[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Aren't they basically magical girls.
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 113
Thread images: 21
File: p.jpg (37 KB, 400x300) Image search: [Google]
p.jpg
37 KB, 400x300
Aren't they basically magical girls.
>>
They're basically a sentai
>>
>>135425666

Ikki best girl
>>
>>135425666
Except they're not girls. That makes all the difference.
>>
DAKISHIMETA
>>
>>135425770

I came here to post this.
>>
>>135425666
More like magical men
>>
What did she mean by this?
>>
>>135427084

Apparently jack shit cuz she was WRONG.

also does anyone know what episode has Ikki hitting a guy with his Demon Fist and making him hallucinate decapitating Ikki?
>>
>>135425666
Sai was the prettiest girl, but I'll bet Seiji's the one who would devastate you in bed.
>>
>>135427134
>also does anyone know what episode has Ikki hitting a guy with his Demon Fist and making him hallucinate decapitating Ikki?
you mean when he hit nachi?
>>
File: saint-seiya-hyoga-shun.jpg (108 KB, 560x361) Image search: [Google]
saint-seiya-hyoga-shun.jpg
108 KB, 560x361
I could totally see this scene be repeated in Madoka.
>>
>>135427249
>shun's master wanted to fuck him
>turned her down
no excuse for this
>>
>>135425666
there's more to magical girl genre than changing costume. They need a secret identity, a power giving mascot animal, and slice of live segments.
>>
>>135427084
SQUADATHENA! WE'RE OFF!
>>
>>135425925
Yeah, this. But the idea it's in principle the same only with less cutesy. inb4 spic.
>>
>>135426228
midnigt blueee?
>>
>>135425666
No, magical girls use one attack with recycled animation to beat the baddy of the week.

The cloth "transformation" is reminiscent to magical girls yes, but from then on it's shounen battle.
>>
>>135427197
Shit freaked me out so hard as a kid.
Fucker was thrown into lava and his flesh fucking melted off
>>
File: manly[recure.webm (3 MB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
manly[recure.webm
3 MB, 1280x720
>>135427784
clearly doesn't watch much mahou shoujo
>>
>>135427539

Good taste
>>
>>135427858
I don't watch precure, But whats the name of the brunnette girl? for reasons.
>>
File: file.png (97 KB, 259x194) Image search: [Google]
file.png
97 KB, 259x194
>>135427901
I tried but it was fucking shit.
My frame of reference is pic related.
>>
File: 1423821502379.jpg (231 KB, 1280x1312) Image search: [Google]
1423821502379.jpg
231 KB, 1280x1312
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dy98T030AB4
Thread theme song
>>
File: My Cosmos burns.gif (2 MB, 335x360) Image search: [Google]
My Cosmos burns.gif
2 MB, 335x360
>>135426228
KOKORO NO KOSUMO
>>
File: mamifight.gif (992 KB, 500x250) Image search: [Google]
mamifight.gif
992 KB, 500x250
>>135427983
watch moar plox
>>
>>135425666
>Middle schoolers
>2 of them are siblings
>Initially 4 but 1 joins later
>They get themed armors when they transfrom
>They fight enemies with the 12 zodiac constelations motif
>They lose their senses when the go all out

Why is Yuuki Yuuna such a Saint Seiya ripoff
>>
File: yuukiyuuna.jpg (542 KB, 1280x720) Image search: [Google]
yuukiyuuna.jpg
542 KB, 1280x720
>>135428585
And as always I forgot my pic.
>>
>>135427084
It means she's tsundere for Seiya
>>
>>135428585
Because Saint Seiya created modern battle shounen and modern magical girls are made by men and for men.
>>
>>135428619
>>135428585
It's worthless without the sadomasochism. See omega
>>
The quality change between episodes is pretty off-putting, the episode where Yoga fights the Crystal Saint looks good, but the one where Ikki returns looks like shit.
>>
>>135429212
That's the 80s for you.
>>
>>135429273
At least some episodes look very good and a bunch of them are fucking beautiful. Nowadays everything is so fucking bland
>>
>>135429273
I know it happened a lot (Macross is another good instance), but in SS Toei just didn't care at all. Dragon Ball, on the other hand, had much more consistency between episodes than SS.
>>
>>135429413
Please, not this "I miss cell animation, fuck current animation" bullshit again...
>>
File: saint precure.gif (923 KB, 264x198) Image search: [Google]
saint precure.gif
923 KB, 264x198
>>135427901
Toei has a love-hate relationship with Saint Seiya. Toei can't stop shitting over it but also can't stop using it as inspiration
>>
>>135428585
>>2 of them are siblings
All of them are siblings
>>
>>135427189
>>135427197

Thanks chaps.
>>
>>135430486
It's Toei's nature to shit on all of their properties. It's how they do business.
>>
No they are manly, you just don't understand.
>>
>>135427134
Also happens in the Lucifer's movie
>>
Let's try this again.

FAÇA ELEVAR
>>
>>135431651
O COSMO DO SEU CORAÇÃO
>>
>>135431823

TODO O MAL

COMBATER
>>
>>135425666
___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|__
___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|__
___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|__
___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|__
___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|__
___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|__
BUILD IT
>>
SIEMPRE LA VERDAD
>>
>>135427197
Hoky Shit, I just realized he got hit in the nuts!

Dick move Ikki.
>>
>>135425666
THERE NOT THEY ARE THE MOST MANLIEST MEN EVER!!!!!.

But seriously they are taking an ass whooping and then getting up again, then shedding man tears for your brothers.
>>
>>135431280
That was based as fuck. The fans tend to despise the Lucifer movie but I think it was pretty cool as action porn. I have very low standards for Toei movies after all
>>
>>135434298
>Dick move Ikki.

Ikki is the king of dick moves, his first fucking appearance he's kicking everybody's ass that he's later gonna befriend.

par for the course. Also a tsundere brocon
>>
>>135434663
To be fair, everyone minus Shun was OK with killing Ikki. Meanwhile, faggots like Sasuke can fuck up like a million times and the good guys still believe in him
>>
File: 1446217290731.png (105 KB, 438x503) Image search: [Google]
1446217290731.png
105 KB, 438x503
>>135430486
>Toei will never make episode g
>>
>>135426800
and this guy never got a golden armor

i call bullshit
>>
For this episode I had the idea to mix in Pegasus Fantasy into the scene they got their new power. Funnily enough it matched up very well.
>>
>>135430486
Seiya and co looks so cool and manly and then generic moeblobs appear
>>
>>135435286
Toei movies and Omega don't count. Ikki wore the Leo cloth on Elysium and he was recently established as the sucessor of Leo on ND
>>
>>135431930
DESPERTAAAR O PODER!
>>
>>135435340
Phoenix armor is cooler though.
>>
>>135435340
He should have been the succesor to Cancer, fits him better.
>>
they tried really hard with Omega. Best girl potential was wasted, shitty season 2, goddamn
>>
>>135435801
Ikki born under the sign of Leo. It can't be helped.
>>
>>135435286
>and this guy never got a golden armor

Has he ever really needed it? Ikki is OP as fuck
>>
>>135425666
Don't you mean aren't magical girls basically them?
Besides Sailor Moon the only other magical girl anime was in 1960s.
While super hero boy groups were out since the start of anime.
>>
>>135435890
Her cloth was s fucking stupid. I know she wasn't supposed to be a saint but Umakoshi should give her a new design instead of using it the original. Well, Toei rushed the production so it couldn't be helped. Omega looks like a rushed poorly thought rushed product because it was a poorly thought rushed product
>>
>>135436039
Sailor Moon seems to be influenced by Saint Seiya though. It may be incidental but Ikuhara sees Yamauchi as his mentor together with Junichi Sato so there are some small homages to SS in Sailor Moon.
>>
>>135436093
I just mean there have been Power Ranger styled groups since the start of anime, it's a unbelievably common theme for both female/male cast.
>>
Why is Saint Seiya so overrated?
12 temples and galaxy tournament only good parts of the main series.
>>
>>135436232

>>135432013
>>
>>135436232
>Only have 1 good arc
>People still think that the series is great
Just like any Togashi manga.
>>
>>135436502
Hades elysion shit was good though
>>
>>135436039
>Besides Sailor Moon the only other magical girl anime was in 1960s.
the fuck. Are you retarded?
>>
>>135430486
I love those kind of sequences.
>>
>>135425666
Both are derivatives of the super sentai series.
>>
>>135425666

Let our powers combine!
>>
File: 1285179095896.jpg (57 KB, 720x720) Image search: [Google]
1285179095896.jpg
57 KB, 720x720
>>135436502
I don't know, I like the Poseidon arc so much, even was better than 12 temples arc.
>>
>>135436900
Some sentais have taken inspiration from Saint Seiya though, for example Gekiranger. The producer claimed SS was one of the main inspirations
>>
Saint Seiya inspired Bleach's best arc. not sure if pro or con.
>>
>>135438469
Kubo is Kurumada's poor man
>>
>>135435286
They pretty much established it that the Phoenix armor was the TOP armor of all.
>>
>>135427306
And to fight for the sake of love and justice, don't you forget that!
>>
>>135437992
Poseidon is definitely underrated
>>
>>135433812
Vencera a todo el mal
>>
>>135426800
Can Saitama beat Ikki?
>>
>>135427297
>turned her down
Except his master was a man, both in the manga and in the anime
>>
>>135427297
You mean June, right?
>>
File: bait.png (57 KB, 625x656) Image search: [Google]
bait.png
57 KB, 625x656
>>135425666
Nice try Satan
>U still mad about that movie huh?
>>
>>135434803
Toei wouldn't be able to do a good work with Episode G because the art is insane.
>>
>>135441023
Am I the only one that actually liked Legend of the Sanctuary?

The only part I cringed at was the Deathmask musical, and even then I kinda just laughed at it afterwards.
>>
>>135435286
He is confirmed as the successor of the leo cloth in the recent ND chapters.
>>
>>135440500
y si tu... quieres ser... un guerrero
>>
>>135435286
Why would he need one?
Being the Phoenix Saint meant eternal life and the ability to resurrect, also, he's the only Phoenix Saint, since no one wore the Phoenix Cloth before him so that pretty much says how powerful he is.
>>
>>135441023
Hey i like that movie
>>
File: 1440482216194.png (40 KB, 392x200) Image search: [Google]
1440482216194.png
40 KB, 392x200
>>135433812
>>135440500
>>135441202
not https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XTkc3e1741w
plebs, the lot of you
>>
>>135441468
nice choice, I'm between that one and Legend of Crimson Youth
>>
>>135427306
Mahou Shoujo should be defined by a prototype definition. The more of the characeristics of a mahou shoujo a show fits, the more typical of a magical girl anime it is. When you start reaching only a few of the traits, you may start to argue if it's actually a magical girl show or not. But having strict requirements doesn't work, because even very typical mahou shoujo may fail some typical traits. If they fulfill many other requirements, they should still be considered well within the mahou shoujo genre.

(There also seems to be some people who simply use a literal definition: is it girl+magic, then it's mahou shoujo. This is a definition I strongly disagree with, and this thought should be disregarded for my post.)

I have put some thought into trying to come up with some prototype traits of mahou shoujo, and I have come up with something, although there may be redundancies, some important characteristics may be missing, and there is overall room for imporvement. However, I will present what I've come up with in order to further explain my argument, as my present work should be suitable for this purpose, despite its flaws. Then, I'll put these characteristics up against some anime I've watched and draw comparions, and we can see if we discover a pattern to how many of the mahou shoujo characteristics a show meet, and how often it's considered a mahou shoujo. So, here are the characteristics I've come up with:

-Mascot animal, often granting powers
-Pre-action sequence, animated outside the typical frame of the show, with animated effects usually not influencing the plot. Happens before the magical girl perfoms an action the show may be build arond.
-Contrast between day-to-day life and world of "magical" powers. (Society should not, on the surface, be built around magical powers.)
-The magical girl should have a different look during action from her regular look
(too long, more to follow)
>>
File: Mahou Shoujo Seiya.jpg (202 KB, 420x600) Image search: [Google]
Mahou Shoujo Seiya.jpg
202 KB, 420x600
>>135425666
No
>>
Tenkaihen was a masterpiece

Yeah I'm the only one who liked it.
>>
>>135442445
I like it too. Unfortunately, Japan has shit tastes
>>
>wanted to watch saint seiya but I only speak english
>lets look for english subbed torrents
>could barely find any and none of them were seeded
>could find plenty of spanish shit
>youtube videos all lead to spanish shit
>had to play the games because the only source I could get for english translated seiya
Fuck you spics.
>>
>>135441141
I also liked it quite a bit.
>>
>>135442306 continuned

-The basic outline of the action outfit should be fundamentally determined by the shape of the main character
-Female main character
-Humanoid main character
-Action outfit should have a girly design
-Effects portraying use of action during the part of the show where the action takes place should have a energy-ish, or at least nontechnological, aestetic.
-Pre-action sequence should be a transformation scene where the heroine changes from her regular outfit to her action outfit

We'll say this is enough, I forgot some of the other ones. But this should be sufficient for something to work with, during the analysis of various shows and how well they fit the criteria, in comparison to how typical mahou shoujo they are.

- Cardcaptor Sakura:
This is an anime very well recognized as a mahou shoujo. And, we can see that it fits all the criteria almost perfectly. However, it is slightly atypical in its lack of a transformation sequence. Overall, fits very many of the criteria very well.

-Princess Tutu:
Also well recognized as a Mahou Shoujo. However, not all of the requiremets for "the perfect mahou shoujo" are met: it has no animal mascot. It also lacks battle scenes, however this was something I absolutely failed to mention.

-Magic Knight Rayearth
An anime frequently brought up as a mahou shoujo. However, it fails at many of the given criteria, and under a strict definition, could very well be excluded from the genre. It has an animal mascot, which I feel should be given much weight, however, there are no transformations or different outfits between regular life and battles, and there is no contrast between a secret magical world and a non-magical world. Can be considered a mahou shoujo, but a very atypical one.

-Revolutionary Girl Utena:
No mascot animal, no action outfit, no transformation, not very flashy action moves. However, has a female main character, and has a pre-action sequence. I have serious trouble considering this a mahou shoujo
>>
>>135435429
SUA CONSTELAÇÃO
SEMPRE IRÁ DE PROTEGER
>>
>>135442765
Not our fault anglos don't seed
>>
>>135425666
Where can I find a place to read the original series?
Between this and Zoids, my childhood nostalgia is going full blown.
>>
>>135443112 continued
but I know many do. Let's just disagree here.

-Kill la Kill:
No mascot animal, although her shirt jacket thingy could be considered a metaphorical mascot animal, serving many of the same purposes. Perhaps not very girly design overall, and the biggest failure, in my opinion, is the lack of contrast between a magical world and general society. However, has pre-action sequences which even are a transformation, and an unique look during action. In my opinion, not a magical girl show, but may be considered a peripherical one if you give the right weight to the right criteria.

- Neon Genesis Evangelion:
Has a mascot animal, to some degree. Special action clothes, pre-action sequence in the form of launching the Evangelion. Contrast between regular life and life as hero. Main character is male, but I'd consider an anime a mahou shoujo even with male main characters if enough other criteria were met. The outline of the bodies of the main characters are not determining for the shape of the action outfit (the robots are too big, do not follow the shape of the fighter in any way. Could just as well be a slug that was the fighter, and the outline would not change whatsoever). Also, a lack of magic and girly aestetics. The biggest failure, however, is the outline of the action outfit requirement.

I'm tired of writing. Let's just say that Digimon fails under humanoid if nothing else, and possibly that it should be a main character? Bubblegum Crisis fails on aestetics primarily, but also on mascot animal and pre-battle sequence if I remember correctly. Some of the more mecha-y mahou shoujos like Symphogear may be dependent on the other criteria. Is Infinite Stratos a mahou shoujo? Ignoring the MC, it only fails on aestetic requirements and mascot. I'd be willing to consider it mahou shoujo, but atypical.

I'm not going to write any more, and don't complain that I stop writing. I've spent so much time writing this, you better be grateful.
>>
>>135443411
SUPERA A DOR E DA FORÇAS PARA LUTAR

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XIxViaRqyhc
>>
>>135443638
>read
pretty much anywhere
>>
File: Saori-san.jpg (42 KB, 720x480) Image search: [Google]
Saori-san.jpg
42 KB, 720x480
>>135436093
I couldn't stop laughing every time Mamoru said "Saori-san" on that SuperS episode
>>
bumpo
>>
>>135425666
magical girls are basically them
Thread replies: 113
Thread images: 21

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.