>I wish Walpurgisnacht was dead!
>>136239199
>I wish Mamifag was dead!
>>136239199
>I wish OP had never existed
>>136239199
Dubs for the Goddess!
With Madoka's power, that would have been a waste.
>>136239199
>I wish this thread wouldn't bump!
>I wish Madoka threads weren't terrible circlejerks!
>I'm sorry, Madoka, but not even the sufferring of a thousand timelines can displace such immese faggotry.
>>136239199
You just saved Mitakihara and doomed the whole Earth.
Good job.
>>136239199
> I wish they would stop milking my franchise.
>>136239761
>1 series, 3 movies, 2 manga
>milking
Those Kazumi and Oriko faggotry don't count.
>>136239199
You have to go to the source, anon.
You must un-create the ability for little girls to be reactors in the first place so that the creators of the Incubators fuck off.
>>136239844
but then humanity never evolves past cavemen, because apparently little girls invented all of human technology with wishes.
>>136239839
Everything past the series was a mistake.
I'm not even a butthurt homushitter; Rebellion was just unnecessary.
>>136239199
>I wish Rebellion didn't ruin a solid albeit overhyped show!
>>136240885
>>136241060
Stop it, Rebellion is a great movie.
>>136241230
>twists you see coming
>derailment of a tight series into more bullshit
>bullshitting a plot for the sake of continuation
Rebellion was the start of what will be Shaft's second long running cash cow. I will meet a cool chick and have children with her, and my progeny will grow up with season 20 something of Mahou Shoujo X Magica.
>>136239199
>Walpurgisnacht dies
>new Walpurgisnacht forms in the future because witch transformation still exists
>>136241377
>twists you see coming
Bullshit. Did you seriously think Homu was going to go devil at the end of the movie? If so, why made you think that?
I still agree that Rebellion was full of shit
>>136241377
>I will meet a cool chick and have children with her
>>136241494
I think he meant the whole "we're in a witch's labyrinth" and "It's Homura's" thing. Nobody saw the ending coming because it was a total ass pull.
>>136241377
>twists you see coming
Nobody saw the ending coming. Nobody.
>derailment of a tight series into more bullshit
If anything, it delved into the psychological aspect, focused on the girls' personnalities and concluded Homura as an allegory of mankind.
>I will meet a cool chick and have children with her
Hahahaha. Nope.
>and my progeny will grow up with season 20 something of Mahou Shoujo X Magica.
Even less likely.
>I wish a group of bald men would creampie me
>>136241494
The entire world was fucked. That meant a witch was around even though Madoka nullified them. Sayaka, Mami and Kyoko both died and moved on with Madoka along with all the other magical girls, leaving Homura as the last magical girl. Furthermore, since Homura is a magical girl at all, she has a soul gem, which gets corrupted via use of magic. We see her using magic at the end of the series, meaning she is slowly but surely being corrupted. No witches means no grief seeds, which means no purification. Which means Homura turns into a witch.
>but since witches don't exist shouldn't homura never be a witch?
In-show, I'd say the reasoning could be that her original timeline had witches, and since she never lost her experience with any of the resets, she is the original Homura simply creating alternate universes through time travel, meaning her contract is still technically valid and she herself is still destined for witchood.
Or, you know, they made movies for more dosh and needed to continue the series.
As far as the devil bit is conceerned, Homura was always obsessed with Madoka, it makes sense that she would make a Lucifer-esque move to keep her Madoka close to her, even if it meant pulling her from her wish.
I put this together after things started getting slightly serious.
>>136241758
It retconned the girls into acting like typical magical girls to entertain the fans. That wife and kids part is hyperbole, I'll probably die alone.
>>136241377
I'm with you on 2 and 3. Madokas original ending was a great resolution, and there was no reason to subvert it other than to create an opportunity to shove out even more Madoka-related content, and the way it was subverted was a punch in the face to everyone who liked that ending because it made everything Madoka did meaningless. It's like if someone retconned StarWars so after the end of Episode VII the dark side wasn't defeated after all.
>>136241857
>The entire world was fucked. That meant a witch was around even though Madoka nullified them
>since Homura is a magical girl, her soul gem can get corrupted
After watching the main series, I just don't see how anyone could assume this. Madokami made it so that witches could no longer exist. That includes any magical girl alive in the present when that wish was made (Homu). This is why the whole "Gotchu! Homu was actually a witch all along and everyone's in her barrier!" was the biggest twist in the movie. It's breaking the laws established in the main series
>Homura was always obsessed with Madoka, it makes sense that she would make a Lucifer-esque move to keep her Madoka close to her
I don't know, man. That seems like a bit of a stretch. I think the main expectation at the part of the movie was the magi girls save Homu from her barrier, then Homu joins the Law of Cycle and enters Valhalla with everyone else. It's the logical conclusion. Despite her obsession with Madoka, who would have thought that she would instead decide to use love to become a devil
>Or you know, they made movies for more dosh and needed to continue the series
I always thought that WAS the reason why they made Rebellion.
>>136239199
Why did you make this thread? What did you hope to accomplish with it?
Seriously, why did you make it?
>>136242537
A vague loophole in the law is magical potential. Madoka's kept growing with every reset. Did he reach her limit at the time she made her wish? Would she have been more powerful if Homura had reset again? Historically, do gods have any limitations. This sounds like empty rhetoric, but if Madoka is weak enough to be pulled down from the heavens by a being she thought she wiped out, then is it sensible the being was not completely wiped out in the first place?
With regards to Homura's obsession, it was a clear flag. Her entire existence by the point of the show was Madoka. She contracted for Madoka. She reset for Madoka. Her obsession gave Madoka the power to become a god. Literally, a divine being. All from Homura's focus. It has to be love. More than that, it has to be sick, selfish, epic love. The kind you hear about in old stories.
>>136242537
> I think the main expectation at the part of the movie was the magi girls save Homu from her barrier, then Homu joins the Law of Cycle and enters Valhalla with everyone else. It's the logical conclusion.
Indeed, this was the movie's original ending. It was changed so they could make more sequels.
I wish Crack guy wouldn't have ruined Madoka threads for all time because a small group of people are fucking awful humans! No, sub-human filth even Hikis should spit on!
>>136242882
It isn't crack guy's fault. It's that one faggot that always bitches him out.
He's just posting dumb pictures, there is nani to be sore.
>>136242734
Witch Homu should have never existed in the first place. Homu could have all the magical potential in the world+1, but she would still be bound by the new universal laws established by Madoka's wish. That's why the reveal that Homu was a witch was complete bullshit.
As far as know after watching the main series, magical potential can be utilized after making a wish. However, it being used AFTER making a wish and being a magical girl (in Homu's case), we don't really know. I suppose it can be used as an excuse to explain Homu's transformation. If you actually managed to hypothesize all that out as the movie was playing, well then damn, good job.
As for the Homu obsession, it was clear that Homu loved Madoka to the point of repeating X amount of timelines so she could achieve the good end, but I never thought that her love was so twisted to the point of becoming a devil just so she could protect Madoka
>>136243067
>Homu could have all the magical potential in the world+1, but she would still be bound by the new universal laws established by Madoka's wish
It wasn't about Homu's magic potential, she became a witch because Incubators interefered with their science. It's just that they didn't notice in time that they should have left the local equivalent of Cthulhu sleeping.
>>136243067
The entire point of the series is a twist from purity into impurity. It's The Urobutcher doing magical girls on the surface level, and if I'm not mistaken another important credit did a similar show before hand.
>>136242810
>wanting a reset button ending
Why don't you just watch Yuuki Yuuna?
>>136243205
>she became a witch because Incubators interefered with their science
I wonder if Madokami's new laws would still apply in a situation where a magical girl is FORCED to become a witch. My reasoning was that becoming a witch in general would activate the Madokami laws and prevent the magical girl from becoming a witch
>>136243251
I still feel like important details, like witches existing in Madokami's universe, were retconned which is why I don't treat Rebellion as movie of the year
>>136243251
>pleb spouting shit
Homura's character is an allegory of mankind created God who in the search of a reason to live and killed him when morals became blurred as to what's right or wrong because Love goes beyond moral values. It's not the love in your everyday Mahou Shoujo show that flows in the world and creates great things, it's a destructive obsession, a will to topple things and established orders for what one believe is right, no matter the cost.
And that itself is deeper than your Mahou Shoujo show #2513.
>>136243436
And my dick is an allegory for shonen anime. I'm just telling this guy my reasoning for seeing Homura coming.
>>136243436
You can interpret things any way you want. I think that's one of Rebellion's redeeming points
Rebellion > original series
>>136243431
>My reasoning was that becoming a witch in general would activate the Madokami laws and prevent the magical girl from becoming a witch
She wasn't forced to become a witch, it's just that the Incubators somehow figured out how to isolate a part of the universe from the new law. Not that it makes much sense, but I guess this is what happens when a show mixes magic and technology.
I hope everybody in this thread has a good day. :)
>>136243067
>As for the Homu obsession, it was clear that Homu loved Madoka to the point of repeating X amount of timelines so she could achieve the good end, but I never thought that her love was so twisted to the point of becoming a devil just so she could protect Madoka
It's all basically a gigantic shout out to the advice Madoka's mom gave her which inspired her to chuck a soulgem off the bridge. I can't remember it directly but it seems to make sense. Sometimes you have to look like a cunt and make a gigantic mistake to save your friend.
But Homura is a bit batshit crazy now.
>>136243436
>morals became blurred as to what's right or wrong because Love goes beyond moral values
>a will to topple things and established orders for what one believe is right, no matter the cost
Which is why we'll always have the "Homu did nothing right/wrong" debates, which I personally enjoy
>>136243494
>>136243496
It's not really a matter of interpretation. There are references to Nietzsche in Rebellion (the Clara dolls shouting "Gott ist tot" for example) and ending Homura is completely nihilist in her behavior. She toppled God and now she's trapped because she cannot have what she desires so profoundly (living alongside Madoka) and she therefore has lost her own foundation. She IS nihilism.
>>136243709
Awesome. Doesn't change that I was telling that guy how I predicted the twist after he claimed bullshit.
>>136243743
Predicting the twists accurately doesn't seem very likely unless you were also expecting retconning and rule breaking
>>136243670
Homu did everything right from her point of view, but unfortunately she was already batshit crazy at that point. The whole plot would be avoided if Sayaka explained everything to her when she had the chance - rather than teasing her until it was gtfo or toki wo tomare, leaving her alone with equally clueless Madoka, and finally letting Kyubey reveal the truth to her.
>>136239199
But she did that and so much more with her wish.
>>136243939
Not like she would have believed Sayaka-chan, who she believed to be the very witch that created the whole mess. The roles were reversed in Rebellion compared to the series, and Sayaka-chan did the same thing as Homura, albeit to her sauce.
Had Homura believed her, it wouldn't have changed the ending anyway.
>>136243883
To a certain extent, yeah. We're looking at cash here. Not integrity or skill, cash. Madoka is one of those series that is a normal story but is just different enough to reel people in and be popular.
These kind of shows are popular, and have been for at least as long as I've been alive, if not longer. From The Sopranos to Game of Thrones, when something is both comfortable and exotic at the same time, it becomes popular. If entertainment is popular, then it is profitable.
Capitalizing on popularity with pandering and shock is a great move for more dosh. I expected pandering, and that pandering lead me to the shock.
>>136239199
>I wish the fundamental problem concerning entropy in the universe was solved in a way that only fucks over Kyuubee's race and harms no one else!
>>136239199
>I wish this was official.
>>136244042
But to think that they would actually break one of the major rules that led to the satisfying conclusion of the main series (magical girls can no longer turn into witches, thus there is no more suffering) is what really surprised me
>>136244072
Would he still grant that wish?
If I wished QB was my sex slave, would he do it?
>>136244072
Probably wouldn't have worked. The brilliant part of Madoka's wish is that she wished for the power to do it herself instead of just wishing for it to happen, meaning Kyubey couldn't fuck her over by "interpereting" it.
Plus, wanting to personally help people is a huge part of her character.
>>136244222
Sure, you'd eventually die or turn into a sex slave themed witch and he's be off the hook.
I want to get raped by Gomadoka!
>>136244014
>Not like she would have believed Sayaka-chan, who she believed to be the very witch that created the whole mess.
Sayaka being as vague as humanly possible, topping it with actually showing her witch form to Homu, might have something to do with that suspicion.
>Had Homura believed her, it wouldn't have changed the ending anyway.
If she didn't talk to Madoka, alone she might not have the chance to pretty much manipulate her into telling her what she wanted to hear. If she wasn't "sure" that Madoka doesn't want to be a god, she might have hesitated in the end.
Of course, if Sayaka wasn't petty enough to have some revenge on Homu, there was no miscommunication and everything went according to plan, then we'd have rather boring plot with an ending making it obvious that the Incubators are going to try this shit again some day.
>>136244072
>Madoka has no clue about physics
>thermodynamics no longer works
>universe suddenly becomes unable to support life
>>136244351
But that would harm people other than Kyuubee's species.
>>136244222
>I want to fuck every Incubator, past, present, and future, with my own dick.
>>136244372
No one was ever born, so no one is harmed. Kyoko's wish has already proven that wishes open to interpretation are a bad idea.
>>136244398
>>136244423
Why would Kyuubee want the universe to end though? Everything he does is intended to preserve it.
>>136244450
I guess wishing that the universe dies and stays dead isn't an option
>>136244450
He didn't want Madoka to become a god either, I guess he's just unlocking some external power, and he's not the one doing the interpretation.
I wish Madoka would claim my testicles as her personal property!
>>136244222
Probably. He has no emotions and you'll be dead soon, so I doubt he'd care all that much.
>I wish entropy concept don't exist.
>>136244512
Imagine the plot of Rebellion with someone constantly fucking QB while he's talking indifferently.
>>136244512
>I wish QB feels the pleasure of being cummed inside
>>136244541
That's changing the laws of the universe, which means Madoka goes kami too
What did Homu wish for in the rewritten timeline?
>>136244814
40 cakes.
>>136239199
not letting you
>>136245241
people seem to forget that disabling Homu's reset button was the only way to make the wish stay
>>136244814
Her wish hasn't changed. She didn't exist there untill Sayaka died.
>>136246878
Mami and Kyoko would be surprised that she appeared out of nowhere then. Also she no longer had her time powers.
>>136239199
>I wish Shinbo and Urobuchi committed suicide before writing this anime!
>>136239199
>I wish forKevin-kun!
Homura's wish will always trump Madoka's. She wished to be strong enough to protect her.
>>136244503
Stop being lewd !GM.
I want to massage andlickMadoka's feet!
a friendly reminder
>>136248259
She's a almost as much of a baka as Sayaka is.
>oh shit, QB is evil and magical girls are witches
>maybe we should takaecondand think abou-
>lolno murder time
Why is she so perfect /a/?
>>136248551
Sorry, I posted the wrong meguca.
>>136248551
homu pls
>>136247464
Everything is explained in wraith arc manga. It's canon as shinbo and inu curry help with it. Her new power is memory manipulating.
>>136248911
Okay, I didn't read that. But how come she's so surprised about being the one to overwrite everyone's memories in Rebellion if she had these powers before?
Practically any other wish Madoka could have made would just have resulted in her becoming a witch and eating everything. All these "why didn't she wish for X" threads are retarded.
>>136249199
You're retarded.
>>136249257
No, you are
>>136249268No you are.
>>136249300
>>136249322
I like this thread
>>136249406
Best cat
>>136249406
A friendly reminder that it was QB who saved Mami, fixed Kyosuke's hand, destroyed all witches, and gave Nagisa a cheesecake.
>>136249770
Not really, the wishes come from the girls' potential, otherwise he wouldn't need them.
>>136249770
And also caused literally everything that went wrong
>>136249823
If it wasn't for him they could wish all they wanted, and nothing would happen.
>>136249837
Nope, that was humanity's curses. Also entropy.Okay, he was a bit of an asshole in Rebellion, though
>>136249823
Middle men are important nigga. You think a teenage ass girl can just be like "i wish i wish upon a fish my husbando's hands weren't broke as fuck"?
Nah man. You need the alien cat to harness their spirirt energy or whatever and make their dreams come true.
>>136249990
I was spooked. Good job.
>>136249990
Well, Homu's "I wish I could fuck over literally everyone I know to make my waifu happy whether she wants it or not; also I wish the alien cat hivemind was my bitch." did work.
>>136244222
what do you think would happen to your dick if you put it in the hole you put used grief seeds in?
>>136250053
Danke. Funny how this image can actually make me wake up in a cold sweat but when I saw some get stabbed irl I didn't care.
>>136250341
it would be purified?
>>136250374
I igured it was like a black hole in there? if it purified the grief seeds couldn't they be reused then?
or is he purifying them to recycle them as a soul gem for the next girl
>>136249770
>and gave Nagisa a cheesecake
That whole experience ended up making her really sad and fall to despair though
>>136250441
It would be against the rules to suggest a better wish.
>>136250364
Wow.
>>136250418
We really don't know what he does with them. I always figured he just disposes of them safely like radioactive waste, but there's always the possibility that he plants them somewhere else to bolster witch populations when necessary.
>>136250487
She was too young to understand what she was doing though. There is a reason that young people cannot be held to contracts.
Why didn't she just wish for unlimited wishes?
>>136250877
probably some sort of rule against that
>>136250784
If he didn't show up, her mother would die anyway. That way she became a magical girl for a while (not QB's fault she screwed it up) and later met Mami, who would adopt her even after their initial misunderstandings.
>>136250987
I suppose it isn't so bad since she seemed happy enough with Mami at the end of Rebellion. Kyuubey should still feel bad about himself for contracting with someone too young to be of sound mind though.
>>136251099
>kyubey
>feel
C'mon anon.
Also Mami is a terrible person for exposing Nagisa to /ll/.
>>136251134
He should feel that way but that doesn't mean he will or even possibly can. Maybe I am just shouting at a mountain here.
I think you have the wrong idea about Mami. I don't think she would do anything bad with Nagisa.
>>136251273
Given that Sayaka remembered everything in Rebellion (both inside Homura's soul gem and in the rewritten world) until Homu erased her memory, I think it's safe to assume Nagisa still remembers how does Mami taste like.
>>136251273
I'm sure nagisa didn't think it was bad
>>136250877
you require more vespene gas
How much is changed in the movies compared to the TV show?
I was going to rewatch the series in one sitting with some friends who have never seen it before but I have been starting to consider the movies might be a better idea because then I wont have to keep switching the episode.
>>136251784
Watch the series, then the movies, then the series again, then rebellion again
>>136251339
Maybe. Do the girls remember their lives from other timelines once Madoka takes them away though? Nagisa hasn't tasted Mami in the current timeline after all.
>>136251512
That picture must be some kind of silly mistake. I don't think you should be sharing something so personal though.
>>136251784
Movies drop Mami's backstory and Homu threatening to kill Sayaka. Perhaps something more, I don't remember. They aren't really that much shorter than the series, though. If you want the movies for the better animation, you should know that someone bothered to cut up the movies and replace the relevant parts in the show.
>>136249027
I didn't remember that Homura was very surpriced in Rebellion. And she probably used her magic on herself too.
>>136251884
>Mami's love
>a mistake
Jerk
>>136251884
>Maybe. Do the girls remember their lives from other timelines once Madoka takes them away though? Nagisa hasn't tasted Mami in the current timeline after all.
Sayaka did remember witches, also both her and Nagisa could use their witch forms.
>>136251273
You're just fishing for that copypasta, aren't you?
>>136251921
Is everything else exactly the same? Or was the whole thing remade?
>>136251996
Eh? It is just that Nagisa is so young. If Mami loved her in such a way she would wait until Nagisa is a proper age before doing such things, right?
>>136252003
Did Sayaka actually have her own memories of witches or only what she had heard from Madoka? And them having witch powers doesn't mean they would have their memories as witches. I have always thought that the girls would be able to see through time and space like Madoka does since they are in the same realm but I don't know if there is enough evidence to actually confirm it.
>>136252058
Not really, no. People just post lewd things at me.
>>136252102
I don't want to mislead you, as it's been a while since I've last watched the movies, but I don't remember any significant changes to the plot. Only some scenes that were dropped, and some rearranged. The animation was redone, but overall it's a faithful remake, not something like Eva rebuilds, if that's what you have in mind. Anyway, if I were to show Madoka to someone then I guess I'd use the movies too, they seem much more concise.
>>136252254
Waiting is for people that don't have to worry about dying every night.
>>136239199
you know the best wish she could have done is wished that girls that had their magic run out or their soul gems destroyed simply have their human bodies restored and their souls put back into them. fucking everything would have been solved.
>>136252514
She can wait all she wants in Homura's new world.Or so she would think. She only has time until Nagisa grows tired sick of the fake world where her mom is still dead, and all her friends her age are just Homu's imagination (remember the scene where Homura erases Sayaka's memory, and for a while there's no one except for them two, and Nagisa running alone?). Of course, knowing what happened to Sayaka, she wouldn't stand up to Homura directly, instead devising some covert plan to reinstate Madoka.
>>136252514
That is true. If they do both truly love each other then I suppose there is no reason that I should object. I don't think there is any reason to think their bond is romantic though.
>>136252567
that wold mean that there's still witches but now no way to stop them because I doubt kyubey wil be willing to make more magical girls since he won't be able to get energy from them so, once the remaining batch of magical girls goes back there will just be powerful witches with nothing stopping them
MAXIMUM LEWD EVERY NIGHT
CHEESCAKE ALL OVER BODIES LEWD
>>136252729
I don't know about that. Incubators still exist in Homu's new universe, as does her soul gem, so magical girls probably do as well?
>>136252736
Pure lust, then.
>>136252908
>I don't know about that. Incubators still exist in Homu's new universe, as does her soul gem, so magical girls probably do as well?
I've thought that the world seen in the ending of Rebellion is some pocket universe separate from the real one. Homura says something to Sayaka about them being accidentally trapped in there, also there are scenes where everyone except for named characters disappears (just like in Homu's labirynth).
>>136252781
Wraiths would most likely still show up in that universe. On the other hand, putting the souls back in the bodies could negate all gains from gathering the curses.
>>136252908
>CHEESCAKE ALL OVER BODIES LEWD
Let's just hope Nagisa doesn't instinctively transform into her witch form.
PUELLAï¼ï¼¡ï¼§ï¼©ï¼ï¼¡ï¼¤ï¼¯ï¼«ï¼¡ï¼ï¼¡ï¼§ï¼©ï¼£ï¼¡
>>136239199
I wish I could go back to 2011 and shit post the threads with spoilers from Rebellion.
>>136253456
Maybe Mami likes it a tad rough
>>136248431
Mami had the right idea but the wrong target.
>>136253472
!Bebe is aso lewd? What is this world coming to?
>>136253472
This picture makes me very sad. Imagine being a magical girl, going on adventures with all your magical girl friends and having fun together and doing cutesy things like this. That will never happen to any of us, at least not in this life.
>>136253743
Why do you think I am lewd?
>>136253863
>That will never happen to any of us, at least not in this life.
On the other hand, there are no witches, and the universe isn't ruled by a crazy girl turned outer god.
Swift death to Homura
>>136253951
> the universe isn't ruled by a crazy girl turned outer god.
You make that sound like a bad thing.
>>136253951
Which one could use to point out that Homura's universe isn't final either, but an intermediary stage.
>implying Nagisa didn't start the relationship
>>136253863
At least you were born in the right time to watch Madoka Magica. Remind the vast history of mankind.
>>136254074
Plot twist: Madoka and Yuuna share an universe, and the clusterfuck in the latter is a direct result of Homura's incompetence as a god.
>>136253863
You are followed by lewd posters who undoubtedly are lead by you. Whos next? Lewd kevin? Lewd apple?
>>136253951
The Madoka universe wouldn't be my first choice if I could be a magical girl. I would really want to be with them but I wouldn't want to fall to despair or die abruptly.
>>136254108
Even better than that, it aired when I was Madoka's age. Sometimes I feel like it was made specifically for me because it helped me out during a very rough part of my life. That is probably not true though. Thanks though, anon, your message helped me.
>>136254162
I don't try to lead them! They just followed me around. I will be honest though, there are two anime girls that I have thought of lewdly but neither of them are Mami or Nagisa. One is a Meguca though but I won't say which because someone here waifus her and I don't want them to feel bad. I tried to waifu her but I just ended up feeling bad; she was a good waifu to me but I felt like a bad waifu to her. I don't think of her like that anymore so she has the opportunity to be with someone better.
>>136254625
>but I felt like a bad waifu to her.
So you are a girl. You are truly lewd.
Reminder that MadokaneverlovedHomura!
I wanna eat qb
>>136254845
Hypothetically, how do you think grilled qb would taste? Would it be tender?
>>136254899
raw qb might be tasty. he's only shown truly happy when he's eating something, and he had the exact same expression when he ate himself.
>>136254899
I think it would be poisonous with all the ingested GS.
>>136254763
I am actually an omnigender transnigger demilich and I use xe/xer/xer-highness pronouns and I would like you not to forget it, okay shitlord?
Actually I won't say if you are right but I don't like the word husbando so I wouldn't use that either way. Just because you are a boy doesn't mean that you can't be someone's waifu!
>>136254899
I wouldn't trust it. You don't know where it's been!
To confess, it seems that Nagisa wasn't that helpful at all.
>>136255097
I have my eyes on both you and !GM. I will strike whenever, whereever. Until then.
>tfw still refusing to watch rebellion
>>136255121
She was literal fanservice.
>>136255121
Mami would disagree. She doesn't even need vibrators anymore!
>>136255314
>Bebe still being ecchi!
>>136255220
Stop caring about trips. Treat them anonymous, for the sake of Madoka threads.
>>136255281
Just do it. It's actually a pretty kickass movie, divisive fanservice aside.
>>136255121
Be nice to her! She tried her best.
>>136255358
Fuck no. The ending to the TV show was literally perfect. Even if Rebellion had a great ending (which I hear it absolutely does not) I wouldn't watch it because I dont want to kill my closure.
>>136239199
>I wish the system could create magical boys!
>>136255427
>literally perfect.
how?
homura ultimately failed
and madoka made the shitty mahou shoujo system slightly less shitty.
>>136255427
Homura telling the incubators about witches at the end of the tv series is the cause of everything that happens in the movie.
>>136240885
I'm a homushitter myself and I think Rebellion actively made the original series less terrible just by being so great.
>>136241377
>twists you see coming
>derailment of a tight series into more bullshit
>bullshitting a plot for the sake of continuation
Rebllion, not the TV series you dipshits
>>136255281
Keep your stance anon.
>>136255477
Its bittersweet and gives good closure, even though the ending isn't exactly happy. I like it like that.
>>136255499
All I know isHomura turns evil or some shit and undoes everything that Madoka accomplishes.
Unless the new movie coming out either retcons rebellion, or actually gives it an ending as satisfying as the TV show, I'm gonna steer clear of it.
>>136255450
maho shonen faustus magicus
>>136255584
Rebellion doesn't retcon the series,at least not completely
It's the witch!
>>136255427
>The ending to the TV show was literally perfect.
I have never seen a TV series with an ending as terrible as Madoka. AO had a better ending. DTB had a better ending. Code Geass had a better ending. DEEN/Stay Night had a better goddamn ending than Madoka. Getter Robo Arc had a better ending and it just stopped halfway through.
>>136255718
Maybe you just have shit taste.
>>136255477
Homura didn't fail, all she did was strictly necessary for Madoka to build up enough power to make her wish. Madoka used her one chance to rewrite the world to make a straightforward but powerful change, that couldn't backfire. All in all, the concept of achieving happiness, but not the one which one was striving for (with Homura digging herself deeper and deeper in pursuit of an impossible goal) meshes well with the buddhist undertones in the show.
>>136256100
Nothing is impossible with AI YO.
>>136256099
Maybe I like stories with resolution
>>136256100
>omura didn't fail, all she did was strictly necessary for Madoka to build up enough power to make her wish.
homuras whole goal was to keep her from making a wish
>>136256502
Incorrect. That became her most successful tactic after a few loops.
>>136256502
At first, she only wanted to save Madoka from dying. Only when she learned that all magical girls either die young or become witches, she changed that to preventing Madoka from contracting. Later Madoka asked her that herself. But this was completely impossible, as Madoka became so powerful that Kyubey would never let her go; even if Homura defeated Walpurgisnacht, Kyubey would still stalk Madoka, waiting for an opportune moment to contract her. Homura would have to guard her every waking moment until whatever is the time limit for becoming a magical girl, defeating every witch that might come to Mitakihara, and if she screwed up just once, she'd have to hit the reset button making everything harder yet again (not to even mention having to fight Walpurgisnight again).
Madoka found a way to use Homu's work to free them both (together with every other magical girl), without dying or becoming a witch, thus not violating Homura's original goal. It's not her fault Homu was stubborn and decided to fuck upalmosteverything in Rebellion by playing ubermensch (thoughmaking Incubators her bitch was a good move, as leaving them in power was the one flaw in Madoka's plan)
>>136257173
Madoka was a dumb bitch. Homura didn't care about being free. She suffered unending bullshit to protect her, so they could be together. So Madoka would be safe. A world without Madoka is a world where she failed.
>>136257506
Well, by the last timeline and Rebellion, Homura wasn't even treating Madoka as a person, just as a precious object to keep safe. She'd routinely deride Madoka's own dream to help people, and she'd rather continue her hopeless fight than accept Madoka's solution, nevermind that her falling to despair without even the decency to kill herself would mean serious trouble (especially if Rebellion's Homulilly was an underdeveloped form, "hatched within a shell"), giving Madoka no other choice but to either contract or be killed by combined forces of Walpurgisnacht and Homulilly. In Rebellion she still can't accept Madoka as her equal, and had to put her in a disadvantaged position to protect her smile. No wonder she ends up hating herself so much she declares herself a demon (which makes Rebellion's ending just as perfect as the series').
>>136255427
>Even if Rebellion had a great ending (which I hear it absolutely does not)
Majority liked the ending
what is it about homura that made her do nothing wrong?
>>136261872
She
>fixed the original ending
>went full JUSTICE on QB
>punished Madoka for acting like a dumb little shit
>is now the sexiest being in existence
>>136251784
the post kyoko death scene was my favorite added scene in the movies.
>>136262332
Isn't it pretty much the only one?
>>136262430
I think so, aside for that I liked the music in the movies over the shows. It fit the scenes better and was less repetitive. Imho watch the first 8 episodes, then the second movie. The second movie is just a better version of episodes 9-12. The first movie loses some of the slice of life scenes and some sayaka scenes but has better music.
>>136262430
Mami's second transformation (before Charlotte) was also longer in the movie.
>>136262547
Isn't Fancutfag the best release? (inserting the new and/or improved scenes from the movies into the episodes) Though one could argue it's "impure" because of it.
>>136262547
>The first movie loses some of the slice of life scenes and some sayaka scenes but has better music.
Am I the only one who thinks that animation in the first couple of episodes gets completely unwatchable every now and then? As much as I like the show, I can't really bring myself to rewatch the series any more because of that, fortunately movies fix this.
>>136248259
The only anime girl who makes me fap and cry.
>>136263510
yea, i just rewatched the series yesterday and now I just prefer to watch the movies whenever I rewatch. Also Its nice on a rewatch to not have to sit through the OP and ED over and over.
I would Walpurgi her Snatch if you catch my drift
>>136263874
>fapping to meguca
>>136258097
>bullshit: the post
Homura's fight wasn't hopeless, for she never gave up hope until the time came when she learned about each loop making things worse by increasing Madoka's karmic destiny. The moment it became hopeless, she gave up on fighting and witched out. Carrying on hope is treated as nothing but a good thing within the story, what with Madoka affirming that under no conditions would she want the act of having hope to be wrong.
At no point did Homura "deride" Madoka's dream. What she did at most was pointing out in a harsh manner what would not work out in the end, especially for errors such as Sayaka contracting and just like that sealing her own doom (this also is why the claim that Homura treated Madoka as anything less than a person is utterly moronic; reasoning with and convincing are useless acts for anything other than another person able and willing to rationalize.) This remains true even after Rebellion, where Homura's own universe seems to retain the changes originally imposed by Madoka's own wish, this being and all but confirmed by the concept movie showing wraiths but little to no sign of witches. That is, unless you are seriously going to argue that Madoka's true goal was to serve as sacrifice for her wish's sake rather than for the results of her wish (saving magical girls everywhere and also Mitakihara through no Walburger), in which case you're painting Madoka to be an utter asshole willing to disregard her family (and right after her mother's speech about how she needed to value her own life, too) and everyone else for no reason if she truly wanted to be removed from that reality as an end in itself, rather than as a means for the wish she had in mind. (Hint: few are the acts more selfish than that of suicide: by design it happens for the sake of solving problems for the one to engage on it and always on the expense of those around them; no wonder it's looked down by cultures everywhere.)
I recommend you fanfiction.net.
>>136248431
I don't get it, what did Mami do besides be lonely and die?
>>136265550
She stole my heart
>>136263874
>that bulge
More like Dadi.
>>136266242
She's just fat.
Which character was the most tragic?
>>136264682
>Homura's fight wasn't hopeless, for she never gave up hope until the time came when she learned about each loop making things worse
It didn't become true just because Homura learned about it.
>Carrying on hope is treated as nothing but a good thing within the story, what with Madoka affirming that under no conditions would she want the act of having hope to be wrong
Making this true and giving hope to everyone was the reason for Madoka's sacrifice, she wouldn't have do do it if it was already true.
>At no point did Homura "deride" Madoka's dream.
>this also is why the claim that Homura treated Madoka as anything less than a person is utterly moronic;
She did call Madoka a fool for wanting to help Sayaka, or resolve her fight with Kyoko. Homura had her reasons to withhold the truth about magical girls, but the moment she started doing this she no longer treated Madoka as her equal. She didn't do that on purpose, of course. It's just that when she ceased to talk to Madoka unless when it was inevitable, she unknowingly became obsessed about the concept of Madoka and not the girl herself. She actually mentions that they're drifting apart with each loop while crying on Madoka's shoulder.
>What she did at most was pointing out in a harsh manner what would not work out in the end
And this is exactly what Madoka ended up doing to Homura, only with more success.
>where Homura's own universe seems to retain the changes originally imposed by Madoka's own wish
You conveniently omit the fact that ripping Madoka from the Madokami wasn't the only change. She reversed their first meeting, supressed her memories, depriving her of a choice to go back, and the world she created is likely an illusion (basing on what she told Sayaka, and that unnamed people disappear in some scenes) making the point about her parents moot, as they're not even alive in this world.
All in all, while I do consider Homura a tragic hero, the "Homu did nothing wrong" meme is plain retarded.
>>136266488
Incubator
>>136251884
Sayaka has Klarissas as backup dancers in Rebellion, and they only showed up in timeline 3, so influences from other timelines are clearly there.
>>136247548
Kevin-kun!
>>136267017
Oops!
>>136266659
In their valiant pursuit of stopping the decay of the universe, they came across thing a space ferret was not meant to know, and paid with their sanity.
>>136247548
>>136267017
>>136267061
No!
Sucky tripfag.
>>136267017
>>136267061
>trip off
Can't you just stay like that forever?
>>136267193
>>136267104
But I wished for!
>>136267447
Shut up nerd
>>136267473
Is this a normal Madoka thread?
And by normal I mean different than expected which is the opposite of normal.
>>136267911
Yes. It's normal.
We have the tripfags, now all we need is crack and the circle will be complete.
>>136267911
It's turning into the usual shit, but that discussion at the beginning was pretty out of the blue.
>>136268016
It's happening more often, which is promising.
>>136267911
It's a 5/10 so far, which is better than the usual 1/10. Had a 7/10 yesterday with actual discussion.
>>136267911
Not enough Sayakaposting.
>>136268066
It's probably the concept movie and shit reigniting the interest in some people who left this hellhole long ago.
>>136268066
New mainstream content is coming out too, so hopefully this den of immense faggotry can make a turn around,
http://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/kino/anime-madoka-magica-eine-maedchentragoedie-14014295.html
>actually decent Rebellion review in a mainstream paper
you Germanons might be interested
>>136267991
Don't start anything please.
>>136268124
>>136268294
>>136267991
and I was beginning to forget why is it usually a bad idea to mention that you like madoka anywhere else.
>>136239199
Why didn't Madoka just wish for infinite wishes? Makes just as much sense as wishing to become god.
>>136239670
>>136270131
>>136239199I wish for Madoka threads for all eternity
>>136267911
It started off well, bright and full of hope, but then quickly drew the attention of tripfags like moths to a flame, at which point it turned into ashen, hatred, and charred dreams.
>>136269463
>>136270495
>>136270533
>>136270495
>>136270611
>>136270662
>>136270829
>>136270533
>>136270909
>>136271044
mfw rewatching rebellion and i find this thread
>>136271131