![[De.us] Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu (1280x720 h.264 Dual-Audio FLAC 10-bit) [905AD0CA].mkv_snapshot_00.43.03_[2015.12.15_17.36.12].png](https://i.imgur.com/jpyE23r.jpg "[De.us] Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu (1280x720 h.264 Dual-Audio FLAC 10-bit) [905AD0CA].mkv_snapshot_00.43.03_[2015.12.15_17.36.12].png")
Finally got around to watching this today. Let me just say is that I can see why people call this one of the best non-Ghibli anime films ever made.
Why has KyoAni failed to make anything this good afterwards?
Was this before or after Hyouka?
Because the validity of your question depends on the answer to that one.
>>134812831
Hyouka was great, but it was nowhere near as good as this.
I hope they don't fuck up FMP s4, if they're even doing it that is.
>Why has KyoAni failed to make anything this good afterwards?
It's only been like 5 years since the film came out. Masterpieces aren't easy to make you know. I'm sure one day they'll top it.
K-ON movie came a year later and topped it. TLS was nearly as good as Disappearance.
>Implying its even possible
>>134813027
Well, there's also the upcoming Koe no Katachi film. Directed by Naoko Yamada too, at that!
We'll just have to wait and see, I guess.
>>134812698
>Why has KyoAni failed to make anything this good afterwards?
Hibike just ended recently.
>>134812698
Haruhi/Disappearance are okay, but there are better KyoAni works.
>>134813131
>K-ON movie
>Topped Disappearance
>>134812698
Violer Evergarden is coming eventually.I thought the title was Violey Ever Garden since they announced it, turns out the girl is just called Violet Evergarden and the title is her name.
>>134813436
>Violer
>Violey
I'm amused by my own mistakes.
K-On! and Tamako Love Story were better films, in my opinion. K-On!, Nichijou, Hyouka, and Eupho were better TV shows. I still really like Disappearance though, don't get me wrong. Watch it every winter.
>>134812698
why didn't you wait a few days to watch it with /a/?
>>134813657
That's the 18th, right? You know what time that happens?
>>134813683
Some anons are streaming it on the 18th, while the guy who's been making the Haruhi Christmas rewatch threads plans to stream it on the 24th. As for the times, I don't know either. They'll probably pop up like a day before the stream happens, though.
>>134814006
Thanks. Always coincides poorly with exams, I'll see if I don't have to watch it alone again this year.
Once you make your magnum opus, you stop giving a shit.
>>134814535
not to discredit the movie in any way, but I feel like fandom ratings shouldn't ever be taken seriously like that
Because it is a masterpiece of the highest quality and you're expecting a lot when asking for "anything this good again" The majority of all studios don't even have one masterpiece.
Hyouka and K-On were already of extremely high quality. Tamako Love Story is very good as well, not to mention Nichijou's visual quality. And the more I rewatch Hibike, the more I love it.
There really isn't anything wrong with not being able to produce masterpiece after masterpiece, especially when KyoAni is already creating shows that are above average in quality.
>>134812698
>watching it for the first time
>just days before the annual /a/ rewatch
You fucked up.
>>134815358
When is it and where do we see it? I'm down for that.
>>134815558
Somewhere and sometime, on the same day as the movie starts.
>>134815358
>wanting to either go through the trouble of watching a shitty stream, or syncing up your player to the stream and keeping the stream or thread open in another window to make sure you get all the epic memes and crap
It's not worth it, if you're watching for the first time just watch it normally and don't ruin the experience.
>>134812698
>I can see why people call this one of the best non-Ghibli anime films ever made
Ghibili has only made two good films.
>>134815629
>not hiding stream chats always
The threads are pretty comfy to post in/lurk while watching.
>>134815590
Thanks.
>>134815666
Wouldn't the threads have the same spoiling effect?
![K-ON! The MovieüEëfëµ é»éóé¿é± (2011) [CoalGuys] [10-bit Dual-Audio FLAC].mkv_snapshot_01.00.49_[2015.05.10_02.04.55].png](https://i.imgur.com/aLesvR8.jpg "K-ON! The MovieüEëfëµ é»éóé¿é± (2011) [CoalGuys] [10-bit Dual-Audio FLAC].mkv_snapshot_01.00.49_[2015.05.10_02.04.55].png")
>>134813131
>>134813566
This.
I don't think K-On! movie can really be topped, and I mean that in the entire medium.
Disappearance is still a masterpiece though.
>>134815695
I guess you would have to be careful even then if it was your first time, true. Best way to do it would be to watch it that same day, alone, then discuss it in the threads once the stream is over.
They K-ON! movie dragged on way too much towards the end. It made the last 20 minutes or so feel like an slow moving eternity.
>>134815777
That's funny, since my biggest problem with Disappearance was its absurd length. The post-return of the K-On! Movie is actually my favourite part. That one scene on the roof was incredible, and I loved the little show they put on in the classroom. Plus Azusa's song. I dunno, I really liked the way they ended it all. I feel like the slowness was a part of the tone they were going for. The vacation is all fun and games, briskly paced, and then back to the reality of graduation with this underlying melancholic nostalgia.
>>134815732
Or watch the stream with the chat off and thread closed, then find the thread when it's done.
>>134815907
>That's funny, since my biggest problem with Disappearance was its absurd length.
It takes all kinds, I guess - despite Disappearance's long running time, I didn't feel it.
>>134815958
Yeah, first time I watched it it never bothered me, but subsequent watches can get a little bit tiring towards the end. All picks up with the ending though so it's forgivable.
>>134813566
Shit, I still haven't bothered to check out Tamako Love Story yet.
Guess I'll download that now.
An amazing movie for fans but outsiders don't connect with the movie as deeply due to its length and wordy script. Knowledge of the previous novels is almost a requirement.
I love this movie and wish more people could appreciate it's beauty.
>>134816140
It's like, my favourite animated movie. If you're okay with the sentimental kitschy stuff Yamada likes to direct, then I think you'll like it. Best showcase of her directing too, she storyboarded the whole thing. Just oozes with style.
>>134815907
I agree with the anon above you, but my problem with the final scenes isn't that they just take too long or that I don't like them. They're great scenes, they just don't belong in this movie. I really think they should have just ended the film with everyone coming back from Britain and not bothered doing the ending over again. It feels redundant and I feel they executed that last scene better in the anime anyway.
>>134816579
Naahhh man. Like, I see where you're coming from, but the ending was given new perspective and the whole "behind the music" thing was a nice ordering principle for the whole movie. Just the trip would have been nice, sure, but the way it is now makes for a better "last K-On! thing we'll ever watch" type of thing, you know?
It's always funny though when talking about the "ending" cause there's like three of them. Tenshi ni Fureta Yo in the show, in the movie, and then the one where the girls stumble upon the new lineup practicing. All three were well done in my opinion, never really taking away from the last.
>>134816777
I dunno. I would rather have a more tightly constructed film than a K-on conclusion experience personally. I guess that's just personal opinion more than anything.
![K-ON! The MovieüEëfëµ é»éóé¿é± (2011) [CoalGuys] [10-bit Dual-Audio FLAC].mkv_snapshot_01.42.14_[2015.05.10_13.03.22].png](https://i.imgur.com/vnVvoXW.jpg "K-ON! The MovieüEëfëµ é»éóé¿é± (2011) [CoalGuys] [10-bit Dual-Audio FLAC].mkv_snapshot_01.42.14_[2015.05.10_13.03.22].png")
>>134816579
It offered a really interesting new perspective on the ending. The TV series just had them coming back and playing the song, but the movie showed how much effort the girls put into writing the song and it makes it that much more impacting.
Not to mention it was a perfect closure to the entire series as a whole.
>>134817078
I dunno, I think the effort they put into it comes through regardless, and I personally didn't find the new perspective any more interesting. The effort can also be applied retrospectively to a similar effect.
Honestly, my ideas are summed up here >>134816913 pretty conclusively. I just really like tightly constructed movies.
>Ah people discussing the Haruhi movie
>Tamago good, Hyouka great, Eu better each time
>Only KyoAni circlejerking
You are worse than Shaft jerkers.
>>134817078
The movie had more music while S1 had more comedy and S2 had more iyashikei. Each showcases a different aspect of the franchise. I think it addressed the complaints that they sit around eating cake instead of practicing.
>>134812698
I loved this, but who knows. Maybe Koe no Katachi will out do it, if it's done right.
Plus it's a self-contained story. No need to watch a whole other 2 season anime to get all the characters and their interactions.
>>134817890
I mean, this is a Kyoani thread, you should expect people who like Kyoani. If you want do offer some actual complaints about any of these films, please do. As you can see above, we're incredibly open to that.
>>134812698
>the best non-Ghibli anime film
Great start OP, being a fag like always.
>>134817983
I have faith in Yamada.
Its going to be amazing.
>>134817983
>Plus it's a self-contained story. No need to watch a whole other 2 season anime to get all the characters and their interactions.
What the actual fuck am I reading
>>134818310
what's wrong with that?
>>134812831
I agree with the other anon. Your taste is shit, and Hyouka while interesting, was under whelming.
>>134812698
So I watched the series years ago, thinking it was alright, but nothing really all that special outside of a few key character interactions and scenes.
I watched this movie some time in the middle of the night back in my freshman year of high school after just finding out it existed. I was not expecting to love it so much.
>>134818542
Watch all of season 1 then watch the movie. DO IT FAGGOT. Maybe now that you're older and have had women under your belt, you'll be better able to grasp all the nuances and under tones that it has.
>>134818457
Why would you watch a SEQUEL first? You miss the entire introduction of everything and everyone. You won't understand any plot points carried over from previous seasons. The circumstances of the characters and setting won't make sense.
You're just lucky Haruhi isn't a complicated series.
Did you also watch EoE before the series you fucking idiot?
>>134818685
He's talking about Koe no Katachi, not Disappearance.
>>134818682
>>134818685
Your reading comprehension is not very good.
>>134818542
Read the LNs, anime seasons are a waste of time (Especially with the way they wasted time with endless 8, when they could have been adapting more interesting chapters/arcs).
>>134817983
Is the source that good? If so, consider me excited for it as well.
I was already a big Haruhi fan in the first place, so when I heard Disappearance was getting animated, it was the an amazing gift. Especially after Endless 8 eroded the fanbase the way it did. It's an excellent movie and I think it deserves the praise it gets.
That said, I was still a little surprised the movie was as well received as it was. The general impression I get is that people thought the TV series was meh but Disappearance was great, though I figured someone who thought the series wasn't that good wouldn't be able to enjoy the movie.
>>134822109
Some of us here are old enough to remember Haruhi before season 2 was created. It was top-shelf must-watch TV back in the day. The diehard fanbase was just waiting for something to deliver as well as Disappearance did. I'm a little surprised whenever I see people not praising the TV show, but I do understand how watching Endless 8 as part of your first experience of Haruhi could taint your impression. Especially thanks to how chronological order mixes both seasons together.
>>134822581
>>134822109I liked Endless Eight
>>134812698
>Why has KyoAni failed to make anything this good afterwards?
Hyouka was after Disapperance.
>>134823060
>Hyouka
Nyquil would be a cheaper solution.
>>134823060
>>134812831
I wish I could see what Hyouka fans see in Hyouka, you guys are a zealous bunch. I found it enjoyable, but Oreki and Chitanda just didn't do it for me, and the whole show felt a little underwhelming. Though it was visually just as stunning as Disappearance was, if not better.
>>134823441
Isn't Hibike even prettier?
>>134823441
I feel the same way. I have a mild grudge against Hyouka because I didn't enjoy it as much as I thought I would, with /a/ hyping it up so much.
>>134814535
tfw we live in a post-Haruhi world
>>134813131
>K-On
>good
>>134823774
Correct.
>>134823809
In a world where no other artistic medium exists, maybe.
![[Coalgirls]_Tamako_Love_Story_(1920x1080_Blu-ray_FLAC)_[ED2903E1].mkv_snapshot_01.20.09_[2014.12.08_01.29.04].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/utkuCr6.jpg "[Coalgirls]_Tamako_Love_Story_(1920x1080_Blu-ray_FLAC)_[ED2903E1].mkv_snapshot_01.20.09_[2014.12.08_01.29.04].jpg")
>>134812698
Not gonna lie. I liked TLS more than Disappearance.
>>134823691
The immaculate presentation makes an uninteresting story seem 'subtle.' I can't say it's wrong to like an anime based on the visuals since I watch plenty of crap because of cool webms, but Hyouka's story deserves all the trash talking it receives. It's amazing in the same sense as Yozakura Quartet; you must disregard the plot.
>>134812698
Partly due to the source material being the best book in the series. I cant remember anything that happens in the later books besides evil neo-nagato and her big ass poofy hair
>>134823952
I can't tell if you're complimenting it or insulting it. Or both.
But I agree with your observations.
>>134824177
Is this Chu2 in 3 years?
>>134823952
>It's amazing in the same sense as Yozakura Quartet; you must disregard the plot.
Man, I don't think Hyouka is masterfully written or anything, but it's a damn sight better than Yozakura Quartet.
>>134823952
The characters are a hundred times better written than YQZ. Did you drop it halfway?
Hyouka isn't about the mysteries, people.
>>134824804
The mysteries aren't the highlight of the story, but it's undeniably about mysteries when they take up a bulk of the show.
![[Coalgirls]_Hyouka_22_(1920x1080_Blu-Ray_FLAC)_[E4D50756].mkv_snapshot_24.59_[2014.12.24_08.17.43].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/HbUK5Cx.jpg "[Coalgirls]_Hyouka_22_(1920x1080_Blu-Ray_FLAC)_[E4D50756].mkv_snapshot_24.59_[2014.12.24_08.17.43].jpg")
>>134824804
>The mysteries are supposed to highlight the characters, guys!
This is right, but I never liked the way people say it, especially with that condescending "you just don't understand this masterpiece" subtext. The detective stuff is what the screentime is dedicated to.
![[Mazui]_The_Disappearance_Of_Suzumiya_Haruhi_[720p][866C4FD2].mkv_snapshot_02.06.10_[2011.01.14_20.43.45].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/AEXYrHm.jpg "[Mazui]_The_Disappearance_Of_Suzumiya_Haruhi_[720p][866C4FD2].mkv_snapshot_02.06.10_[2011.01.14_20.43.45].jpg")
>[Mazui]_The_Disappearance_Of_Suzumiya_Haruhi_[1080p][D0A1AC19].mkv
10.21 GiB
>[Coalgirls]_The_Disappearance_of_Haruhi_Suzumiya_(1920x1080_Blu-ray_FLAC)_[237D6BB3].mkv
5.1 GiB
Bloatgirls they said.
>>134825299
obviously means mazui looks better
>>134825373
Is there one of those comparisons for the movie?
The movie didn't make up for the rest of the series being shit.
I really wish you fags would stop pushing this "K-On is good" meme.
>>134825512
Season 1 was godly though. Maybe not godly, but really good.
>>134825590
But K-On is good.
>>134813566
>>134815710
>>134813131
You can tell these fags didnt watch the series before the Haruhi movie.
Choosing a story where nothing really happens vs a movie with revolutionary character development is beyond me.
>still waiting
>>134825924
>revolutionary character development
What was revolutionary?
>>134825924
Sorry to tell you this but there are indeed people that watched all of Haruhi and all of K-on and still enjoyed K-on more. Both are great and both are something I'd call masterpieces in a way. Yes, people are serious when they call K-on a masterpiece, the pinnacle of anime, the best anime ever made, etc. They're not necessarily wrong, K-on is a great series.
![[De.us] Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu (1920x1080 h.264 Dual-Audio FLAC 10-bit) [017CB24D].mkv_snapshot_01.22.21_[2014.12.25_16.25.34].png](https://i.imgur.com/M7Dhild.jpg "[De.us] Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu (1920x1080 h.264 Dual-Audio FLAC 10-bit) [017CB24D].mkv_snapshot_01.22.21_[2014.12.25_16.25.34].png")
>>134825299
Post a .png please, show us how it looks.
>>134825924
>>134826616
I haven't downloaded either yet, I wanted to replace my 720p rip.
Yuki deserves the entire world.
I should really rewatch the movie, it's been years. A few days ago I watched episodes 11-13 (without seeing any other episodes) of the Nagato Yuki-chan anime and it was really touching. Are the other episodes worth watching even though I've spoiled it for myself already?
>>134826769
Is 11-13 the ones titled "The dissapearance of Yuki Nagato parts I, II and III" ?
If so, then yes that's the best ones. Watch the final 3 episodes too since those have a resolution on the disappearance of alternate personality Yuki.
I'm more wondering if I should watch any other episodes when rewatching Disappearance, it’s been years for me too.
>>134826635
>muh healing
Kill yourself neckbeard
>>134826980
>neckbeard
He's clearly a Navy SEAL though.
>>134826935
The last Endless 8 episode if you want to.
>>134827080
Was it before or after?
>>134827102
It happens before Disappearance as basically what sets the movie's plot in motion. If it's really been years since you watched it maybe rewatch the melancholy part 1-6 episodes too to remind yourself about everyone's background stories.
>>134827080
Nah, Yuki's stuff in E8 happens over the course of the eight episodes, and you only really get the weight of it if you watch them all. Watching the last episode is not the same. I feel bad for people who outright skipped E8 or just watched the last episode.
>>134826935
Don't forget the 1st episode of Season 2. The Baboo Rhapsody. It's the set-up episode for the movie.
>>134812698
It's easier to pander
>>134814535
Finished reading Disappearance a couple of days ago and starting Rampage soon, reading it really showed me how good the adaptation is.
Literally the most overrated piece of garbage on this site.
>>134823039
I liked it too - but would be really annoyed watching it on tv
>>134823866
More like in a world where other animated movies don't exist.
>>134830295
I'd tell you to gb2reddit but not even reddit is that bad.
Source material was just too good. Everything else pails in comarison. The only hope for them doing something better is by getting the rights to Murakamis catalog.
Dumb fucking Chuu2 and Amagi bullshit. Fuck you KyoAni.
I watched it 2 months ago and thought it was okay but nothing special.
It's easily the most overrated animated film on /a/ other then 5cm Per Second.
Hibike ep. 8 was their true masterpiece in my opinion.
>>134831933
It was great, but I don't think it beats K-On! episode 10, K-On!! episode 20 and the finale.
There's also that episode with the train scene in Clannad AS.
>KyoAnus lickers in full damage control trying to defend their worthless SoL turds
Everyone realizes that Yuki is a literal eldritch horror, right? Kyons egotistical nature that makes him white knifgt for her is cute and mirrors the audiences obsession with her. But she is a being with unfathomable power.
>>134832348
If she's cute, where's the problem?
>>134827080
The first 2 and last 2 are probably the best to watch for it.
>>134814735
Pretty much this. All those rankings and scores were given right after the movie aired. It's obvious the hype would still be a heavy judgment factor when people vote for it. Also, the amount of people voting/scoring isn't even significant enough in most of these ranks.
At least it proves that once MALshit wasn't entirely cancer.
>>134827022
I dunno, American media has taught me that many special forces members have beards.
