Result:
01) Golden Kamui by Satory Noda (91 pt)
02) Dungeon Meshi by Ryôko Kui (78 pt)
03) Blue Giant by Shinichi Ishizuka (68 pt)
04) Erased by Kei Sanbe (55 pt)
05) Hyakumanjô Labyrinth by Takamichi (49 pt)
06) Nami yo Kiite Kure by Hiroaki Samura (43 pt)
07) Koi ha Amaagari no You ni by Jun Mayuzuki (42 pt)
08) Machida-kun no Sekai by Yuki Andô (38 pt)
09) Tokyo Tarareba Musume by Akiko Higashimura (29 pt)
10) Okazaki ni Sasagu by Saho Yamamoto (28 pt)
11) Tonkatsu DJ Agetarô by Yûjirô Koyama et Ipyao (25 pt)
>>139276449
Kamuy anime when?
>>139276683
when there is enough chapters to animate.
I'm glad someone picked up Blue Giant at least.
>>139276826
Although where's more chapters of Samura's when you need them?
>04) Erased by Kei Sanbe (55 pt)
reeeeeeeeeeeee
>Golden Kamui by Satory Noda (91 pt)
>>139276449
>golden kamui in first place
I hope this is a sign for all the good times to come
>>139276449
>04) Erased by Kei Sanbe (55 pt)
this is the 3rd time.
>>139276449
>01) Golden Kamui by Satory Noda (91 pt)
>>139276449
>05) Hyakumanjô Labyrinth by Takamichi (49 pt)
Someone pick it up again already.
>>139276861
>reeeeeeeeeeeee
Fuck off.
They made a PV of the manga: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=njNGDHbX0ss
and a website page: http://youngjump.jp/goldenkamuy/
>>139276449
Best manga won for once, what happened?
>>139277067
As opposed to what, such garbage winners as Otoyomegatari, Silver Spoon, and 3gatsu?
Fuck. Where the hell is Helck?
>>139277119
>such garbage winners as Otoyomegatari, Silver Spoon, and 3gatsu?
Those aren't garbage, kill yourlsef.
>>139277098
I also like it, I'm just happy that Aniplex didn't buy the first place for Erased to promote their anime.
>>139277119
Didn't know about that, usually these awards end up going for the most "popular" anime/manga of the year but great to see that the Taisho Award actually worth something.
>>139277137
In the garbage bin.
>>139277137
Why it should be there?
>>139277185
Usually the winner is still overhyped. And I would say those three are quite popular. Sangatsu and Silver Spoon sold quite high. Enough to come in top 10 of lists. You have to pick a crowd favourite.
>>139277201
Uh, I don't know, maybe because it deserves to be on the list?
>>139277137
Already done being FOTM garbage on /a/.
>>139277191
>>139277251
>>139277296
>hurr durr bait
>>139277306
> hurr durr
Got anything better?
>>139277356
I don't know, did you? Helck was just another flavour of the month like the shit known as JOHJ before it.
>>139277137
Didn't even make the longlist, better luck next year.
>>139277383
Are you a fucking idiot? Do you not realize that Helck wins when it comes to the writing?
Golden Kamuy, Dungeon Meshi, and Koi wa Ameagari no You ni
I couldn't be happier.
>>139277428
People say the same thing about Tokyo Ghoul.
>>139277424
What are the requirements usually? It came out in 2014 (Helck) so who are the judges usually? Is it because of the publisher it is in?
>>139276971
>takamichi
Is that the same guy that does the gorgeous covers for that pedo magazine?
>>139277428
Helck is just mediocre bait & switch that relies on shock value, just like Madoka and Muvluv.
Is Helck doing well in terms of sales, I'm just wondering.
>>139277464
> Comparing Helck to Tokyo Ghoul
Are you a fucking dumbass? You realize how much you will be shit upon by actual people that know what real writing is?
>>139277467
Oh, it's eligible, they just didn't care. The only requirements are that it had a volume released in 2015 and has eight or fewer volumes total or a previous (shortlist?) nomination.
>>139277510
>Helck doing well in terms of sales
no. Only the magi spin off on urasunday is doing well.
>>139277500
> Mediocre bait and switch
My friend, it introduced the serious plot early and built the ironic twist of a hero out to destroy humanity. It built the depth of the story and is able to add layer upon layer leading to the past which became even clearer how the story is to be.
>Helck whining in manga award thread
Every fucking time.
>>139277492
Yes.
Is Erased's manga even worth reading when there's the anime? The art is so fucking garbage that I don't see reading it to be enjoyable even when it did the story better from what I've heard. Looks like some Invader Zim style shit.
>>139277542
So it was scrapped out because it was a web manga and that was what triggered them.
>>139277583
if anything, it has 1/3 of the popularity of Mob psycho.
>>139277594
> samefag that should realize that he has lost the argument and does not even critique back in a effective manner.
>>139277638
You seem awfully upset that Helck didn't win this one award.
>>139277633
The plot points and time travel system is still weak unfortunately. It did not do as well as you think other than making more details of events but not really much of importance in the end kinda.
>>139277679
Calm your tits,fanboy.
>>139277638
>Mob psycho
Mob psycho isn't selling either. Only Sinbad no bouken (Magi spin off) is selling like more than 200k a volume.
>>139277746
mob is still selling better than helck
>>139277710
If anything, I am mad that there are other manga that don't deserve this injustice. I've seen quite a few of those manga on the list especially erased and realize what bullshit it is that erased would be regarded higher than Helck and many other manga that could have a spot.
>>139277746
The ranking of sinbad is pretty low in comparison but views are pretty high but not as much as kengan Ashua I think.
>>139277638
>So it was scrapped out because it was a web manga and that was what triggered them.
Nope, there are web manga that made it.
>>139277144
you so completely missed the point that you got the opposite of what was conveyed
good work
Looked on urusunday site and saw Zelda Twilight princess manga update.
>>139277144
He was being ironic, though.
>>139277931
yeah, it has a manga.
>Helck fanboys
Come on. I love Helck, I REALLY do, but it's generic as fuck so I can totally see it not winning awards. Most of these titles are real stand outs and different, far as I can tell.
>01) Golden Kamui by Satory Noda (91 pt)
>02) Dungeon Meshi by Ryôko Kui (78 pt)
I like Golden Kamui a lot but Dungeon Meshi is a better food manga. GK claws some point back for actually being a good action manga, for once.
>04) Erased by Kei Sanbe (55 pt)
You mean Boku Dake ga Inai Machi, Erased was a shitty anime /a/ made even worse.
>06) Nami yo Kiite Kure by Hiroaki Samura (43 pt)
First chapter was awesome, I waited forever for it to get scanlated and there hasn't been any release since. Fuck this gay earth.
>07) Koi ha Amaagari no You ni by Jun Mayuzuki (42 pt)
Good so far and seems to be heading in the right direction.
Overall a good list.
>>139276912
>I hope this is a sign for all the good times to come
Not really, it will probably get an anime and that'll be the end of decent discussion and threads on /a/.
>>139276683
fuck off animefag, anime adaption are awful. Remember Toriko? soul eaters and the recent one piece episode?
>>139276449
>07) Koi ha Amaagari no You ni by Jun Mayuzuki (42 pt)
Based.
>>139281380
While I agree that anime adaptations aren't some sort of step up, this is cherrypicking. Also
>Toriko
The manga went to shit as well.
>>139281512
toriko manga is top tier man, but the anime was like 4kids censored crap with shitty animation.
>Bears and other animals will throw off pursuers by carefully walking backwards along their own tracks
Is this true?
Didn't know bear are that smart.
>>139276683
>anime cancer
hopefully never
>>139277500
I like Helck but it's not even close to the same category as Madoka which was actually unanimously praised by critics, while drangoquest berserk is just a silly niche thing.
>>139282139
oh fuck off
>buttmad Helck fanboys
everytime
>>139281883
why
>>139281817
Yes. I learned it from JoJo.
>>139276449
>01) Golden Kamui by Satory Noda (91 pt)
>>139277638
>So it was scrapped out because it was a web manga and that was what triggered them.
Golden Kamui is from same webmanga service - Ura Sunday
>>139284585
>wanting a mediocre adaption and shitposters
>>139284807
No, weekly young jump
>>139282139
Is this bait? That does not make it better.
>>139280165
> generic
what makes a series generic? Because really, you have to realize the distinction of storytelling, quality, and execution.
