![[HorribleSubs] One-Punch Man - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_07.51_[2015.11.12_02.14.18].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/E75iu6C.jpg "[HorribleSubs] One-Punch Man - 05 [720p].mkv_snapshot_07.51_[2015.11.12_02.14.18].jpg")
Just finished One-Punch Man anime, so I want to read the manga. Should I choose the original or the remake?
Webcomic
Then Murata's remake
Remake then original.
ONE's online comic is further than the remake, but the quality is much lower. I still love ONE's comic but Murata really does a fantastic job adapting and serializing it.
Murata's then ONE's.
Easier for newfags to chew.
why not both
It really depents on your sense of humor.
If you used to enjoy drawing dicks in your notebook when you were younger then you should go for the webcomic.
It worked for me.
>>135027776
Murata's, then the webcomic. AND THEN Mob Pshycho 100, much better than OPM.
You should fuck off and make your own decisions
>>135027776
Just read both.
>>135028121
Well that's rude.
Maybe the rest of use were interested in discussing the comparisons between the manga and the webcomic, and this thread provided the opportunity to do that.
![[HorribleSubs] One-Punch Man - 11 [720p].mkv_snapshot_22.03_[2015.12.21_02.24.38].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/A4Ae9L4.jpg "[HorribleSubs] One-Punch Man - 11 [720p].mkv_snapshot_22.03_[2015.12.21_02.24.38].jpg")
OP here. Seeing the art style of the original made me choose the remake.
>>135028185
There's nothing to discuss, really.
They're both fun in their own ways.
>>>/reddit/
>>135028303
>They're both fun in their own ways.
I want to discuss those ways.
>>135027776
Both. At the same time.
>>135027955
>>135028164
>>135028340
This.
Cross your fucking eyes, faggot.
>>135027776
Remake to catch up, then original.
>>135028338
This has been discussed to the death
>>135028220
The first few chapters are brutal. Absolutely brutal. It gets better, up to okay-ish.
>>135029909
Or I could just read the remake and not deal with those shitty scribbles.
Read the remake first, it keeps to the story and dialog very faithfully, then transition to the original and skip up to where the remake leaves off.
also do yourself a favor and rewatch the final fight at 75% speed, its glorious
>>135027776
the remake dosnt go much further than this
and so does the webcominc, where there are still like 50 chapters, they consists of 2 fights, nothing to fill up another season
and seeing how one pretty much dosnt update it anymore, last one being over a month
i would say its the end of rine for this series
>>135027776
Unless you want to see literally deviantart-tier work, you should read Murata's and never go near ONE's. The only reason people in this thread like OPM and aren't yelling about One's artstyle is cause of Murata's adaption. Had it just been ONE's artwork, these fuckers would be laughing their asses off, bad mouthing and talking how tumblr-tier cringe his artstyle is. Not even an opinion. That's a fact.
What scanlator should I go with for the manga.
>>135030712
>Had it just been ONE's artwork, these fuckers would be laughing their asses off, bad mouthing and talking how tumblr-tier cringe his artstyle is. Not even an opinion. That's a fact.
Except you're wrong, you fucking faggot. Mind you that you're talking about a board that worships(ed) Ryukushi07 and Touhou. On top of that, you're talking about a board that discusses LNs on a regular basis as well.
Seriously. How on earth do you deal with being so new and out of touch? I can't even fathom being as stupid as you.
>>135030734
Get the volumes from viz
>>135030109
Remake has filler and you'll be 200 chapters behind or something.
just read the wiki summary bro
one has shit art
the other has to much
>>135027776
Murata then ONE
>>135030891
Not him, but this is also the board that talks shit on Takeuchi's old style because the necks are too long.
>>135030891
>How on earth do you deal with being so new and out of touch? I can't even fathom being as stupid as you.
From what you just said, you are the new one here friend. The irony is really seeping from your post. You're on a board that literally hates majority of artstyles even in manga to date.
>>135031158
But it won't have shitty art
>>135031378
But when it comes to ONE's webcomic it's just so amateurish that people around here actually give full focus to everything except the drawings because they acknowledge how crude it is.
>>135031378
You're completely missing the point.
What I'm saying is that /a/ is more than capable of overlooking shitty art styles if the content itself is substantial enough to look past it. ONE's comic had a decent following long before Murata serialized it, even if the adaptations have drastically improved their following. I'm speaking from personal experience as someone that was following OPM threads on /a/ well before Murata chose to remake it.
>>135031769
>What I'm saying is that /a/ is more than capable of overlooking shitty art styles if the content itself is substantial enough to look past it.
Because /a/ was talking about OPM in droves long before Murata's adaption took place? Pal, you aren't making any sense.
>>135031563
That's not the point at all.
>>135031476
Holy shit just kill yourself.
>>135032848
If I had to deal with that fucking art, I would.
>>135032848
One's art is fucking garbage, killing myself would be an honor. I'm not lowering my standards because your dumbass likes 7th grade pen art in math class.
>>135032960
You sound pretty shallow, son.
>>135033025
Everyone knows ONE's art is garbage.
The same applies to both Zun and Ryukushi. No one admires their work because of their style or artistic skill though.
>>135028074
>Mob Pshycho 100 is better.
It really isn't.
Aside from Reigen and Dimple, all the other characters are far blander than their OPM equivalents and nowhere near as much fun.
>>135033283
>No one admires their work because of their style or artistic skill though.
The webcomic wasn't known except a few web forums in japan for literally 3/4th of its existence. No one here admires the art, they like the cynical satire comedy behind it. But Visual is a key element. That's why Murata redid it, cause even he knew. It would never make it big with shitty art.
>>135033248
and you sound like a faggot
>>135033380
fucking this! I can't fucking find it anywhere. It used to be right THERE but now it's gone. WTF
>>135033466
Tumblr.com, I recommend you read it there.
>>135033432
>The webcomic wasn't known except a few web forums in japan for literally 3/4th of its existence.
You are literally on one of the boards that was actively discussing it at the time.
>>135027993
wow, i didn't get the dick reference until I saw the kids hair in this picture.that kid was such adickhead
>>135033491
The fuck is tumblr?
>>135027852
>ONE's online comic is further than the remake, but the quality is much lower
Are you braindead or just blind?
>>135033517
>You are literally on one of the boards that was actively discussing it at the time.
....hownew.ru?
>>135033626
Neither.
>>135033599
Its a wonderful site for people looking to be spoonfed sources for comics, especially webcomics. Man I know you'll fit in!, Go there now man! The OPM comic awaits you!!!
>>>/tumblr/
>>135033724
calm down you fucking nerd
>>135027776
It's compulsory to read both.
ONE's storytelling is not to be missed but you can't skip Murata's top tier art.
>>135033670
>....
>>135033724
>ask a question
>spoonfed
>/b/ tier shit posting
Nah I'm good niggertron. Keep being fat doe
>>135033842
Who are you quoting? Also the word is "though".
>>135033799
One's story telling...
This is gold, next thing people will say is he's a better writer than many professional mangaka because he made a standard cynical series pandering to those who feel their taste in manga is so high that the only thing fitting for them is to be sarcastic.
>>135033977
keep up sanic.
>>135034031
Yet his characters are more dimensional than Shinji.
>>135033380
tfw the best place right now is probably manga traders.
and their translations are from viz.
>>135027776
Read the manga then the webcomic if you want.
>>135034200
>>135034200
That's the site I was trying to find. Big thanks for the tip Anon.
>>135034031
jokes on u one punch man is the first mango i've ever read
>>135034368
Was it also the anime that got you into anime, anon?
>>135034428
nah ive watched akira and dbz and cowboy bebop and ghibli stuff and death note and attack on titan and some planetes
>>135034673
oh and evagelion of course
Is the ost out?
>>135033724
Trying entirely too hard
>>135034736
This so much. I want to know.
>>135034736
>>135036214
JANUARY YOU COLOSSAL FAGGOTS
>>135028338
No one wants to discuss it with you, use the archive for old discussions
>>135028220
>ignoring quality art
Come on OP
And this is why newfag secondaries should be ignored, no matter what show it is.
Which chapter of One's version is Murata's version up to now?
>>135033626
Is he wrong?
>>135031158
The filler is worth it though. It's all good.
>>135033724
With your writing style, you would certainly fit in too. Why not just go there and never fucking come back?
Reading the webcomic makes it fun to think how Murata will show it.
I can't for him to reach the Monster Association arc and see him drawing
>Pig God eating a dude
>Fuhrer Ugly
>Evil Natural Water
>Psykos
>"God" killing Homeless Emperor
>Golden Sperm is born with a blast
>And Garou's absolute hopelessness when he faces Saitama
Can Metal Bat beat Amai?
>>135028220
>>135040392
>>135041404
Yes? Amai is A and Bat is S.
Having read the latest Murata chapter, where should I pick up the ONE version?
Is it safe to assume what Psykos saw in the future was what Shibabwa saw in the prophecy?
>>135041599
From the beginning, man. The difference is fascinating to compare.
>>135041640
These...
these are some real shitscribbles. Still, I'll read for the story.
Hurry up, Murata!
>>135040860
ONE's skills doesn't rely on drawing but more on scenery and expressions. Drawing well is a thing, but being able to properly present a scene is another. Murata can do both, but ONE while drawing not very good looking thing will present them in such a way that you cannot dislike it. Now you might like Murata's manga over ONE's manga, or the other way around, but you can't just say "ONE's manga is shit because of his bad drawing skills", that would be straight stupid
>>135041735
He didn't say it was shit he just said the quality was lower which you just agreed with in your post.
>>135041773
He said the quality was lower. Quality isn't just "being able to draw a pretty face" my friend, this is exactly what i adressed in my very first line.
>>135041860
You're gotta be the biggest contrarian hipster I've seen this whole month.
Congratulations.
so this is how JOJO fans feel.
>>135041860
You literally said that Murata could do everything ONE did but better.
>>135042535
Then you should learn to read
>>135042028
I don't care about what you think of me my friend
>>135028220
And this is why I hate tertiaryfags.
Road to Hero is non-canon right? Are One or Murata working on it?
Saitama can't breathe in space.
Saitama is weaker than Freiza and Goku could just Instant Transmission him to space to kill him
>>135043167
Wouldn't he have died in that environment anyway if he couldn't breathe? Wouldn't his lungs explode or something? You're not supposed to hold your breath.
It remains to be seen until he fights an enemy in space. I would bet he could hold his breath for a really long time.
>>135043366
Lungs decompress not explode.
>>135043416
Anyway. We still haven't seen him fight anyone in space. How far past Garou is the original manga? Have we gotten to god level yet?
>>135027776
remake. the original art is shit.
>>135043489
so edgy
Here is my christmas gift for all OPM fans.
https://my.mixtape.moe/avfgpg.webm
Enjoy it niggas, headphones recommended for a more immersive experience.
>>135043664
I don't get it. Why are sound effects needed?
>>135033626
Are you honestly trying to claim that the art in the webcomic is better or that the story is better paced? I love the webcomic but the manga makes it look like story boards.
>>135031158
The "filler" is still written by ONE and actually fleshes out the universe and the characters. I love the webcomic but compared to the manga its more like storyboards than anything else.
>>135027776
Read both
>>135043167
Are you weaker than a fish because you can't breathe underwater?
>>135043098
pls reply
>>135041599
Chapter 52
>>135043098
That OVA, and the mini-OVAs that will come with each volume of the BD are original stories written by one.
>>135046669
Thanks. I'll probably save those.
>>135046669
Has the newest been subbed yet?
>>135046903
The first BD isn't out yet.
>>135034428
Being this newBut I welcome you
>>135043167
>Saitama can't breathe in space.
We don't know, we know that saitama wondered if he HAD to hold his breath
For all we know he could hold his breath for 10 years
>>135027776
Murata until it catches up to the webcomic's chapter. No need to punish yourself with ONE's scribbles.
So is it really done? Or will there be a second season sometime next year?
>>135048445
Murata will finance it personally.
I just hope they get to the monster association arc
>>135028220
Web comic is good despite the art. If after you reach the latest part of the remake you still want more, I recommend giving the WC a try as it's quite further on the story.
>>135028220
>webcomic art is 3shitty5me
When will this meme end?
>>135049026
>turns into this
>is actually weaken than before
Monters confirmed shit
>>135049059
He didn't put his heart into it.
>>135042557
Stop acting like a retard, anon.
>>135041094
>>135035331
>>135033842
>>135033798
I'm not sure if you're just new or retarded, but spoonfeeding idiots is not a good thing and you acting out against somebody who wants to keep the place clean is also not something you should feel proud of.
So stop chimping out while smearing shit all over the walls.
