Of all the things she did wrong, what is the most wrong thing she did?
Saving Madoka.
>>139496277
She was gay.
She didn't do it faster. All that time she could've spent cuddling with Madoka is wasted on wraith killing.
>>139496277
Enlarging her chest
She didn't do ANYTHING wrong though
Being such a train wreck that she couldn't do a single thing right.
And being a raging dyke.
>>139496277
>"""artists""" who draw tits on flat girls
They should be gassed.
>>139496277
Not using her time loop power effectively. She literally just kept doing the same thing every loop instead of trying a new approach.
>>139496277
Thinking Madoka is best girl.
>>139496782
This.
Not rebelling against the law of cycles. Not making her wish in the first place.
Just being a complete spaz who can't into friendship.
>>139496991
But Homura being a complete spaz is one of her charming points.
>people badmouthing homu
>>139496782
But she did change her approach every loop.
The first time she let Madoka sign the contract and thought that it would be fine if she fought alongside her.
>>139496277
She did nothing wrong.
>>139497080True.
>>139496769
>>139496277
Not outright exterminating the Incubators.
>>139497421
So homu stole Mami's mamis?
PSA: Friendly reminder that ACK will be coming soon and people should just post whatever they want and ignore him. He wants attention, that's what gets him off. Pay him no mind, logic is not his first priority. He's just here to cause trouble.
Do people who say she did nothing wrong say and believe this unironically?
>>139497564
Of course, she is evil, after all.
>>139497564
Wouldn't you?
She should have used one of her loops to kidnap Madoka and lock her up somewhere safe to prevent her from making a contract.
As a bonus she has a toy she can play with during her off time when she is not busy fighting witches.
>>139497652
The true patrician opinion of Homura's actions is that she did the best she could, but the best she could wasn't good enough.
>>139497652
Do people who think she did something wrong watch a different movie?
>>139496277
She was never best.
>>139496277
Not fucking me
>>139497890
Anon, there's still time
>>139498002
what does the foot of a dark sorceress taste like?
>>139497652
Tell me anon. got a favorite charater? If you do, Homu saved your favorite character and offered them a better. happier life. That is how great Homu is.
>>139498087
Just like honey.
>>139498087
I'm not sure, but I think they would smell like delicate lavender
>>139498087
Like Madoka's fluids.
>>139498168
Did she do it on purpose or unwittingly? Her main focus is Madoka anyway.
>>139497704
there's a fanfic that's basically about that
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/11339239/1/Perfect-Crime
>>139497704
She's not that obsessive.
>>139498352
She did it unwittingly but it was still made possible by Homu.
When she was about to murder Sayaka in cold blood just so she wouldn't have to watch Madoka suffer. Fucking psychopath.
>>139496277
Leaving the Iraq.
>>139498352
She seems like the end justifies the means kinda girl.
She's gonna build a new universe and make the incubators pay for it
>>139498559
It's not her fault that Sayaka is a baka.
>>139498559
Ummmm, when the hell did that happen. I recall her saying she doesn't care if Sayaka lives or dies, but she never tried to murder Sayaka. In fact, she did the oposite and tried to save her, just for madokas sake, but still
![[Coalgirls]_Magical_Girl_Madoka_Magica_the_Movie_III_-_Rebellion_(1920x1080_Blu-ray_FLAC)_[557238A8].mkv_snapshot_01.42.28_[2016.04.02_23.00.12].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/wQxpVbi.jpg "[Coalgirls]_Magical_Girl_Madoka_Magica_the_Movie_III_-_Rebellion_(1920x1080_Blu-ray_FLAC)_[557238A8].mkv_snapshot_01.42.28_[2016.04.02_23.00.12].jpg")
I hope the next project explains how this happened. Homura never intended to have everyone getting sucked in as well? Then what did she actually want?
>>139498559
Wouldn't you?
>>139498745
Episode 8 roughly halfway through
>>139498559
>>139498745
It was cut from the movies. Watch the series, anon.
>>139496348
someone got a translation for that pic?
>>139498846
Was obviously meant for >>139498745
>>139498527
She is pretty obsessive. Maybe not in the kind of way homuhaters say, but I could totally see her taking some kind of extreme measure after so many failed timelines
>>139498846
Hm, what episode is that from, I need to rewatch it. I have watched both the series and the movie version but don't remember this.
>>139498950
Sure, she's pretty obsessive, but Madoka's happiness is still a major factor. I don't think Madoka is into that.
>>139497724
Im inclined to think that that opinion is incorrect, like Im seriously questioning whether that opinion can belong to anything more than a retard
>>139499042
Episode 8, around the 11th minute.
Would you kill yourself if that meant reincarnating in Madoka world asHitomi?
>>139498087
Ask your mother
>>139499294
She's rich as fuck. So yes.
Homura is a good girl who deserves love and eternal salvation.
>>139499215
Good for you.
>>139499386
Gracias amigo.
,r´=＝∞、 i>i<!´｀⌒ヾ<i
＿＿!l|从ﾊﾉﾘ!| (（( ﾉﾉﾘ从从ゝ__
| |ﾘ.*ﾟ ヮﾟﾉl| ゞ(ﾘ ﾟ ヮﾟﾉﾘ |
|＼ ⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒ ⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒＼
| ＼＾ ⌒ ⌒ ⌒ ⌒ ＼
＼ ..｜⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒⌒.｜
＼|＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿＿|
>>139498753
She meant the other girls part of LoC, so Sayaka and Nagisa. I'm pretty sure she did intend everyone else.
>>139499870
So Sayaka and Nagisa weren't even supposed to exist? What a bitch.
>>139500026
Or you know, she could just be lying. Characters have lied before.
>>139496277
Letting Sayaka live in the new universe as Madoka's friend. She'll end fucking shit up, I'm sure.
>>139500194
They aren't friends in this new universe are they?
>>139499870
>all of you
>all
I think she meant more than one person anon.
>>139497652
Had the film ended with no sequel in mind, she'd have legitimately done nothing wrong. Because there was a sequel in mind, her psychosis will get worse and Sayaka's justice faggotry is going to come into conflict with it. Madoka will have to keep her bff and her lowkey lover from killing each other.
Production notes say she's doing the best she can and she's only perceived as evil. Make no mistake, she is the hero of this series.
>>139500335
Homura specifically tells Sayaka not to fight with her in front of Madoka, but she doesn't seem to have a problem with them being friends.
>>139498846
Reminder Madoka thanked her for this in episode 12.
>>139500384
Since when are Sayaka and Nagisa one person?
>>139500629
Wait. Meant to say, more than 2 persons.
>>139500528
>she doesn't seem to have a problem with them being friends.
>threatens to make Madoka ending up hating her
>>139500816
>Implying it's Homura who would make Madoka hate her
>>139500881
>implying Madoka is capable of feeling hatred
>>139500706
She says "anatatachi" in japanese, which doesn't imply more more than 2 persons.
>>139500939
You got me there.
>>139496277
She didn't give Kyubey a worse fate.
>>139496277
No, not another pointless Madoka general.
Why does the devil have blush sometimes and other times not?
Perhaps what Homura meant was that she didn't want to suck in the parts of Sayaka and Nagisa that were a part of the LoC. Just like how she only sucked in Madoka's human part.
>>139501256
I don't think she thought she could bring people back from the dead.
>>139496595
>that trigger discipline
think again, anon
>>139501285
I don't think that's it. Since Sayaka wasn't supposed to be dead at the moment of Homura and Madoka's first meeting.
>>139501362
Kyousuke's arm wasn't supposed to be healed nor where Hitomi and he supposed to be dating. It's pretty strongly implied Homura doesn't have a full grasp on her power. She didnt even know she was going to be come a "demon".
>>139501239
She is still a human being with feelings!
>>139501347
You only put your finger on the trigger when you are ready to shoot. How do you know she isn't ready to shoot?
Nagisa wasn't even supposed to be a human at that point. They got dragged in without Homura consciously wanting it. This>>139501285 is true.
>>139496277
She rejected theAppleof Kyouko, though I understoodthe bad apple is bad.
>>139501465
Kyousuke's arm was already healed and he and Hitomi were already dating. The only thing that Homura didn't expect to happen is for Sayaka and Nagisa to be alive again. And while she doesn't have a full grasp on her power, she's still very capable of manipulating certain events such as defying the laws of physics,
>>139501468
>She is still a human being with feelings!
Madoka will go down as a god-tier villain in my book if Homu dies next project.
>>139501716
>>139496277
god hates lesbos ;_;
>>139501746
Madoka will redeem Homura and deliver unto her eternal salvation.
>>139501733
Yes, I am agreeing with you. I was responding to the anon who said Sayaka wasn't dead at the time of Madoka's first meeting with Homura.
>>139501148
That picture warms my cold dead lifeless heart everytime I see it.
>>139501863
So you're telling me Sayaka and Nagisa are actually ghosts?
>>139502036
Ghosts aren't that lewd.
>>139501914
Yeah. Kyubey was a little shit to her. It would be nice to see it worse off.
>>139501716
She rejected the apple to keep Kyoko distant. Are you saying Mamis tea is a bad tea since she also rejected it? If so you are an idiot.
>>139502279
Anon, that's a joke.
>>139502484
You keep saying that in the past. It is a terrible joke and you really should stop.
>>139502554
Hi! Apple-chan!
Which meguca do youfapthe most
>>139502749
I know you have many devices.
Also I just blushed like a red apple.>>139502647
>>139502831
>being pathetic like you
I shall stop replying.
>>139502704
Also, no one faps to the megucas and all pervs should die.
>>139498559
Really though, it was to Sayaka's benefit as well. She was going to become a witch.
>>139502885
>I shall stop replying.
You keep saying that.
So from what i undestand about this >>139501716 tripfag he likes !gm but wants to cheat on him because he is worse than kyuubei.
>>139503360
Stop talking about tripfags.
>>139502949
Why didn't you die? When you watch lewd pics, you always go red Apple-chan.
>>139503360
I want to meet !GM but he doesn't appear in front of me. I don't know why. I want him to get jealous like you.
>>139503519
Harsh!
>>139503519
Sorry. This one in particular has got to be the most annoying one ever. Madoka and friends would be so disappointed in him.
>>139503602
You cheat on !gm with !bebe. You will make no one jealous.
>>139496277
She didn't give me a Madokami vs Homucifer fight. I was waiting for that exact moment, and then she doesn't deliver.
Hopefully the supposed upcoming movie has it.
>>139499294
Kyuskiko or whatever he is called seems pretty rich and shit.
Would be kinda bad that you lose all of your friends for some reason but hey violin and shit
>>139503730
Hi! ACK or his supporter! Why do you love me so much?
>>139503730
Stop talking about tripfags
Stop talking to tripfags
Stop talking to and/or about tripfags, stop interacting with or mentioning tripfags in any way, verbally, textually, or mentally
Stop it
>>139503826
>wanting to choose a violin over women
>>139498559
She literally offered her a grief seed 5 seconds before and was very rudely rebuffed. Everyone loves to omit that part. We can debate Rebellion, but the series goes out of its way to justify almost every single action Homura males.
>>139503872
Woah anon.
I don't dislike trips but I have a question. How do you people find these threads so quickly ? Did you make a contract or how does this work ?Are you strayans by any chance?
>>139504015
>>139500445
Got a sauce on those production notes? From what I've read her familiars hunt people for sport. Sounds pretty evil to me.
>>139504094Don't lose your head over this.
>>139496277
The only thing she did wrong was telling Kyubey about the witch timeline.
>>139504182
>>139503838
Don't say his name. Don't talk about crack. And don't try and convince him you are not !Akemi. Doing so will only result in the derailing of this thread.
>>139504018
Hint; Search the word "Madoka" or"Apple"in Desustorage or Use the catalog orthe power of the will.
>>139504313
Okay.
>>139504321
I want to cum all over Homura's legs
>>139504434
Stop wanting that
>>139504018
Same way as anyone else.And we probably wouldn't be alive if we were.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
But homulucifer is part homulilly right?
That's why she still has the dolls, she is still effected by her witch side and if you ask me that's important detail and I think it may have led to her doing what she did to madokami.
>>139504434
Her legs are beautiful!
>>139504492
She is a new kind of existence that is neither magical girl nor witch, but probably shares aspects of both
We don't really know what her deal is
>>139496277
Letting best girl die. Multiple times.
>>139504814
Letting Kyouko die a lot truly is a crime.
>>139504878
What makes you think best girl = Kyouko?
It's obviouslySayaka
>>139504492
Witches are basically Stands now. Sayaka was shown with Oktavia behind her at the end of Rebellion.
>>139504935
Kyouko and best goes hand-in-hand.
>>139504939
Sayaka's a whole different case, since she died and became part of the LoC and got in touch with her inner despair or something.
>>139504547
I want to give a hickey on her legs, barefeet and asscheeks
>>139504878
Second best girl m8.
>>139504935
You have fine taste.
>>139504434
>>139504162
The ending is ambigous at worst.
https://wiki.puella-magi.net/Rebellion_Material_Book
From Urobuchi:
"But I'd already ended this story once, so it was hard to figure out how to expand it. That was when Mr. Shinbo suggested, "How about a story with Homura confronting Madoka as an enemy?" I thought, if that's at all permissible, then I'd suddenly have all these options open to me, and that's how the current plot developed.
Now that I look back on it, I think it might have pushed the boundaries of the viewers' sense of morality. I'm sure there are people who view that as a "bad end," and there are probably also people who are more forgiving. I think it's an outcome that straddles that borderline. But people watch because they want to ponder whether the outcome is good or bad, so if they knew from the start that it was either a "happy end" or a "bad end", then there'd be no point in watching it in the first place. And if it's clearly a "bad end", then worse and worse things would occur, and if ten people saw it, all ten of them would be holding their heads in their hands. This film left enough room for interpretation, so it wasn't a "bad end". In that sense, I think it was the kind of film that allowed people to accept whichever outcome they liked — "happy" or "bad"."
From the voice and music team:
Specifically, what kind of direction did you take for the second take, which was the version you decided to go for?
TSURUOKA: Basically, the movie's purpose was to investigate Homura's psychological state, and as more of the story progresses, the more it escalates, until it's honed to a fine point. What I wanted to do was to revert a little to her psychological state near the beginning. The world might see her as evil, but I wanted it to be clear that she was just doing her best. That was what I focused on the most.
>>139504999
Nope. She's second best though.
>>139505054
You don't have to say that about Sayaka.
>>139505084
I know Sayaka is.
>>139505042
She did not become part of the LoC. She soecifically states she is not. Do people listen to dialogue?
>>139505144
What? Yes she did.
>>139505138
I respect your opinion but Sayaka is best.
>>139505202
I respect your opinion, but Kyouko is best.
>>139505144
>She soecifically states she is not
Pay more attention. She states that she still vaguely remembers belonging to the LoC.
>>139498559
She did know that Sayaka would turn into a witch at that point though so it is more of a mercy killing.
>>139496277
The most wrong thing that she did was not writing me into the universe with her
>>139505248
But the title of best girl already belongs to Sayaka.
>>139505202
Man, you aren't as fun as Kevin-kun.
>>139505481
Funny, I see it with Kyouko.
>>139505508
Kevin is shit. SHIT.
>>139505508Not using your trip I seeWhen will you finally admit you want to get into Kevin's pants.
>>139505049I'd like to punish Homura for stealing Madoka's (my) memories.
>>139505144
Sayaka is a part of mine!
>>139505508
Apple. If you say the thing and use the filename, you are obvious.
>>139505618
Lol
>>139505565
He is much more fun than you.
>>139505618
Fine and never.
>>139505556
Sayaka is better.
>>139505748
Kyouko is better.
>>139505565
Also this. What does Apple see in him.
>>139497080
Got anymore cat megucas?
>>139505635
I'd like to see madokami punish homu. A spanking should do the trick, or maybe some public humiliation, or tickle torture, or something like that.
>>139502704
My wife, Homura.
>>139505782
But you are wrong since Sayaka is already best.
>>139505845
Only homu is cat
>>139505712死ね
>>139505872
>>139505799
I don't know!
>>139505913
So why do I feel right? Must be because I am and Kyouko is truly best.
>>139505872
Forgot pic
>>139504453
The power of autism?
>>139506028
>>139506010
But it doesn't feel as right as Sayaka being best girl.
Kyouko is feeling down. What would you do to cheer her up?
>>139506083
Madoka domming Homura is so cute
>>139506157
Of course it doesn't feel as right. It is less right than Kyouko being best girl.
>>139506226
Lots of food.
>>139506226
I'd save and post a picture of her that was not intended for ants
>>139506226
Take her to the arcade, and when we are done there we'll get some icecreme, and I can take her home and run her feet after a long day.
>>139505845
>>139506279
You got that the wrong way. It doesn't feel as right because it's Sayaka who is best girl.
>>139505845
>>139498087
>what does the foot of a dark sorceress taste like?
to Love and Betrayal
>>139505799
Apple is as shit as Kevin.
>>139506010
>I don't know!
I know you don't really like him and you just want your supporters. You were just fighting against him at first.
>>139506226
>>139506279
There is no point giving her an apple.
>>139506270
Yes, yes.
>>139506364
I love you!
>>139505845
>>139506080
If that is how everyone finds them.
>>139506389
Yet it is shown that Kyouko is best.
>>139506526
>>139506438
I guess a Sayaka's fine too.
>>139506270
Has ayane done any fanstuff recently or are they just doing het for pay?
A true Sayakafag wouldsniff her farts
>>139506526
Whoops, not cat.
>>139506550
Who's gonna make you fall in love?
>>139506457
>You were just fighting against him at first
Like kyoko and sayaka?
>>139506675
Yes! Apple and Kevin were enemies with each other at first!
>>139506664
>>139506775
I want to make love to Homura again and again
>>139506816
Are you Madoka?
>>139506775
>ぬくもりをわけあいながらふたりのきょりをちぢめよう
>温もりを分け合いながら、二人の距離を縮めよう
Oh! I was not ready! I love you, !GMeguca.
>>139506664
Not you, ever.
>>139506988
Harsh.
>>139506988
I know this post>>139506775 is yours.
>>139507069
I think I just ntred a tripfag by accident
>>139507069
Nope
Where were YOU when you realized that Homura is a good girl who deserves love?
>>139496277
Existing
I just had a bad dream now!
>>139507272
Nope. This is happening. Even !GM loathes you.
>>139507272
You don't spam KyouSaya, I think you're aight
>>139507407
>>139502983
>>139505872
there are doujins already about that, i think one is called 'GIRLIE'
Only look at this pic if you have no problem with cute magical dinosaurs
>>139508229
What?
>>139506457
>twf you will never be Homura getting dominated by Madokami.
>>139508035
6.022x10^23 years in MS paint
>>139508501
Excellent.
>>139508052
I read girlie, it looked promising until it turned into futa shit
>>139508695
>it looked promising until it turned into futa shit
98% of porny yuri
>>139496277
Disregarding Rebellion, what she did wrong? Because the only thing was not accepting her and Madoka's fate (but we all know that movie was shit so let's forget it).
>>139508868
You mean their fate as witches, once the Incubators repeat their plan with Kyouko and Mami's isolated soul gems?
>>139508695
There is literally nothing wrong with futa, especially MadoHomu futa.
>>139508052
A sequel just popped up on panda too.
>>139508952
I usually hate futa, but for some reason I don't mind it for MadoHomu. I don't understand why.
>>139509049
How else would two girls have sex?
>>139508949
No, their fate as in the true end, aka, the 12 episode, where Madoka is a goddess and she fights the ghosts.
>>139508952
I just can't get off to it. I love dicks, but not on girls.
>>139506775
s-sauce?
>>139509201
Loves dicks, but hates futa.
You are a strange man, anon.
>>139509250
>man
May be part of it.
>>139509126
There is another way you know.
>>139509280
And I never said I /hated/ it. Just can't cum to it. I wouldn't mind some cute sol futa or something.
>>139509234
http://exhentai.org/g/824997/faa588d907/
>>139509317
You would know
>>139501716
Of all the tripfags I've seen come and go you are by far the most autistic in a long fucking time. Please kill yourself
You guys are getting weird now.
>>139509431I said that because I didn't.
>>139507153
Episode 8. Even after Rebellion, she can do no wrong because the others are either insufferable or useless.
>>139509486
>in a long fucking time
He was the most autistic in a span of a month.
>>139509487
I do seem to end up weirding you out whenever I'm in one of these threads. You're so sensitive for someone who clearly spends so much time on 4chan.
Not violently raping Madoka in one of the timelines.
>>139508952
I don't know, personally it just disturbes me and kills my erection. That's just me though. To each his own.
>>139505270
>Kyubey: What are you? Are you part of the Law of Cycles too?
>Sayaka: No, we're more like her private secretaries.
>>139509660
I don't see a "no" in my subs.
>>139509049
Because it's MadoHomu.
>>139509775
They make everything pure.
>>139509907
Anyone who hates MadoHomu has to be a miserable person. Explains why Tumblr is so assmad over it.
Sad blushless edition
>>139510046
Yeah, what even is with that.
>>139510445
So many of them do so because they ship crack and use Rebellion as a reason to push their ships. He who must not be named isn't terribly wrong.
When will I find enjoyment again?
>>139510994
What happened to the days when you could just have fun with crackshipping? Dumblydore and the giant lake squid, I'm secure enough in my crackshipping not to need to knock other people's ships down to make me feel better about my own.
>>139511140
>>139511170
Tonight!
