[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Why is Fateshit more popular that Tsukihime?
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 145
File: 01-HSS-Saber-Arcueid.jpg (57 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
01-HSS-Saber-Arcueid.jpg
57 KB, 1280x720
>better plot
>better setting
>better girls
>inarguably better MC
>>
Better adaptation
>>
>>138293810
Good thing you answered your own question OP
>>
>>138293810


Tsukihime has less supplementary material to buff it up, and it's debatable how much of stuff that happens in Melty Blood can be taken seriously.

Fewer characters, and those characters are not as exciting. The most interesting characters (some of the members of the Dead Ancestor Apostles, Aoko, Altrouge, etc.) are getting screwed for face time too.

Also it's harder to snag people with this because it's got no anime to catch the attention of the lay person, where Fate has no less than four separate attempts at adaptation in addition to two updated re-releases of it's original material.

An adaptation of the Tsukihime manga would be amazing. I sincerely hope to see this one day.

>>138293892
how the story of fate better than Tsuki?
>>
Because the art in Tsukihime is pretty mediocre?
>>
Why don't Fate bait threads get an instant ban?
>>
>>138293810
Carnival Phantasm is only sorta Fateshit but everyone knows that Carnival is the best adaption of any TM work.
>>
>>138293810
because tsuki's lacking an adaptation and funded source material
>>
>>138293959
KIMI TO
>>
File: 1457149364183.png (222 KB, 629x500) Image search: [Google]
1457149364183.png
222 KB, 629x500
>>138293810
Because it would appear your hot opinions don't translate to everyone.
>>
>>138293810
Tsukihime was actually quite popular, but its the difference between a first, still somewhat underground hit, and a now established author hitting it big.
Had they been released in the opposite order Tsukihime would be the famous one.
>>
Because as much of a hack Nasu is, he came up with a pretty cool and novel idea for Fate.

His own rendition of vampires in Tsukihime is also slightly different from the norm but it didn't carry as strong of an impact.(Especially since Hellsing/Alucard was already a thing, otherwise Nero Chaos would've probably been more popular.)

And above all else Fate is newer, had better art and budget, and not the same two goddamn songs playing over and over.
>>
>>138294100
The thing about Nasu is, underneath his terminal case of chuuni, he actually writes really good characters. Rin in particular has a lot of subtleties to her character in UBW and HF that make her really likeable. If anything, I'd like to see Nasu team up with another writer who can do the world building and plotting for him, while he focuses on the characters.
>>
>>138293986
aren't they releasing Melty blood HD?
>>
File: tsukihimeremakearcueid.jpg (95 KB, 563x634) Image search: [Google]
tsukihimeremakearcueid.jpg
95 KB, 563x634
It's going to be more popular with the remake.
>pic related is literally a copy pasta of saber
>>
>porkslope turkeyhandle
>atari dumbledore
No anime.
>>
>>138294253
>Implying the remake is ever going to be released
>>
>>138293810
At least we got Melty Blood while Fate gets plagued with fanservice shit like prisma.
>>
>>138294253
the sameface is real.
>>
File: Unlimited hand work.jpg (283 KB, 1000x1493) Image search: [Google]
Unlimited hand work.jpg
283 KB, 1000x1493
>>138294296
>Prisma
>Shit

3rei is the best thing about fate series right now
>>
But you just gave the reasons Fate is more popular.
>>
>>138293990
ISSHO GA ICHIBAN
>>
File: Best MC.jpg (78 KB, 1024x819) Image search: [Google]
Best MC.jpg
78 KB, 1024x819
>>138293810
>better setting
>better plot
Are you kidding? Shiki is more average harem MC then Shirou. And tsuki is popular m8
>>
>>138294495
>shiki drugged and paralyzed in bed slowly descending into madness for half the VN
>shirou whining about muh superhero ideal and cooking dinner for half the VN

it's not even close senpai
>>
>>138294529
>shiki drugged and paralyzed in bed slowly descending into madness for half the VN
Only in one route.
>>
File: 1453590379364.jpg (51 KB, 400x323) Image search: [Google]
1453590379364.jpg
51 KB, 400x323
>>138294390
>that dick-arm
>>
>>138294205
yes. sometime in spring
>>
>>138293810
because look at your image OP, saber is objectively cuter than arc. This is why.
>>
>>138294205
Actress Again on steam for now. Melty blood HD is something they want to make but need to wait for remake
>>
File: GARcher.png (1 MB, 721x1080) Image search: [Google]
GARcher.png
1 MB, 721x1080
>>138294583
isn't he badass?
>>
File: 55454089_p0.jpg (1 MB, 3600x1900) Image search: [Google]
55454089_p0.jpg
1 MB, 3600x1900
>>138294065

Not entirely. Tsukihime had a lot of interesting ideas and stuff introduced in the many versions of Melty Blood that came out over the years. The problem is that Tsukihime itself is mostly a very self contained stories and the characters are very much within that self contained story. While the Fate characters are more ambitious and looking forward to things in the future, as well as spreading their wings in the wider world.

Whereas you could get one solid action with Shiki, as long as it had to with with helping Arc post story or fighting something, that's about it since he wants to live a mundane life. Akiha isn't exactly going to go out looking for shit and will just head the family. Ciel like Shiki could have one good actiony plot, but you need an initiator. Arc needs to either be cured or sealed. Kohaku and Hisui have no real interests except living peacefully.

Compared to other characters in Fate who have bright or ambitious futures to look forward to. Shirou finding his purpose and actively helping people, Rin not only heading her family as the sixth head, but traveling and in some ends, working as a disciple of Zel. Sakura ends up getting a cool mentor who is a badass priest himself, and rebuilding her life, which opens up a lot of things.

So Tsukihime has a limited scope unless they rely on Melty forever, which will end up suffering from fighting game plot syndrome like BlazBlue or Guilty Gear and become all kinds of convoluted.

Fate has interesting plotlines outside they can use, and unlimited ways to work the characters in that are believable, that is why it has become Nasu's Gundam, not that Tsukihime is bad.

It's like if you compared Kojima's Zone of the Enders to Metal Gear.
>>
File: 20130921104140c41.jpg (461 KB, 3248x2161) Image search: [Google]
20130921104140c41.jpg
461 KB, 3248x2161
>>138294653
How? I just need to change her hairstyle and her eye color to make her look exactly like Arc.
>>
>>138294684
True but it's more about Fate plot (holy grail war, Servants) than characters.
All I need from Tsukihime side is remake, MB HD and Tsukihime 2. After that they can milk Fate for eternity if they want
>>
>>138294253
>remake
when was it announced?
>>
>>138294808
do it, and tsukihime will once again become popular. until then, saber is cuter. vampire saber a shit
>>
>>138294947
reddit pls
>>
>>138294808
Blue girl is the best grill
>>
>>138293810
Tsukishit MC wear Eyeglass
EYEGLASS
>>
>>138294921

The first two are guaranteed at this point unless they want to waste more money. The last one is Nasu's chronic need to mull over a manuscript for ages.

as for Fate, the Servants are part of the characters, so its almost completely about the characters, its mostly now starting to give us additional settings for the human characters. If Nasu is smart, he will use them, he tried to hide it well, but from his reactions about Prisma, he really wants to use Luvia too, so he better start doing it.

As well as an after story for HF like he did with UBW.
>>
File: shiki_nanaya.jpg (9 KB, 270x365) Image search: [Google]
shiki_nanaya.jpg
9 KB, 270x365
>>138295013
>implying
>>
>>138294921
>Tsukihime 2
this was only a joke.
>>
anyone playing Melty currently?
>>
>>138294205
Only after UNiEL dies completely
>>
File: Ryougi_mb.webm (3 MB, 720x540) Image search: [Google]
Ryougi_mb.webm
3 MB, 720x540
>>138295163
me
>>
File: Character_Material_36.jpg (144 KB, 785x1161) Image search: [Google]
Character_Material_36.jpg
144 KB, 785x1161
>>138295109
Talk and Prelude disagrees
>>
>>138294684
GG's plot isn't convoluted because they literally said what was canon and what wasn't.
>>
>>138295209
>this Hakumen shit
>>
>>138295209
>Crescent
>Not Half-moon
I'm not very good though so it's not like I know what I'm talking about
>>
File: 1444252116903.jpg (56 KB, 500x500) Image search: [Google]
1444252116903.jpg
56 KB, 500x500
>>138293810
Fate has more fights and more commercial things. it has a lot of anime while Tsukihime never got one.

Also

Fate/ = Shounen While Tsukihime=Seinen.
>>
File: satsujinki isn't impressed.jpg (50 KB, 363x314) Image search: [Google]
satsujinki isn't impressed.jpg
50 KB, 363x314
>>138295209
>>138295217
they have no current plans to do this and they will never do it because Nasu is too lazy to go good stuff.
>>
>>138295209
Those EX shields are pretty hard to pull off, but I probably just suck. Nice work.
>>138295377
Personally, I like crescent mode the most for combos, but half the most for just about everything else.
>>
File: 1449467477805.png (3 MB, 2048x1365) Image search: [Google]
1449467477805.png
3 MB, 2048x1365
which one do you like?
>>
File: 1455904155000.png (207 KB, 700x560) Image search: [Google]
1455904155000.png
207 KB, 700x560
>>138295921
Neither of them
>>
File: matoufamilyhouse.jpg (261 KB, 985x1400) Image search: [Google]
matoufamilyhouse.jpg
261 KB, 985x1400
>>138293959
>Carnival
>best adaptation
The Matou Family House episode begs to differ. The director let his delusional bias get in the way of actually being funny or faithful to the source material. There were also way too many unfunny running gags.
>>
>>138295921
Both but Shiki>Shirou
>>
File: TpwN1a3.png (325 KB, 540x270) Image search: [Google]
TpwN1a3.png
325 KB, 540x270
>>138295921
he's like shiro now desu
>>
>>138294495
Agreed. Nasu himself admitted in an interview that Shiki ended up too much like an average VN MC.

Shiki feels like a generic harem MC. Only difference is that he occasionally flips out and becomes a super-assassin. He's not that good or interesting. Shirou is completely crazy and has a very abnormal set of beliefs that makes him quite unusual and interesting.
>>
File: Shiki kill servants.png (448 KB, 640x442) Image search: [Google]
Shiki kill servants.png
448 KB, 640x442
>>138293810
>No Anime
>Less supplemental material
>Less adaptations
>Original game has no VA (Mahoyo has none as well, but that's another problem)
>Less overall appeal to mainstream
>>
>>138296074
>No Anime

Nice maymay dude.
>>
>>138295921
Tsukihime Shiki < Shirou < Melty Blood Shiki
>>
>>138295984

It was funny that they used the same "Sakura is unpopular" jokes even after Nasu dropped the act and was like, "yes she is popular".

It didn't make sense for her to be mad about Rider's popularity when she was in TM's overall top 10. Hell, even some Rin fans were saying they oversused the "bad with tech" joke.

Now One Day, that is a true Fate comedy. Wish Nasu hired Fue for Fate comedy.
>>
File: s412-25.jpg (35 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
s412-25.jpg
35 KB, 640x480
The only really great thing about Tsukihime was the main bad guy desu
>>
>>138295921
They're both irritating and should be replaced with white-haired lolis
>>
>>138295984
I agree that the Matou Family House thing was pretty bad. The way it tried to turn domestic abuse into some sort of joke didn't work for me at all.
>>
File: 591605_p0.jpg (398 KB, 800x611) Image search: [Google]
591605_p0.jpg
398 KB, 800x611
>>138296212
poor SHIKI
>>
>>138296074
>Less overall appeal to mainstream
>>
>>138295921
Fate has been exploited too much nowadays. They should do something new after Tsukihime remake. Is it to hard to do? I want new fresh Idea, new characters etc...
>>
>>138296028
nah, it's different
>>
>>138296327
typemoon is afraid taking a risk
>>
>>138296339
he just need to take off his glasses to be Emiya.
>>
File: Sakur-Ai.png (318 KB, 400x900) Image search: [Google]
Sakur-Ai.png
318 KB, 400x900
>>138293810
Sakura falls in love with Shiro.

Unable to confess, the wormslut is gifted by a deus ex machina with the boy's phone number. Never minding the strange area code, she immediately calls him, and is overjoyed to find out that he has a crush on her as well.

But, the next day, when the educated prostitute recounts the previous day's confessions to the boy, he only looks at each of her with a perplexed expression. After some investigation, she finds out that the boy she called is not the same boy she fell in love with. In fact, he doesn't exist in this universe at all. He is the alternate universe counterpart of her crush, who has fallen in love with her AU self, who too is blissfully unaware of his crush.

Hijinks ensue as they strike up a deal to give each other their darkest, most private secrets in order to equip each other with the weapons they need to conquer the heart of their other selves. While the two chase their respective loved ones, DRAMA ensues as they begin to fall in love with each other instead and question the NATURE of FISH.

>Sakur-Ai! Because, you know, she's Sakura and it's a love story. Get it, get it?
>>
>>138296164
Sakura is the least popular of the Fate heroines though

Which is funny because her fans insist Heaven's Feel is best route

Top fucking kek
>>
>>138296414
Don't even bother.
Sakurafags are delusional
>>
>>138296401
>TAGs: NTR, WORM, BESTIALY,
>>
File: Arika.png (997 KB, 628x2252) Image search: [Google]
Arika.png
997 KB, 628x2252
>handsome
>can drawing
>doesn't like imoutos
>doesn't like gays
>doesn't like traps
>baseball player
>doesn't has sense of fear
>has a job
>good with dogs
>not edgy
>milf magnet
>>
>>138293810
Because it's newer and is being constantly drilled into fans' heads.
>>
>>138294495
I would kill for an anime or manga adaption of this. 3rd volume when?
>>
>>138296414
>>138296450
>samefagging this hard
Also, reminder that Sakura has beaten Rin in a poll, despite not having gotten nearly as much exposure in adaptations and advertising.
>>
>>138296474
Of course though, his sister wants to eat him.
>>
>>138293810
>>>inarguably better MC
I like Tsukihime more than Fate, but Shiki isn't anywhere near as complex or developed as Shirou. No contest there, Shirou is better.
>>
File: Shingetsusing.jpg (235 KB, 825x1165) Image search: [Google]
Shingetsusing.jpg
235 KB, 825x1165
fate has better marketing

story wise and even the MC, tsukihime is better
>>
>>138295921
Death Perception ftw
>>
>>138296497
>Sakura has beaten Rin in a poll
top kek, this is an extraordinary delusion
>>
Should i wait the the remake or play tsukihime now? Also, how good is Mahou Tsukai no Yoru?
>>
File: 234231534565465.png (116 KB, 588x690) Image search: [Google]
234231534565465.png
116 KB, 588x690
>>138296667
Sakura haters being crossboarding newfags? Gee, what a surprise.
>>
File: 1347074610421.jpg (301 KB, 1280x800) Image search: [Google]
1347074610421.jpg
301 KB, 1280x800
I think tsukihime is the only VN I played where every heroine actually tried to kill the MC at one point and all of them are also cray cray
>>
>>138296667
Rinfags are delusional
>>
File: 1439894905909.jpg (44 KB, 544x529) Image search: [Google]
1439894905909.jpg
44 KB, 544x529
>>138296765
>seems it's official
>seems
kek, really anon?
>>
>>138296847
>kek
Yes, really. Now fuck off, crossboarder.
>>
>>138296802
I thought I remembered Hisui being the only good girl though.
>>
>>138296802
when did hisui tried to kill him?
>>
>>138296327

TM is about as expansive as Index. They don't NEED new characters, Nasu just needs to actually use more of the ones he has in fully fleshed out stories and settings.

But since these days its harder to take huge risks as a company, I don't blame them. I mean, people say they want new things but look at the fanfiction in the community, every Fate fic is using a grail war as a template, and most if not all Tsukihime ones hardly use many characters or diverge from the same dead apostle plotline, few about the Church, hybrids, or the Demon Hunter Families. You think these companies don't observe the fandom? Nasu trawls discussions on boards sometimes. They know it works because it works and people buy it. Its business.
>>
>>138296879
please anon

女性部門
1位 セイバー
2位 式
3位 凛
4位 アルク
5位 青子
6位 桜
7位 有珠
8位 琥珀
9位 赤セイバー
10位 秋葉
11位 イリヤ
>>
>>138296765
1 Saber 19821
2 Shiki Ryougi 18904
3 Archer 12338
4 Rin Tohsaka 12131
5 Arcueid Brunestud 11824
6 Rider (Fate/Zero) 11269
7 Aoko Aozaki 9628
8 Sakura Matou 6822
9 Gilgamesh 6507
10 Alice Kuonji 6491
>>
File: b1351.png (680 KB, 800x738) Image search: [Google]
b1351.png
680 KB, 800x738
>>138296802

Hisui and Ren didn't.
>>
File: 1234867.jpg (656 KB, 1618x1823) Image search: [Google]
1234867.jpg
656 KB, 1618x1823
>>138296765
>>
File: uAnl03s.jpg (388 KB, 716x1034) Image search: [Google]
uAnl03s.jpg
388 KB, 716x1034
>>138296414

The least popular doesn't mean not popular, nor is the least popular a bad thing when its the undisputed most popular IP of the company. Unless you wanted to argue people hate Shirou or something.

I ain't saying she is absolutely loved but its pretty delusional to say she doesn't have a good fanbase. If i remember right, Nasu said quite a few of her fans are employees from the jump.
>>
>>138293810
the girls have more boring designs
fsn has a better world for rps. people love worlds for which they can create their own individual characters, which also explains the popularity of stuff like naruto (make your own ninja), one piece (everyone can be a pirate or marine!) and bleach (let's become a shinigami!)
>>
>>138297033
>>138297042
Bringing up other polls doesn't change the fact that Sakura has beaten Rin, crossboarder.
>>
File: smug.jpg (100 KB, 720x960) Image search: [Google]
smug.jpg
100 KB, 720x960
>>138296802
they're all shit now. The new homeroom teacher is the new best girl.
>>
>>138297107
>the other poll
that's the most recent OFFICIAL popularity poll faggot, bring your delusion to somewhere else
>>
>>138293810
Because it sells.
And has a catchier name.
>>
>>138297198
>Kohaku is the second most popular Tsukihime character

God tier taste. She should be higher than Arc but still bretty good
>>
File: Noel.jpg (494 KB, 1554x2213) Image search: [Google]
Noel.jpg
494 KB, 1554x2213
>>138297142
At least post actual scan.
>>
>>138297177
You sound a bit upset that Rin was less popular, crossboarder.

>>138297198
>LOL
Sakura haters, everyone. Once again, that doesn't change the fact there's an official poll where Sakura scored above Rin.
>>
>>138296474

Arika, is okay, but too much of the sardonic MCs turn me off. i like people with energy. And are you saying he is homophbic? That would be a strike, being good with dogs is a plus though. Fear is a good thing to have at times, because it keeps you from being reckless.

Shirou has had a job since he was 12, and attracts milfs too.
>>
File: how.jpg (701 KB, 1000x711) Image search: [Google]
how.jpg
701 KB, 1000x711
>>138297100
>>
>>138297198
Holy fuck, please fuck off back to /v/ or wherever you came from. Your new is showing.
>>
>>138297293
Those updated designs are late, FSN overtook Tsukihime long before them. And the old designs are really bland.
>>
>>138297269
>everyone who disagrees with me is a crossboarder!

Are Sakurafags always this insufferable?
>>
File: 1449922381652.png (17 KB, 300x500) Image search: [Google]
1449922381652.png
17 KB, 300x500
>>138297269
>being this faggot
just give me your delusional "official poll" link
>>
File: manga.jpg (43 KB, 355x499) Image search: [Google]
manga.jpg
43 KB, 355x499
>>138296753
For tsukihime, the manga is better than the VN by FARRRR
>>
>>138297198
>8th place
That's not even unpopular, particularly considering most of the characters above her are just flavor of the month or series mascots who get high rankings by default. She's popular as fuck for being a character without any support from secondaries.
>>
File: Sakura is a waste.jpg (44 KB, 539x449) Image search: [Google]
Sakura is a waste.jpg
44 KB, 539x449
>>138297322
>he posted something that blatantly contradicted my argument!
>Better say he's from /v/!
>>
>>138297398
but it's only arc route
>>
>>138297198
who is 7th?
>>
>>138297340
You mean not at all? Take a look at retards like >>138297383 and say they're not underage or crossboarding. The way they type says it all.
>>
File: Aoko_mbaa.png (38 KB, 301x419) Image search: [Google]
Aoko_mbaa.png
38 KB, 301x419
>>138297439
aoko
>>
>>138297423
>4th place
Real unpopular character there.
>>
>>138297423
>caring about shitty Newtype ranking
Kill yourself
>>
>>138297453
just give me the link, what? you can't?
>muh underage
>muh crossboarding
>muh wormslut
>>
>>138297491
>wormslut
Yup, confirmed for underage crossboarder. Try learning how to type like a sensible human being.
>>
>>138297491
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtmdnB95Uxc

>1 756 583
Are others routes even trying?
>>
>>138297340
yup

>>138297535
just give me the link newfag
>>
>>138297560
>youtube views
oh shit now this is clearly a bait
>>
>>138296028
It's modern Shirou who is like MB Shiki.
>>
File: 1399991036402.jpg (65 KB, 560x560) Image search: [Google]
1399991036402.jpg
65 KB, 560x560
>>138297198

That doesn't say she is bad or unliked though.

I don't really care if Rin scored higher, I love both sisters and am a Sakurafag.
>>
>>138297590
>can't even into capitalization and punctuation
>calling others newfags
A quick Google search gives this.
http://forum.saintseiyapedia.com/index.php?topic=1045.700
>>
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
File: FGO anime.jpg (37 KB, 549x528) Image search: [Google]
FGO anime.jpg
37 KB, 549x528
Who is hyped?
>>
>>138297706
>Sakura so popular she sold out and was restocked first
Weak bait.
>>
>>138297711
Lets be honest, it's gonna be a mediocre 20 minute GO OVA by A-1pictures.

Some HF news is the best we can hope for.
>>
File: fucking really.jpg (307 KB, 1024x1498) Image search: [Google]
fucking really.jpg
307 KB, 1024x1498
>>138297711
Wasn't it confirmed to be fate/zero cafe anime?
>>
>>138297754
no, it's going to be revealed in 21 days.
>>
File: fa6.png (82 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
fa6.png
82 KB, 800x600
>>138297688
see? you can't even provide the original link to the poll
>>
>>138297754
>fate/zero cafe
>peppy loli Rin trying to stop Kirei from calling himself her daddy
>sarcastic as fuck loli Sakura who secretely eats like a horse

Sign me up.
>>
File: 1443146162122.png (513 KB, 1178x1694) Image search: [Google]
1443146162122.png
513 KB, 1178x1694
>>138297711
I hope they do animated shorts of the F/GO comics CP style
>>
File: Arc.png (38 KB, 345x600) Image search: [Google]
Arc.png
38 KB, 345x600
Left or Right?
>>
>>138293933
>how the story of fate better than Tsuki?
Mostly because when it comes to the MCs, Shirou is a lot more interesting than Shiki, and the story is inevitably the MC's story.

Shiki has practically no character in Tsukihime.
>>
File: v2.jpg (146 KB, 343x597) Image search: [Google]
v2.jpg
146 KB, 343x597
>>138297925
better
>>
>>138297936
Hisui&Kohaku routes>anything in FSN
>>
>>138296401
Threadly reminder that you should stop posting that because it's a thing.

https://www.fictionpress.com/s/3206139/1/
>>
File: 989ds0falkj.jpg (45 KB, 500x375) Image search: [Google]
989ds0falkj.jpg
45 KB, 500x375
>>138296401
A fish fishes in fish with a fish.

Fishing to confish, she is fished by a pisces ex sakana with the fish's fish. Never fishing the fish fish, she fishingly fishes her, and is overfished to fish out that she has a fish on her as well.

But, the next fish, when she fishes the fishes fish's fishes to the fish, she only fishes at her with a fished fish. After some fish, she fishes out that the fish she fished is not the same fish she fish in fish with. In fish, she fishen't fish in this fish at all. She is the fish's fishenate fish, who has fishen in fish with the fish's own fish, who too is fishfully fish of her fish.

Fishes ensue as the two fish up a fish to fish each other their fishest, most fishate fishes in order to fish the other with the fishes they fish to fish the fish of their other's fishes. While the two fish their fishpective fishes, fish fishes as they fish to fish in fish with each other finstead and fish the NATURE of FISH.

>Fish-Ai! Because, you know, they can communicate only through fish and it's a fish story. Get it, get it?
>>
>>138296401
http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/keit-ai-finds-a-way/
>>
>>138296802
That's part of the reason Tsukihime is unappealing compared to Fate. Saber,Rin and Sakura's crazy is at least possible to deal with for Shirou, where as Shiki's constantly walking on eggshells with these bitches. Even the Shiki in Kara no Kyoukai isn't quick to flip out and super murder everything and she DID make an effort to kill her lover. Tsukihime bitches be crazy in the bad way.
>>
>>138297960
left is a slut.

>>138296401
OH SHIT LOOK, HE POSTED IT AGAIN.
>>
>>138293810
Why is either of them popular?
>>
>>138297800
The poll itself was held on the now defunct mobile-only version of Type Moon's official website, but here's a link to the results.

http://otakomu.jp/archives/18884.html
>>
>>138298560
Because of Kinoko Nasu's ability to create a strong plot around the setting that builds from small details and individual points into powerful climaxes that thematically pay off the events of his story. Characterization is Nasu's greatest strength and the reason his works are so popular too. They are all top tier, no question in my mind about it.
>>
>>138298560
They do things differently. Not much better, really, but the medium's become so stagnant that a mediocre story that does it's own thing is more welcome than a good story that everyone's seen a hundred times.
>>
File: Saber Armor (5).png (663 KB, 500x600) Image search: [Google]
Saber Armor (5).png
663 KB, 500x600
>>138293810
>better girls
>anything being better than Her Majesty King Arturia Pendragon
>>
>>138293810
shounen shit.
>>
File: Seo-Ai.png (2 MB, 1146x1200) Image search: [Google]
Seo-Ai.png
2 MB, 1146x1200
>>138296401
FINDS
>>
>>138298184

Compare Hollow to KT, Shirou's place is pretty much Full House. The heroines may be competitive, but the gang actually protects each other, manages the household and can stand living together. If everyone moved into the Tohno mansion it would be destroyed in a week.
>>
>>138298858
I've taken shits that would compare favourably to Seiba in both character and looks.
>>
File: consider.png (15 KB, 123x143) Image search: [Google]
consider.png
15 KB, 123x143
>>138298858
>Arthur
>Girl
A shit
>>
>>138298560
why shouldn't they be?
>>
>>138293810
Nasu has forgotten there is more to the Nasuverse than Fate0
>>
>>138296802
Fate has that too.
>>
File: 1438381388507.jpg (48 KB, 376x507) Image search: [Google]
1438381388507.jpg
48 KB, 376x507
Because Fate also has husbandos
>>
>>138299556
This, Fujoshi run the anime market.
>>
>>138299556
My husbando might be in the Fate series, but fuck everything yaoi that has come from disgusting fujoshits. I love my husbando, I don't want him fucking guys.

Tsukihime was a little harder to get through for me than F/sn, but all the bonus spin-off stories for Tsukihime are god-teir. Kohaku's hide and seek game was the funniest thing I have read for a side story
>>
>>138294044
>>>/v/
>>
File: 08.png (424 KB, 800x636) Image search: [Google]
08.png
424 KB, 800x636
>>138297047
because they are best girls
>>
>>138294575
>Only one
which one?
>>
>>>/jp/
>>
File: illys 2.gif (2 MB, 499x281) Image search: [Google]
illys 2.gif
2 MB, 499x281
>>138294296

>Prisma
>fanservice-shit

What the fuck are you talking about? It's literally better than the source material.
>>
File: Sounoji After His Bath.jpg (114 KB, 649x3075) Image search: [Google]
Sounoji After His Bath.jpg
114 KB, 649x3075
>>138296474
Are...are they twins?
>>
>>138293810
OP, did you mean to list the reasons why F/SN is better than Turkeyhandle?
>>
>>138293810
Saber>Arc>Ciel>Rin>Akiha>Hisui>Kohaku>Sakura

Just in terms of best girls. Heaven's Feel is the best route of both visual novels for a multitude of reasons, including but not limited to:
>Kotomine
>setting up actually important backstory
>coolest fights
>Kotomine doing something
>seriously Kotomine is the best part

Shirou is the worst here, to be honest. I liked him being a justice fanatic.
>>
>Read Kagetsu Tohya
You'll like Tsukihime more

>Did not read Kagetsu Tohya
You'll like Fate more
>>
>>138302205
how can you love kotomine but not shirou
they're two sides of the same coin
>>
File: 1456851482765.jpg (199 KB, 640x742) Image search: [Google]
1456851482765.jpg
199 KB, 640x742
>>138302404

>two sides of the same coin

SHUT THE FUCK UP
>>
>>138302532
they're both shit
>>
>>138302367

It was okay, but Hollow was much better and included several minigames.
>>
>>138294149
Is there anyone better at world building than Oda?
>>
I was really enchanted by Kara no Kyoukai and Nasu's charismatic characters and use of magic in his world-building so I decided recently to give a try to the Fate VN.

Oh gosh, this was some painful chuuni shit.
>>
>>138293810
I always sort of figured the idea of a bunch of legendary figures duking it out in a battle royale type setting would appeal to more people than Tsukihime
>>
Fate/ had four anime adaptations.

Tsukihime had 0.
>>
Tsukihime's adaptation is outright worse and clearly didn't have an unlimited movie-tier budget like Fate.
>>
File: older hairstyles.jpg (221 KB, 1116x762) Image search: [Google]
older hairstyles.jpg
221 KB, 1116x762
>>138296028
Actually, if you're not a newfag to TM, you'd know that Shiro copied Shiki's hair and even facial structures from Melty Blood.

Takeuchi can't draw for shit.
>>
>>138305729
Kinda this. Unless you count Carnival Phantasm.
>>
File: 7.png (1 MB, 981x1600) Image search: [Google]
7.png
1 MB, 981x1600
>>138301997
Well Arika doesn't have any special abilities except phantom pain and memory loss. And he's not "good" guy like Soujuurou.
>>
File: QWHT4on.jpg (315 KB, 768x1024) Image search: [Google]
QWHT4on.jpg
315 KB, 768x1024
>>138306093

>Takeuchi can't draw for shit

Wel duh, its why all the Sakura fans who work at TM like Koyama are better at drawing Sakura than him. Since they give girls more than two body types.
>>
>>138306093
>Takeuchi can't draw for shit.
Come on. He's professional now.
>>138307269
Koyama has more experience
>>
>>138307269
I've never been a sakurafag, but this picture makes me want to fuck her to no end.
>>
>>138302205
>Saber this high
>>
>>138307678
As expected of the king
>>
File: 1448903453468.jpg (202 KB, 707x1000) Image search: [Google]
1448903453468.jpg
202 KB, 707x1000
>>138293810
>better plot
shounen battle royale is simpler and mass appeal
>better setting
aren't they both japan
>better girls
not really; tsukihime was the beta test
>inarguably better MC
no shiro while being bland/etc has more depth because the structure of the routes

also:>>138305689
>>
File: tm10thfemale.jpg (439 KB, 800x1094) Image search: [Google]
tm10thfemale.jpg
439 KB, 800x1094
>>138302205
>>
>>138305446
Togashi.
>>
Tsukihime is incredibly generic and dull. The MC was explicitly designed to be a faceless mook that the reader can reliably self insert into, even giving you the option of raping most of the female cast. Your typical generic "rape the maids" visual novel. The popularity of Tsukihime didn't really take off until Melty Blood fleshed out the lore and cast.
>>
>>138308730
>Tsukihime is incredibly generic and dull.
read the manga.
>>
File: 1450005274666.jpg (49 KB, 414x600) Image search: [Google]
1450005274666.jpg
49 KB, 414x600
Why is Tsukishit more popular than KnK?
Knk has
>better plot
>better setting
>better girls
>inarguably better MC
>>
>>138308953
because Tohno > Ryougi
>>
>>138308953
no lewds
>>
>>138308953
Look>>138308437
How is KnK less popular than Tsukihime?
>>
>>138308581
h-how? HxH is my favorite series but it doesn't really have world building.
>>
>>138308953
KnK is more popular you fuck. When was the last Tsukihime got something? Knk just got included in FGO.
>>
>>138308953
Is Nasu the example of a writer who did nothing but getting worse as time went by?
>>
File: 26151599.png (232 KB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
26151599.png
232 KB, 640x360
Sensei route when?
>>
File: Noel.png (2 MB, 520x2432) Image search: [Google]
Noel.png
2 MB, 520x2432
>>138310408
When remake comes out
>>
>>138310408
Hikaru Genji Plan.
>>
>>138293854
Considering both adaptations are shit, this still sounds true.
>>
>>138310862
both??
>>
>>138308953
>>138310543
>better girls
>>
>>138310915
The original DEEN adaptation of the 2 first routes were terrible, Ufotable's adaptation is so recent you can't even count it to gauge popularity anymore.
>>
>>138310980
the ost was amazing though.
>>
>>138297423
>>138297477
That was like, the one time Sakura placed in that poll, and that was the same month that the Heaven's Feel Manga started.

She was out of the top 10 a month later, and never returned.
>>
>>138311305
>manga
no, that's when they've shown this CM at the end of the last episode of UBW:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=efP12GVOQ64
>>
>>138311418
No, that poll was released around episode 20-21. Note how Shirou's that high.

That CM didn't come out until around a month later.
>>
>>138293810
Did ufotable ever get to animate something about Tsukihime?
>>
File: 1280.jpg (126 KB, 762x531) Image search: [Google]
1280.jpg
126 KB, 762x531
>>138297960
>>
File: 1436169080755.png (709 KB, 612x1055) Image search: [Google]
1436169080755.png
709 KB, 612x1055
>>
File: 2013081314375672f.jpg (459 KB, 1015x642) Image search: [Google]
2013081314375672f.jpg
459 KB, 1015x642
>>138312887
>>
>>138311305

Yeah, but it was also in a route where she had little to no screentime. I will guarantee that when HF comes out she will be #1 for a bit.

Either way, that is a Newtype poll which is odd in many ways, Hanekawa beat Saber recently too on one.
>>
>>138313095
>Yeah, but it was also in a route where she had little to no screentime

Again, it was the same month that the HF manga came out for the first time. It wasn't just some random thing for UBW.

>I will guarantee that when HF comes out she will be #1 for a bit.

It'll just mean Saber gets in the number one spot again.

>Hanekawa beat Saber recently too on one.

Yeah, but like, after how many months of UBW being off the air?
>>
File: 1444266490679.jpg (172 KB, 850x1227) Image search: [Google]
1444266490679.jpg
172 KB, 850x1227
>>138312415
Miniskirt doesn't make sense.
>>
>>138293810
all look same to me
>>
>>138309838
only if you're EOP who didn't play CCC
さらばだ、悩み多き少年少女!せいぜい人に恋し、愛に迷い、生に苦しむがいい!無駄に使える時間はないぞ!
>>
>>138313777
Is this supposed to be something other than average?
>>
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YR4ff-PtT6Y
>next 10 years
>>
>>138313304

The HF manga is monthly, so i can see why.
>>
>>138314299
Remake by 2020 confirmed.
>>
>>138297966
My brother
>>
>>138297966
I really liked Hisui's route, but I thought Kohaku's was shit.
>>
>>138297966
>Kohaku

Nah, Hisui was the best though and second was akiha.

Hisui>Akiha>Arc=Kohaku>Ciel
>>
>>138293810
It's a shame really, since Tsukihime is superior.
What makes Tsukihime better than FSN is the atsmosphere, you can feel the danger , the drama, the mindfuck.The music does a better job to add to the atmosphere than FSN.The characters interactions are so superior to the character interactions of FSN that it hurts,and the slice of life segments and Shirou's Pov are fucking annoying.FSN plot is too forced at times, some times they lead to plot holes,weak plot or unexplainable developments.Tsukihime's plot flows better, it's simple and credible.

Tsukihime's plot is also more mature, each resolution have more weight to them 1) Arc and Shiki didn't end up in good terms in Ciel's True End, 2) After every single of the Far Side of the Moon routes, Arc and Ciel will keep hunting Roa, 3) Akiha ends up as a doll in one ending, 4) Akiha and Kohaku die in another end, 5) Hisui's Good End wasn't precisely happy. In F/sn, only 2 characters couldn't be saved: 1) Ilya in UBW, 2) Saber and Ilya in HF.

Shirou never actually shows his resolve when it comes to deal with people who are prepared to kill,and the story does not have serious and mature Masters - aside from Zōken-and the only time Shirou had to confront one of his friends, was in HF against Black Saber. Shiki, on the other hand, had to fight Arc, Ciel, Akiha, and Satsuki at some point - there's also the point when he realises all what Kohaku has been doing.

FSN is just too light and aimed at teenagers. That why the dark and cold as ice Tsukihime is superior.
>>
>>138315753
route order: Arc>Ciel>Akiha>Hisui>Kohaku
>>
>>138315875
This pasta is getting stale
>>
File: 4.png (264 KB, 1000x1000) Image search: [Google]
4.png
264 KB, 1000x1000
>>138293810
Because Fate is the magnum opus of Otaku/Weeaboo pandering.
>>
>>138316429
it's true though.
>>
>>138316429
all of that is true
>>
>>138315753
Hisui's route felt like a preface to Kohaku's route, considering the ending of the former
>>
File: laughing cry.jpg (28 KB, 390x310) Image search: [Google]
laughing cry.jpg
28 KB, 390x310
>>138297904
>Don't avert your eyes
Holy shit
>>
File: 1444525647279.png (34 KB, 380x480) Image search: [Google]
1444525647279.png
34 KB, 380x480
>dishonest, especially with you
>plots the murder of your family
>for no reason

Why people like this cunt again?
>>
>>138316926
I disagree. I feel like all of the important and most interesting things happen in Hisui's route, with Kohaku's mostly just wrapping up loose ends.
>>
>>138299017
I'm amazed you could even give them a week. Red hair would rather burn the place to the ground before letting fatass and vampire set foot in the place let alone live there.
>>
>>138305588
Painful chunni shit is pretty much what made it become such a powerhouse later on,anon. Especially the sex. Lots of manga have made quips about "mana sharing"

Still, What is it with the japanese and wanting to be taken by force when it's time for sex?
>>
File: 020.png (1 MB, 1120x1600) Image search: [Google]
020.png
1 MB, 1120x1600
BB vs BB in the newest chapter of Foxtail
>>
File: 021.png (1 MB, 1120x1600) Image search: [Google]
021.png
1 MB, 1120x1600
>>
File: 022.png (1 MB, 1120x1600) Image search: [Google]
022.png
1 MB, 1120x1600
>>
>>138293957
Mods haven't given a shit for a long time now.
>>
Who's all hyped for the next Typemoon April fools day event in 4 weeks?
>>
File: Spread.png (2 MB, 2240x1600) Image search: [Google]
Spread.png
2 MB, 2240x1600
>>138319318
Its too soon, I'm not ready

I have to take that day off to see this all unfold. After what they did last year, I can't miss out.
>>
File: 1.jpg (203 KB, 720x1074) Image search: [Google]
1.jpg
203 KB, 720x1074
>>138294296
Fuck you faggot, at least Shirou is bearable in 3rei.
>>
Will the remake remove the sex scenes?
Will that make it better or worse?
>>
>>138319832
>Will the remake remove the sex scenes?
Probably
>Will that make it better or worse?
We'll have to see
>>
>>138319696
Shirou continues to be the best thing about Fate as a whole.
>>
>>138317153
I agree anon, she's shit
>>
>>138319832
I seem to recall a while back Nasu saying that it'd end up being 18+ regardless of sex scenes because of the violence.
>>
>>138319318
about?
>>
>>138319832
>worse?
Only the new design of Arcueid is horrible so far.
>>
>>138320621
We generally have no idea ahead of time, but every year it's great.
>>
File: 2.jpg (182 KB, 720x1082) Image search: [Google]
2.jpg
182 KB, 720x1082
>>138319696
>>
>>138320621
There is no "about?"

Type Moon just always holds a huge April Fools event each year. Its always the biggest thing they do each year, and it involves a lot of people and new content happening.

Last year they had twenty or thirty Fate characters playing the roles of the characters on twitter and posting all day for twenty-four hours. The people who were playing the roles were the various writers or VAs for the franchise.

The entire thing had a huge overarching plot with a lot of twists and oddities. Not only did they do that, but they did four other things in the same day and a few vids.

No one knows what TM is planning until it happens. They always do something different each time.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 145

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.