This board is lacking me... Let's fix that.
3x3 thread
>>120862446
>Kill la Kill
>>120862446
5/8. Where did you watch Ribbon no Kishi?
>>120862637
I like you
sup
>>120862446
8/8
>>120862637
pretty great
>>120862998
4/4
8/8
9/9
>>120862446
I thought you had good taste and then I saw KLK
>>120862689
I don't see the problem.
>>120862446
6/6 good shit.
>>120862637
4/4 animu 4.5/5 movies 3/3 indie. I also love Tarkovsky but other than that I only recognize Pather Panchali from the 3DPD 3x3.
>>120862998
Well I've only seen Mushishi and some of Anne from the TV chart. Not really into little girl shows and I haven't seen that many of the western novel adaptations. 6/6 movies, 7/7 mango.
>>120863071
7.5/9
>>120863785
/a/ tells him klk is bad and that anyone who likes it is a newfag with shit tastes who is probably from /v/ so he believes it.
>>120862446
>shit la shit
Pfff.
Also, why mixing Anime and m´Manga together?
>>120862637
Heidi, Niea_7 and DoReMi suck, I bet you put them in your 3x3 to show how much of a fart-sniffing and special snowflake you are.
And for fucks sake, nobody cares about the non-/a/ shit.
>>120862998
Great taste in manga.
>>120863071
Not bad, though I still don't see what's so good about Golden Boy.
>>120864007
>5x5
Kindly kill yourself.
>>120864822
>I still don't see what's so good about Golden Boy.
for me it's mainly the dub that makes it so good.i watched it with subs first and thought it was pretty good, but the dub elevated it to a 10/10.
>>120862446
>NSFW/10
>>120862637
2Hipster4Me/10
>>120862998
Banner of the Stars was good/10
>>120863071
4/6
>>120864007
Poorly Made Chart/10
>>120864822
>Heidi and DoReMi suck
this
>>120862998
Manga 6/6
>>120862446
Manga 2/2
>>120864822
People enjoy different things, there is no need to assume one is being dishonest because it is incompatible with your own preferences.
>>120865175
Would you mind spoonfeeding the source of all of those?
>>120864949
May i ask tittle for pic between Hanbei Reimei and GiTS
>>120866894
LotGH.
I thought it would be pretty recognizable because of the suits.
>>120867004
thanks a lot
it's for sure recognizable for those who watched it
Im making a copypasta for when I see people starting rec threads, you guys review it for me? here it is:
Spice & Wolf
>Just Superb, My current favorite series. The anime wasn't enough for me though and I am reading the LN's currently.
Moribito: Guardian of the Spirit
>Great choreography of the fight scenes, I like all the characters other than the Muslim kid.
Ghost in the Shell GITS 1&2
>I like both, 2 is better IMO. ARISE NEVER HAPPENED
Kara no Kyōkai
>8 movies, they average 1:15 long. Amazing visuals and music.
Eureka Seven
>Really good, If you have not seen it yet you are doing yourself a disservice.
>>120866721
Are you new to manga anon or are you just trying to trick me into spoonfeeding?
>>120867170
>Im making a copypasta for when I see people starting rec threads, you guys review it for me? here it is:
Nice bait, I can see you put a lot of work into this.
I'm sure this is the reply you were expecting so enjoy it: Fuck off.
>>120862998
I like you also.
>>120867180
I'm genuinely interested. They all feel familiar but I only recognize I Am a Hero and Berserk.
>>120862446
1.5/2
>>120863071
3/4
>>120864007
A bit above decent
>>120864949
2/2
>>120867576
Okay the I'll list them left to right,top to bottom it goes: Rookies, Berserk, Vagabond, Gantz, prison school, I am a hero, Real, Oyaji, jisatsutou
>>120867872
I guess I'm just shit at recognizing stuff. Inoue's stuff has been in my fucking backlog for years and I can't seem to get myself to finally read them. I've read Gantz, most of which I found kind of bland and forgettable despite the crazy premise, and Prison School, which is shit.
>>120864949
>Sengoku Rance, SoTN, Gunbuster, EoE, Tylor, Lotgh, GiTS, whisper of the heart.
Holy shit, I don't say this often, but do you want to be friends?
>>120862637
7/7
>>120862998
3/4
>>120863071
4/9
>>120864007
Jesus fucking christ.
8/21
>>120864930
1/8
>>120868383
>8/21
That's surprising since we have a lot of the same stuff in our charts. Did you really dislike all of those?
13/13 for your 4x4.
>>120862446
>>120862637
>>120862998
too many things going on
>>120863071
5/6
>>120864007
9/12
>>120864930
2/2
>>120864949
1/1
>>120865175
6/7
>>120867830
7/11
>>120868383
7/8
>>120868798
3/4
>>120865175
I will forgive Gantz but only because you have Oyaji in there
Im the best
Just the best
>>120862998
I didnt watch princess knight. I read it. You can find it on bakabt
Manga only 3x3 of 3x3. Don't expect anyone to be able to rate it. Hoping to make 2 more of these (one animation themed, one character/relationship themed) and then stack them on top of each other so I can make 3x3x3 of 3x3.
>>120869059
cool
>>120863071
I cant get happy about a perfect score when others get perfect scores. It's not enough that I succeed; others should fail.
>>120863425
And then you fell in love, right? Sorry, baby doll. I'm not about relationships right now. I'm doin' me.
My original 3x3 is in the middle.
>>120862446
+ Lupin, Tengen, Kill la Kill, Amazing Nuts
+/- Dragonball
A bit suprised to see Amazing Nuts. It was fun to watch and to listen too, but I would never have thought of it as 3x3 material
>>120862637
+ Niea, Memories
- Metropolis
>>120862998
++ Mushi, Ghost in the Shell
+ Banner, Tsumiki no Ie, Eve no Jikan, Aria, Solanin, JoJo
>>120863071
+ Bebop, Golden Boy, DtB, Sayonara, FLCL, Kino's Journey
>>120864007
I'll rate the expanded ones:
+ Haibane Renmei, FLCL, Tutu, Dennou Coil, Redline, Whisper of the Heart, Cat Coup, Kaiji, Patlabor 2, Azumanga Daioh, Aria
+/- Totoro
- Metropolis
>>120864930
++ Meguka
+ Bake
>>120864949
++ EoE, Ghost in the Shell
+ Nausicaa, Whisper of the Heart, Gunbuster, Haibane Renmei
>>120867830
+ Ghost in the Shell, Punpun, Tatami Galaxy
+ Medaka Box, Onani Master, 20th Century Boys, Katanagatari, NHK, Tengen, Ping Pong
>>120868383
++ Mononoke, EoE, Tatami Galaxy, Kaiba, Mushi, Ghost in the Shell
+ Onizuka, Whisper of the Heart, Angel's egg, Tutu, Banner, Cromartie High School
>>120868798
++ Mushi
+ Sora no Woto, JoJo, Hellsing
+/- K-on
>>120862446
3/4
>>120862637
anime 2/2
film ova 3/4
>>120862998
anime 2/2
movies ova 2/3
manga 4/4
>>120863071
3/5
>>120864007
9/12
>>120864930
1/3
>>120865175
3/3
>>120867830
manga 6/7
anime 5/5
>>120868383
8/9
>>120868798
2/5
>>120868856
2/2
>>120869870
>>120869696
>Not rating others
Selfish bastards.
>>120869825
7/7.
What top right and bottom left?
>>120869906
Rating is stupid imho (neither of those posters).
Oh wow, anon #290439888943 has seen 5 of my 9 favorite shows and liked 3 of them. Wow. Who cares though?
>>120862446
Still shitposting heh, Steel?
>>120862637
You honestly thinks his taste is good? I would assume your tastes would be incompatible.
Anime: 3/5 - NieA_7, Kemonozume
>>120862998
Anime: 1/1
I don't know whether to be impressed by your interesting looking shows, or upset with myself for not watching barely anything in your tv 3x3.
OVA/Film: 4/4
Manga: 7/7
>>120863071
8/9 -+ NHK, Darker
>Big O
Noice. Though frankely after all this time I think it would of been a better show if it just focused on the interesting city-wide Amnesia noir story. Despite my love for the Megadeus's, they mecha aspect of the show was sort of just crowbared in. Also, you must have a tolerance for poor second seasons to have both Big O and Darker on your 3x3.
>>120864007
19/23 -+ Aria, Tanuki - Azumanga, Shiki, Coil
No change with Ghost.
>>120864930
3/5 -+ 08th, Madoka, - Oreimo
I dropped the second season of Chu2, but the first season was so sweet and fun that I don't want to negatively rate it.
>>120865175
3/3
>>120867830
Manga: 4/5 - Medaka
4.5/6 -+ NHK, - TTGL
Is bottom left Bartender? If so, 4.5/7
>>120868383
15/15
>>120868856
0/0 I think.
Bottom middle looks like it is by the same guy that did Parasyte, but the character doesn't look like Izumi.
>>120869150
Seinen: 6/6
Josei: 2/2
Shounen: 5/6 - SnK
>Stupidest Crap
>PunPun
I'm interested. Mind expanding on that anon?
>>120869680
20/23 -+ Madoka, NHK, - Planetes anime, Black Lagoon
>Ergo Proxy
Nice. It's pretty interesting rewatching it. Nice to see it on a chart (even if it is only a 5x5)
>>120869958
>Imho
Rule 4.
>wow, anon #290439888943
Hey, welcome to /a/.
This informative guide should help you not look like a total shitposter.
>>120869680
What's bottom left? Surely that's not Mindgame.
+Mononoke, Planetes, Princess Mononoke,*Monogatari, Penguindrum, Utena, Eva, Millennium Actress, Trapeze, Kaiba, Naussica, GitS, Angel's Egg, Perfect Blue.
+/- Black Lagoon, Mushishi, Haibane Renmei
- Erin, Ergo Proxy, Welcome to the NHK (though I love the manga)
Amazing Nuts is one of the first shorts I watched along with Robot Carnival. But Amazing Nuts inspired me deeply. Kung Fu love was just gorgeous, and Global Astroliner made me fawn over it for months. Years even. Putting all these wonderful ideas and scenarios in my head. That's what a short should do.
>>120869996
>0/0 I think.
that sucks
>Bottom middle looks like it is by the same guy that did Parasyte
Yes, same guy.
Manga is Historie
>>120869996
>bartender
It's Rainbow actually.
>>120870168
>Manga is Historie
Ah, thanks anon. Sorry you didn't really get a score.
>>120870182
God fucking damn it. 5.5/7
>>120869996
11/13
>I'm interested. Mind expanding on that anon?
I think I just had very high hopes since it was so highly rated and tagged as "coming of age" which I do like, and I thought the bird thing looked cute. But then when I read it it felt miserable and grimdark and gross. I don't know if it gets better or not because I didn't get through to the end.
>>120862446
2/3
>>120862637
0/3 TV
>>120862998
1/3 TV, 2/4 Film, 4/5 Manga
>>120863071
3/7
>>120864007
12/17
>>120864930
Good taste in girls/10
>>120864949
1/4 Anime
>>120865175
1/1
>>120867830
1/3 Manga, 6/7 Anime
>>120868383
2/6
>>120868798
7/8
>>120869680
10/17
>>120869696
2/2
>>120869870
2/3
>>120869996
14/18
>>120870096
What do you surely? It is Mindgame.
>>120870238
It's ok, we all make mistakes
>>120870281
1/9
+Space brothers
>>120870327
Epic/10
>>120870239
So you don't weather despair very well. Well as a personal reason that's perfectly fine. Thanks for the response ,anon.
>>120869996
>>120870239
That said, good job even rating it, I feel like most of /a/ doesn't read too much manga.
>>120870327
6/8
>>120870327
9/9
>>120862637
oh, good old heidi. best girl.
>>120870327
I also enjoyed Yuru Yuri.
>>120864930
0/9
>>120864949
3/3
>>120865175
2/5
>>120867830
1/6
>>120868383
11/11
>>120868798
1/9
>>120868856
1/3
>>120869680
5/9
>>120869696
2/6
>>120869825
4/4
>>120869870
didn't rate/10
>>120869996
5/17
>>120870281
0/9
>>120862446
3/7
>>120870306
Well then -Lain and +Mindgame
16.5/22
Next time limit yourself to a 3x3. It gives a clearer idea of who you are.
>>120868856
>Fuckin' Kekkaishi on a 3/3
Never thought I'd see the day.
>>120870663
I post my 3x3 rather often in these threads. It's the nine tiles in the middle.
>>120869996
I have literally never shitposted in my life.
>>120869870
You're amazing. Watching Gd Gd Faries now.
>>120862998
Did you watch the dub of Swiss Family Robinson or do you have Japanese skills?
>>120862998
Manga 5/6
OVA: 6/7
Anime: 5/7
>world masterpiece theater
:^)
>>120870737
In a bad way?
One of the few [semi long running] manga that is good all the way through.
>>120871071
I was mildly interested in it, but I got bored and never completed it.
I liked the older brother's fish radar? (I don't remember this very well)
>>120862637
Nice La Strada.
Here is mine
>>120862446
.5/2
>>120863071
1.5/3
>>120864007
2.5/4
>>120864930
1.5/3
>>120864949
1/1
>>120867830
1.5/3
>>120868383
1/1
>>120868798
.3/1
>>120869680
3.3/5
>>120869996
5/8
>>120870327
10/9
>>120870815
You're a tripfag so every post you make is a shitpost, why do you need to use a trip? Are you important? Are you currently the OP of a thread? Does your identity contribute to the current thread?
No, fuck off.
>>120870815
>I have literally never shitposted in my life.
>>120871030
>:^)
Liar
>>120871240
>Are you currently the OP of a thread?
I think you will find he is actually.
>>120871284
It would make no difference if he was posting anonymously, his trip has absolutely zero use regardless if he is the OP or not.
>>120871434
Fuck off autist.
>>120871115
I had several false starts before i finally got really into it.
It has good characters and character developmentfor a shonen
great story(ies) and a cool magic/ power system that makes sense.
>>120871472
He's right though. Unless a trip is absolutely necessary for whatever reason, using one just makes you an attention whore.
You can't argue that, it's truth.
>>120871472
>Defending tripfags, especially new tripfags with shit taste in anime
This rarely happens, and its almost always the tripfag posting anonymously to defend himself, I'll assume you are infact that tripfag.
Strongbird confirmed for unmatched cancer of the highest extent.
>>120871642
Sure and derailing a thread over it is just as obnoxious.
>>120871472
You're the one that should fuck off, go to reddit if you want to circlejerk with people that have usernames. Why the fuck would you come to an anonymous community and tell people that are defending anonymism to fuck off?
Can we put this thread back on track?
>>120871714
>Why the fuck would you come to an anonymous community and tell people that are defending anonymism to fuck off?
Because board police who like to argue over such things and derail threads that were just fine before are just as destructive to board quality as the people they are criticizing unless you think an argument about "tripfag r cancer" makes for a quality thread?
>>120871671
Hey, I've been here all winter, pal.
>>120871642
who the fuck cares if he's using a trip, get over it autistic piece of shit.
>>120871780
No.
I'm not the guy that called out the tripfag but it wouldn't have derailed if you didnt defend the tripfag for whatever reason. If you ignored the fact that a tripfag was called out for his bullshit none of this would've happened.
>>120871832
>All winter.
>Implying thats not new as fuck
Not only should you lurk more but you should do it anonymously. Even anons that are as new as you should lurk for a while before posting, having a trip just makes you the ultimate shit eater.
>>120871832
>All winter
>>120871832
>All winter
I don't have a reaction image worthy of the disgust i'm feeling right now. Fuck right off, get rid of your trip and lurk more.
>>120871915
>people actually buying this
You must be laughing quite heartily, especially at the ones lecturing on not being a newfag.
Rating 8 anons before me, excluding manga ones:
>>120871239
Pretty cool/6
>>120870281
Not my cup of tea, but nice/4
>>120869996
Little to much, but neat/14
>>120869870
Irresistible/3
>>120869680
Cool/20
>>120868798
Kind of weak/5
>>120868383
The shittiest of tastes, would drink beer with/10
>>120867830
Neato/7
>inb4 thread 404s
>>120871832
Filtered at the speed of light.
>>120872033
>Not being around during the tripcoclypse of 2011
>>120862446
1/2
>>120863071
3/3
>>120864930
2/6 shit taste sol fag
>>120868798
5/6
>>120869870
0/0 congrats
>>120870281
2/4
>>120870327
3/9
>>120871239
7/9
>>120872128
>0/0
>2/4
>1/2
>3/3
Watch more anime.
![[Commie] Teekyuu - 08 [BD 720p AAC] [E28026DD].mkv_snapshot_00.51_[2014.10.05_10.31.54].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/O96ua1U.jpg "[Commie] Teekyuu - 08 [BD 720p AAC] [E28026DD].mkv_snapshot_00.51_[2014.10.05_10.31.54].jpg")
>>120872128
>0/0 congrats
At least watch Teekyuu and read Thermae Romae, dude.
>>120872127
"buying this" was with reference to winter not your image.
>>120872128
3/5
>>120872056
1.5/2
>>120871751
3x3 threads are shitty, circle-jerking, thinly-veiled recommendation threads anyway.
>>120869938
nausicaa and eden
Since so many people are doing it I guess I'll post my 5v5 too this thread.
>>120864007
I must say I do like your 5x5 much better than just your 3x3.
>>120864930
6.5/7
>>120868798
6.5/8
>>120868856
1/1 Crows a cool
>>120869825
4/4, amazing taste
>>120867830
8.5/9, More amazing taste. I already love this thread
>>120869996
13/15
>>120870327
I miss cat guy
>>120872056
5/6
>>120872396
4.8/8
>>120872056
>The shittiest of tastes, would drink beer with/10
The first one's on me.
>>120872396
And my manga, with the newly added HolyLand
>>120862446
2/4
>>120862637
8/8
>>120862998
11/11
>>120863071
5/6
>>120864007
14/15
>>120864930
3/5
>>120864949
7/7
>>120867830
5/7
>>120868383
9/9
>>120868798
2/5
>>120869680
14/15
>>120869996
14/15
>>120870281
3/3
>>120871239
3/6
>>120872056
4/5
>>120872128
5/5
>>120872396
11/14
>>120872834
What is row 2 center? Patlabor?
![[140704][AniMan]もっかいしよ？ ちーぷ▼すろーと.mp4_snapshot_05.30_[2014.07.05_17.14.05].jpg](https://i.imgur.com/2jCKuFQ.jpg "[140704][AniMan]もっかいしよ？ ちーぷ▼すろーと.mp4_snapshot_05.30_[2014.07.05_17.14.05].jpg")
>>120872396
>Bear
>Lain
what?
>>120872920
Yep
>>120872834
2/2
>>120873059
Yeah I rewatched it about a month ago and I actually really enjoyed it that time. I regret talking shit about it that whole time.
>>120873286
You are literally the hypocrite and shitposter of the millennia, i'll never forget getting angry at the shit you spewed in Lain threads and the multiple threads that became derailed because of you.
Burn in hell.
>>120873391
>getting angry at what a tripfag with a low powerlevel and god awful taste posts on /a/
Why do you care so much really? It is just some silly posts by a silly person on a silly imageborad full of similarly silly people.
>>120873286
Wow you really really suck. Guess it's time to block the next tripfag.
>>120872834
2/5
>>120872128
4/8
>>120872056
2/6
>>120871239
6/9
>>120870281
2/4
>>120869996
14/20
>>120869680
14/23
Would make a 5x5 myself but I don't have enough shows I liked that much;_;
>>120868856
0/0 good job
>>120868383
6/9
>>120873564
If you're not a lain fan you wouldn't seem to understand.
Imagine going to a thread and having this one fucker derail the thread by doing nothing but pure shittalking.
Imagine that happening nearly every lain thread.
Now imagine that same fucker becoming a Lain fan and you have bear.
>>120873733
That sounds awful, good thing I'm not a Lainfag.
these are the plebbiest threads ever, stop seeking mild attention and approval from people you dont know.
instead, go watch more anime
>>120871239
>>120873663
What shows did you dislike? I'm curious.
Also 2/2
>>120869825
>2/2
>>120869996
>0/0 I think.
>>120870632
>1/3
>>120872396
>1/1 Crows a cool
>>120873663
>0/0 good job
Come on, its not like >>120868856
are really obscure or anything.
>Crows
>Kare Kano
>Hinamatsuri
>Katsu!
>Historie
>>120873733
No, it is nothing to do with liking a show. Getting mad at things on a message board like this is pretty pathetic.
>>120873286
>>120872396
This is pure Chaotic evil.
>>120873914
If you didn't condem shit on the spot and try to burn it at the root, that shit would be deemed acceptable and would multiply. /a/ would turn into /v/ after only a couple of weeks.
>>120873960
Recognizing and/or telling people they are posting badly is not the same as being made angry by their posts.
>>120873915
>>120873733
>>120873663
I-I'm sorry.Liking the show a lot now still doesn't change my opinion that a good amount of Lainfags are shitposters.
>>120873887
+DN EVA SSY Haru Bake Drrr -Shiki, Terror in Tokyo or what it was called, Ching Chong
But they are probably good shows in general. I just don't like some of these.
>>120873663
>2/5
What did you not like?
>>120874115
Bear was that really you in the archive who asked how to delete that thread you made about /v/ when you were new from there or someone pretending to be you?
>>120874186
Don't remind me
>>120874115
>Liking the show a lot now still doesn't change my opinion that a good amount of Lainfags are shitposters.
The majority of anime has awful fanbases, i'm not even a fan of Lain myself but purposely going into threads of a show you don't like to shitpost is disgusting.
I was on the fence about this for a while now since we've discussed quite a bit for months now and generally I know you well as a poster, but Its finally time to filter you.
>>120874296
I meant that someone made a ghost post in that thread under the name bear asking how to delete it today.
>>120874149
+Lain, Tenshi -Honneamise, Gianto Robo, Patlabor
>>120874186
Yup was him
>>120863785
>>120864577
>lisening to /a/
Not even once. Its bad, liking it or not doesn't change that. There are better series you could have put there but like and enjoy what you like even if its shit.
>>120874186
That's funny as hell that you saw that. Yeah I said that as a joke, I didn't think anyone actually checked that. How did you even see that so quickly?
>>120874317
Sorry you feel that way anon,, bye bye.
>>120874627
It bumps the thread to the top of /ghost/ when you respond.
I'm not gonna rate anyone because my taste is the best and I'm an elitist.
>>120875131
Me too
>>120875131
Be more subtle in your bait, that way more people will take your shitposting seriously.
>>120875131
Is this bait? anyway 2.3/5
>>120875204
Pretend bottom right is Saki.
I was a fool
>>120875131
>SAO
if you want to bait do it right faggot
>>120875131
2/9
>>120875204
0/8 I haven't seen Kaiba or bottom right.
candy candy is the middle bottom one, correct? I dropped it.
>>120875296
Is your picture an example of bait?
That poorly edited mess and mix of great shows and awful shows seems to me like you're trying to make an example here.
>>120875296
SAO is not that bad, the fights are the best from the last 15 years of anime, the cast Is pretty good and it's fun.
Stop hating what is popular, you look 13 yo with this 3x3.
>>120875332
>0/8
>haven't seen 2
>8+2 = 10 series
>this is a 3x3
>only 9 series on it
>Not liking Lucky Star
>Not liking Teekyuu
>Not liking Windy Tales
>Not seeing Kaiba
>Not liking Potemayo
>Not liking Chibi Debi
>Dropping Candy Candy
>Not seeing Strike WitchesThis spot is now reserved for based Saki
Worst taste 2015 award.
>>120875296
Why are there 4 amazing shows on your supposed bait chart?
The rest aren't even bad, they range from mediocre to good.
>>120874695
Oh, heh.
>>120875633
Death Note, Ping Pong, Mushishi and Planetes?
>>120874358
>-Honneamise, Gianto Robo, Patlabor
How?
>>120875549
>SAO is not that bad.
Except its fucking retarded
Look at this shit
Who the fuck acts like that? IM IN LOVE WITH ONII CHAN
WHY
WHY THE FUCK ARE YOU IN LOVE WITH ONII CHAN
THAT'S YOUR FUCKING CHARACTER
THAT'S ALL THE CHARACTERS IN THIS FUCKING SERIES ARE DEFINED BY
THEIR RELATION TO GARY STU
THEY EITHER HATE GARY STU AND WANT TO FUCK HIS SUPER SPECIAL RICH WAIFU
OR THEY WANT TO FUCK GARY STU BECAUSE THEY'RE SUPER SPECIAL WAIFUS THEMSELVES
EVEN KLIEN IS DEFINED BY HOW HE WANTS A SUCK OF KIRITO'S COCK
I HATE THIS
THESE CHARACTERS AREN'T HUMAN FUCKING BEINGS
>>120875679
Haven't seen Planetes yet.
Ping Pong, LoGH, Clannad and Mushishi. Even Death note counts too though. There's only one show I wouldn't give a + on that chart and it's TTG.
>>120875699
Do you know this feeling when you don't like something?That's it.
>>120875711
I'm not even saying it's good, it's just not as bad as all of those Light Novels and Visual Novels adaptations that come out every season.
And stop writing like you are super faney haha lel xD.
>>120875549
SAO is legitimately bad. Some popular things are good, some are bad, mediocore bland characters, asspulls, character development thrown out of the fucking window during timeskips, fanfiction tier writing. The only redeeming quality is that the romance is not that bad, except Kirito is a fucking idiot.
>>120875793
https://sys.4chan.org/a/imgboard.php?mode=report&no=120875793
>>120875839
Yeah the writing is bad, but it's not the only thing you should evaluate when rating a show.
>>120875549
>Fights are the best of the last 15 years
If you watch complete trash like Bleach regularly, maybe
Just maybe
>>120875931
>Shit writing
>Shit mc
>Shit otaku pandering tier characters
>Shit development
>Decent romance subplot
>Good music
>Good art and animation.
Overal rating, 2/10 + 1 for music, + 1 for those three episodes of built up romance.
>>120875755
>Bear likes the b8 chart
>>120872201
i've seen over 200.
>>120875985
It's like you don't know who Tetsuya Takeuchi is.
>>120876007
I give it a 5/10. Very mediocre. Only the OST and visuals are worth watching for. The were more average than complete shit things in the series.
>>120875775
No seriously how can you not like honneamise, GR, or Patlabor? All three are super well made. But then again you have Haganai on your 3x3, so am not really surprised.
>>120876121
>Not liking the tatami galaxy, ping pong, lotgh, planetes, mushishi
Its probably not even a bait chart, your post also proves you like Orimeo which is one of the only shows on the chart that would be considered bait, along with deathu nottu.
You are a fiend.
>>120876250
I don't rate shows based on their artwork, the music can also be enjoyed separately via youtube albums but honestly I didn't even enjoy the OST that much outside of the opening.
>>120876353
>Death Note
>Bait
>recommendation thread
>on /a/
I was surprised until I saw everybody was shitposting
I did it.
It's complete
>>120876536
Welcome to the 3x3 thread, where everyone's taste is shit and we discuss how much we hate anime.In reality, there usually are pretty good and there is a high level of discussion going on. Also its kinda fun in a way to rate the shows on other anon's lists, for me at least.
>>120875711
>THESE CHARACTERS AREN'T HUMAN FUCKING BEINGS
That's true for virtually all anime. The only anime that I can think of right now that has realistic characters is Mushishi. Tatami, LOGH, Katanagatari, Ping Pong, all of those great anime don't have realistic characters.
>>120876539
Wait, this one is more aesthetically pleasing.
A must when you consider this is a moeshit 3x3.
>>120876636
>Thats true for virtually all anime.
What the fuck kind of garbage are you watching? None of the shows on my list have characters that one track minded and flat.
Watch more anime.
>>120876636
Thats true for virtually all HAREM anime.
Fixed.
>>120876683
Alright, name 3 to 5 of your best shows and I'll tell you why the characters are not realistic at all.
>>120876328GR: seemed like any other shounen. Story was rather boring and stupid. Little boy with a big robot who only follows his instruction? I just didn't like it.
Honneamise: Was also pretty boring. I have to admit I don't remember much of it because it has been so long since I've watched it. Some scenes were pretty cool though. For example this big fight at the end (?)
Patlabor: To make it short it bored me as well. I'm not in the mood now to explain it in every detail but I don't liked the characters, the pacing of the story, the story itself and I really hate mecha Animu.
I think Patlabor and Honne are great Anime though. I just don't like them. They are probably better than Haganai but I really enjoy Haganai and fun things are fun. I could make a 3x3 of Lain, Tenshi, EVA, Kaiba and so on myself. But I want my 3x3 to show my taste in Animu and not which Anime I think are great pieces of art (or what some anons would call them).
TL;DR I've shittaste and you don't
>>120876713
Nah. Harem may be the worst but all other genres of anime greatly suffer from having non realistic characters. And their interactions are very cingeworthy. Maybe it's reflective of how the Japanese interact but I heard they interact more formally and reserved than other cultures, so it's probably not that.
>>120876715
Nice, I love challenges like this.
Lain, Cowboy bebop, Vision of escaflowne, Kaiba, Princess tutu, Rose of versailles, Kino ( she's not the most realistic character but its not like she's a flatly written one, she also has good depth and Character development, but still the weakest link on my list), Kenshin, Ippo, Monster, Evangelion, NHK, Platabor, Turn A gundam, Zeta gundam, and a few more but i'm dragging this on.
Anyway, i'm interested to hear your rebuttle, I love arguments like these.
>>120876886
strongbird™ approved
You can still have interesting and well written anime characters without them having to fall into the same 1:1 pattern that makes them realistic.
>>120864949
4/4 0/0
>>120876886
I was rewatching Clanned yesterday and noticed that Tomoya is actually really well written and a believable character. Everyone is usually focused on how sad it was, how depressing the developments were; not that many paid attention to how developed. And how different Tomoya was from the beginning of Clannad, to the end of After Story.
>>120870327
13 years old/9
>>120876662
Your 3x3s could still use more effort as far as aesthetics are concerned. Except maybe the one with movies.
6/6 moeshit.
>>120876662
I don't understand why use a picture of Kaiba if you could use one of Chroniko.
>>120876886
>Lain
Okay good example. I won't argue that the interactions are not realistic. It's probably the best anime when it comes to realistic interactions.
>Cowboy bebop
Besides Spike and Fayne, the other characters act way too overtop and they do throw in cliche lines. A bad example but obviously not as bad as SAO.
>Kaiba
Haven't seen it.
>Princess Tutu
Haven't finished it, it wouldn't be a fair judgement but there are some pretty bad examples of unrealistic interactions."
>Kino
Like you said, she's not realistic at all. And I don't care if the low bar of what you consider to be acceptable is Kino, it's a pretty shit low bar. The anime is good, but we're talking about how close to human beings these characters act.
>Monster
This one is interesting. At first, it's easy to think that it's easily the most realistic but the anime fools the viewer into thinking that because of the modern setting and continuous revisiting of real life events. But the antagonist doesn't act like a real sociopath, at least according to modern understanding of anti social disorder.
>Kenshin
Kenishin's mental troubles are some of the most contradicting ones with regards to what caused them. It's not realistic at all. Then again, it is anime and anime tend to exaggerate.
>Ippo
Haven't.
>Evangelion
This is very poor work. Anno basically took 101 psychology textbooks and wrote a character for 3 psychological pers. disorders. but what you get is just that, no other depth or facets of them.
>>120876715
Literally everything on this list has well written and realistic characters.
Also I want an excuse to post this.
>>120872396
>Bear's 5x5 is has better series than his 3x3
Nice Bear.
Chroniko is most moe when Kaiba uses her body
But you're right. There are some serious buttcrack shots I could use.
I know it's mostly casual shit.
I gotta find something to take out fro Cromartie.
Also gotta get on a manga one.
>>120876475
I mean animation but the visuals were okay. The animation was top teir. Characters, character development, story, and writing were average. Character interactions with Kirito and any female were cringeworthy.
>>120877348
My effort days are behind me, but who knows. Maybe I get bored one day and make it perfect.
You know I love you/8
We are king and queen of moeshit.
>>120877442
>It's probably the best anime when it comes to realistic interactions.
I hope you mean most realistic on the list and not most realistic of all anime. All you need to do is look at something like Omoide Poroporo for a better example of realism. Even WMT shows like Little Women or Anne of Green Gables.
>>120874342
No trip, no bear
>>120877687
How are they more realistic?
>>120877442
>It's probably the best anime when it comes to realistic interactions.
Not really.
>>120877442
>Besides Spike and Fayne, the other characters act way too overtop
There is nothing unrealistic with acting over the top, the villains have logical and consistant motivations that made sense and added layers of depth to their character.
Edd is also a child, she acts fairly over the top but she has character development on her own especially during the end of the series. There aren't any characters in the show that step out of the boundary of realism but they can be goofy at times.
>Kaiba
>Haven't seen it.
Watch it, its my second favourite anime of all time.
>Tutu
>but there are some pretty bad examples of unrealistic interactions."
So you agree with me? Alright, moving on.
>Kino
>Like you said, she's not realistic at all.
I didn't say that she was unrealistic, I said she was a weak link mainly because her personality is highly introvered, but to be honest its not at all unrealistic. Kino provides the balance admits the hell of the show but she still has emotions, especially in the last episode. She thinks, acts and speaks realistically and calculated. Its not abnormal for a human like her to exist, nor would it be strange if she existed in this world.
>Monster
>This one is interesting. At first, it's easy to think that it's easily the most realistic but the anime fools the viewer into thinking that because of the modern setting and continuous revisiting of real life events. But the antagonist doesn't act like a real sociopath, at least according to modern understanding of anti social disorder.
Johan Liebert is the most realistic villain that i've ever seen in anime. He doesn't think and act like the stereotypical villain which is a good thing. he's probably my favourite villain i've ever encountered because of how highly realistic his general actions are. The character development actually made me even relate to him. Character limit reached
>>120875549
4/10 i am slightly flustered
>>120877785
Really? Have you seen them?
>>120877905
>>120877442
Continuing.
Johan Liebert is a perfect example of how nurture can completely corrupt a person. Monster does a great job of expressing the strength of nurture over nature, and even foreshadows it in his name. Lieben is the German verb for to love; if you form it into the comparative adjective lieber, it becomes to prefer. This is a brilliant irony the writer has incorporated into the very text, itself.
Naoki Urasawa built a great case for how antisocial personality disorder that a lot of people can relate to, especially on /a/ it can be introduced into a person instead of it being an inherent property. The character of Johan was a brilliant insight into a new type of bad guy for the world of anime. And easily the villain that hit closest to home for me.
Ok next
>Kenshin
The reason I put him on this list is because he is a flawed character, and not the shining perfect Gary Stu MCs. In his own way he is actually a highly fragile character. He vows never to kill again, he is the kind of character that typically puts others above himself, a fairly common trait that is played with the inner struggle of having to break his vow and kill again. person and to do everything within his power to protect people from being killed. Despite this, however, he holds his own existence cheap and carries in his heart a grievous guilt that prevents him from becoming emotionally close to the people around him and compels him to a life of humble service and selfless personal sacrifice. Even with his prodigious skill as a prolific swordsman. Though unwilling to simply be killed by unrelated attackers, and will face their hatred or judgment without complaint, believing that he does not deserve the same happiness as others. Spending much of his alone time in quiet contemplation of his past misdeeds and future retribution, Kenshin often ponders what the right path toward redemption is and laments each life lost due to his weakness.
>>120877905
>There is nothing unrealistic with acting over the top
Over the top is literally unrealistic.
>the villains have logical and consistant motivations that made sense
That's not even what realism necessary entails. They could be very irrational, that's not the issue...
>So you agree with me?
I said I wouldn't judge Tutu until I finished it. Learn to read.
> She thinks, acts and speaks realistically and calculated. Its not abnormal for a human like her to exist, nor would it be strange if she existed in this world.
Kino is a fucking robot in the body of a human. She's not realistic at all. It plays well with the anime and makes it interesting but she is not realistic at all.
>Johan Liebert is the most realistic villain that i've ever seen in anime.
Except he's not realistic.
>He doesn't think and act like the stereotypical villain which is a good thing. he's probably my favourite villain i've ever encountered because of how highly realistic his general actions are.
Just because he's better written in your opinion does not make Monster's villain a realistic character.
I haven't been vague with what realistic would mean with Johan. He's not suppose to act like the average guy, he's a sociopath. And sociopaths have been studied for a while now. He lacks many sociopath traits even if he lacks empathy.
>made me relate to him
I had a sense you were arrogant but I gotta tip that fedora to that.
We're not arguing what's well written but what is realistic.
>>120877442
Continue x2
>Ippo
>Haven't seen.
Oh man
>Evangelion
>This is very poor work. Anno basically took 101 psychology textbooks and wrote a character for 3 psychological pers. disorders. but what you get is just that, no other depth or facets of them.
I feel like if I tried to counter this, I would write an entire novel, so i'll keep this short to say, I hope this is bait.
>>120877971
Yes. Now answer the fucking question instead of thinking that your opinion is self evident truth.
>>120878388
Little women is a semi-autobiographical novel, Anne of Green Gables is based upon the childhood experiences of the author living in the location, Omoide Poroporo is in a large part critically acclaimed for bringing a realism above and beyond what anime usually achieves.
This is just me though.
Friendly reminder that people can be one dimensional, and this is not a valid criticism of writing quality.
I like some of these. I like serious dramas with realistic character interactions and I sort of hate chipmunk-voiced moeshit bullshit.
I don't care if some neckbeard finds my tastes tryhard because they want to see catgirls and eyes that occupy one third of a person's face flourish (if you could even call characters with the personality of wet cardboard a "person").
>>120878496
>>120878388
Also can you tell me how they are not as realistic as Lain now?
>>120878257
>>120878364
Again, you're not arguing if those characters are realistic, you're arguing if they are well written.
But it seems you have very little understanding of psychology and have very limited real life experiences to know what's real and what isn't. Normally, I wouldn't expect someone to know what a schizoid person is like but there is lots of research on the subject. So educate yourself.
Also this was very stupid:
>Naoki Urasawa built a great case for how antisocial personality disorder that a lot of people can relate to
No. Just stop. Anti social personality disorder is not relatable, not at all. And if it's written to be relatable than it's very badly written.
>Kenshin
Except killers don't act like that. Once you stop, you get PTSD. There is no evidence that he has PTSD. He acts too chill for someone who regrets killing for so long.
I think what you're trying to say is that Johan's background story was well written because viewers have empathy for him. That makes for good writing and not necessarily realistic. But even if it is realistic how he acts in his adult stage is not how a real sociopath acts.
>>120877542
1/2
>>120878559
A character can be one dimensional, but if all characters are one dimensional and they all share the same dimension and it doesn't matter to the story if they're there or not, then the writer's failing.
And that's okay if you ask me. Some stories are made to satisfy the creator's needs. They're not aiming to be fine writing, just fulfilling the writer's fantasies.
There is a problem when these kind of stories become the norm.
>pic related
>an example of a character that adds fuck-all but titties to the story
>>120878608
1.5/5
>>120878608
I swear someone out there has a folder full of b8worthy 3x3s they post while laughing their ass off at everyone fighting over them.
>>120878496
I'm not the guy you talked to and I haven't seen Anne but I don't think it's fair to praise it for it's classic source material.
Here's my shitty 4x4
>>120871239
8/9
>>120872056
2/4
>>120872128
9/9
>>120872396
19/21
>>120872834
1/1
>>120873663
7/9
>>120874140
1/1
>>120875204
2/5
>>120877348
6/7
>>120877542
4/8
>>120878509
2/5
>>120878608
2/5
>>120878364
>I feel like if I tried to counter this, I would write an entire novel, so i'll keep this short to say, I hope this is bait.
You know it's the true that EVA's main characters were written out of an intro to psychology textbook. They have no other trait but what is easily know by anyone who reads a little into those personality disorders.
A character in the show that doesn't suffer is the major. But she gets outnumbered by 3 cardboard psychology 101 characters. So that's a no for the anime.
>>120877442
>It's probably the best anime when it comes to realistic interactions.
What, you mean by Lain? Considering she has DID, the anime managed to handle that well by her constant state of confusion and distinct tonal and lexical shift(seriously Karoi Shimizu did an amazing job with her performance).
But as for her friends; they kept dodging subjects constantly and were really vague "Lain, did you do it? What? It couldn't of been Lain. What..what are you talking about? Lain was it really not you." etc. Kids would straight up state why they were angry after they were asked, for them to keep Lain(and by intention of the writers the viewer.) in the dark for little reason is silly. And lets not even justify Lain's interaction with her family considering what they are.
>Bebop
>act way too overtop and they do throw in cliche lines
I'll talk to you about this.>>120877905.
The cliche part we can ignore, but in terms of being over the top he does have so validity to that(However weak). For example the episode of Cowboy Andy. Now, oddly Andy himself his quite realistic all things considered, but the bomber of the episode is not. He basically admits that he wanted attention and was being silly, something a serial bomber would not even conceive of thinking as they would continue to justify their actions and use thinking errors. Still that's based upon the dubs performance, and that's only one example out of a show with hordes of great characters.
>Monster
>at least according to modern understanding of anti social disorder.
You mean your understanding. I should hope your using the DSM classification of the disorder and are also not assuming that since Johan doesn't fit all of the symptoms then he's not a sociopath.
You haven't gone into any real depth with any of these points. You've just said they were unrealistic and moved on. I appreciate that you don't want to type out a bunch of long, indepth analysis of characters, but you won't convince people unless you do.
>>120878608
I honestly didn't like Madoka Machoka Maniggah's ending.
>>120878729
>2/5
That's 4 out of 10. Not bad.
>>120878721
It is a 1:1 adaptation.
>>120878704
>if all characters are one dimensional and they all share the same dimension and it doesn't matter to the story if they're there or not, then the writer's failing.
This I can agree with.
The characters in Lucky Star are well written.
>>120871239
>>120878729
>8/9
Nice, what anime was the one you disliked?It was ZnT, wasn't it?
Also .5/1
>>120878847
Evangelion
>>120878729
The point of a 3x3 is to limit yourself to few titles so your true character shines through.
>>120878803
>The characters in Lucky Star are well written.
About half are, the other are just filler.
I actually really like Lucky Star but it has the same flaws every other shonen anime has in that they only have to dick around until they face the final boss, and then some supah-dupah-magic emotion attack magically defeats it.
It doesn't matter because they always end the same:
>KYYYYYYYAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!!!!!
>all is well
>>120878761
>You've just said they were unrealistic and moved on.
Except I haven't. I have pointed out what's the problem. Sure I could go further but I don't feel like writing an essay about cartoons. And I'm assuming people have watched the anime and have a basic knowledge of psychology and an average person's life experience (assuming they're not teenagers).
>they(Lain's friends) kept dodging subjects constantly and were really vague
That's how real people act.
There's a recent tv show that's been praised for its realistic interactions. I haven't finished it but it looks pretty real so far. You're probably not the type who goes out much so I suggest you watch The Affair. It's only 10 eps.
Pay attention to how subtle the interactions are and how vague the dialogue is.
>>120878890
>so your true character shines through.
>>120878909
Who would you say is a filler character in Lucky Star?
Aside from one-episode characters and faceless classmates that aren't part of the story, I don't agree.
>>120878869
Wasn't expecting that, anyway thanks for answering.
>>120878991
Carry on, then. All is forgiven.
>>120878957
>And I'm assuming people have watched the anime and have a basic knowledge of psychology and an average person's life experience (assuming they're not teenagers).
Except that's the thing. Most animes start out as mangas the creators started out in their teenage years.
They're meant to vent their teenage frustrations, not be an actual story that makes sense.
I'm not justifying it, I'm just saying that you can't expect that much from anime plots in general because their story-creation is not the same process as a movie or even a TV show.
They're just watered down versions of a manga that has to fit 12-50 episodes of a story which the guy who started it never had any idea how it would end or where it would go.
>>120878344
Over the top characters are not unrealistic. Human beings can be wild and unpredictable along with be shallow and petty, there is no static unanimous point where an enthusiastic/over the top character becomes inhumane AS LONG as the actions are based in a logical way that are associated with general and believable human traits that are explained and showcased in a viable way.
Sine you don't understand the meaning of what realism in literature is i'll define it for you.
REALISM: An elastic and ambiguous term with two meanings. (1) First, it refers generally to any artistic or literary portrayal of life in a faithful, accurate manner, unclouded by false ideals, literary conventions, or misplaced aesthetic glorification and beautification of the world.
>Kino is a fucking robot in the body of a human. She's not realistic at all. It plays well with the anime and makes it interesting but she is not realistic at all.
Did you watch the same show that I did? Granted she doesn't show her emotions as often but she reacts and speaks realistically, she gets incredibly emotional especially during the last few episodes which ties into her general character development. "She doesn't speak much, she doesn't change her expression much, she doesn't do X as much as regular humans that must must mean she's an unrealistic character" You would be surprised to know how many humans speak as much as her or even less just out of choice, its not unrealistic for a character to be calculated and planning, but that pretty much goes out the window in the later episodes when she deals with the horrors before her.
>>120878957
Any other anime suggestions that feature realistic character behavior?
I have a huge problem with unrealistic reactions in my series.
>>120878999
I just realized we're not talking about Soul Eater.
For some reason I had a huge brain fart.
Why did you let me keep on talking, anon?
>>120879179
nigga you even typed Lucky Star.
>>120879179
I as a casual observer wondered what the fuck you were talking about when I read that but then thought I suppose you could interpret Lucky Star that way if you wanted to be abstract about it.
>>120879246
What part of "brain fart" didn't register?
>>120879254
No, man. I was just talking about Soul Eater but for some reason since I saw the other anon write Lucky Star I just rolled with it.
It's fucking hot outside.
>>120879333
Mixing Lucky Star and Soul Eater is not normal.
But on meth it is.
METH. NOT EVEN ONCE.
>>120878344
Johan Liebert
>Except he's not realistic.
>Just because he's better written in your opinion does not make Monster's villain a realistic character.
> He's not suppose to act like the average guy, he's a sociopath. And sociopaths have been studied for a while now. He lacks many sociopath traits even if he lacks empathy.
There is no such thing as a static degree present in all sociopaths, it ranges.
The degree of psychopathic traits present in a character are not what ties into realism either, however you are wrong. He possesses many of the textbook examples of a sociopath,
The first example is GLIB.
The tendency to be smooth, engaging, charming, slick, and verbally facile. Psychopathic charm is not in the least shy, self-conscious, or afraid to say anything. A psychopath never gets tongue-tied. They have freed themselves from the social conventions about taking turns in talking, for example.
The second example is
PATHOLOGICAL LYING, Either moderate or high this is a very common reacurring trait in sociopaths and one of Johan's defining traits; in moderate form, they will be shrewd, crafty, cunning, sly, and clever; in extreme form, they will be deceptive, deceitful, underhanded, unscrupulous, manipulative, and dishonest.
The third example, general premeditated plans. The use of deceit and deception to cheat, con, or defraud others for personal gain; distinguished from Item #4 in the degree to which exploitation and callous ruthlessness is present, as reflected in a lack of concern for the feelings and suffering of one’s victims.
The fifth example and generally most notable trait that nearly all sociopaths possess.
LACK OF REMORSE OR GUILT.
He possess A lack of feelings or concern for the losses, pain, and suffering of victims; a tendency to be unconcerned, dispassionate, cold-hearted, and non-empathic. This item is usually demonstrated by a disdain for one’s victims.
I have more but I reached the limit
>>120879333
That goes behind brain fart, anon. You had brain diarrhea
>>120879082
I never said that "unrealistic=bad". I actually don't care at all even if characters are speaking incomprehensible nonsense. I was just calling out another anon's bullshit. Anime simply for the most part are not realistic. Elitists should just accept that before they get humiliated by normies who'll tear you apart.
>>120879084
Wild and unpredictible does not mean over the top. Over the top literally means over the boundary, as in the unrealistic. When I said over the top for CB, that's exactly that. The interactions are constantly too over the top to be real. It's like their brains are on some sort of drug. It'd be fine if they were regular hardcore drug users but they're not.
>realism in literature
Anime isn't literature. Your definition is moot.
>Granted she doesn't show her emotions as often but she reacts and speaks realistically, she gets incredibly emotional especially during the last few episodes which ties into her general character development
Schizoids don't end up like that. You actually just destroyed your own argument by mentioning the development since it's the most unrealistic part of her character. Once a schizoid, it takes years to change. Heck, I'm not even sure if there has ever been one who changed.
>>120878761
>>120877442
Ran out of space.
>Monster Cont
Now, if arguing over Johan's ability to "magically" persuade and control people is unrealistic, then I'd say it's not. The financial world is an example of this, in both the idea of lacking empathy and the ability to manipulate. Aggressive competition is common in businesses, encouraged even, but to be able to compete with someone else you must understand that your success equals their failure. Typically dissociation is used to deal with this, but those who enjoy particular success often do so by clear and forward attacks on competing colleagues and constant lying and manipulation of customers.
Commonly you'd associate this with Historic symptoms, but it works in sociopaths as well. Johan had no regard for others around him yet was still able to make them do his bidding, and if you'd ever studied a socio/psychopath you'd understand very clearly why. You do not interact with them, end of. You just run. Johan's diragrd for others and ability to manipulate, while extreme in portrayal in some ways, is not outside of possibility. Look a fucking Ted Bundy. Nigger is the poster boy of "the modern understanding of anti-social personality disorder". And while is victims were female(thus more open to manipulation), he still has Johan levels of charisma. But he's just one popular example, there are better ones, but he does the job well enough.
>>120879446
>Anime isn't literature
Yes it is.
Anime is literature, video games are literature, movie scripts are literature.
>>120878715
It's not bait.Dansai Bunri is more of a placeholder for ridiculous gimmick LN adaptations, which I love.
>>120879446
No, there isn't anything wrong with realism as long as its well written.
Except, they're all pretty realistic characters because realism is a very loose term.
>Anime isn't literature. Your definition is moot.
Anime is a visual medium for storytelling, I think you are literally fucking retarded.
>One guy in this thread says Johan Liebert isn't a realistic character
>Thread derails into a flood of text calling the guy out on his shit.
I'm laughing, good for you /a/.
This is the 3x3 thread, why is there so much anime discussion going on?
>>120878957
>That's how real people act.
No. If the dialogue was realistic(barring any ethnocentic differences and what not) Lain's friends would of first been vague, and then answered Lain's questions since they would recognize her confusion/suspected attempts at playing dumb and would try to force a clearly answer/reaction by telling her the situation. People do not persistently and vaguely accuse someone of something unless they themselves are lying about the accusation. Also there was a lot of unnatural pauses between utterances.
>You're probably not the type who goes out much
You're a rude dude.
>>120879496
>>120879507
It's not a loose term. Realistic is a reflection of what's empirically understood to be the real (i.e what we perceive to be the world.)
In this contest, what's being put into question are characters and their interactions with other characters. Those are not realistic.
>anime is literature
You guys are morons. Stop talking. Just stop.
>>120879403
Ted Bundy wasn't invincible. Johan was.
You just disproved your own argument by bringing out a real world example...
>>120877442
>This is very poor work. Anno basically took 101 psychology textbooks and wrote a character for 3 psychological pers. disorders. but what you get is just that, no other depth or facets of them.
Since no one did, I'll comment on this one. First of all, yes the characters in evangelion, at least the children do not have realistic personalities, but that doesn't mean they're poorly written. You just flat out didn't get the purpose of why the characters were presented the way they were. They are just as the plot and setting elements of the deconstruction. They are stereotypes on purpose. The kuudere/tsundere/whatever tropes aren't anything evangelion has created, it just used them. Then it attempted to analyze them and act them out in a realistic manner and that's just what the show did. If it were like most other previous or even later titles. Shinji being the typical introverted weakling would gain strength and confidence, Asuka would have revealed her charm and Rei would have completely opened up. But that's not how it works and years of trauma can't just be healed with some magic-type moments.
So on the surface you might be write but fundamentally you lack understanding.
>>120879763
>You just disproved your own argument by bringing out a real world example...
He seems to be talking about Johan as a realistic character, not his plot armor.
>>120879763
>It's not a loose term.
Do you even know what literature is?
Are you underaged?
>>120862446
3/6
>>120863071
5/5
>>120864007
10/11
>>120864930
2/3
>>120868383
9/9
>>120868798
2/3
>>120869680
21/21 Pretty fucking good
>>120869996
15/21
>>120870281
5/5
>>120870327
3/8
>>120871239
6/8
>>120872056
6/6
>>120872128
7/8
>>120872396
16/19
>>120872834
7/7
>>120873663
6/6
>>120875131
6/9
>>120875204
1/3
>>120875296
8/9
>>120876662
2/2
>>120877348
7/7
>>120877542
5/7
>>120878509
6/7
That Memories God Taste
>>120878608
3/6
>>120878729
5/7
>>120877446
Yeah, maybe most of them, but please. Aria characters are idealized tropes. Nausicaa is the mary sue of anime in general, Metropolis characters have no character.
>>120879724
>would try to force a clearly answer/reaction by telling her the situation.
People don't act like that unless what's being hidden is something that they think is very personal to them. So for example, thinking that a partner cheated on you and telling them to spill the beans. This is a cliche example but it illustrates the pojnt.
>People do not persistently and vaguely accuse someone of something
In Japanese culture of "avoid shame as much as possible" yes.
>Also there was a lot of unnatural pauses between utterances.
They weren't.
>You're a rude dude.
I'm not the one who thinks people will force something out of their friends when it's not related to them. People will ask you if something's wrong and when you tell them no, they either stop bothering you about it or they'll bring it out once in a while.
Alright, there's no point deal with you guys. You're either so religiously attached to anime that you won't see reason or you have no real world experiences. I hope it's the former but who am I kidding, this is a board where 3dpd was taking seriously for a long time.
>>120879763
>You guys are morons. Stop talking. Just stop.
