>Kyubey is evil
Evil? Saving the universe is evil?
Humanity is dumb and foolish, i see.
Not only the girls chose those powers, they are not affected in any way aside from having to protect a gem around.
Not only Kyubey makes them a fair contract for a wish, he gives them inmunuty to most diseases and physical trauma.
"But they are human beings!"
Who cares? We are just another species.
Six of them getting their inmature asses killed doesnt matter at all!
"Evil", "evil", "evil"
Is everything white or black with you people?
Now, he and his entire race are getting brutally tortured by a 26 year old pedophile.
Did he deserve this?
shut up qb
It's not a fair contract. He doesn't tell them that they have to keep killing witches or they become one.
>>139330147
>implying saving the universe is good
All things must come to an end some day.
>>139330572
They didnt ask.
>>139330463
Make me, you're no Homura.
But the cubes started the unending circle of despair. Without cubes there would not be witches.
His plan was kinda stupid.
I mean, he is preventing Heat Death, but is also creating invincible abominations like Kriemhild that would presumably haunt the universe after destroying their home planet.
>>139330718
Wait! I don't remember the Cubes to develop a plan to save universe. I remember they needed a form of energy for themselves. And Kriemhild is the specular force born from Maduka becoming a Megiuca, when it had the time to destroy cubes' planet?
EXPLAIN PLEASE!
>>139330147
>fair contract for a wish
A contract that does not explicitly state the terms and conditions of said agreement is open to legal challange. A contract in which a party knowingly omits cruicial information from the terms and conditions and which is negotiated in bad faith is not a contract and thus is subject to be voided.
>>139331171
Well, it is a bit naive to have granted a wish for nothing. No girls asked what is the compensation for the wish while Cube always talked about to subscribe a contract. This isn't bad faith, it is plain idiocy from girls part.
The only excusable one is the blond one who has to subscribe the contract to save her life. The same goes for Madoka when subscribed the contract during the Walpurgis night.
>>139331409
You mean to say that the only excusable one is the underaged one.Oh wait, that's all of them. They're all actual kids in very stressful circumstances. It would be the shittiest of shot writing of they handles things like mature, reasonable adults.
>>139331409
Dude, they are fucking early teens, they don't know shit about life, you tell them they can have something nobody else can and they're gonna want it, especially if they can help people along the way.
>Hey girl, I'm gonna give you super powers to fight evil AND make one of your wishes come true
It sounds like all good to a girl. And it's not like the girls didn't think about it and asked questions. But Kyubey can dodge points easily and remained vague when it suited it.
>>139331409
The girls are already told that death is part of the deal. However, they are not told how they will die, nor why their wishes are being granted in the first place.
>Q: Where do Witches come from?
>A: If Magical Girls are born from hopes, Witches are born from despair.
This omits crucial information and because he himself created the system in which witches are born from magical girls, he is acting in bad faith.
>>139330960
Incubators needed that energy to prevent heat death, or so says Kyubei.
And the production of energy inevitably produced stronger and stronger witches, that required stronger and stronger Mahou Shoujo. So, there is no way his plan doesn't destroy the Earth.
>>139330147
Kyubey was handed a system by Madoka in which he could stave off entrophy and not be a dick to magical girls. He instead opted to try and capture the law of cycles. Homura, admitting he has a purpose in the universe, chose not to genocide the Incubator race and instead enslaved them as punishment for their deeds and now forces them to do their job under her watch. Kyubey is the greedy fuck who messed everything up, or did you miss the first hour and forty minutes of Rebellion?
>>139330147
I think they did well in making him hard to understand as a human. You sort of see where he's coming from, but it just doesn't feel right.
Go to bed, Kyubey.
What Kyubey was doing was a moral wrong but a utilitarian good. The problem of whether he "should have" done what he did is unsolvable because entirely different types of value are conflicting each other.
>>139331784
I didn't remember the heat death of the universe. In this case HyperCube did nothing wrong: if the suffering of a small number of naive and selfish bitches can grant time to the life in the universe than it is the right choose. Not ethically acceptable, because teens, but without any doubt the right one.
Now I like Incubator.
>>139330147
>>139330147
>makes a contract
but that contract is invalid since you let an underage girl sign it without the consent of her parents
>>139330147
Kyubey was a libertarian
That is as evil as you can get
>>139330147
Moral relativism bullshit. If you're a starving man and someone makes you an omelette, that person is "good" in your eyes, right? But if you're one of the eggs that was broken to make said omelette, you have every right to view that same person as "evil".
It's literally as simple as that. Kyubey, by being willing to sacrifice the planet Earth and all who inhabit it, no matter what the reasoning behind it, means that every creature on Earth has the absolute, unquestionable right to view him as "evil" and if you're one of those people and you do not, you are an idiot who probably votes against your own interests every election cycle.
>>139330147
>evil
depend of your moral guideline
>implying you can judge everything in black and white
>>139334004
>interestellar legal issues
I want to see this
>>139331171
well, the part "living for kill witches" is explicit, the problem come when the girls don't think that is literal
Nice tumblr gif OP.
>>139330147
If you wanna see the world in this terms, everyone is evilish and core rotten
>>139335252
>it's only morally good if it serves me and / or my kind
>>139336405
>I'm such a beta cuck, please rape my ass as long as you tell me it's for the "greater good" first
>doesn't understand morality
>has no compassion
Lmao highest form of intelligence in the universe my ass
>>139336773
Not condoning the little rat, but I think his argument was that morality and compassion were, in themselves, illogical constructs born of emotional, inferior minds.
>>139336105
Wow! Nice eagle eye! Thank god Anon #139336105 was here to point this out! Everyone cares very much!
>>139336763
>sacrificing a speck of the universe in exchange for the well being of the rest of existence is "evil"
>realizing that the choosing of a different species to contract would lead to even more deaths as a result of inefficiency makes you a "beta cuck"
Why should a minority try and bring the majority down with them, especially if they're going to die either way? One way, they die out but the universe lives on. The other, they linger on for a hike longer, but eventually still die out, along with the rest of the universe. Doesn't that sound a bit selfish?
Of all the things I didn't like about Rebellion, turning Kyubey into a straight-up villain was the worst.
>>139337561
Why is it the minority's obligation to pay the price for a situation they did not cause? The majority by definition has contributed far more to the problem than any minority has, they should pay their own price.
Isn't imposing your will upon a minority just because you can and it's expedient to do so the literal definition of evil?
>>139336894
And the desire to survive indefinitely isn't?
>>139337110
Thanks, I thought that Global Rule 6 is underforced, so seeing a kindred spirit in these wretched lands fills my heart with fuzzy feelings.
>>139336773
He's literally autistic.
>>139340053
Stupid idiot.
Human values are irrelevant to HyperCube. Actually its species is trying to save the entire universe.
Talk about morality, by human standards, and compassion, in a state of crisis, is beyond stupid.
Actually only an idiot is not able to see how the big picture of the things is so similar to our life: the suffering of a little number of beings for the best outcome of the majority. This mechanism rules our world and affects our everyday life without someone stops one second about it.
You are only a bunch of sad faggots.
>>139341250
Bump
>>139341250
You're making a huge, HUGE assumption that Kyubey- a known liar- is even telling the truth about their work to prevent the supposed heat death of the universe. Taking the words of an amoral alien that has absolutely no regard for you or your people, to the point of even being happily willing to throw your entire species off a cliff because it tells you to, is what a real stupid idiot would do.
Feel free to die like a dog for anyone who asks you to, by all means. Just don't impose your retardation upon those around you.
>>139330147
Nice try, QB. We all know it's you.
>>139341759
The heat death of the universe is, you know, a probable thing. There are many theories about the end of the universe but what is 100% sure is that humanity at the moment doesn't have tools and knowledge to be even remotely correct about it.
An Ayylium species able to come here has surely something more and better than us in this department, not considering they found a way to transform emotion in energy and grant wishes... actually they are gods.
And btw Incubator's attitude is to omitt informations, not to blatantly lie like humans use to.
You are a sad little pathetic hypocritical thing.
>>139342161
>Oh boy, I can't wait for this knowledgeable alien to ram his marshmallow feline cock up my ass
This is literally what you sound like. You have some kind of death fetish, but instead of just offering yourself you want everyone on your planet to die with you. If we don't have enough knowledge to be "even remotely correct about something", then why, like a dumb faggot, do you assume we're even correct about said thing's existence at all? Kyubey could be here simply to harvest power for its own purposes, and bothered to take a few seconds to look in a science journal and go "Yep, I'll just say it's because of that dumbass "heat death" or whatever theory lol"
You're dumb enough to sign up for euthanasia at the drop of a hat- just off yourself and cut out the middle man.
>>139342660
What you stupid sad cunt forget is that only naive selfish underage bitches have to perish. Not the whole world.
Actually that stupid cunteater Homura found a way to create the basis for Kriemhild to even exist and put the whole world in danger.
About knowledge: scientist hypothesized about gravitational waves at least 50 years ago; we were able to verify that hypothesis only recently. Meanwhile it was used as a piece of a jigsaw finding its place in the big picture.
The same goes for other theories: at the moment we don't have tools to verify them.
Stop being this insufferable whiteknight count. Magical girls don't exist. They don't need your help. Let them die like the sluts they chose to be.
become Meguca
>>139345651
what happens if i do
Why is Kyubey invading 4chan?
>>139330147
>Now, he and his entire race are getting brutally tortured by a 26 year old pedophile.
How exactly did you come to the conclusion that Homura is 26? I don't remember the number of times she went backwards in time ever having been stated so its kinda like you're bullshitting.
>>139345709
sool jim no longer turn to greef sid
>>139345769
100 times.
>>139345872
i become Meguca?
>>139345948
When is that stated though? I'm just curious because I don't remember it at all. I thought it was just simply implied that she went back countless times.
Kyubey will be the first to hang on the day of the rope.
>>139346009
no
being Meguca is suffering...
>>139346142
>kyubey thread
>>139346020
A Q&A shows that Homura has repeated around 100 times.
>>139346295
Destroy Incubator. Feed to Kyorca
>>139346675
>>139346792
i do not understand
>>139346839
QB isn't smart enough to use a phone?
>>139346993
Kyubey. Must. Die. Simple, right?
>>139347077
kyuubei's kyuubeis
