPTN476OvI
>>
>>141369949
>fillers
>dumbed down gon
>edgy dark atmosphere
>no hisoka vs kastro in arena
>shit animation and sound
2011 >>>>>> 1999 in every arc
>>
>>141369914

He killed one person and Ubo was hardly interesting. Pakus character arc was over when she died.
>>
>>141370002
Yes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kG1NjoIhAKA
>>
>>141367663
>kite is extremely important to gon and he often thinks about him on his journey
>he also often forgets about ging
>gon even shows killua where he met kite
>there are people who think ging is more important to gon than kite
Thanks Badhouse.
>>
>>141370006
>shit animation and sound
Its music and animation is overall better than the 2011 version.
>edgy dark atmosphere
Did you read the manga? It's dark and edgy.
>fillers
They don't take anything away from the story.
>>
>>141370084
(You)
>>
>>141370054
It was alright for the first 20 episodes but I really started to dislike this song after 3 years of having it shoved down my throat.
>>
>>141369914
>killing interesting characters
Only a handful of the PT are actually characters. I don't understand spiderfags.
>100% power on every nen skill
That's not what it does you fucking mongoloid, and even then he only uses it with enhancement. The fact that he got his arm shattered even when he was using gyo on it should tell you it doesn't improve it as much as you think.
Jesus Christ, there was an entire 500+ posts long thread about it a couple of weeks ago and there are still retards to spout this.

>stoic and serious as fuck
He always opens up and is cooperative.
>edgy
Nice buzzword you fucking faggot.
>sad background
What's your point? Do you also complain when you meet people who have sad backgrounds?
>everything he says is right
You're retarded, the entire ending of Yorkshin was about how he made a mistake and felt guilty for acting irrational and putting others in danger for no reason.

You're dumb anon.
>>
>>141370191
>pikafag calling others faggots
YOU CAN'T MAKE THIS SHIT UP
>>
>>141370104
Is it just one autist spamming this or is this really the best 2011fags can come up with to justify their shit opinions?
>>
>>141370226
We get it, 2011fags are spergs who can't argue while mangafags actually post facts.
>>
>>141366783

While 99 is better in my opinion because it has better pacing and atmosphere overall 2011 adapted the whole chimera ants arc so it has at least that going for it.

Don't really care which one is better as long as it keeps being popular enough for them to keep adapting when new material comes out.

Just don't watch the movies...
>>
>>141370191
Not to mention he was completely duped by wobles mom
>>
>>141370244

Just report and don't reply.
>>
>>141370104
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uw8Io09FeL4
>2011 butchering this scene
>>
>>141370317
>that going for it.
>keep adapting

Reddit is not this way.
>>
>>141370428
>2011's plastic downie Chrollo
Bravo
>>
>>141370428
2011's character designs look absolutely disgusting when you put them side by side.
>>
>>141370382
>2011fags are reddit frogposters
I'm starting to hope this is falseflagging, i can't imagine them being this cancerous
>>
>>141370531

HxH reddit is exactly that bad, at least the last time I checked it because of these kind of posters.
>>
>>141370531
It isn't that surprising because one of 2011's animators is a frogposter. She's a Killuafag too.
>>
>>141370428
>2011 version
God that's embarrassing.
>>
>>141370428
Look at all the shortcuts 2011 version is making. Absolutely horrible.
>>
>>141370606
>Killuafag frogposter
This is the worst combination conceivable.
>>
>>141370428
>that movement on Kuroro's hair on 99
>that hilariously bad Nen blast from Zeno on 2011
>>
>>141370606
Is she also Korean?
>>
You guys are all grade A fags, 2011 is much better in every aspect.
>>
>>141370888
Shit is only one aspect.
>>
People underrate the 2011 anime way too much. It's fantastic to watch. For a long running series, it had good animation and the pacing was nice, too. It's highly faithful besides a few details and Kite's introduction (which I agree is a pretty big deal). If someone wants to watch 2011, I think they should.
>>
>>141371007
>People underrate the 2011
Stopped reading there.
>>
>>141371043
I mean it. People shit it on it constantly when it's a great series on its own. Even if it has some flaws, it's not shit.

By the way, I'm only talking about /a/. I don't know what other people think.
>>
>>141371007
It's overrated anywhere but here.
>>
>>141371111
On its own? Maybe. As an adaptation? No.
>>
>>141368647
Of course anon, it's not laziness it's valuing atmosphere and theatrics, which also just so happens to be easier and faster to do than good art.
>>
>>141371007
Even though I often argue that 1999 is better, I will admit that Greed Island and the second half of the Chimera Ant arc were really good in the 2011 version. Also various scenes such as Hisoka vs Gon were done really well too.
>>
>>141371237
They rushed through Greed Island and they did the opposite with the second half of CA where they used the narration to make every scene drag on as much as possible without much animation. Those are probably the parts the butchered the most with Yorkshin.
Gon vs Hisoka was pretty good though.
>>
>>141371347
>they used the narration to make every scene drag on as much as possible without much animation
Isn't that basically true to the manga?
>>
>>141371409
No, because the manga isn't anime and the narration flowed naturally in the panels while the narrator in the anime was a shittily voiced annoying disruptive faggot.
>>
>>141371409
The difference is that the narration in the manga can be read at your own pace and the composition is built around it. In the anime it's just obstrusive, you're listening to a dude talk while there are stills of characters doing nothing like it's a powerpoint presentation or something. And it takes even longer when the characters talk after the narrator.
>>
>>141371195
What do you call good art?
>>
>>141371574
One Piece
>>
>>141371409
Yes, as flawed as 2011 is I don't think that's their fault. Narration in the manga is a small text box here and there, it's quick to read and adds to the scene, but when it's read aloud it becomes annoyingly conspicuous and lengthy. They're kinda stuck between a rock and a hard place because either the adaption gets rid of some of the narration and becomes less accurate, or it reads everything aloud to the point that it's an obnoxious, near constant presence.
>>
>>141371524
>>141371549
Fair enough, but from partway into the Chimera Ant arc a lot of the story is told through the narration. It's not like they could just cut it out, and reducing it too much would lose a lot of the details of the story. I think it's just an awkward part to adapt to animation.
>>
>>141371195
If it gets the atmosphere across as intended it IS good art, and there are no issues with his anatomy etc to detract from that. You're the dumbass who clearly thinks 'good art' is solely clean and polished linework with lots of detail. Togashi does that when it suits the scene, and avoids it when it doesn't. Pouf and Welfin freaking pissing themselves in fear are scenes that are very suited to more rough lines.
>>
File: 1462573415906.jpg (409 KB, 784x1145) Image search: [Google]
1462573415906.jpg
409 KB, 784x1145
>>141371841
>>
>>141371937
Flawless page.
>>
>>141371937
>would you like to hold her?
I liked niggastream's translation of that one line better, it felt more touching.
>>
Spoilers when?
>>
>>141373294
353 when?
>>
>>141370428
They're practically the same, do tiny differences really bother you guys that much?
>>
So this thread confirms 99fags are shitposters?
Also
>Taking up for nippon animation

They're dead in the ground for a reason. They were shit.
>>
File: 1461448052853.jpg (93 KB, 600x700) Image search: [Google]
1461448052853.jpg
93 KB, 600x700
I don't fucking get you people
not just 99 fags
not just 11 fag or even manga fags
but all of you on /a/ argue about petty/subjective things, and ye tin the end you all mostly like the same thing. Is being a special snowflake for liking a specific version of the (more or less) same source material that important to you?
>>
Any spoiler image?
>>
>>141367298
>keep out edgy Naruto crowd
>chimera ant arc shit is edgier than anything in Naruto and most shonens period
>>
>>141372092
>Would you like to cut the bullshit Sakura?
>>
>>141367603
Where can i read the redrawn chapters? besides buying the volumes oc
>>
>>141374043
>>chimera ant arc shit is edgier than anything in Naruto and most shonens period
>>edgier
Elaborate.
>>
>>141371937

would you let kurapika be a nanny for your baby?
>>
>>141366783
because they were compared horribly to first run and corrected it for the following seasons, for the rest of the episodes past 20
>>
1999 censored the entire kastro fight?

how is that acceptable 1999 fags?
>>
spoilers when
>>
>>141377354
once you let the thread die.
>>
>>141377416
Sorry anon
no more bumps
>>
>>141368272
Which chapter was this from again?
>>
>>141377354
hisoka dies
>>
>>141366783
has /a/ gone a day without this thread? without multiple of this thread?
>>
>>141366783
Only people who can't read books praise it.
>>
>>141374753
Who was Kastro again?
>>
>>141369556
I recall the entire York Shin arc being more bloody than the 1999 version. It was at this point that some people started liking the new one as well.
>>
2011 wins be default just because it has Chimera Ant arc and an actual conclusion to its premise of "I gotta find my dad".
>>
>>141380216
A Cuban communist.
>>
When there's nothing to be discussed about the current chapter, the 1999 vs 2011 shitpost begins. Sigh
>>
>>141368854
We still don't have separate boards for anime and manga.
>>
File: 1455547738552.png (51 KB, 200x221) Image search: [Google]
1455547738552.png
51 KB, 200x221
Killua is cute!
>>
>>141368587
g-gum and r-r-rubber?!
Chrollo is fucked
>>
>>141371007
It's on the top 10 according every anime review website you fucking bad
>>
reminder that 2011 also fucked pakunoda death scene
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udR6RdFpSVk
>>
File: 1424335372482.jpg (28 KB, 180x284) Image search: [Google]
1424335372482.jpg
28 KB, 180x284
>>141381892
>anime review website
>>
>>141382392
It'd be easier to list things they didn't fuck up.
>>
>>141367966
nice b8 m8
>>
New spoilers when?
>>
>>141383651
This. It's 50 hours long and after reading the manga, most of it felt like dragging with no animation budget. Togashi telling everything with exposition and Madhouse making no effort to move beyond 1:1 mindless pasta sure doens't help.
>>
>>141384351
Tomorrow.
>>
Let-s be honest here, even if it had been 100% faithful, would there really be any reason to watch this show other than the Chimera Ants?

IMO, it suffers from the same issue as Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, in that it just wants to get the early arcs done to focus on the new material.
>>
File: Killua_misses_his_target.jpg (88 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
Killua_misses_his_target.jpg
88 KB, 1280x720
Killua is cute!
>>
>>141381277
>Sigh
Kill yourself
>>
>>141380926
It does in 99's GI OVAs too as long as you don't continue on after that.
>>
>>141385517 (You)
>>>/Youtube/
>>
Dear 1999-fags and 2011-fags

Please

Die.
>>
File: 11 vs 99.jpg (11 KB, 255x223) Image search: [Google]
11 vs 99.jpg
11 KB, 255x223
>>
Spoiler image of Crollo fucking Hisoka when?
>>
File: Gon's change.jpg (649 KB, 1280x2455) Image search: [Google]
Gon's change.jpg
649 KB, 1280x2455
>Wahh wahh it's not edgy like the 99 series

Did no one really see the director's intent on purposefully contrasting the Hunter Exam with every other arc in the show or is everyone that autistic/ shitposting?
>>
>>141387201
Chimera Ant was an amazing instance of original author intent and directorial vision perfectly converging
>>
>>141387201
>director purposefully butchered Gon's character in the beginning
Bravo, what a hero
>>
>>141387350
>2011
>director
Pick one.
>>
>>141387350
No retard, Gon was cheerful and naive in the manga too.
>>
>>141387397
Animefags, everyone.
>>
>>141387201
You wont give the chance to 99 director for doing CA adaptation
>>
>>141387201
But Gon was fucked up from the very beginning.
>>
>>141387437
Mongoloids, everyone.
>>
File: 1456809003737.png (2 MB, 1440x1080) Image search: [Google]
1456809003737.png
2 MB, 1440x1080
>>141367035
They totally wimped out on Kil's backstory
>I'm as fucked up as I am because my parents abuse me, this is also why I ran away from home
>comes back and has a peaceful talk with his father
? This makes no sense. Where was he going with this?
>>
>>141367603
That still looks kinda shit...
>>
>>141387397
He really wasn't, Gon only seemed that way at first glance in the manga, but the first chapter pretty much dissuades that notion.

Rather than naivety it's more that he didn't care.
>>
>>141387201
Problem is that that wasn't how Gon was supposed to come across.
>>
>>141387397
>Gon was cheerful and naive
Holy shit nigger, did 2011 really fuck Gon up that much?
>>
>>141387996
That the Zoldycks were all fucked up, and can't really be judged by normal moral conventions.

Just like how the hunters in the manga are chaotic and selfish.
>>
>>141388166
How are they all fucked up? It just seems like Killua is a spoiled rich kid with teen angst. He's capable of talking to his dad just fine. His dad also seems supportive of his sexuality.
>>
File: Hunter X Hunter v1-123.jpg (723 KB, 2037x3056) Image search: [Google]
Hunter X Hunter v1-123.jpg
723 KB, 2037x3056
>>141388129
He was, though. Read the manga.
>>
>>141374043
>>141374286
How are Naruto and Hunter x Hunter edgy?They had some dark moments but never went full edge.
>>
>>141388206
You don't think that torturing a child isn't fucked up? Granted they did it for their own reasons, manga depicts their behavior as strange but they're not unlikable as characters.
>>
>>141387996
It's a purposeful anti climax. HxH is a literary manga so you should learn to appreciate the concept or drop it.
>>
>>141388228
That's really just an example of him bit giving a fuck.
>>
>>141388313
I don't know, that's exactly why I was asking him to elaborate.
I don't know about Naruto, but there's nothing edgy in the CA arc.
>>
File: Hunter X Hunter v2-122.jpg (487 KB, 2037x3056) Image search: [Google]
Hunter X Hunter v2-122.jpg
487 KB, 2037x3056
>>141388357
Totally a melancholic and not-cheerful character.
>>
>>141388493
He's only melancholic in the first chapter because he's leaving home.

Besides that your not disproving my point about Gon just not giving a fuck.
>>
>>141388862
So we're in agreement that manga and 2011 Gon are the same.
>>
>>141387996

I think he ran away from home because he didn't want to be an assassin and his family wouldn't let him have friends or anything. The abuse thing doesn't seem to bother him anymore. They have a really weird relationship with each other. Illumi's care for Kil is just one example. I think Silva is the only one he's okay with just talking to, but even then Kil doesn't fully trust him.
>>
>>141389034
They aren't.
>>
>>141387996
>because my parents abuse me
He never said this.
>>
Spoilers in about 9 hours or so
>>
>>141389820
Giving me a (You) doesn't change anything. Maybe you'll find somebody on reddit to go along with your delusion though.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 92

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.