How do you feel about MAL's current top 10?
(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
>>139303349
Gintama is not funny and they should feel bad for liking it so much, I miss back when LOTGH was always #1
>>139303349
Gintama is good but it's obviously overrated there.
>>139303349
> No ERASED
Good.
>>139303349
Almost everything there is pretty decent, actually.
It doesn't matter. You should be spending your time watching anime instead of bitching about lists.
>>139303349
Indifferent
>"ERASED" gets cucked out of top 10
I really don't get why one series is in the top 10 so many times.
MAL has a casual user base anyway filled with faggots. Who gives a fuck about their shit tastes and low power level.
>>139303349
>MAL
Fuck off.
>>139303349
I don't really care. why should I?
>>139303480
>Who gives a fuck about their shit tastes and low power level.
Mostly this, but the reason why Gintama is up there so many times is how it's inflated due to the fact that no one who didn't like the first seasons already are going to watch the newer ones. Note the number of members.
>>139303349
And not enough Gintama.
>>139303349
>gintama everywhere
>steins gate
>hunter x hunter
Who cares about a top 10 when you have dubs
>>139303473
kek
>>139303349
LOGH looks so out of place on there.
A few years ago iy was pretty accurate then newfags came along.... They need a wait a while before a series ends before allowing people to rate otherwise its a heat of passion voting.
>>139303404
It was never number 1.
I don't care. Everything in the list is entry-level and overrated by popularity.
>japanese MAL
https://www.anikore.jp/pop_ranking/
>>139303892
>LOGH is entry level
>fullmetal alchemist
what the fuck is that?
>>139303755
It's the only good one on there.
>mal hates boku inai erased dake machi now
>gintama
>gintama
>gintama
>gintama
>gintama
A joke, much like their whole site.
>>139303918
>karuta no.10
SEASON 3 WHEN
>>139303918
It's all shit.
>>139303918
Japan better taste confirmed
>>139303944
Objectively Gintama is good but those mal babies have over-hyped the show completely. Only Gintama' should be the one barely scrapping the top 10.
>>139303921
It is.
>>139303918
>ちはやふる
>top 10
what the fuck Japan? why?
>>139303918
>hyouka
>24
Holy SHIT maybe the Nips do have taste
>>139303994
The Gintamas' ratings are inflated because only people who liked the original are going to be watching all the sequels, and they all rate it 10. If it was all just 1 "Gintama" instead of being split up then it would not be like that.
>>139304000
And you formed this opinion from actually watching the series?
The only reason LoGH is up there is because newfags rate it 10/10 after watching 5 episodes to look sophisticated and mature on their fuckin profile
>>139304020
Apparently nips actually have taste
>>139303918
The Japs really like melodrama.
>>139303918
better than MAL
Why is Steins;Gate so popular
>>139303918
nips have objectively shit taste
why do you think the large majority of anime is utter garbage? because idiot otaku eat it up
>>139304069
This is the inherent flaw with MAL. Various seasons being split up doesn't work.
>>139303921
It is now thanks to the books being translated.
>>139303349
>Gintama
Never seen it
>FMA:B
Respectable if ever so slightly overrated
>Steins;Gate
It's pretty good but I wouldn't rate it in the top 10
>HxH
Never seen, don't tend to watch shounen stuff since I'm in my mid 20s
>More fucking Gintama
Wow I guess this is pretty popular huh?
>Clannad
Overly melodramatic, the anime equivalent of a soap like Eastenders. Definitely doesn't belong here.
>LOTGH
This deserves it.
>More Gintama
STOP
>>139303349
The reason most of Gintama and Logh have such high numbers is because of the 5 digit viewership and being fairly good. Just add the MAL tendency to rank anything they like a 10/10 leads to this exact situation.
>>139304090
babbies first drama
>>139304020
>not having superior nippon taste
>>139303918
>Nagi no Asukara
>17
This list doesn't look so bad overall but there are some selections that make me wary.
>>139303918
>11s again prove to have superior taste
I'm not even surprised. But MAL must have massive homolust fujo infestation to get fucking garbage like Gintama that high.
>>139304120
It aired in the season a bunch of people got into anime.
>>139304084
Then there is this guy.
Shouldn't anime be enjoyable? If an anime isn't enjoyable, hasn't it failed? In my opinion, yes, Anime should be enjoyable. In my opinion, LOGH isn't. I know there are people who share this opinion, but are just to afraid to voice it, due to the people who actaully have the patience to finish the horrid show being vicious when disagreed with about the show, like rapid, foaming at the mouth Twilight fangirls.
Story - 6/10
Almost directly plagiarized from Star Wars. I'm surprised George Lucas hasn't sued them. Imagine Star Wars, only with no light sabers, no plasma guns, and no awesomeness. Oh! And it's run by aristocrats from France. Alright, now you have Legend of the Galactic Heroes. If you haven't seen Star Wars, just imagine Star Trek, only more boring. If you haven't seen either of those, I'm not sure why you're even reading my review.
Art - 7/10
Nothing to write home about. Very average. Almost everything I watched was a Laserdisc rip though, so you can kind of see how it might not look too nice. I mean the art really is truly average 90's art, which I happen to be a fan of. But that's it. Nothing special. I will add though that the command deck for the Empire is quite detailed.
Sound - 4/10
Subpar - not even worth getting into. Very little background noise, just voices, and many annoying ones at that.
Character - 4/10
You know lots of people rant and rave about how human the characters in this series are. The trouble is, they aren't. Every character - stock. It's like the author of the original book (ahaha, yes I do know that much!) just got a list of all the stock characters of all time and just decided "Whoop! I guess I'll use these!"
>half of this shit is gintama
>>139304135
>>139304217
>Everything is from the last 8 years
No one likes any anime from the 70s, 80s, 90s or early 00s anymore?
>>139304244
Cont: Yeah, so all in all, LOGH isn't worth your time, or hard drive space since the only way to watch it is to download. Most people who will read this review will probably be outraged. Hey - if this review has angered you, feel free to leave me a comment about it. But atleast be civil. Remember that everybody's opionion is different, and just because I don't agree that LOGH is the best anime ever doesn't mean I'm stupid, dumb, or have bad taste. It just means I didn't like LOGH.
>>139303918
>https://www.anikore.jp/pop_ranking/
My only problem is Fateshit being that high.
>>139303918
>Laputa the top ranking Ghibli movie
I think this is the most offensive thing on here. It's an 8/10, well-crafted adventure movie, but that's all it is. It doesn't have any major themes and the characters have no discernible traits.
>>139304217
This is kind of just what happens, though. Shows blow up and bring new people of various demographics into the medium, they hear about sites for keeping track of what you watched, and rate the shows that got them into the medium super high.
It's shitty, but not surprising.
>>139304244
>a site with millions of users have some people that don't like LoGH
WOW, MAL sure is cancer.
>>139303349
I'm two episodes into HxH `99 and I can already tell it's better than 2011.
Congrats 99fags you were right all along.
>>139304244
>Story - 6/10
>Almost directly plagiarized from Star Wars. I'm surprised George Lucas hasn't sued them.
>>139303672
S;G and HxH are good though.
>>139304224
Gintama doesn't even have fujobait
>>139303585
This is why the second season of something always will be higher rated than the first one. The oens that didn't like it as much as less likely to watch the second season, while the ones that liked it will watch it and rate the second one just as high. Code Geass and Spice & Wolf for instance.
Only exception I can think of is Nisekoi, but that's because the second season there was absolute trash.
>>139303349
Too much gintama. But well, not that bad
http://www.redditanimelist.com/index.php
Literal reddit anime.
Gintama is overrated shit.
Steins;gate is overrated shit and Chaos;head is much better (the VN).
FMA and HxH are okay I guess.
Clannad is good but Little Busters is better.
I haven't seen gay lactating homos yet.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
wew la
>>139303918
>Sao that high
Despite that nips have a good taste
>>139304244
nice bait
http://yaraon-blog.com/archives/81855
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Based
MODS = GODS
>>139304071
No, but is really popular with casuals.
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Is my list better than Mal's? Be nice anons I'm sensitive.
1. Gankutsuou
2. Tatami Galaxy
3. Ashita no Joe
4. LOGH
5. Mushishi
6. Hyouge Mono
7. GTO
8. Ping Pong
9. Gintama' (Fuck you and evaluate the list as a whole)
10. Mononoke
11. GitS:SAC
12. Galaxy Express 999
13. Kaiba
14. Space Battleship Yamato
15. Serial Experiment Lain
16. Natsume Yuujinchou
17. Rose of Versailles
18. Revolutionary Girl Utena
19. Rurouni Kenshin
20. Welcome to the NHK
>>139303349
Holy kek mods=gods
>MODS
>>139304267
You know very well that normalfags can't watch "old" anime (anything before 2006/7), because they aren't HD.
And if an anime isn't 16:9, it's automatically shit for them, that's why studios usually change the ratio from 4:3 to 16:9 when they release BD.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Good, now ban 75% of this board which consists of reddit tumblr and mal please mods.
Stories are necessarily subjective, so what delivers the greatest entertainment or meaning will differ from person to person.
I guess I don't disagree that all the top 10 aren't pretty good
but why so many gintama...
>>139304217
>4 shows from 2015-2016
I just realized I share my hobby with a bunch of children.
>>139304244
>307 people found this review helpful
>28 of 110 episodes seen
>>139303349
>USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST
I'm not even sure what rule he's breaking, but MODS=GODS
>>139303349
>USER WAS BANNED
AHAHAHAHAHAH
>>139303349
There's still hope for this place
>>139304445
Too much 3x3core.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
>>139304496
Dumb frogposter
>>139304492
MAL is not anime, for starters
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
>>139303349
Heh. Thank you, God~
Here comes the spam of >USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST accompanied with a reaction image.
>>139304496
Kill yourself dumb frogposter
![[HorribleSubs] Osomatsu-san - 24 [720p].mkv_snapshot_15.51_[2016.03.21_20.26.16].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/K5AoDgS.jpg "[HorribleSubs] Osomatsu-san - 24 [720p].mkv_snapshot_15.51_[2016.03.21_20.26.16].jpg")
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Finally.
>>139304522
Neither is half the shit on the board right now.
>>139303918
I like their taste more, less mindless shounen shit.
>>139304400
>>139304496
Both of you should be banned too.
>>139304400
>gintama
>gintama
>gintama
>FMA
>S;G
>fucking Haikyuu
Into the trash.
>>139304487
I was expecting the pig speaking human language picture. Nice one I haven't seen that pic in a while.
>>139304445
You're missing KyoAni/Shaft anime
>>139304545
Seriously? Would that not kind of mean that mods themselves break the rules?
MODS = KAMI-SAMAS
>>139304445
Nice tastes senpai
(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Awesome
>>139304445
>no nge
>no gundam
pleb taste
>>139304617
No? They just choose not to enforce the rules on shit that no one will care about.
>>139304671
Name 1 good gundam.
>>139304617
What does it matter anyways, if mod actually moderated like they shpuld more than half of the board would be gone.
>>139304671
>nge
You're the pleb
>>139304671
>Mentions nge and pleb taste in the same post
>>139304688
G-Reco.
>>139304700
They shouldn't moderate the way they "should". The site has always operated with tons of leniency towards rules.
>>139304688
0080
>>139304726
>>139304688
08th MS Team
Turn A Gundam
Origin
Thunderbolt
UC
Zeta
Oh wait, you said 1..
Can we stop with the reaction face meme posting to someone getting banned? It got old 8 years ago.
Why did OP get banned anyway? Don't mind, but bashing redditors for having shit taste is basically what we do anyway.
A top-something generated by the votings of a public userbase is bound to be filled with plebshit, it's not just a MAL thing it goes for every types of medium.
>>139303349
Best thread
>>139304445
>Gankutsuou at number 1
Other people have watched this anime?
>>139304726
lol
>>139304754
I don't know. It was kinda anime and manga related.
>>139304688
X
the original
unicorn
>>139304752
>08th MS Team
>good
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Just to clear up any confusion regarding /a/'s taste. Pic related
>>139304217
>>139304400
>Haikyuu in top 10
Told ya, HQ was great.
/a/ just literally being paranoid about MUH FUJOSHIT.
>>139304819
08th MS Team is phenomenal. That city battle alone is still one of the best fight scenes in any anime period.
![[HorribleSubs] Argevollen - 07 [720p].mkv_snapshot_10.49_[2014.08.19_16.03.05].png](https://i.imgur.com/vjQ1bK6.png "[HorribleSubs] Argevollen - 07 [720p].mkv_snapshot_10.49_[2014.08.19_16.03.05].png")
>>139304752
>origin
>thunderbolt
These haven't even finished yet, you idiot.
>08th MS Team
>UC
Okay nevermind.
>>139304754
It was more about another website than it was about anime and manga.
Bringing that kind of shit, is like always talking about CR, it was a somewhat justifiable ban.
>>139304819
up until the director died it was alright
>>139304739
My point is, if they did enforce the rules they'd have to erase so much content out of the board. I just wish they'd actually ban people like this faggot>>139304799
>>139304855
Expected response.
>>139303349
Haha get rekt.
>>139304855
>UC
>bad
We've have a full blown Gundam discussion in a thread that started about MAL.
/a/ daisuki desu
>>139304705
>>139304725
>being this much of a pleb
>>139304965
*had
>>139304905
are you salty about no one liking g reco?
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
MODS=GODS
>>139304967
Says the casual
>>139304929
These children all of the sudden came out of nowhere around the time when episode 5 aired. Unicorn was seen as a masterpiece up until then with very little criticism. I still don't know where all the children came from, I feel like it was a large scale trolling effort that some people took seriously and decided they agreed with it.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Nice
>>139304905
>I just wish they'd actually ban people like this faggot
Why? He doesn't do a single thing to you or anyone around here. People need to relearn to ignore posts they don't like. He has just as much of a chance being a newfag or crossboarder as you.
>>139304754
Nice try you fucking MALfag
>>139304929
I don't hate it like a lot of other people, but when tasked with naming 1 good Gundam series, Unicorn shouldn't even be considered.
>>139305010
Only casuals are the ones who watched just enough anime to turn hipster on the best selling anime of all time that literally saved anime and try to claim its bad because they watched 300 whole animes now.
How can you take a list seriously that has Welcome to the NHK at 139, NGE at 197, and SZS at 453
>>139305005
No you stupid fuck I don't give a shit about whatever the discussion was about it's the fact that he posted that shit. But nowadays noone even cares about it so I guess it doesn't matter.
>>139304841
is that legends of the galactic hero?
>>139305032
>bridal gauntlet
>hair flower
Top-notch taste, Anon.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
JUSTICE!
>>139304853
Gouf custom vs ez8 is still very good, it's just that the stupid love plotline was really bad
>>139305071
>like a lot of other people
You mean literally /m/? Because it is praised everywhere else, especially in Japan.
>>139305047
I can tell you're a crossboarder newfag.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
>>139304545
Rules need don't need to be applied rigorously all the time. It's perfectly fine to be lenient in some ways and rigid in others.
MAL is a cancerous website nobody should visit and banning people for starting threads about it is well deserved.
Do you think OP is watching this thread? Fuck you OP.
>>139305047
Eh, if you post just 'lol' alone it's not contributing in any way, plus you're speeding up the process with killing a thread by it no longer getting autobumped after it reaches the post limit.
This is most often not a problem since we rarely reach that limit anyway, but it's worth mentioning at least.
What Japan thinks about the western animefans taste.
http://www.all-nationz.com/archives/1054772914.html
http://yaraon-blog.com/archives/81855
>>139305132
Is it my posting style, anon? Am I too reddit for this place?
>>139305024
That's because Unicorn started going down the shitter starting with episode 4, and finally culminating in the newtype magic bullshit we see in episode 7.
Everything else besides the last half of the series was pretty damn good.
> Everyone is arguing till the last breath of this thread
This is /a/. Never change.
>>139305146
Except the mods didn't ban the OP for that, they banned him because it's not about anime when there's tons of other threads that aren't about anime too.
>>139305165
It's literally a shitposting thread on autosage though. Yes, with the way the site runs, simple 'keks', 'lols', and laughing images can be a problem, but only when it's a fast moving thread.
>>139305194
It's your poor bait that lets me know anon.
>>139305128
On /a/ too. What, you think I have exposure to anywhere else's opinions other than here or something? Well I don't, and don't even try to bring up Japan like their taste isn't shit.
>>139305207
Threads that are not anime may still not be as cancerous as MAL threads, so it's perfectly fine for them to be tolerated to a certain extent.
MAL needs to go however.
>>139305074
You're show is not perfect, deluded evafag
>>139305146
>MAL is a cancerous website nobody should visit
Try harder to fit in. Nobody here hates MAL on its own. It's good for keeping track of what anime you've watched. The community there is the issue.
>>139305312
This. Anyone that isn't a bandwagon faggot knows that we only hate MAL for its posters. The site itself is fine and can be a great tool.
MAL + Taiga
>>139305308
Nothing is, that's not exactly grounds for criticism to claim its bad just because Ltd not perfect or insinuate there's something wrong with it being a favorite.
Modfag, I'm waiting for you to ban all the other MALfags ITT.
>>139305312
>Nobody here hates MAL on its own.
Get the fuck out you worthless subhuman. Every reasonable person hates shitty communities and in using a completely useless feature which - if you really need it - can be replicated with the regular notepad, on a website with a shitty community you're essentially supporting said shitty community.
People like you are rightfully banned.
And I can point you to countless threads over the years where MALfags like yourself got told hard to get the fuck out of /a/.
>>139305312
>The community there is the issue.
Which includes posting about their top 10.
Plus there was already a thread about this earlier today and it got deleted.
>>139305430
Why do you still reply to him, can't you realize it's just shitposting unless someone slaps your butt with memes?
>>139305312
>>139305354
These are probably the best arguments against those who completely disregard MAL.
>>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
So I'm guessing this is the monthy false flag thread the mods create to fool people into thinking they still do shit.
>>139305354
I completely agree with you.
I use MAL™ myself and I'm having a great time on this awesome website!
I would recommend everyone to give it a try. The community is really great too and loads of fun discussion can be had there.
>>139305503
Shame they won't do the same with rec fags
>>139303349
Their top 30 isn't bad because of the individual shows as it is because it reflects their overall taste. Not even talking about muh deep or old shit, this list reflects the casual nature of MALs users consisting mostly of shounen edgelords and fujoshit tumblrinas. The irony of LoGH being there? Fujos watch it as much, if not more, than pretentious deepfags. Other shows that make the lineup are pretty much a followup on the top 10, with FEELS shit filling in the gaps for the emotionally unstable cucks.
I'm glad that I didn't make an account on any of those community shitholes, A-P and AniDB included.
>>139303918
>Cowboy Bebop 12
Where is your "but the nips don't like Bebop" meme now, /a/?
>>139305563
>we only hate MAL for its posters
Try to be less of a bandwagon faggot.
>>139305430
Please do link me these threads you talk about. I use MAL to keep track of my backlog. Not a MALfag by any means.
And no, MAL is better than notepad for the simple reason that it can be acessed anywhere on any device.
Seriously, you're transparent as fuck. Fuck off right back where you came from. We don't need bandwagon faggots like you here.
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
Based mods. Making a thread to talk about what people in other sites say is not /a/.
>>139303918
It isn't really that different to the usual rankings from the west except for maybe fucking Nagi no Asukara that high WHAT THE FUCK
>>139305642
>We
Why should I feel an-
Oh well, good job.
>>139305602
It's a meme I haven't seen in awhile
epic simply epic
>>139304754
I don't know but can we ban even being allowed to mention reddit or MAL to stop the fuck off too meme?
>>139306038
Literally all that would do is have people type M.AL or Leddit instead
>>139306038
Already a thing because of /tv/.
>>139305602
What people never said: the post
Cowboy Bebop DVD BOX released in 2004 sold 20k. The show is popular retard.
>>139303918
Holy shit it's the same shit
>>139303349
>(USER WAS BANNED FOR THIS POST)
wew nip moot
>>139304754
You clearly haven't been here for 8 years, if anything posts using images has decreased and people aren't calling out bait enough.
>>139304445
Gankutsuou was ruined by Albert. He had no right to interfere with the Count's revenge.
