[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Fate/stay night
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 87
File: ibyfHPUgVS3qXA.jpg (1 MB, 2560x2980) Image search: [Google]
ibyfHPUgVS3qXA.jpg
1 MB, 2560x2980
>>
File: iuWWr8RsoAs5A.jpg (757 KB, 1575x2277) Image search: [Google]
iuWWr8RsoAs5A.jpg
757 KB, 1575x2277
>>
File: 1410469346558.jpg (32 KB, 395x389) Image search: [Google]
1410469346558.jpg
32 KB, 395x389
>>114256355
>>114256378
The only thing DEEN didn't fuck up were the character models.
>>
I like how a TV show looks better than a movie.
Sasuga Ufotable.
>>
>>114256378
Holy shit. That Shirou. Deen, what were you thinking?
>>
>>114256503
Shirou looks alright.

Hell, Saber and Sakura look decent too.

For some reason Rin just had a terrible case of longface.
>>
>>114256503
What you meant to say was
>Ufotable improved the character models

Go on, call me a ufofag, I know you will.

On a further note, I just finished the Fate route yesterday, holy hell were those sex scenes shitty and forced as all hell. Starting UBW route tonight, both of these routes are non-canon as I hear since Ataraxia goes with Heaven's Feel being the canon one, I hope this is true, since I really dislike all sorts of "Alternate dimensions" and "all timelines can be true at once" bullshit since it makes things extremely confusing. And I know Rin fucks time up in Ataraxia, it's a nice way to make them remember the previous routes, but it doesn't mean they happened in that universe.
>>
File: 1395593345574.jpg (19 KB, 144x149) Image search: [Google]
1395593345574.jpg
19 KB, 144x149
>>114256675
Still better than this. Not by much however.
>>
>>114256378
Shirou looks hott.
>>
>>114256734
Whoever told you that Ataraxia continues HF is a fucking secondary or retarded or both. Ataraxia takes place in it's own magical route where a little of every route happened.
>>
>>114256734

HA is based off some kind of merged route, saber and rider are both alive during and after it which is impossible in every route
>>
>>114256797
Holy fuck is that just shitty as all hell? So all routes are fucking canon? That's disgusting.
>>
>>114256734
>Starting UBW route tonight, both of these routes are non-canon as I hear since Ataraxia goes with Heaven's Feel being the canon one,
This nigga right here
>>
File: 1411429689187.png (140 KB, 312x572) Image search: [Google]
1411429689187.png
140 KB, 312x572
>>114256856
Yes, fucking 2nd magic bitch, Kelidoscope. Deal with it. Also Shirou is the red man.
>>
>>114256864
I will refer to the comment on me only hearing this. I'm only reading the novels anyway since people keep telling me it's better than Fate/Zero, so far, hell no. Granted, it's good, very good, but it's not Fate/Zero.
>>
>>114256946
Everyone knows Shirou is Archer, that's still shitty, you can't have three different routes be valid at the same time, it just makes no damn sense. What is Nasu thinking. Shit's going to be so damn confusing.
>>
>>114256952
>has read one route
>judging it already
Top kek

Also, you better not become a wormfag.
>>
Why does ufo field of swords look like shit?
>>
>>114256952
you will find few people who think that fate was better than zero
>>
>>114257044
I do.
>>
File: the_dayface.jpg (930 KB, 1278x1920) Image search: [Google]
the_dayface.jpg
930 KB, 1278x1920
>>114257009
Of course I'm judging it as I go along, I can also change my judgment as I go along, but Heaven's Feel or UBW better be fucking amazing to beat Fate/Zero. Especially since the original has such a shitty character cast in comparison to Fate/Zero, and not even going to the fact that Fate/Stay focuses on a single team in the war. Hardly gives a bigger picture. Unless we do get a lot of screentime from other teams in UBW and HF. I fucking hope so, Shirou/Tohsaka/Saber are so fucking boring. Jesus.
>>
>>114256952
If you think the Fate route is very good, then you have seen nothing yet.
>>
>>114256952
Zero > Fate
UBW > Zero
HF > Zero
>>
File: 1411510391648.jpg (50 KB, 614x572) Image search: [Google]
1411510391648.jpg
50 KB, 614x572
>>114256989
They all take place in their own parallel universe, which means that everything in F/SN is canon. Bad ends as well. Besides if by your own logic one route has to be canon then the route Shirou became Archer is canon which is neither UBW, Fate or HF.
>>
>>114257119
>he watched/read F/Z first
You done fucked up.
>>
>>114257134
Now that would actually make for an interesting story. How to make the monkey-brained idiot a legit edgemaster.
>>
File: 1355730078604.png (75 KB, 983x1013) Image search: [Google]
1355730078604.png
75 KB, 983x1013
>>114256989

>secondaries
>>
>>114257178
I watched the DEEN adaptation and movie first, then watched Fate/Zero, now reading the original material.

As for the "you done fucked up". Hell no, Fate/Zero was fucking magnificent. As it stands now, nothing Stay related even compares, although I am hyped for Heaven's Feel, it better not dissappoint.
>>
>>114257125
you didn't compare HF and UBW afraid of the routewar?
>>
File: 1349468126491.jpg (303 KB, 902x896) Image search: [Google]
1349468126491.jpg
303 KB, 902x896
>>114257248
>I watched the DEEN adaptation and movie first,
>>
>>114256989
>Nasu
>thinking

I found your problem.
>>
>>114257125
I'll remember this opinion, and laugh at it after I've read all routes.
>>
File: Kaza.jpg (20 KB, 250x300) Image search: [Google]
Kaza.jpg
20 KB, 250x300
>>114257183
When you kill too much people you legit become an edgemaster. Try JU-C YU-G in Grisaia, literal fucking edgemaster, but extremely likeable. But his edge is explained and makes fucking sense which is really hard to do nowdays.
>>
>>114257248

you are basically the embodiment of everything that will suck about the new UBW adaption
>>
>>114257283
I watched them because of a suggestion, I didn't know what Fate/ was before I saw 'em. Be glad it managed to get me interested, I wouldn't be enlightening myself with the original content if I didn't gain interest through something. Besides, I'm sure a fuckton of people have done their introduction to Fate/ just like I did.
>>
File: 1372563198207.gif (493 KB, 246x246) Image search: [Google]
1372563198207.gif
493 KB, 246x246
>>114256734
>since Ataraxia goes with Heaven's Feel being the canon one
You do realize that's Heaven's Feel epilogue takes place two years after the Holy Grail war.
>>
>>114257248
Yes, "you done fucked up". You just don't know it yet. Just because you think you didn't because you enjoyed Zero doesn't mean shit.
You might just have ruined part of Heaven's feel for yourself.
>>
>>114257248
As I said. YOU DONE FUCKED UP.
Also HF is only good for the last 3 days unless you like long expositions of plot in your face, oh woe is me and cooking.
>>
>>114257298
It's much more likely that you will agree
also UBW >HF
>>
File: 1349471737896.gif (2 MB, 236x132) Image search: [Google]
1349471737896.gif
2 MB, 236x132
>>114257248
God damn it, I was hoping we'd at least be spared this shit for another week or so...
>>
>>114257386
Bullshit let me fix that for you.
Last 3 days of HF = UBW > HF Kotomine scenes > shit > rest of HF.
>>
>>114257349
I'm hyped for the new adaptation, but I firmly believe it won't live up to Fate/Zero.
>No Iskandar
>Generic highschool students fucking around
>Not giving the picture of the entire war, but focusing on a single team
>No Gilles de Rais
>No HASSAN
>No Banquet of Kings
>>
>>114257357
>Be glad it managed to get me interested,
Yes, because you're going to be such a welcome addition, I'm sure.
>>
File: 1409256761304.gif (170 KB, 850x900) Image search: [Google]
1409256761304.gif
170 KB, 850x900
>>114256734

You didn't enjoy Saber's deep throating?
>>
File: Best girl.png (902 KB, 799x599) Image search: [Google]
Best girl.png
902 KB, 799x599
>>114257252
I like HF and UBW equally But Rin is best girl..
>>
>>114257463
This fucking shit. I hate secondaries, I really do but shit likes this makes me want to outright murder them. Fuck you, fuck you Frodo.
>>
>>114257463
2/10
too obvious
>>
>>114257467
Yeah, because I partake in one thread per half a year is such a steep price to pay. I'm sorry I won't be an elitist who thinks that all anime adaptations are rotten, on a board that focuses partly on anime.

>>114257491
No, it was hideous.
>>
>>114256856
Welcome to VNs.
>>
File: blacknight.jpg (14 KB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
blacknight.jpg
14 KB, 640x360
>>114256355
>FUCK YOU ARTHUR, I'M SO DONE WITH YOUR WHITE KNIGHT FAGGOTRY
>>
>>114257463
>Generic highschool students fucking around
Because a nutcase sword elemental and a magus are your average highschoolers.
>>
>>114257248
>I watched the DEEN adaptation and movie first, then watched Fate/Zero, now reading the original material.
>Fate/Zero was fucking magnificent.
It hasn't even been a week and they're already here. You Fate/Zerofaggots are the worst part of Type-Moon saying that Fate/Zero is some 'epic zero moeshit dark fantasy masterpiece'.
>>
>>114257560
And what exactly in that makes you angry? You think some fucking H-scenes with saber is better? Good for you. I personally have no interest in Tohsakas anus, Sabers deepthroating, Sakuras worms, nor do I have interest in the entire powerstruggles on "which one is the strongest servant". I liked the wit and strategic moments in Zero. Shirou is a master fucking strategist, sure thing.
>>
>>114257571
>steep price to pay
You're implying there's some benefit of you being here. That's funny. You're funny.
>>
>>114257648
I'd say they are still better than prismafagd
>>
File: 1410749297690.png (824 KB, 587x539) Image search: [Google]
1410749297690.png
824 KB, 587x539
>>114257655
>>
>>114257655
>Expecting a 18 year old to be a better strategist than a killer with 20+ years of experience..
Yeah, you forgot who you're comparing him to.
>>
File: prisma SHIROU 423475.png (975 KB, 781x683) Image search: [Google]
prisma SHIROU 423475.png
975 KB, 781x683
>>114257717
Which reminds me; Shit's getting real, yo.
>>
>>114257655
>strategic moments
what?
>>
>>114257637
In anime they are.

>>114257648
>You shouldn't enjoy Fate/Zero because it came out after this product, which I enjoyed more, thus my taste is far better than yours.
I'm saying that I, as an individual, favor Fate/Zero over the original, due to it's characters. I don't give a fuck about anyone else who likes Fate/Zero or /Stay for other reasons, or thinks one is better than the other. Feel free to think that, just don't slander other peoples tastes.
>>
>>114257655
Oh you're one of those edgemasters who liked how tactical and cool Kerry was, got it.
>>
>>114257708
There's no benefit to anyone of us being here. None of us are capable of being civil, or allowing other people to have their own opinions on matters. There's literally no profit to any of us being here.
>>
>>114257467
why do you come across as such a dickbag?
>>
>>114257762
Chapter 24 fucking when
>>
>>114256734
>I hear since Ataraxia goes with Heaven's Feel being the canon one
No it isn't.
>I really dislike all sorts of "Alternate dimensions" and "all timelines can be true at once" bullshit since it makes things extremely confusing.
It's so hard to accept that individual routes are simply parallel worlds to each other?
Maybe you should read this:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiverse
>>
>>114257771
noone thinks that the deen anime were better than zero faggot
>>
File: 1304654355572.png (219 KB, 548x526) Image search: [Google]
1304654355572.png
219 KB, 548x526
Hopefully Ufotable shows Saber as the eternally hungry creature she is and not try to pander it to be like F/Z in how the majority of the story was serious.
>>
>>114256624
I disagree with you
Seriously the left side looks better
>>
>>114257815
I do try to keep it short and snappy, while keeping it as inhospitable as possible. Thanks for noticing!
>>
>>114257750
It was sarcasm.

>>114257766
Yes, there were moments in which the characters talked about their plans, and some plans were excecuted and used in succession, I also liked the parts where the teams were figuring out what the other masters and servants were up to via deduction, shit was cool.

>>114257808
I liked Kerry, sure, but I loved the shit out of Kotomine, Waver&Iskandar, Gilles de Rais, shit, I can't really even decide. There wasn't a character that I "didn't especially like". Tokiomi could've used some more focus on his motives and character, and Iri wasn't all that special, although not a bad character by any means.
>>
>>114257824
This weekend or next week.
Double Emiya
Double Kanso+Byakuya
GET
E
T
HYPE
Y
P
E
>>
>>114257889
It will be fun
UBW is Saber's jobbibg route
>>
>>114257889
Saber is eternally hungry for cock.
>>
>>114257884
Well that much is obvious, I'm talking about the overall stories of Fate/Stay and Fate/Zero. The characters, the setting.
>>
Shirou is the blue man
>>
>>114256734
All the three routes in f/sn are canon, go ask the old man with jewels.
As for ataraxia, that shit already started when avenger tainted the grail( The great fire in F/Z, the black goop in fate, the shinji grail blob thingy in UBW and angra mainyu near birth in HF).
>>
File: Thank you based Zelretch.jpg (315 KB, 1000x750) Image search: [Google]
Thank you based Zelretch.jpg
315 KB, 1000x750
>People not understanding the multiverse made all the routes canon

It is explained in the cave in HF when Rin uses Zelretch.
>>
>>114257771

Jesus christ, get over yourself.
>>
>>114257994
Everything not Fate is Saber jobbing.
>>
>>114257248
>As for the "you done fucked up". Hell no, Fate/Zero was fucking magnificent


You watched/read Zero before experiencing HF.

As my colleague once said: YOU DONE FUCKED UP

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGp9P6QvMjY
>>
>>114258027
>Shirou hates Archer
>Lancer hates Archer

>Shirou has red hair
>Lancer is Irish

It
all
makes
sense
now
>>
>>114258047
No, I believe it is you, who needs to get over yourself. People have different opinions, and not everyone decides to slander other over their opinions.
>>
File: Saber (170).jpg (26 KB, 400x450) Image search: [Google]
Saber (170).jpg
26 KB, 400x450
>>114257994
They better not skip her going to school with Shirou.
>>
>>114257717
Prismafags will get what's coming when they see that Ilya is a psychopath and when she get's her heart ripped out. Zerofags however are worse as they are composed of insufferable fujoshit (Gilfags and Diarmuidfags) and dudebros (Iskandarfags). I eagarly await the RPing anime only Gilfags getting jobbed by Shirou and Sakura.
>>
File: BAIT OF BABYLON.jpg (72 KB, 625x626) Image search: [Google]
BAIT OF BABYLON.jpg
72 KB, 625x626
>>114257248
>>
>>114257306
The only route that contained so much edge was in Makina's, he was full white knight/ James bond with the other girls.
>>
>>114257889
>why is saber moe now? why isn't she a badass knight like in zero? urobuchi really fucked up her characterization
>>
File: 1410881387598.jpg (115 KB, 1440x810) Image search: [Google]
1410881387598.jpg
115 KB, 1440x810
>>114257762
Miyuverse Shirou is based as fuck.
>>
God, Zerofags are so obnoxious.

Everyone knows the Third was was the best one.

>Dual Sabers with Edelfelt twins as masters
>midget Assassin making people explode
>Nazis and the Japanese army fucking shit up
>Einzberns summoning "All the Evils of the World" for shits and giggles
>Tohsaka defeating and NTR'ing one of the Edelfelt sister away, stealing 90% of the magic in the process
>Zouken actually for once fighting
>>
>>114258147
>having sex with a weapon
I never got this. Man Shirou is a stupid fuck. Not to mention he completely tramples on Arturias wishes and dreams. A disrespectful piece of shit.
>>
>>114257655
You need to realize that this fanbase is 90% pure fucking cancer who just came for the porn and ended up becoming enthralled because there was more to it than that. Good luck. Threads are pretty much always pure shit.
>>
File: Doors that way.jpg (93 KB, 640x360) Image search: [Google]
Doors that way.jpg
93 KB, 640x360
>>114258092
Welcome to /a/, daily reminder that: My Taste > Shit > Your Taste.
Also if you don't want your opinion fucked up, dragged through the mud and proven the fuck wrong go to Gaia, MAL or Reddit, I hear they are filled with filthy secondaries like yourself.
>>
>>114258182
There's really content on the third war? You're not just trolling out now? Because I really want to have that.
>>
>>114258084
I cant imagine how it feels for secondaries that watched F/Z before playing F/SN.

The idea and going through the story feels awkward and weird.
>>
>>114257044
I think that's mainly because very few people have read the VN.
>>
>>114258203
Man I've had the urge to rewatch Carnival Phantasm for a good while now. Guess I should get to it.
>>
>>114258199
Yeah, I'm trying to skim through the shit to find the people who actually are interested in the entire concept of the war, and not having sex with girls and creatures.

>>114258203
>proven wrong
Heh heh.
>>
>>114258217
It's in Hollow ataraxia. Anymore statement I make will be regarded as a spoiler.
>>
>>114258217

Some of it is covered in HA, I think the rest of is from extra materials.
>>
>>114258112
>Deermundfags
I refuse to belief thy exist
>Dudebrofags
Lancer is, was and will be best servant
>>
>>114258182
By the way, how many masters from Third War we know?
Edelfelt sisters, Darnic, anyone other?
>>
>>114258278
>>114258291
Thanks, now I really have a reason to read HA after /Stay.
>>
>>114258317
Shirou Kotomine being ruler class
Risei Kotomine as well from what I've remembered.
>>
File: butthurt report form.jpg (217 KB, 576x720) Image search: [Google]
butthurt report form.jpg
217 KB, 576x720
>>114258092
>>
>>114258270

You called Shirou a "generic high schooler"

Not even that guy but: Yes, you were fucking proven wrong when we laughed at you and if you'd shut the fuck up about how great F/Z is and actually play the VN to completion you would know why.
>>
>>114258000
You mean my cock.
>>
File: 1402355074388.png (102 KB, 200x298) Image search: [Google]
1402355074388.png
102 KB, 200x298
>>114256378
Oh fuck DEEN's Shirou
>>
>>114258348
Let's see if I'm wrong on any points here
>Shirou is an anime character
>Shirou goes to highschool (before/after the war, we know he skips some days in between)
>Shirou has special powers

Anything wrong?
>>
File: 1233512872123.jpg (71 KB, 316x341) Image search: [Google]
1233512872123.jpg
71 KB, 316x341
>>114258332
>anons face when it's all slice of life
>>
File: Brain Bullet bitch.png (115 KB, 310x225) Image search: [Google]
Brain Bullet bitch.png
115 KB, 310x225
>>114258182
>>midget Assassin making people explode
That hassan's zabaniya made me chuckle, Brain bullet is literally the most creative way to assassinate someone.
>>
>>114258443
>Anything wrong?
It's a VN dumbass
>>
File: Trace man.jpg (20 KB, 206x220) Image search: [Google]
Trace man.jpg
20 KB, 206x220
>>114258388
What's wrong with DEEN?
>>
>>114258460
Well, truth be told, I really did fucking learn to hate Shirous kitchen, and I fully expect there to be more of it in Hollow Ataraxia, but I'm not a person who can't adapt to other genres.
>>
File: image.jpg (303 KB, 2048x1536) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
303 KB, 2048x1536
DEEn
>>
>>114258340
>Shirou Kotomine being ruler class
That just in Apocrypha's world. Nasu confirmed that Ruler class is exclusive class in Apocrypha and in original timeline under normal circumstances isn't present.
>>
>>114258443
>character goes to high school
>this makes him generic
A generic character wouldnt be the red man.
>>
>>114258332
Oh yeah, I forgot to mention that don't expect to much because although its plot is quite interesting, It's basically as this anon says>>114258460
>>
File: 1410806304636.png (451 KB, 545x759) Image search: [Google]
1410806304636.png
451 KB, 545x759
>>114258509
N-Nothing
>>
>>114258443
why the fuck are you even in this thread instead of reading UBW?
>>
>>114258443
You forgot
>orphaned twice
>survivor's guilt out the ass
>literally lacks the drive for selfishness
>has been mutilating and torturing himself daily for 8 years
>hangs out with Yakuza and fixes/tunes up their motorcycles for cash
>works in a liqueur store despite being underage
>>
>>114258486
Ah, okay, I'll fix that then.
>Shirou is a Visual Novel character
>Shirou goes to highschool (before/after the war, we know he skips some days in between)
>Shirou has special powers

Still, how is this not generic? He also has
1. A dark&edgy past
2. An edgy dark side he must not show anyone
3. Is able to ignore mortal wounds by merely "wanting to protect something", even after losing Avalon.
>>
I missed out on Zero while it was airing. Were all of the threads as absolutely awful as this one?
>>
How did king arthur know how to give blowjobs?
>>
>>114258443
>Let's see if I'm wrong on any points here
>>Shirou is an anime character

He's a VN character

>Shirou goes to highschool (before/after the war, we know he skips some days in between)

Are you saying that any character who goes/went to high school is automatically a "generic high school character"?

Are you fucking retarded

>Shirou has special powers

So having special powers makes you a generic high schooler no matter the nature and acquisition of said powers?


Yet, secondaries wonder why we shit on them, they are functionally retarded.
>>
File: 1362934367732.jpg (442 KB, 633x2000) Image search: [Google]
1362934367732.jpg
442 KB, 633x2000
>>114256355
is it bad that I like DEEN's Rin more than UFO's?

She just looks god awful in this remake
>>
>>114258582
>Shirou
>Underage
isn't he 18, or is the age in nipponland to not be a minor 21?
>>
File: oimg002.jpg (317 KB, 869x1273) Image search: [Google]
oimg002.jpg
317 KB, 869x1273
>>114258510
You should totally check out Shirou's cooking manga, where his parents never died.
>>
>>114258656
Everyone in F/SN is "18"
>>
>>114258631
The combination of the three makes them the generic highschool character, not that you "non-secondaries" could understand multiple things combining to form a big whole, that's way over your little head, don't worry, math starts slow for everyone, even you!
>>
>>114258040
>when Rin uses Zelretch.

But yeah, Rin was draining the Mana from infinite worlds.
>>
>>114258656
Realta Nua is canon and he's in high school.
>>
>>114258679
Shougeki no Soma is my guilty pleasure, I'd love to see Shirou go one on one with Souma in a Shougeki.
>>
>>114258262
>to rewatch Carnival Phantasm for a good while now. Guess I should get to it.
I'm waiting until I finish all other translated TM works.
>>
>>114258592
Are you seriously calling Shirou edgy?
>>
>>114258594

Nah, it's actually worse this time around. This is seriously worse than the Frodos ever were.
>>
>>114258443
Shirou is a retarded batman who actually managed to fuck his heroine for energy transfer. There, that ends the argument.
>>
>>114258679
I think he'd look better without Shirou's color scheme. Is it intentional?
>>
>>114258733
Well, obviously. He was in Highschool in the original as well.
>>
>>114258717
I'm being trolled aren't I.
>>
>>114258717
So if he doesn't have super powers, then he's not generic?

I don't get it.

Also, most high school students don't spend their entire evenings just fixing and cleaning up after other people because they were asked.
>>
>Getting real sick of your shit Archer
>>
>>114258766
Oh he isn't?
A-hemm:
I AM THE BONE OF MY SWORD-
or before turning into Archer
I MUST INJECT MYSELF WITH HUMAN PAIN AND SUFFERING DAILY!

So not edgy.
>>
File: 1399719171565.jpg (155 KB, 850x1304) Image search: [Google]
1399719171565.jpg
155 KB, 850x1304
>>114256355
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=61RuoLIlCUM
>hideyuki fukasawa
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxTeTu56Bgo&list=PLqiXJLRsaDFOsWagCahrmGQUc6WVBu1KQ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_g6dBNTysbg&list=PLeoUxW43hilHIUuqv96kkEfVOPckwS6JW
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIYSCRgzAtY&list=PLCSnfdeGCbIajU3rLf7Kg3Shl7cdo1fwT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=litqSUuMei8&list=PLAE1EFE0210BCA2BE
>>
File: objective-rating1.jpg (850 KB, 2560x2980) Image search: [Google]
objective-rating1.jpg
850 KB, 2560x2980
Here's the official rating of which shots are better.
>>
>>114258811
No Name > EMIYA.
>>
>>114258717

>You people who know the whole story and understand the nuances of a complicated characters are really the ones who are retarded and its us who judge him before his development that are enlightened!

Your next words will be: "I was only pretending to be retarded!"
>>
>>114258592
Wait, how is Shirou's past any more edgier than Kiritsugu's?
>>
>>114258811
>>
>>114256355
ufotable's Rin looks so shitty. It's like she's never shaded enough or properly or something.

It's weird, because evertyhing else looks better.
>>
>>114258778
10/10, I can agree to this. Also, you made me splurt all my drink all over my keyboard, comedy fucking gold.
>>
Stop responding to it. Its a troll playing the part of a dumb secondary or just a dumb secondary. Either way.
>>
File: 1293416893923.jpg (26 KB, 314x295) Image search: [Google]
1293416893923.jpg
26 KB, 314x295
>>114258825
>A-hemm:
What are you doing? This is a step away from *action* shit. Stop it.
>>
File: objective-rating2.jpg (464 KB, 1575x2277) Image search: [Google]
objective-rating2.jpg
464 KB, 1575x2277
>>114258839
#2
>>
>>114258856
Well, duh. Getting elevated into a real heroic spirit kind of does do that.

Though the loss of his EoTM is serious bullshit.
>>
>>114258941
>go fuck a whore
>im trying to
>>
>>114258860
Complicated does not equal good, you doofus. A character is a good character or not is up to your personal opinion, you know, the thing that makes you like shit? You like something 'cause you just feel like you like it. Then again, maybe you like a character if it's complex, that's good for you. I like a character if he's a good fucking character. Needs a bit more than complexity.

In before "he doesn't like complex characters! In which case, read my post again.
>>
>>114258877
This is probably the best promo I've seen in a while
>>
File: screenshot2ly9.png (687 KB, 795x594) Image search: [Google]
screenshot2ly9.png
687 KB, 795x594
>>114258766
Well, technically...
>>
>>114258856
Archer with E luck >> Archer with D luck
>>
>>114258626
When heroic spirits are summoned they receive basic information about the age they're summoned in. Blowjobs are obviously a crucial aspect of today's society, so it's obvious Saber-chan would know how to perform royal bjs
>>
Won't be long till Ufotable runs out of money, at which point the anime will be full of QUALITY

The quality in F/Z really dropped off after a couple episodes
>>
>>114258933

DEEN's necklace looks terrible, how can you rank it better? You can't even make out the cross and the bright glare but dim crystal looks hideous. It's supposed to be magic and seem like it's glowing of its own accord, like the ufotable one accomplishes.
>>
>>114258866
It's less edgy
>>
>>114258960
Well when you can Trace Excalibur without burning your circuits out that throws bullshit out the window.
>>
>>114258866
Did I ever deny that Kiritsugu was an edgemaster as well?

>>114258907
Irrelevant, he's edgy. Just as edgy as Kiritsugu, if not more.
>>
>>114259030
Reminder that Shirou is both dense and surprisingly sharp, almost like a sword.
>>
>>114259017

It seems that in addition to be functionally retarded you are illiterate. You aregued that Shirou was a "generic high schooler" and we informed you that he was a complex character. This has absolutely nothing to do with quality and everything to do with you assuming shit and being dead wrong.
>>
The quality of the threads lately has made me wish this wasn't getting another anime.
>>
>>114257808
It still bothers me how zerokids believe that Kiritsugu is such a cool adult man when in fact he is a manchild and Urobuchi shits on him more than on Saber.
>>
>>114259047

>Ufotable
>runs out of money

Wasn't Fate/Zero one of the most successful animes of all time?
>>
>>114258839
>Equal
Fuck no. DEEN/Takeuchi's old Rin models were MUCH better.

>BEtter
I'd actually say equal. If ufotable wins, it's barely.

>Better
Agreed. but Saber's face looks a bit derp.

>Better
Agreed again. ufotable's rendition isn't as faithful to the VN and is full of shitty CG again.
>>
>People defending DEEN
It's sad how much /a/ has fallen
>>
>>114259103
>animes
>>
File: 41299010.jpg (621 KB, 1280x748) Image search: [Google]
41299010.jpg
621 KB, 1280x748
>>114257594
>Ride through the storm, see the knights fighting evil and crime
>A modern day team of heroes in medieval times
>Arthur and the Knights of Justice, putting evil down
>Ride through the storm with the knights of the table ’round >Come on, come on
>King Arthur ride
>>
File: 1410613880957.png (138 KB, 375x375) Image search: [Google]
1410613880957.png
138 KB, 375x375
>>114259103
>most successful
>not Gundam
Try harder if your span of anime only lasts 5 years.
>>
>all these F/Z fags
>all these F/Z fags trying to defend being a secondary

How do these retards rationalize this shit

>>114259143
>Not liking simoun
>>
>>114259072
>Irrelevant, he's edgy. Just as edgy as Kiritsugu, if not more.
I have no reaction face appropriate for this.

>>114259062
That's got nothing to do with Archer though, just Se.Ra.Ph. being hospitable.
>>
>>114259049
That shot of the necklace is when the prana was drained reviving Shirou, which explains why it's dull. ufotable fucked up.

>>114259103
>Animes
Out.
>>
>>114258626
>Living in the castle while hiding her gender was an endless string of stressful situations. The matter of producing an heir was particularly troublesome, but it seems that she managed to get by without any problems thanks to Merlin's sorcery. In the story, when she said that "she knows how to please a man", she was speaking from actual experience.
>>
>>114259143
Deen gave us the dildo on a string. I cant stay mad at them.
>>
>>114259049
>It's supposed to be magic and seem like it's glowing of its own accord
I don't remember exactly, was this shot before or after Rin used it up? Because if it's the latter I can see why DEEN might have chosen to do it that way.
>>
>>114259167

>"one of"
>>
>>114258199
I only picked it up for the memes.
>>
>>114259017
> Being a good character makes a character a good character.
What the one you're replying to is trying to say is that you don't know much about Shirou's character as you've only read the first route.
>>
>>114259058
I'm going to need more than that.

Not being able to work past a fire seems less edgy to me than a zombie apocalypse (caused by your dad) that leads to you being trained by a literal assassin. Beyond that, the two are pretty much the same character, that have different ideas about what it means to save people.
>>
>>114259143
DEEN has made a lot of good shows. I'm more inclined to think that the people who say they are bottom barrel are underaged who have shit taste in anime.
>>
>>114259103
>animes
>most successful
How new
>>
>>114259171
I keep forgetting that the SE.RA.PH allows you to summon fucking gods as servants. Especially when the last boss of Extra was motherfucking Buddah.
>>
>>114259175
>>114259194

It still has a very small amount of energy in it and that fact is CRITICALLY important in Heaven's Feel.
The completely drained gemstone belongs to Archer.
>>
>I like star wars
>I watched episodes 1-3 first
>you should watch it like this, episodes 4-6 spoil stuff about anakin's future
>Why are episodes 1-3 so much better?

People will always be retarded
>>
>>114259072
>Did I ever deny that Kiritsugu was an edgemaster as well?
>Following an ideology is edgy
>>>/v/
>>
>>114259249
>It still has a very small amount of energy
Which is why you can't see a glow. ufotable on the other hand, shows it as fully glowing which is just plain wrong.
>>
File: 1375774690018.jpg (10 KB, 147x143) Image search: [Google]
1375774690018.jpg
10 KB, 147x143
Is there even any reason to watch this if I've already read it? This thread is proof enough that all sequential threads will be shit with F/Z babbies
>>
>>114259228
Their VN adaptations are dog shit.
>>
File: 0000_EVENT_C23_FACE_1_1hip.png (28 KB, 152x100) Image search: [Google]
0000_EVENT_C23_FACE_1_1hip.png
28 KB, 152x100
>>114259284
>shiro is THE edgemaster
>>
>>114259234
Every "God" you see in CCC are basically just deities anyways. The real God would fuck everyone's shit up if it cared.
>>
>Tokiomi with EMIYA
>Fast Wheels with Cu Chulainn
>Waver with Medusa
>Ryunosuke with Medea
>Kotomine with TA
>Kariya with Hercules
>Kerry with Nero
How would this war play out?
>>
>>114259114
In these sheets I rated the complete scenes including the design, lighting and composition.
The design of Rin might be better from DEEN, but the whole scene looks better on the right. Even if the scenes are unrelated.
The scene where Saber first appears is better from Ufotable because it reads better. DEEN fucked it up with too much lens flare and blurry shit.

>>114259049
The necklace is rated better because it's placed more dynamically into the scene. It has a more dynamic perspective going on while Ufotable just has a straight look onto it.
>>
>>114259362
But I never said that you retard
>>
>>114259350
Name me 3 good VN adaptions.
Seriously.
>>
>>114259335
same reason why people watch movie adaptations of their favorite books/comics; to get pissed off, bitch, be hipster, and lord it over secondaries/casuals/normals
>>
>>114259276
that never happens though.
>>
File: 17-P03-145.jpg (48 KB, 800x600) Image search: [Google]
17-P03-145.jpg
48 KB, 800x600
>>114259300

There's nothing in the VN that indicates it stops glowing, ever. It's always the same bright CG.
What it does do is become lighter.
>>
>>114259423
>hipster
Go back to reddit
>>
>>114259411
>The design of Rin might be better from DEEN, but the whole scene looks better on the right. Even if the scenes are unrelated.
I suppose that's because of the difference in budgeting.

>The necklace is rated better because it's placed more dynamically into the scene. It has a more dynamic perspective going on while Ufotable just has a straight look onto it.
Agreed.
>>
>>114259335
Just watch it and avoid the threads. Maybe come every once in a while to reminder yourself how bad secondaries are. That's what i'm planning on doing anyway.
>>
>>114256355

why is saber a fucking giant in the DEEN one. She could fucking cradle him in her arms
>>
>>114259335

Yes, hopefully. The fighting animations of Fate/Zero were excellent, and I pray they do Stay Night just as well or better.
>>
>>114259436
Then I like DEEN's interpretation of the scene more. An adaption doesn't, and shouldn't, be 1:1.
>>
>>114259414
Steins;Gate
White Album 2
Higurashi
>>
>>114259371
>every god is a deity
no shit sherlock
>>
>>114259097
It's going to be hell with all the F/Z babbies, newfags and shitposting reverse trolls here. Same goes to Terra Formars and Parasyte this Fall.
>>
>>114259411
>>114259462

The "dynamic perspective" is idiotic when it's covered by a hideous glare and doesn't stand out very well. The ufotable one catches the eye properly having the jewel be highlighted, and again, you can make out the actual details of the pendant instead of SHINY METAL GLARE.
>>
>>114259414
Clannad
ef
Steins;Gate
>>
Is there any Fate Anime where the characters have the same Seiyuu as in the VN?
Will the new series have them? I love all the voice actors from the VN. Beside Sakura who always sounds like she's trying too hard to sound weak.
>>
>>114259533
>Higurashi

Shittiest and most abysmal taste ever detected.
>>
I wonder how varied the other new character scenes are going to be. There's no way it'd be like Zero without having been written that way in the first place, but hopefully they give us different perspectives from the first episode instead of treating us as clueless as Shirou seeing as that isn't really necessary with probably 85% of the viewers coming in from Zero in the first place.
>>
>>114259560
Heh even, Grisaia threads aren't even safe from the animeonlyfags.
>>
>>114259533
>S;G
>Good

>WA2
>Finished

>Deengurashi
>Good

>>114259588
>Clannad
Only AS, which was linear. S1 was pretty forgettable if not outright shit.

>Ef
Admittedly didn't watch.

>S;G
Once again, not nearly as good as the VN.

>>114259581
I don't see what's bad about the glare. I can see the cross and details just fine. Are you blind?
>>
>>114259623

Literally every single one. As far as I can tell they have never used alternate voice actors in anything, from games to drama cds.
And Sakura's seiyuu said she wasn't fully into the role at the time, she got better by Fate/Extra CCC.
>>
>>114259648
Well Grisaia was shit to begin with so I fail to see the problem
>>
>>114259432
But secondaries sound just that retarded
>>
>>114259560
i'm surprised F/Z FS/N hasn't been chosen for Toonami yet.
>>
>>114259581
The unimportant part which is the chain is blurred out and the viewer has more view in the important part, the gem. So you're wrong.
>>
File: 1409535328057.jpg (79 KB, 600x397) Image search: [Google]
1409535328057.jpg
79 KB, 600x397
So, who else is gonna stop coming to these threads entirely once it starts airing?
>>
>>114259623
Yes, every anime adaption ever that had VAs will have the same VAs.
>>
>>114259669
>I don't see what's bad about the glare. I can see the cross and details just fine. Are you blind?

I can only make out the cross if I lean forward and deeply inspect the still image. I'd never be able to tell at a glance.
>>
>>114259623
the seiyuu chosen for the DEEN anime reprised the VN roles after re-releases.
>>
>>114259643
I hope they spoil the shit out of the entire thing in the first ten minutes. Even better if they throw a few in the OP.
>>
>>114259683
Somebody never read the sequels.
>>
>>114259669
>>S;G
>>Good
But it was
>>
>>114259699
I barely come to these threads as it is. For some reason I just decided to jump into this one on a whim.
>>
>>114259698

Except the gleam on the metal setting of the gemstone is what I'm talking about, not the chain.

The ufotable one meanwhile has none of these issues. It is unquestionably the more fitting image.
>>
>>114259706
But Kirei and Ilya sound kinda different in DEENs movie. Also in Carnival Phantasm I don't remember anyone sounding like in the VN.
>>
>>114259669
>Once again, not nearly as good as the VN.
like most adaptations
>>
>>114259722
>I can only make out the cross if I lean forward and deeply inspect the still image
I don't even know what to say to that.

>>114259752
Not as good as the VN. If you watched the anime first (just like F/SN), you might feel otherwise. I felt it was pretty lacking. Only SN or linear VNs make for good adaptions.
>>
>>114259795

>Kirei and Ilya sound kinda different in DEENs movie

That's because the DEEN movie had shitty directing.

>Also in Carnival Phantasm I don't remember anyone sounding like in the VN

Nobody was trying to sound like themselves in Carnival Phantasm. It's lighthearted comedy.

Definitely all the same actors though.
>>
File: 1381463084751.jpg (51 KB, 625x552) Image search: [Google]
1381463084751.jpg
51 KB, 625x552
what's the difference between original f/sn and realta nua?
>>
>>114259876
1. replaced sex scenes with non-ero
2. extra CGs and music
3. extra ending scene
4. slightly cleaned up dialogue
>>
>>114259820
Well of course it's not as good as the VN
>>
>>114259876
New scenes, better CGs and sound effects, new music, and some extra scenes.
>>
>>114259775
Ufotable's just looks boring. It looks so boring I can't even look at it 3 second without getting anxious. The left one on the other hand is nice and intriguing, you really want to grab into the screen and get that nicely placed gem. I don't get you. Do you like boring things so much?
>>
>>114259876
Some changed lines, removed sex scenes, added some stuff like making the UBW date longer and now special effects.
>>
>>114259876
New scenes which didn't make sense, plotholes, better CGs, more sound effects, remixed+new music and a extra ending(Last Episode)
>>
>>114259953

I am baffled by you in turn, because the DEEN one is just laying there while the ufotable one is face-on with the camera and looks mysterious and eye-catching.
The DEEN one looks literally like jewelry and not the magic artefact that it is.
>>
>>114259699
Just go to the one on the other chan.
>>
>>114256355
>comparing Shirou's world with Archer's world
>>
>>114259876
>>114259923
>>114259944
>>114259978
>>114259982
Also new really good OPs.
>>
File: 1410871621074.jpg (254 KB, 800x837) Image search: [Google]
1410871621074.jpg
254 KB, 800x837
Finished the Novel today, was epic. I dont regret watching fate zero first at all, it was cool to peace together those little spoilers from it, is it wrong that i wanna see sparks liner high animated (ufo should give us ovas of all bad ends). My thirst for more Fsn continues though, should i watch the ubw movie and the anime or nah.
>>
>>114260000
Nah I agree with him, the DEEN one is positioned much better. Dynamic angles are a fundamental of art, and ufotable's looks flat. You can see it in their Rin design as well - she looks flat and bland.
>>
>>114260089
>Realta Nua
>Better Openings
Pick one, also I am not refering to the Vita version.
>>
>>114260124

I don't give a fuck about your "dynamic angles" if the actual item the scene is depicting looks like ass.
>>
>>114260102
As cancerous as your post is, you're not wrong to want to see Sparks Liner High animated no.
>>
>>114260102
no
>>
>>114259923
5. a ruined heaven's feel
>>
>>114260000
>mysterious and eye-catching
No, the plain orthographic view makes it look like some image out of a (fake) jewelery pamphlet which you find in your mailbox and throw it away instantly by just seeing how bad it's layouted. You don't feel the action. Besides that, the jewel is out of energy anyways, so that over saturated red glow makes you think it's so full of energy that it's already annoying.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 87

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.