Why is Yosuga no Sora the greatest love story of all time?
>>139491464
YnS wa really good
But nowadays the whole imouto deal became way too much mainstream that it's boring.
Imouto has became the next childhood friend trope
>>139492007
I welcome this development
>>139492007
As someone just getting into imouto, I don't see a problem with this.
![banner_1399[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/QjHe28r.jpg "banner_1399[1].jpg")
>>139491464
It wasn't even the best incest story.
>>139492150
Go watch Koi Kaze instead.
>>139492576
>Go watch Koi Kaze instead.
Just finished it a couple days ago, was an enjoyable ride.
>>139492576
Koi Kaze is a lot creepier just by the age difference. Rings a bit of abuse of trust.
>>139494487
>Rings a bit of abuse of trust.
I didn't get that vibe, the amount of effort he goes to to push her away dispels it I think.
>>139494487
I read the manga so I don't know if there are any differences, but that's the point of the manga: a love story that breaks multiple taboos, namely incest and age gap.
I liked it but it was too dramatic in my opinion, I guess it can't be helped if you want to portray a brother/sister relationship realistically
>>139492576
Koi Kaze was great. Very convincing drama, didn't feel like it was just pandering to my fetishes.
>>139491464
>codependency
>love story
Also you can't have a love story with what practically is a sex toy.
>>139491464
>2 episodes of incest proceeded by 10 episodes of bullshit
Yeah, no. Also you should just read the VN instead.
YnS had a really comfy setting and OST.
>>139492007
Not at all, name another story where the imouto actually got with the MC, I bet you can count them with your hands, and YnS is shit anyways.
It's the passion between the couple, but still the sequel will never be animated.
>>139492576
this looks intresting.
>>139491464
Because unlike 99% of all other anime, it delivers.
>>139491464
>streaming
>>139491464
Yes!
>>139491464
GENETICALLY
MUTATED
OFFSPRING
>>139496248
>2 episodes of incest proceeded by 10 episodes of bullshit
I liked the first 10 episodes, even if they were getting in the way of the 2 episodes I wanted to watch.
>>139497078
>but still the sequel will never be animated.
Is there even more material?
>>139494839
>namely incest and age gap
You obviously know very little about Japanese culture. The big taboo it broke was talking about divorce. Episode 8 wasn't even aired by some stations because of that.
>>139491464
As a love story it wasn't that great. It basically moves at mach speed as they become a couple the moment they fuck. Their relationship is more assumed than shown. There's not much actual bonding with her, for 10 episodes she's pretty much ignored and then suddenly for the last two episodes she's his fucktoy.
It's good, but I feel like it's only the "greatest love story of all time" because anime that actually has an incest end is rare, so it doesn't have much competition and if incest is your fetish you just need to bear with it.
>>139499241
>for 10 episodes she's pretty much ignored
Jesus fuck, have they shut down the mental hospitals where you live? It's not a linear narrative.
>>139499122
Yes, Haruka na Sora fandisk, with the extension of Sora route plus store owner and class president routes.
>>139499349
No, he has a point. Sora is pretty much a non-character in all of the other routes.
>>139499395
>extension of Sora route
I mean, they already had sex. What else is there left to do for them?Start a family?
>>139499349
You're pretty desperate to be condescending, aren't you?
Even if you think it's fine to ignore Sora entirely because it's not her route, that doesn't change that it felt like they went from 0 to fuck-me-silly-and-call-me-Sally within one episode.
>>139499472
Do you even know what a route is? If I'm in New York and I'm on a route to Chicago, you won't see much of Florida.
>>139499524Yes, actually. It ends with a reveal that Sora is pregnant.
>>139499524
There ismore sex and couple stuff
>you will never have a twin imouto who wants your dick
Why must life be suffering
>>139499557
>You're pretty desperate to be condescending, aren't you?
>>>/mal/
>>>/animesuki/
>>>/ann/
>>139499678
>Damage control
>>139499631
I guess that family arc will require 3 episodesone for each chromosome 21 of their child.
>>139499663
Really, what else more there could be, like for fucking really.
>>139499524
I'd extend it from before they had sex. Add more cuddling andhand-holdingbefore they do the deed.
>>139496056
Will this just end with him being abandoned by all of them?
Yosuga no Sora was great and way underrated. Point.
Liked it even though I actually hated this different routes stuff.
>>139499195
Tell me again how the other two are acceptable then
>>139494487
I prefer large age differences. The innocence/experience gap is thrilling.
>>139496056
>>139500365
Fuck off crossboarding cuck.
>>139501013
>/a/ hates ntr
loser and old
>>139499195
>The big taboo it broke was talking about divorce. Episode 8 wasn't even aired by some stations because of that.
Wait really? That seems hilarious to me.
>>139491464
Because it's the ultimate middle finger towards societal normality, following your hearts desires and just doing what/who you want. Same reason why a percentage of the population wants a zombie apocalypse to occur.
>>139501991
Following your penis is not following your heart, but ok.
>>139496056
Shotacon impregnating tall women has always been my fetish. Sauce?
>>139492007
Laughable post. YnS is just soft core fodder and nothing else.
Stop.
>>139492007
There really aren't that many imouto endings in anime.
Aki sora was better
>>139502132
>Aki Sora
>better than anything
>>139502132
It was more realistic, yeah.
>>139502132
Aki Sora is god awful and I'm glad the government killed it.
Best winning imouto right here.
Never forget imoutits.
>>139496056
Look at those rediculous tits. Seriously this is just stupid, why would that even turn anyone on?
>>139502421
Killed how? It's been a while since I read it, but as far as I can recall it was complete?
>>139502813
It was pulled by the magazine because of new obscenity laws, I think.
>>139502813
If by complete you mean it has a terrible ending, then yes.
>>139494487
I like that it's more morose if not creepyThe complications of incest are ignored and mollified by Oreimo and Yosuga No Sora.
>>139502813
they stopped production of its reprints
>>139502132
How could it be with such a shit ending?
>>139502926
>>139503057
>being this salty
They decide to respect their parents will, plus constant inbreeding will lend to defective offspring, it was realistic.
>>139491464
Omnibus done right. Even though there were multiple paths they all served to build up the main route from different angles, effectively conveying the VN experience in anime form. The general production quality was also surprisingly good. It gets underrated a lot because its subject matter blinds people (both for moralistic and fetishistic reasons) to the anime's merits.
>>139503234
>salty
Back to twitch with you.
>>139503234
>>139502282
If I wanted realism I'd read the news.
>>139502927
>The complications of incest are ignored and mollified by Oreimo
Do tell.
>>139503234
Spoil me, Senpai. Is this an incest anime where the parents go fucking batshit?
>>139502927
>>139494487
>creepy
Am I on tumblr or what?
>>139503319
Watch Koi Kaze in comparison, because of the age gap more is taken into consideration. Yosuga No Sora they just romp for a bit.
Oreimo they kept trying to pass it off as done once they kissed.
![koi-kaze-1[1].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/3kxQDkb.jpg "koi-kaze-1[1].jpg")
>>139503516
Adding a bit of creepiness is the risk and taboo of the subject otherwise you just have a boring romance.
Where's the fun and tension otherwise?
>>139503700
Risk and taboo is hot, not creepy.
>>139502646
no blood relation does not count
>>139503584
I'm not talking about a comparison, definitely Koi Kaze issues were more complicated than the other series mainly for the age gap, but
>The complications of incest are ignored and mollified by Oreimo
They have to deal with that shit for a whole 12 volumes and took a lot of hard work from both Kirino and Kyousuke to end up in the relationship they are now, it wasn't easy, and is not easy, society will still look at them like scum, but they are smart enough to know how to deal with that.
And I didn't see any kind of dilemma on YnS.
>Man, I want to fuck my sister, but that's wrong, so no no
>a week later
>Man, screw this, I really want to fuck my sister, come with papa
Why arent there other anime like YnS? Its like no one else wants to take the risk of actually showing sex in an anime.
>>139504083
Go back to watching your dubs, cancer.
>>139503878
Right, but without it being portrayed as slightly creepy in the media itself it comes off as too dull for me.
>>139504062
I felt with Oreimo it was too perky, I'm a sour sod.
YnS was trash in the greatest Danny DeVito sense.
>>139504083
Speed Grapher was crap.
>>139502421
>>139504030
I'd rather pretend that implication never existed.
>>139504030
I understand it was only like that in the PS2 version.
>>139502076
He gets NTR'd in the end, so fair warning, but the first chapter/arc is good. I don't know the title of it but there is usually always a thread on /h/ about it.
>>139504684
What is it with shota doujins and NTR
What kind of heartless piece of shit would NTR a shota
that?
>>139504788
The same thing that it's with MILFs and NTR.
They are all connected.
>>139504806
NOPE
NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE
>>139504062
>it wasn't easy, and is not easy, society will still look at them like scum
Except it doesn't. At the end of the series 4 people know about Kyousuke and Kirino but no one seems disgusted at all. Koi Kaze was much more realistic in comparison.
In YnS it's not that unbelievable that they both gave in quickly. They're two teenagers living alone and dealing with the sudden loss of both the parents. Until the rep walks in on them it was as if they were living outside the society that would have looked at them in contempt.
>>139504806
>snuff and cp
By the gods.
>>139492007
Except it's still mostly NBR which is almost the same as a childhood friend.
>>139506032
Good lord, read my post again, also there are more than just 4 people that know about their relationship and all of them are the people close to them, they are family, and it took a long way to get them to understand and accept who they are(not just talking about their relationship), is not like they start making out in front of their class or some shit like that.
>>139504030
>Not reading the VN where they are BR.
The imoutits is a god tier imouto.
>>139506530
>there are more than just 4 people
That's right, I forgot one: Kuroneko, Saori, Saori's sister, Sena and Manami.
>family
Surely you're not implying their parents know about them?
>it took a long way to get them to understand and accept who they are(not just talking about their relationship)
The only ones who had a clue about their feelings before the confession were Kuroneko and Manami, maybe Saori too, but even so for 90% of the story Kyousuke and Kirino are trying to admit their feelings and then gathering the courage to confess.
After the confession (which, by the way, would have pretty much the same effect of them making out in public in real life ) the only person who had a believable reaction was Manami. I can't seriously take the others' reaction as realistic, because it isn't, and it's not the point of the story to portray one either.
>>139507433
.cont
The only time they actually have to deal with society is when Manami confronts them. All the other people are like "eh, whatever"
>>139504806
I feel dumb, it taken me a minute to remember these too then I laughed heartily.
>>139506609
She's also the canon end girl
>>139503234
If it were written better I'd maybe accept it, but its clear that it was rushed, the ending is so sudden and out of no where.
>>139491464
its a story about taking advantage of someones debilitating psychological problems but with a healthy dose of vanilla on top of it to hide that fact
>>139508123
>it's always the man's fault
They both wanted it
>>139506032
>At the end of the series 4 people know about Kyousuke and Kirino but no one seems disgusted at all
>What is Manami?
Also, remember that Saori and Kuroneko are degenerates, looking at /a/ I don't think its absolutely outlandish to say that they wouldn't be 100% opposed to the idea, they're degenerates.
>>139507433
>That's right, I forgot one: Kuroneko, Saori, Saori's sister, Sena and Manami.
Kuroneko, Saori, Kaori, Manami, Ayase, Daisuke, Sakurai, Mikagami, Kanako, and not 100% sure about Sena.
>Surely you're not implying their parents know about them?
You have the worst reading comprehension I have seen this week, kudos.
>The only ones who had a clue about their feelings before the confession were Kuroneko and Manami, maybe Saori too, but even so for 90% of the story Kyousuke and Kirino are trying to admit their feelings and then gathering the courage to confess.
And this is where I stop replying to you, there wasn't any romantic feelings beforehand, nobody was trying to admit any feeling towards each other, it's just after volume 9 that they start feeling something more than just normal love, before that they were just getting back all the time lost for their grudge, making up their minds and starting a renew relationship, the whole resolution at the end was shocking but it made sense for everything that they go through.
>After the confession (which, by the way, would have pretty much the same effect of them making out in public in real life ) the only person who had a believable reaction was Manami. I can't seriously take the others' reaction as realistic, because it isn't, and it's not the point of the story to portray one either.
You gonna need to be more detailed here if you want another reply. Are you trying to say that you wanted everyone to pursuit them after the confession? Tell me a reason why they would and I shut up, they are their friends and again, it took a long path for them to accept it, just imagine the old Ayase hearing about it. The only "believable"(so you say) you are talking about was from the only person against their relationship. I agreed that is not the point of the story, but the prejudice it's always there.
>>139508123
Poor Sora, she doesn't know anything better in life. If only they had a gardener or someone else close to them to help her to move forward.
>>139508123
She was masturbating to the thought of him before he even considered an incestuous relationship. Besides, she was the one who initiated it Unless you're trying to say being a good brother is "taking advantage" of her.
>>139502046
Sometimes it is, anon.
I know it's useless and you're all sick deformed products of incest but this is very wrong in all ways possible and you should NOT fuck your sister. Other people sister's is fine.
>>139491464
REMOVE
IMOUTONao a best, incest-fags be damned.
>>139509741
I want to fuck anon sister.
>>139509792
Akira is easily the best non-imouto followed by Ojou.
>>139509792
This. Nao is so best it hurts. Not-the-sister is always best.
>>139509879
This thread doesn't deserve 50 posters
>>139509456
thats like saying shooting up with and buying heroin for an addict is the right thing to do because you care about them
>>139510356
What if I like heroin too? What then anon?
>>139498346
Sibling incest does double the chance of genetic defect. From 3% to 6%, presuming no dominant illnesses (which would transfer no matter who you made babies with).
So, you still have a 94% chance of a normal kid. European royalty had to interbreed for several generations before serious problems sprang up.
Blood related or not, I want to see this semen demon tenderly loved by her onii-chan.
>>139511754
I want a reverse NBR bad.
>>139512061
>reverse NBR
Like, they think they are just step-siblings, proceed to fall in love just to then discover they are actually related?
>>139511754
Is this any good? I mean its NBR so its already dead in the water, but besides that is it okay?
>>139512275
Yes, just like how NBR drops in at the end.
>>139512275
Yes. And because of that they fall deeper in love since they now know that they also have the same flesh and blood. Can't get more romantic than that.
>>139512497
>Yes. And because of that they fall deeper in love since they now know that they also have the same flesh and blood. Can't get more romantic than that.
Anon please, too lewd.
>>139491464
Someone post the explanation on how all the episodes before the Sora arc were important for charactization
>>139514494
>>139514927
Not that anon, but thanks.
True hero of the series coming through.
>>139510356
Can you explain to me how you made that far of a reach?
>>139519769
Not that anon, but I can see his point.
Sora's love for Haru is a pretty unhealthy obsession. So even if she initiated all of it, doesn't mean he should enable her to continue this behavior, just like when you find out a friend is a junkie you shouldn't buy him more drugs.
Don't mean to reign on anyone's purity or innocent parade, but Haru fucked her not only to take care of her, but for his own gain as well, since he's pretty hot for his sister. This is probably what he meant when he said he took advantage of her psychological problems, aka her extremely dependent obsession, which you should usually try to treat if you intend to live a healthy life.
That said, it's just a 2D story that caters to my fetishes, so I don't really mind. What I wrote only applies to 3D and I doubt anyone would try to take any life lessons from YnS.
>>139492576
I haven't watched Koi Kaze but I read it. It was ok, very serious approach. But I wanted something that has both drama AND "action".
Pic related, Rika was promising but the author chickened out and suspended it.
>>139519111
Trips confirm. Also, are there any other shows that have this line?
>>139520545
Sora is a sickly girl who latched onto the only thing she could love when trapped in her hospital. I liked in the anime Haru was equally attracted to Sora.
>>139521834
You are supporting what he said though.
>>139522614
It's true.
>>139491464
Is this the one where they fuck in the front door hallway and they get walked in on by their friends?
>>139504806
Are those the ones from Shakugan no Shana? They were hot as fuck. Tongue kissing in public.
>>139520978
Yes, I've seen it posted a couple times but not sure what the others are.
>>139502076
It's not what you think.
>>139520545
>That said, it's just a 2D story that caters to my fetishes, so I don't really mind. What I wrote only applies to 3D and I doubt anyone would try to take any life lessons from YnS.
I understand the idea behind this sentence and even agree to a degree. But I also understand when someone wants to criticize works for this kind of shit.
That said, I don't fully agree with that anon you're explaining, but I may just be blinded by the purest form of love.
>>139491464
Nah that's oreimo
>>139525084
Then what is it?
>>139525248
As long as imouto wins its a contender.
>>139499395
>class president route
No. The whole point of her and her character is that she was never an option, no matter how much she pined.
