Now that the dust has settled, let's rate this show.
http://strawpoll.me/7235120
6/10, I mean it was good but nothing that will make me remember this show down the line.
>>139359888
I can't in good faith give it a full 7. I'd give it a 6.5 if I could, but 6/10 will do.
Started weak, ended great. Last 2 episodes were easy 8/10s.
2/10
Fucking shit trash. Only good thing was the animation.
Aside from pretty colors and animation, the show was garbage. Shitty plot, shitty pacing and shitty writing. 4/10.
>>139359888
It's hard to rate since the writing and direction were generally terrible but the presentation was great enough to carry the show. It's a genuinely bad show that I enjoyed from start to finish because of what it did right.10/10 AOTS
>>139359888
7/10 AOTS
Originally 6/10 but the final 3 episodes bumped it up for me. They were just really good.
Final Score: 7/10
>People rating shows based on predetermined criteria instead of criteria based on the purpose and spirit of the show
It's like you don't want to enjoy things
>>139360400
>things Phantom World tried to do
>funny comedy
>episodic structure
>things you're judging Phantom World from
>writing
>overarching plot
I don't think you understand
>>139360848
Go cry on MAL about it faggot
>>139361008
The comedy was garbage.
Hopefully KyoAni will realize their animation can't carry a show alone after this.
>>139361044
You're garbage, kudasai.
It wasn't anything good story wise, but 8/10, and easily AOTS since everything else was shit
Also I never had a good relationship with my mother so it appealed to me
>>139361129
>Also I never had a good relationship with my mother so it appealed to me
Thread over.
>>139361129
If nothing else they managed to do well to make the viewer sympathize with the cardboard-cutout characters.
>>139361129
It's Kyoani, so I rated it 10/10, but then downgraded to 9/10.
Seems like everyone but the extremists who just hate kyoani on principle agree that it was a nice solid "ok".
>>139361250
Dropped it at episode 6. Did it get better?
It was 7/10, last eps 11~13 were the best moments on the anime.
>>139361424
No.
6/10 watchable in a bad season
>>139359888
>putting a poll in the OP so people that didn't even watch it in full can just give a random low score for their own amusement
Anon, please.
>>139361790
It was nice background noise.
7/10. Would have been a solid 4/10 if not for ep. 11.
>>139361129
I feel the same.
Why is there no other nonsexual /ss/ anime
7, I liked it enough that I would rewatch it.
Solid 6.5/10.
it had great potential but it was wasted so 5/10
>>139361424
Retard, episode 7 is the turning point for the show. It improves considerably after the loli episode. Pick it back up now.
Not that bad just a bit boring but girls are cute
7/10 just for her
>>139365490
I want to commit a crime
>>139365866
Same, I want tosteal her bear
>>139366037
I want to cum inside AlbrechtIn front of her
>>139359888
6/10
Weak start and weak finale.
>>139365866
I want to her to sit on my lap while I rub her young legs
10/10 IGN
>>139366140
Got to assert your dominance over her and Albrecht.
>>139359888
>people unironically rating this 8+
Tempted to give it 8/10 but I'll go with 7/10 instead.
Most underrated show this season, easy AOTS for me.
>>139359888
>captcha
Fuck you shithead.
5/10
7/10. Koito and Ruru best girls.
>>139359888
7/10
Some episodes were pretty enjoyable.
>>139359888
7/10
Thank God they didn't went edgy LN route.
>>139368894
>edgy LN route
How did the LN get edgy then?
>>139366707
I'd rank it 7/10 as well. Not bad but there were certainly better shows. AOTS for me goes either to BokuDake or KonoSuba. I know they're direct opposites as far as tone is concerned, but bot did their respective thing better than any other show this season.
>>139369019
Novelanon posted a pastebin with Vol 2 spoilers and anime-original changes in the last thread.
>rating this show above a 5
Terrible characters, shitty humor for most of the time, bland designs and music. Too many miss episodes for the small good ones it had (2, 3 at most). Easily the most overrated show this season I expected more from Kyoani.
4/10
Solid 7/10 to be honest
Mai made it 10/10 for me. She is so perfect.
>>139369050
I see. Could you please repost that pastebin?
Let us see
>Characters are bland and one dimensional
>Character designs are terrible
>Episodic plot that doesn't work to captivate the viewer's interest because the characters are too flat and the general premise isn't anything special
>Show banks on the comedy, even though the show isn't funny in the least
>Music is average
>Visuals and animation are superb
4.5/10 because the opening was decent and the visually this show is that good, otherwise it is below average in all other aspects.
I gave it a 8.
It's a low 8 though.
>>139370074
There's no such thing as a low 8.
Cute girls, flashy animation, would have enjoyed it more if it had remembered to have a plot the entire time but instead we got two pretty satisfying ending episodes after 10 episodes of directionless nonsense.
6/10 - worthwhile waste of time
Ishihara's gotta find a good fantasy manga or novel to adapt next.
5/10
No change in the characters at all, plot took ages to start and when it did it was lackluster, looked pretty and all but step it up Kyoani.
>>139370153
Then just an 8.
>>139359888
2/10, it was god awful. Had a more fun time watching SAO.
I am just salty af that mai didn't win the harubowl
>pic related
>>139370338
BTFO
I bothered calculating the current average vote, it's 5.73. Still too high.
>>139370431
Slightly above average. No it will suffice and is a much better representation of the anime score.
>>139370260
>No change in the characters at all
There's change, it's just very minimal and its idea of giving them more characterization was to introduce more cliches.
>>139370431
Too low. It should be 7.53.
>>139370431
You can probably thank the fact that most people vote 7 as an "ok" instead of a 5.
>>139370460
>>139370260
You say no characterization all i read is
>can't into subtlety
Fuck you and him, go consume more of your idol-moe shit, the day you develop a taste and the ability to read between the lines or use critical analysis will be the day pigs fly.
>>139370471
this garbage show doesn't deserve more than 6
>>139370654
>You say no characterization
I said the exact opposite, you idiot. There's nothing subtle about Phantom World.
![[HorribleSubs] Musaigen no Phantom World - 13 [720p].mkv_snapshot_14.03_[2016.03.31_17.00.34].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/4IpXrxP.jpg "[HorribleSubs] Musaigen no Phantom World - 13 [720p].mkv_snapshot_14.03_[2016.03.31_17.00.34].jpg")
5/10 for Mai's red panties
>>139370696
You don't deserve more than an execution. Sub-human garbage.
>>139370696
>6
>garbage
>>139361790
>My favourite show shouldn't be rated on a random poll by people who didn't enjoy it, only by those who finished it and usually visit the thread
>>139370766
There's no hyphen in subhuman, subhuman.
>>139370744
> I am not smart enough to see.
> Therefore it doesn't exist
Self-Disembowelment is really the only way.
>>139370744
The characterization and world building is pretty low key.
>>139370809
>Look at this guy he can't into grammar what a shitter XDDD
Sudoko plz
>>139370812
What world are you living in? In what way is there any characterization in this shitty show? Amuse me and give the jist of your argument.
>>139370861
Plz isn't a word, subhuman.
>>139370654
There's no lines to read between and no depth to analyse, it's a pleb show and if you actually see more in it than good animation and fan service then you're probably autistic.
>>139370812
Are you being stupid on purpose, or is that an actual rebuttal despite you clearly not understanding my post?
>>139370858
I really don't think so. Sure, it didn't put giant bright signs on the screen to direct your attention, but this show is anything but low-key.
>>139370918
You watch dagashit, i am sure you wouldn't know a plot if it hit you on the head with an anvil.
>>139370919
No you just think its ''cliche'' shit, that's how i know you have the intellectual capacity of a goldfish.
>>139370858
I really liked how subtle the buildup and foreshadowing was.
>>139371024
All right, so you're an idiot who can't read. Good to know.
Favorite Kyoani show?
>>139371090
I can read, you just lack comprehension, no wait for you its comprehenshit because that's all you could possibly understand with that slab of fat you call a brain.
Characters were okay, visuals and OST were best of the season.
The episodic plots ranged from very mediocre to great.
So I gave it a 7/10, a bit better than average.
>MAL reviews: 6.98/10
>/A/ most option voted: 7/10
ha
>>139371072
Too bad Reina became nothing after her episode because her memory was rewritten by phantoms.
>>139371150
You thought I said the opposite of what I wrote and then went on a mini tirade about "idol moe-shit." Either you're a hasty and overly emotional faggot, or you're an idiot. Probably both.
>>139371241
Ill explain it in a way that your peanut for a brain can understand.
The first guy said there was no characterization, you said that there was but that it was very little and cliche, i proceeded to chew both of you out for not being able to see what was there.
The only part that wasn't ''clear'' about my response when i didn't add to my first sentence ''You say little to no characterization''.
That's it, the rest is just insulting you for not being able to see whats there.
>>139371447
>there was no characterization
No, he said there was no character development. This confirms that you're an idiot. Is English your first language?
>>139371513
English isn't my first language and even if it were, this is just arguing semantics. characterization is showing and telling you who a character is, while character development is change, growth etc.. I get that. I just don't see the necessity to separate them In this discussion.
>>139370968
Dagashi is shit and I dropped it halfway through, and so is Phantom World, posting pictures from a show doesn't mean I like it.
>>139371598
>Backpedaling
How about shutting the fuck up and not exposing your stupidity more than necessary?
>>139371626
I'd call you cancer, but cancer is at least useful at combating over population.
>>139359888
8/10. I had a lot of fun with it, KyoAni did a great job with the animation and overall design and I liked that we all delved into the characters Psychology a bit.
>>139371661
Who backpedaled you inbred? I stand by my statements.
>>139371661
#rekt
>>139371702
Someone who thinks Phantom World is deep is more cancerous than anything I can imagine friend.
How anyone can give this show more than 5/10 after that abomination of a final episode is beyond me.
Instead of hinting at the universe destruction they settle it with a fucking Deus ex Machina.
>Enigma can kiss people to steal their power
>Haruhiko can for some unexplained reason kiss Ruru and merge their powers which for some reason are even stronger than his own
What a fucking mess.
>>139371214
do the math
the average on /a/ is 5, worse than MAL
>>139371769
>How anyone can give this show more than 5/10
Because pic related.
>>139371739
>I get the difference between the terms and see that you purposely differentiated the two, but I'll act like an blathering idiot until called out multiple times and then cry "semantics"
So are you backpedaling, or backpedaling and stupid, or just an idiot?
>>139371850
Still doesn't explain why he even could merge with Ruru and the way they hand-waved that shit was insulting.
>"Just try doing what enigma did"
>It just works
If it was given some fucking foreshadowing then sure, but nothing gave us the impression that he could merge with Ruru while also being powerless himself.
it looked nice. but its rather forgettable because the episodic format so all you're really going to remember is the characters.
>>139371899
Never mind fuck this, congrats i concede.
>>139359888
6, the weakest Kyoani show ever.
>>139371975
The characters were boring and generic so there's really nothing to remember.
I'm just pretty upset Enigma didn't get a happy ending.
>>139359888
6/10, aside of a good fap this series had no meaning to exist, it looked pretty.
![snapshot_00.14.55_[2016.03.31_07.29.04].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/0blt1Ep.jpg "snapshot_00.14.55_[2016.03.31_07.29.04].jpg")
>>139372706
But at least she died happily.
>>139361424
Don't blame you, it only get sightly good at episode 9.
>>139372477
Mai will always hold a special place in my heart no matter what you say.
>>139373362
Until Spring anime get into gear.
I want to hatefuck Harumom.
>>139373616
I haven't found a girl with more desirable traits, how could I ever forget her?
>>139359888
4/10, shallow, pretentious, boring. Had a single episode with a somewhat interesting premise, still managed to play it safe and be generic as possible. Having the MC literally narrate the most stale, overused psychological concepts in fiction at me was patronising. Animation has that KyoAni sheen and smoothness, but the cinematography and technique itself was subpar for any show, and especially bad given this studio's usual level of mastery. It's shit.
>>139373955
That's version 3.0 you've taken a liking to.
May I interest you in the original version 1.0?
>>139373989
>cinematography and technique itself was subpar for any show
It was miles ahead of any show this season, and probably every show barring Eupho last year as well.
>>139374088
Too buggy.
>>139370338
>>139370424
both of them BTFO by best girl!!!
>>139374088
>No martial arts and fitness enthusiast
>No hourglass figure
>No motherly disposition
Think I pass.
>>139374088
Version 3.0's got a shitty design, hope 4.0 is better.
>>139374265
Then surely the second edition suits your needs the most! Who's to say she's not motherly, when she does not bully random little girls, which is a bug recently discovered on the third version?
>>139374344
Her design is cute.
>>139374492
Too kuudere for me. Being genki is another very important trait, you see.
>>139359888
4/10. That's the best I can do.
>>139374492
A better version of 2.0 is in the works.
>>139359888
5.5/10. It was just okay.
Shinkas are constantly improved with every new release. Version 4 will be expected to break all sales records, combined.
>>139374797
Violet is an ex-soldier. I wonder how strong she is.
>>139361148
My dick needs the right half of it.
>>139374797
Shinkas needs long flowing hair dammit, I'm cancelling my preorder
>>139359888
Dropped/10
>>139375006
This one's neater and high class.
>>139359888
4/10
It was extremely dull for a comedy show.
Would've rate it lower if it isn't for Ruru.
7/10
I didn't like it at first but towards the end it really picked up and I ended up really liking the show, would love a season 2.
I hope people soil don't think that a 7 is an score for an average as fuck show.
I have it a 5.
Good animation and good fanservice but plot only in the last two episode.
Too little, too late
5/10
Which model version is this from?
it speaks volumes about the state of anime when people are giving this 7s and 8s
>>139359888
last two episodes were good but overall this series was terrible. way below kyoani standards.
>>139375726
This is the wallpaper model.
>>139375166
Science went too far.
Give it a 7 just for the fact that they were able to keep constantly good animation quality throughout the series despite being a monster of the week type show. It was something good to zone out too.
>>139375166
cute
I always wondered why anime goes "dark", like in change of lighting, when they apply some kind of special effects.
Like in this scene for example:
https://sakuga.yshi.org/data/10501d6efd695fbe7d091a3157a1065c.mp4
>>139371904
What was good with this show was how they didn't bother to explain anything. Noone cares anyway, if you're trying to analize it, it wasn't for you.
>>139369704
Not the anon you were replying to, but here:
http://pastebin.com/Z2W3UTw2
7/10 means shit in millennial speak.
>>139378308
They started doing that recently. It's to prevent seizures or something.
6-10. Average as fuck with a cucked MC.
>>139378308
Wasn't it because of Porygon?
>>139359888
1 cuz kyo anus
>>139378308
I always thought it was intentional for atmosphere.
>>139378581
You can't be serious.
>>139378602
Yeah, but that's over a decade ago and PW isn't exactly targeting that audience. I never noticed something like that with SHAFT for example.
>>139378594
>a cucked MC
What?
>>139359888
7/10
Only because it gave us delicious brown mini girl for doujin material.
>>139359888
Where's the 0/10 option?
>>139378656
http://anime.stackexchange.com/a/5334
>>139379584
Huh, thanks. That's kind of retarded, sasuga nippon.
>>139359888
5/10 just for the animation and ep11. Weak plot, weak comedy and weak development, and you all know it.
At least ABP had that "meme magic", we got some hilarious webms, gifs, threads, etc out of it and Sento and the fairies were god tier.
>>139379232
Even you know it isn't 0/10.
>>139379773
How is it retarded?
>>139379773
What would be even more retarded is having another 700 seizures on your hand because you couldn't learn from a national incident.
>>139360153
Enigma arc was fucking stupid. If they had devoted an entire season to it it would have been fine.
I hate when studios do this shit. Just commit to being stupid fun fan service show instead of trying to tack on a story in the last 2 episodes.
>>139380555
There's been a story all along, you just didn't get it
>>139380555
I don't know how low an IQ one has when they can't even read a story in this haremshit.
>>139380555
Yeah, I hate it when studios adapt things too.
