[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Home]
4chanarchives logo
Is this what passes for a good MC these days? An emotionless
Images are sometimes not shown due to bandwidth/network limitations. Refreshing the page usually helps.

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 79
Is this what passes for a good MC these days? An emotionless drone who happens to be able to figure everything out while others wallow in their own stupidity?
>>
File: 1405367744537.jpg (46 KB, 509x501) Image search: [Google]
1405367744537.jpg
46 KB, 509x501
I'm watching it for Ruuko.
>>
>>111177821
>who happens to be able to figure everything out
You make it sound like his autism doesn't have anything to do with the ridiculous shit he pulls.
>>
>>111177821
>An emotionless drone
Being neutral is inherently better than being an insufferable crybaby.
>who happens to be able to figure everything out
Every MC does that. That's like a requirement for being a MC, you have to be useful and relevant. Why focus on you if you didn't do anything special like kicking the bad guy's ass when everyone else fails at it?
>>
Better than shitty emofags like Haruto
>>
>>111177821
And also while the main girl which is also a princess thinks he is so dreamy.
>>
File: 1405952366186.jpg (549 KB, 1200x1350) Image search: [Google]
1405952366186.jpg
549 KB, 1200x1350
>>111177821

Yes.
>>
It took me a few episodes to warm up to him but now I like his autism.
>>
Nigga Hyouka was bretty good
>>
It's a nice change from the complete opposite. But anyway it's obvious he does have emotions, but with the way his mind works and how his personality is I guess they're kept to himself or else displayed lightly. Apparently this is what /a/ calls autism so lets just go with that. I like my autistic MC.
>>
>>111178514
>Apparently this is what /a/ calls autism so lets just go with that
Nope. Autism here means a fag who's unreasonably fixated on having things his own way. Inaho on the other hand does seem genuinely autistic.
>>
>>111178514
You do know actual autists also have emotions?
>>
>>111178895
>Autism here means a fag who's unreasonably fixated on having things his own way

No, uh, autism means autism.
>>
>>111179237
Are you new to these parts or are you just trying to bump your own thread?
>>
File: 1405476694096.jpg (40 KB, 388x306) Image search: [Google]
1405476694096.jpg
40 KB, 388x306
Inaho and his classmates were raised fight this war from the day they were born. He's just a calm, efficient, spacenoid removing machine, doing one of the two things he's knows how to do, the other being cook eggs.
>>
File: 1406398858246.webm (251 KB, 960x540) Image search: [Google]
1406398858246.webm
251 KB, 960x540
>>111179505
>she wants breakfast
>>
>>111179505
They had one additional class that taught them how to robot. That's like saying a high school student would know how to build a rocket because they took physics.
>>
dat fucking music tho
>>
>>111177821
he's just your average gary stu mecha MC
>>
>>111179461

Do you want to be called an autist?
>>
>>111177865
What
>>
It'll likely be explained in future episodes, trauma or some shit.

Also it's a refreshing change of pace from most whiny protags that we get.
>>
>>111179953
>Also it's a refreshing change of pace from most whiny protags that we get.
I've been reading this way too much these times. It's been people start realizing it's not a new thing anymore and stop using this shitty argument.
>>
>>111177821
What's wrong? 2kuu4u?
>>
>>111179953
>whiny protags
Nigger whiny protags arent in every anime now.
>>
>>111177821
Good? No, but he is something different than what we usually get.
People are tired of whiny faggots, lecturing moralfags, and those who keep screaming about "tomodachi" as if his enemies would care.
This MC is different thus refreshing.
>>
>>111179721
More than just mech piloting, they've had training on general preparedness to fight the Martians. It's why Inko could be entrusted with the civilian evacuation and Nina is allowed to pilot the ship. It's why they're so calm under fire and the adults don't bat an eye when they jump into action. They're not just a bunch of random kids playing hero, this is what they have been raised to do and it's all they've ever know. Remove Martian. Remove Martian.
>>
>>111180000
>refreshing = new
You need to read more books anon.
>>
>>111180000
Competent protags are rare in anime. Writers don't know how to do any sort of character growth aside from "protag struggles to tie his shoes grows into ace pilot." They're probably too afraid people wouldn't be able to self-insert if the MC wasn't worthless at first.
>>
>>111180291
Yeah, you're right, I chose my words badly, I didn't mean new. It's not a rare thing anymore. I've seen more shows with ballsy and determined MCs than pussies recently, and I'm obviously only talking about seasonal shows.
>>
File: BestMC.png (816 KB, 656x1128) Image search: [Google]
BestMC.png
816 KB, 656x1128
Maybe try another series.
>>
>>111180375
>Competent protags are rare in anime
not really
>>
>>111180265
yeah they are more calm than the actual Soldiers, great writing right there
>>
Unfortunately.

God willing it will be a short lived fad.
>>
>>111182616
From what I remember, most of the soldiers were fairly calm until they were met with imminent death.

I'm sure there will be a scene where one of the kids breaks down and starts sweating profusely while their eyes shake about. Don't worry anon.
>>
>>111182485
Akashi is such a charmer
>>
>>111182760
IMMA STAND HERE AND HOLD DOWN THE TRIGGER EVEN THOUGH IT DOES NOTHING doesn't seem like the decision making of a calm individual unless they are literally retarded.
>>
>>111182485
how misogynistic is this show?
>>
>>111182616
But they are actual soldiers. That's what I keep saying. They're an entire generation that knows only the Martian threat and have been brought up to remove it. The only person we've seen so far with any real experience fighting the Martians in Marito.

The other soldiers are dead because they got thrown to the wolves against unknown enemies. Inaho had an entire day to hatch a plan for use against bowlcut, and lightsaber wasn't already on top of him before he could blink.
>>
>>111177973
Can you also explain why the Terran mechs just stood in place and got slaughtered until MC's heroics bailed everyone.
>>
>>111183186
>But they are actual soldiers.
no they fucking aren't. In the first episode sensei made it clear that they didn't take the whole thing seriously at all.
>>
>>111183412
Marito said they treat it like a game, but I have to interpret that as being because it's so natural for them, not that they don't take it seriously. It's second nature. It's normal. It's what they've been brought up doing. It's just how things are in the world that they live in. Their society has been heavily geared toward their next war, and they are the product of that.
>>
>watching Aldnoah Zero for shit MC
>>
>>111177821
Considering the alternatives are either Gary Stu who is god incarnate or someone who's too dumb to tie his own shoes, yes he's still better than average.
>>
call me when MC beats someone competent, he would have been fucked if sword guy decided to charge instead of just sitting there deflecting shit
>>
>>111184344
Yes, those are the only types of characters possible.
>>
>>111182485
Picked up ;)
>>
>give weak MC
>whine
>give strong MC
>whine
Oh thou
>>
>>111185124
You can't satisfy everyone. /a/ is full of a lot of people. The sooner you accept the fact that everyone has shit taste except you, the better.
>>
I want to play with nee-san's nee-sans.
>>
>>111177821
Fresh/different does not equal good. Not saying I am not entertained by him, though.
>>
>>111185124
Classic /m/ retardation.
>>
File: [NTR INTENSIFIES].jpg (147 KB, 640x1440) Image search: [Google]
[NTR INTENSIFIES].jpg
147 KB, 640x1440
NTR! NTR! NTR!
>>
>>111177821
Do you prefer a bitch like Shinji?
>>
>>111185612
your retarded
>>
THAT'S NOT EVEN WHAT THE LEIDENFROST EFFECT IS, YOU EGGSTISTIC FUCKER
>>
Much better than that faggot from Tokyo ghoul.
>>
File: 14071420061212.jpg (781 KB, 2560x2160) Image search: [Google]
14071420061212.jpg
781 KB, 2560x2160
I can't help but love Inaho. Yes, I find him to be a great protagonist so far.
He has a combination of being amusing while also being interesting, that I dare say I enjoy.
>>
>>111186001
Man has his priorities straight. Eggs > Martians
>>
File: 1406379195061.jpg (56 KB, 720x400) Image search: [Google]
1406379195061.jpg
56 KB, 720x400
>>111177821
As it turns out, I like Inaho for pretty much the same reasons I like Kuudere type girls. His calm demeanour in any type of situation is right down my alley. It's as though they just genderflipped a Kuudere FeMC without losing any of the charm. It's interesting for me to realize that I apparently like similar qualities in both men and women. If he was girl, he could've been a waifu contender, in fact.
>>
>>111186150
He made his sister the the rolled omelette she desired.
>>
>>111186161
That's dandere, not kuudere.
>>
>>111185716
Slaine, please.
>>
>>111177821
So, it's better than Gundam.
>>
File: yuki_kaizuka_60804.jpg (96 KB, 300x470) Image search: [Google]
yuki_kaizuka_60804.jpg
96 KB, 300x470
>>111177821
As expected of Oni-chan.
>>
>>111186394
The part where the MC has to rely on tactics and teamwork is also a nice change of pace. When is the last Gundam series that does this, the 08th MS Team?
>>
File: OP.jpg (9 KB, 259x194) Image search: [Google]
OP.jpg
9 KB, 259x194
>>111186394
Which one?
>>
>>111186489
00
>>
>>111186483
But he's an otouto.
>>
>>111186489
I don't like how to show off MC's baseline tactical ability everyone else is pantsu on head retarded.
>>
>>111186577
B-But Slain is also planning something.
>>
File: 1393564184914.jpg (23 KB, 438x500) Image search: [Google]
1393564184914.jpg
23 KB, 438x500
>>111186518
Which also had a superior emotionless character
>>
File: Amuro_swanson.jpg (63 KB, 640x352) Image search: [Google]
Amuro_swanson.jpg
63 KB, 640x352
>>111186510
>Amuro
From fag to the most interesting man alive.
>Kamille
From psychopath to decent guy to vegetable
>>
>>111186577
While it perhaps doesn't excuse the extent of how most of the military has been shown to act.
Just to be fair, the backstory to the show is that Earth covered up the events from 15 years ago, while lying to everyone making them think that they are prepared and have a chance even though nothing could be further from the truth.

So aside from the towers they dropped, most people on Earth don't even believe Marito when he speaks of the super mechs the Martians have.
>>
>>111177821

It's better than having a beta male lead. Seriously, fuck Gundam, Valvrave and Guilty Crown for ruining that for me. Accel World, too.

Some leads just shit up the screen every time they're on it. I'll take a thousand Inahos/Kiritos/Tatsuyas any day, no joke.
>>
>>111185550
This also applies to /a/ from /m/
>>
>>111183325
They were surprised or scared?
>>
>>111186774
You have to admit though that at the end of Accel World Haru was alpha when he stood up to his bully and utterly defeated him without mercy or trying to make him his friend.
>>
>>111186842
That part I liked
>>
>>111186842

Yeah, I like the fact that he simply shivved his ass. It was kind of anticlimatic that they had to wait for Black Lotus to turn up and save them...

AGAIN.
>>
>>111186774
>Gundam
What was the last one too have this, even if they start off beta they always man up midway through
>>
>>111186890

AGE's third protagonist, Kio, is possibly the worst shitstain on the series.

Banagher isn't quite as bad, but he gradually loses more and more brain cells after Episode 3. Episode 4 has him crying a lot over a brown terrorist girl.

I mean, he defeats the final villain by chest-massaging him to death. I miss the old days when the final battle was just a knock-down, drag-out fight.
>>
File: 1406341586643.jpg (93 KB, 822x759) Image search: [Google]
1406341586643.jpg
93 KB, 822x759
>>111186946
Reco-G will have a coked out protagonist.
>>
>>111186161
I'm pretty sure that all the people hating Inaho are Asukafags.
>>
>>111186998

I don't really have high hopes for that one, to be honest. It seems a bit too wacky for me.

I like mecha shows which focus on the 'war' aspect of things. Japan usually doesn't really do war stories, so to speak, but it's what I enjoy.
>>
>>111186998
Apparently the first episode will have him defeating and capturing the main Gundam using a maintenance mech
>>
>>111187121

Actually, the first episode has him defecting to the side he's technically been fighting against.

Why?

Because the female pilot of the Gundam (Who's a space pirate) is fucking hot, that's why.
>>
File: 1406340349805.jpg (50 KB, 620x806) Image search: [Google]
1406340349805.jpg
50 KB, 620x806
>>111187121
Probably more dumb luck than anything.

Besides, the only reason I'll be watching is for the onesan love. Also the cannibalism.
>>
>>111187217
He's supposes to be an ace pilot.

>A cadet in the Capital Guard Academy, created to advance the protection of the Capital Tower. His prodigious talents carry him upward in the ranks quickly, earning a double promotion.
>>
>>111187251
My guess is that he'll start fumbling as soon as he gets in the Gundam though.
Otherwise how will they make us root for him?
>>
>>111187344
Who knows we still don't have info on the enemy faction.
>>
>>111186577
Is this your first mecha anime, son?
>>
>>111177821
do you want another 'MC that suddenly find himself in giant robot that has super OP power and defeat veteran enemy in one episode?'
>>
>>111187667
>Nani, he cant possibly do that he just started piloting.
>>
Is the animation really bad on the mechs or is that just me?
>>
>>111187667
What you have to realize is that people bitch and moan about literally everything. /a/ is infested with a cancer so deep it will be in a permanent state of death.
>>
>>111187787
it's A-1 first mecha so don't be surprise
>>
>>111187821
>otaku
>permanent state of death.

aaand?
>>
>>111187851
It's just annoying because everything else looks great but then you have this awkward as fuck mech that looks like bad cg running down the street it ruins it.
>>
>>111187913
yeah I give you that but it could be worse ignore that fact and you got a solid stand alone mecha anime I would have really dropped if they literally gave MC or Slain a MAH SUPER OP Mecha by episode 3 or 4 hopefully they don't do this and I still wonder why Gen or Aoki didn't went with production I.G instead
>>
>>111186191
Such a great brother.
>>
>>111188456
Cause Aniplex funded it and they own A-1
>>
>>111185124
>give shitty MC
>whine
>give good MC
>don't whine
More like that.
>>
File: lelouchchest.jpg (56 KB, 603x640) Image search: [Google]
lelouchchest.jpg
56 KB, 603x640
>>111177821

someone that's likeable.
>>
I guess they should have just given MC a super-allpowerfull mech which can move at the speed of light (of course hes the only one capable of piloting it and removing the martian threat) to make him a good protagonist.
>>
>>111186998
This will flop harder than A/Z. Fucking guaranteed.
>>
>>111177821
>>An emotionless drone
Just because he didn't express it doesn't mean that he is emotionless.
>>
>>111189482
But he should also have strong pacifistic convictions and be visibly tormented whenever he's sent out to kill (which he then ironically proceeds to do better and more efficient than any other person alive)
>>
File: KingGainer.jpg (128 KB, 1024x768) Image search: [Google]
KingGainer.jpg
128 KB, 1024x768
>>111186998
Reco-G will be shit.
>>
>>111177821
Yeah, this is the trend. They should keep this shit as a side character and have more charismatic leads for a change.
>>
File: 1405878961391.jpg (67 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
1405878961391.jpg
67 KB, 640x480
>>111191244
>Inaho
>charismatic
>>
>>111180375
>Competent protags are rare in anime.
No.
>>
>>111187667
How about a solider who isn't a junior high schooler and trained for years. There's a guy like that in Aldnoah itself, but the only one who can get shit done is a child. It's ridiculous.
>>
File: noep.jpg (38 KB, 640x480) Image search: [Google]
noep.jpg
38 KB, 640x480
>>111177821
>An emotionless drone
I bet you thought Rei was an emotionless drone too, you stupid faggot.
>>
>>111191276
>reading comprehension
I said they should keep Inaho-types as side characters and give more charismatic leads, anon.
>>
File: 1353522002613.jpg (80 KB, 597x781) Image search: [Google]
1353522002613.jpg
80 KB, 597x781
>>111191439
>being buttmad about high schoolers saving the day in anime
>>
File: best scene in the anime so far.jpg (377 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
best scene in the anime so far.jpg
377 KB, 1920x1080
>>111187667
No. I want scrambled eggs.
>>
>>111191633
Well if you want to argue Inaho is somehow acceptable and fresh because he's a robotic child who is smarter and more resourceful than every adult involved then yeah.
>>
Yeah I hate the MC too.
>>
File: 14071220183087.jpg (485 KB, 1280x2880) Image search: [Google]
14071220183087.jpg
485 KB, 1280x2880
>>111191884
>smarter and more resourceful than every adult involved then yeah.
He has his strengths over most of the cast for sure. But at the same time he falls completely flat in other areas where others have him beat anyday.

Such is the life of our autistic hero.
>>
>>111191722
>a tomato on top of scrambled eggs
>>
>>111192883
Couldn't it be a radish?
But even if it's a tomato, it would be one of those cherry tomatoes. They taste very differently from regular tomatoes.

But regular tomato works perfectly fine with eggs.
>>
This MC is worse than Kirito.
>>
I kinda like him, I prefer this to than some beta fucking faggot.
>>
He isn't emotionless. You'll see, one of those dirty martians will stomp on his newly cooked omelets and then the rage that will come from him will surpass even the gutts watching caska getting raped scene.
>>
File: 1397005492759.jpg (207 KB, 600x900) Image search: [Google]
1397005492759.jpg
207 KB, 600x900
>>111177821
You gotta understand that he's basically Lelouch. He's a military genius and won't easily lose his cool. He's like the Napoleon or Alexander of Aldnoah.Zero
>>
>>111185612
SLAINE BTFO
>>
>>111193244
That wouldn't be so bad but Inaho also has genius-tier mech skills. At least Lelouch acted more like a general and rarely ever got into combat because he knew he sucked at it.

You can either be good at strategy or good at combat. If you get both people will call you gary.
>>
I'm only watching this to see Slaine cry when Princess fucks Inaho
>>
>>111193410

You'll be disappointed.
>>
>>111177821
So.. you would rather have what? An idiot airhead shounen character who wins through deus ex machina, power of friendship and love, and spends every minute crying and emoing.
>>
>>111193461
Oh really? This isn't an adaptation so you have no idea.
>>
wud u a princess servant loli?
>>
>>111177821
Sadly, some people just don't understand the brilliance of Inaho.
>>
>>111193410
>implying that goddess will settle for robotic Terran dick when Slaine is on the way
P-please
>>
>>111193663
What Inaho has done so far in the anime is enough to make most girls wet. What has Slaine done? Get his ass kicked like three times and murder a man in cold blood. Bravo Slaine.
>>
>>111193516

Opening lyrics kill her off. So do the ending lyrics.

She's become token motivational girl. She'll die before the first half, leading to Slaine and MC to team up.
>>
>>111193244
Lelouch had a personality.
>>
>>111186644
Setsuna at least has a dark past that lead him to being emotionless, this fag is only a bad written character.
>>
>>111193718
>muh flags
fuck off

has there been confirmation? no? so this is all personal speculation? cool story bro
>>
File: glance.jpg (80 KB, 525x800) Image search: [Google]
glance.jpg
80 KB, 525x800
>>111193697

Yet, she shows zero interest in him. Even the character designer knows.
>>
>>111193763
But she already has. She already has.
>>
>>111193787

Nice fanfic. Please post official art featuring them.
>>
>>111193718
>grasping at fucking lyrics
Never seen shit this pathetic in a while.
>>
>>111193815
>>111193748
>being this mad about token boring princess being killed off to prompt character development when there are better girls in the show
>>
>>111193763
>chara designer draws derpy art simply of headshots
>prying meaning out of this
Seriously.
>>
inaho > slaine
>>
File: Vs_003-2.jpg (240 KB, 840x1140) Image search: [Google]
Vs_003-2.jpg
240 KB, 840x1140
>the princess bedchambers has the Earth view too

Oh. So why did she have to bother Slaine so late at night and lost the track of time with a view she can enjoy in her room?
>>
>>111193851
I don't care about that, I'm not so attached to them. But you are seriously stretching to say you know sit about where the story will go from a fucking lyric. How do you expect anyone to take you seriously? This is some tumblr level reasoning.
>>
File: 54574554.jpg (99 KB, 1266x1437) Image search: [Google]
54574554.jpg
99 KB, 1266x1437
>>111193881
Enjoy your birdending
>>
>>111193941

The song features Slaine and Inaho teaming up against a castle. The princess will die. If you even watch Gen shows, you know her type ALWAYS DIES and is always to bring manpain.

If you look for romance, Rayet and Inko are more feasible.
>>
>>111193932
>>111193978
>>111193763

Interesting. I hope Eggs doesn't enter into a love triangle. Those are shit. I prefer if he fucks Inko anyway.
>>
>>111193881

Yeah because she's not blushing and holding Slaine's memento in the manga cover either. Or features in Slaine's room in the OST cover. Look, I don't want to break your delusion, but so far the official art has pushed her to Slaine's direction in a extremely unsubtle way.

The only way she's not ending up with him is because: 1) she'll die. 2) he'll die. 3) they are siblings. All very likely. Inaho's not a factor.
>>
gen is a faget. he's going to kill off neechan.
>>
better than the faggot MC from Argevollen who makes me want to kill myself
>>
>>111194235
>>111194018
You guys know he's not writing any more episodes right?
>>
>>111193068
>Couldn't it be a radish?
Don't you even know what a radish looks like? Even the leaves are wrong.

But putting a tomato on top of scrambled eggs is stupid because A) the tomato will warm up B) the tomato gets dirty which is generally unappealing C) being a hard round object on top of a soft semi-liquid mass it's harder to pick up: if you try to stab it with your fork it will sink into the eggs, if you try to lift it with your fork it will probably roll off your plate, and you can't cut it without moving it somewhere else.
There are better ways to decorate a plate than this nonsense.
>>
>>111194306

He wrote the story. They are changing it as they like, but in case of Asshime's character, she is unchanged and she's described as token peace princess with some quirks (only in a more elaborated way because they are trying to sell her quickly). She's as good as dead. The only thing that can save her is the upset shipperfag fanbase of Slainefags. Because the waiufags are more into Neesan and Inko.
>>
If Yuki was my nee-chan I wouldn't be a worthless NEET
>>
>>111193244
>Alexander
>won't easily lose his cool
>>
>>111189465
Most human feeling protagonist
>>
So why does /m/ hate the show?
>>
what does yukinee's chest feel like on your face when you hug her?
>>
>>111193244
>Napoleon or Alexander
>no personality
>didn't easily loose their cool
I'm pretty sure Napoleon and Alexander weren't crossing swords with the enemy either.
>>
>>111194665
Bags of sand.
>>
>>111193727
>4 episodes in
>don't even know if Inaho's past will come up on why he is the way he is
>comparing a character from a show that's already finished to one that's 4 episodes in.
>>
>>111194771
We're already 1/3rd into A/Z, fuck off.
>>
>>111194771

Setsuna's past was clear since the first episode. Inaho is just shitty. L-Elf, who was from a shit show, had the stoic genius thing but he actually show more emotional range which made him engaging.

Inaho is pretty insipid and dull. Just admit he's awful and can't carry the show.
>>
>>111194771
Usually we get clues to the main characters past by now so people are free to critique a shitty character if they see one.
>>
>>111194834
1/3 into the first season of a split ocur show

you think they can end a planetary-wide war in 12 eps?
>>
>>111186774
Very few gundam protags are beta males. You can argue that some are whiny, but the only ones that are beta males are: Kou, Asemu (for the first half of his arc), Shinn, and Banana
>>111186946
>Kio
>beta male
I don't think you know what beta male is. For starters, if Kio is anything, he's a fucking Gary Stu.
>>
>>111194892
Given how stupid this show is I fully expect them to pull it off.
>>
>>111194937
being whiny is inherently beta
>>
>>111194673
Alexander was actually fighting on the front lines.
Napoleon hid and commanded from the backlines, but Alexander fought deep inside the melee. It got him almost killed in a campaign in Persia iirc.
>>
File: kek.png (63 KB, 271x267) Image search: [Google]
kek.png
63 KB, 271x267
>>111177973
>Every MC does that. That's like a requirement for being a MC, you have to be useful and relevant.

kek'd
>>
>>111195079
Shinji is alpha as fuck though.
I don't get this "Shinji is beta" meme, he pulls through every single time when he's needed.
>>
>>111194834
The show is 24 episodes long. We haven't even had an episode dealing with his backstory (assuming we'll have one) and you're already judging the characters backstory.
>>111194887
Usually doesn't mean always, so it doesn't make sense to start complaining about it when we're not even at a point in the show where we can start assuming things in the larger context of the show.
>>111194994
Kio wasn't whiny, he was just a moralfag. 2 different things. Hell, the only reason people started hating Kio was because of the second half of his arc when he started to become an overpowered moralfag, which is as bad as being whiny, but it's not the same thing.
>>
>>111195188
He cowers and whines. Refuses to try to understand others. Stuff a kid would do.

I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing. It's certainly human. I don't think he can really be classified in the alpha/beta dichotomy, tbh, but I think the dichotomy itself is a load of baloney.
>>
>>111177821
MAXIMUM
EMPTY
SHELL
TO
SELF
INSERT
???
>>
>>111195221
Also, I'm not arguing whether or not Inaho is a good protagonist or not, just that you're judging a character [on whether or not his backstory will play a part with why he act the way he does] that's 4 episodes into what will be a 24 episode show.
>>
>>111194630
The last mecha show /m/ praised was Gundam Build Fighters. And it still has among the biggest vocal hatebases focused on it.

/m/ doesn't like mecha.
>>
>>111178895
HAve you ever met an any one with actual Autism? this kids a poster child for Assburgers bordering on psychopathic with his complete lack of emotion, Same thing with Nagate from Sidonia
>>
>>111195356
Most people aren't as oblivious as he is, while also being as keen as he is.
He is not really normal. A normal character would be a lot better for self-inserting.
>>
>>111195334
He cowers and whines when he's not fighting, but in combat he saved everyone's worthless lives despite them hating him for it.
>>
File: 1390620904830.jpg (68 KB, 641x450) Image search: [Google]
1390620904830.jpg
68 KB, 641x450
>>111177821
>WAAA WAAAA GARY STU GARY STU WAAAA
Everyone in this thread.
>>
>>111195641
He's not a Gary Stu, the problem is that he's only kinda smart but everyone else his fucking legit retarded.
>>
>>111195440
He doesn't succeed all the time (see Bardiel/Toji and Armisael/Rei II's death), but that's not really the point here.

He's just doing what he's told for the majority of the anime, not out of a sense of heroism or anything. He struggles with his reason for why he pilots the Eva at all. It's more human than the trite hero complex bullshit, where they magically summon the courage to do anything.

Also, they don't "hate" him for how he saves them. They're just frustrated with how he acts like a child.
>>
He's a cautionary "everyone has to relate to him by default" blank slate and there's no two ways around it. Unless he genuinely has autism, which I highly doubt this show would push those boundaries, then it's just shitty writing, period.

It's probably haremshit-eaters who are defending him too.
>>
>I bet 4chan can't even name a good anime MC/hero.

This place pretty much hate anything.
>>
>>111193727
>>111186644
Setsuna was stoic, not emotionless. You clearly see him lose his cool several times in both seasons of 00.

>Ali trying to take the Exia from him
>Graham touching the Exia with his Flag to get evidence on it
>Lockon's death
>>
Inaho a shit.
Worst than Tatsuya, Izayoi, Touma and Kirito.
>>
>>111195894
Pico from Boku is a good MC.
>>
File: 1242591026412.jpg (45 KB, 593x708) Image search: [Google]
1242591026412.jpg
45 KB, 593x708
>>111195947
>>111195894
>>
>>111195872
They are the only ones who like him.
>>
>>111194673
Alexander did pretty often, he did have a routine of Cavalry dubbed out in the best armour money could buy though
>>
File: 44990370.jpg (88 KB, 550x722) Image search: [Google]
44990370.jpg
88 KB, 550x722
What if Bowlcut had been the MC?
>>
>>111193244
>Napoleon or Alexander
Napoleon and Alexander had hot tempers. Alexander, much more so.
>>
>>111193244

Napoleon and Alexander (and Lelouch) had charisma. Inaho is a fucking shell.
>>
would this series even be able to sell mech models?
>>
>>111196054
Improvement.
>>
Why did Inaho attracted to the Princess, who is Slaine's girl, when he already has first choice pick out of his nee-chan, Inko, and Rat?
>>
File: yuki3.jpg (212 KB, 1920x1080) Image search: [Google]
yuki3.jpg
212 KB, 1920x1080
Why does she lack art? Why nips don't like Yuki-nee?
>>
>>111196137
I don't think it's that type of series, contrary to the mech formula.
>>
>>111196188
They like her. I watch the episodes on Nico and every time she show up the comments go "Yuki-nee is so cute".
>>
>>111195802
To be fair, I mean, the fucker is 14 years old. He practically is a child and, hell, they call him the "Third Child."
>>
>>111196137
This is monster of the week so far but I doubt it, the mechas are shit
>>
>>111196178
He likes that Scandinavian beauty
>>
>>111191145
Not sure what the image has to do with it.
>>
>>111196293
Oh I know, he's a child thrust into a position that requires him to act mature.

His life's also pretty fucked up, given his mother "died" and his father abandoned him.
>>
>>111196178

Because this show is aimed at fujoshi who like shitty drama of two guys fighting over a princess self insert.

>>111196342

She's the ugliest girl of the cast.
>>
>>111194771
This is still the MC we're talking about. Using 00 as a convenient example again the anime opens with his past as a child soldier completely disillusioned with his idea of god. Cue 0 Gundam showing up as a literal deus ex machina and in the first 5 minutes it creates the foundation for his character that rest of the series follows.

That's not to say Setsuna is well written or Inaho isn't, but I think it's completely understandable that people aren't thrilled about being left in the dark. Especially when the MC has the kind of personality that needs context to be believable.
>>
>>111196410
>this show is aimed at fujoshi
Really, the entire show? Don't you think you're exaggerating?
>>
>>111195437
He's a perfect self-insert for all the people who see themselves as a cool stoic tactical genius. Which is a lot of people consisting how many posts I've seen where people say that they themselves would be calm and collected as fuck no matter the situation.
>>
>>111196410
Dat delusion.
>>
>>111191722
What's the difference between a scrambled egg and an omelette?
>>
>>111196447

The set up of the triangle is for girls. The princess is popular among girls in Japan, not among the guys who prefer inko and the sister so far.
>>
>>111196468

Even the loli maid is better looking while dressing a shittier outfit. She's pretty shoujo-esque self insert.
>>
>>111196410
Fujoshi isn't a catch all term for female fans. Fujoshi care about gay relationships, not straight ones. And I highly doubt romance is going to be a big deal anyway.
>>
>>111196512
You're basing this shit off pixiv again aren't you. Stop posting.
>>
File: 1404305840602.jpg (24 KB, 189x198) Image search: [Google]
1404305840602.jpg
24 KB, 189x198
>>111194879
>can't carry the show
His scenes are literally the biggest reason why I'm here.
>>
>>111196613

No, I'm not. She looks terrible.
>>
>>111195437
>He is not really normal

Are you implying that people on /a/ are normal?
>>
>>111196298
The Earth Mechas look cool, the Martian are utter shit
>>
>>111196671
Not talking about her looks. Are you even reading the delusional shit you're posting?
>>
>>111196778

Did I offend your waifu?
>>
>>111196654
Why? Are you one of those people that enjoy shows ironically?
>>
File: 1406419388444.jpg (100 KB, 998x810) Image search: [Google]
1406419388444.jpg
100 KB, 998x810
>>111196410
>aimed at fujoshi
>fujoshi like shitty drama of two guys fighting over a girl princess

And then there's this guy.
>>
Kudos to whoever predicted this series would go to shit the exact episode Urubochi stopped writing it. Going to be really fun having no actual development at all for at least until this season's finale, instead having shitty love triangle bullshit. It literally turned into Gundam Seed.
>>
>>111196473
Omelette is a scrambled egg made by someone with OCD.
>>
>>111196109
If anything that makes him less of a stu.

lelouch:
>large ham/inspiring leader
>chessmaster (strategic)
>chessmaster (tactical)
>also got a superpower

inaho:
>chessmaster (tactical)
>has some science books memorized

So if anything inaho is much less of an overpowered character and his abilities are far more situational.
>>
>>111196966
lelouch
>personality

inaho
>blank self insert
>>
>>111196837
Low b8 m8.
>>
> original mc with disorder that makes him not display emotions like normal people
> competent but not ubergod-level like Tatsuya or Sora
> people will complain about any mc because that's what people do
>>
>>111197038
Nigga he boring. That's all there is to it.
>>
>>111197038
>disorder
You're just making assumptions.
>>
>>111193244

No, he's God-Emperor. Know your shit.
>>
>>111197032
Self insert as an (outwardly) emotionless teen?
>>
>>111196918
Can't imagine Gen wasn't involved at all in the overall plot writing, so he should most likely be blamed just as much. It's like episode 4 took away exactly everything about episode 3 that made it stand out from the pack and tried to make it as generic as possible.
>>
>>111197098
> friend dies in front of him
> sure whatever
> lets kill martians
> not a disorder
>>
>>111197038
>disorder

What disorder? We see him living like an average high school student with his sister and having friends. He's not some child soldier who was trained since crib to murder people in cold blood.

He's just a boring Gary Stu.
>>
>>111196512
>is for girls
>The princess is popular among girls in Japan, not among the guys

Pay attention you ignorant buffoon, I'm only going to explain this once. First, if a love triangle with the object of affection is a girl and you want to claim it's aimed at girls, it's called otome and not fujoshi. Fujoshi only like gay shit, otome are the ones who like to self-insert in het romance. So if you say this show is fujoshit all you're saying is that people only watch it for Slaine being fucked by faceless men or Inaho. Second, hime is most popular with the guys who want to fuck her. Just because girls in pixiv draw Slaine with her and there's not pictures with hime sucking socks yet it doesn't mean guys hate her.
>>
>>111197179
>>111197184
>>111197038
It's terminal autism.
>>
>>111197196
>Just because girls in pixiv draw Slaine with her and there's not pictures with hime sucking socks yet it doesn't mean guys hate her.

kek.

Yuki gets most of that art.
>>
>>111197196
otaku want wincest, not the shitty princess with love triangle drama.
>>
>>111196442
>Cue 0 Gundam showing up as a literal dues ex machina
Stop posting.
>>
>>111196852
Not him, but I like him because he just solves problems with some basic engineering. Sure, he got plot armor on his side, but so do most MCs.

He's pretty much my chuuni self-image. Stroll in, casually look at problem, solve it with ease, save the day

>>111197126
providing rough outlines of what should happen for the sake of the main plot and fleshing out individual episodes is a big difference. The copy-pasting episode 3 onto episode 4 thing and yet being worse is exactly what makes the difference.

I don't get why they don't have gen write all of it.
>>
>>111197078
That's just your opinion though, I think he's pretty interesting.
Much better then having a MC who seeks revenge and yells a lot.

>>111197032
>blank self insert
Maybe if you have autism.
>>
>>111197038
Sora isn't an ubergod.
He has social anxiety and can't go out in public without his sister.
>>
>>111197196

The Hime isn't the most popular with the guys. That guy is full of shit about being a fujoshi show, but he's right about the guys favoring characters like the big sister and Inko over her. Love triangle involving the two male protagonists isn't something the male audience wants at all.
>>
>>111197196
The Slaine - Inaho - Hime love triangle is pretty bad for otome fans as well since Hime is not a good self-insert. They'd prefer someone like Inko.
>>
>>111197724
It's fine if both male protagonists are likeable and not just fantasy-fulfillment perfect guys for women.
>>
File: 1380473718247.jpg (322 KB, 914x887) Image search: [Google]
1380473718247.jpg
322 KB, 914x887
>>111197038
>original
>>
>>111197894
So, A.Z is not fine.
>>
>>111197817
You kidding? Women love Hime. She's perfect for self insert. Like Lieselotte. She has no character at all other than generic quirky princess who wants peace/coexistence.

Lieselotte at least had an offputting TWEEST.

>>111197817
>stoic guy she can melt and who does not do things for anyone else
>faithful emotional follower who would die for her

They are perfect for them.

Guys who watch mecha don't want love triangles involving the protagonists. That's why they always have an assigned different love interest. It's not something they like.
>>
>>111197998
eruefu also had hax-tier CQC skills and prediction abilities that bordered on clairvoyance and his planning could get them out of impossible situations.

Inaho is more limited than that. He has top-notch deductive skills, but he needs luck on his side and people to assit him left and right
>>
>>111197817

>Inko
>popular with women in Japan

Not at all. She's otakubait. Even the seiyuu.
Thread replies: 255
Thread images: 79

banner
banner
[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content you can contact me at [email protected] with that post and thread number and it will be removed as soon as possible.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com, send takedown notices to them.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from them. If you need IP information for a Poster - you need to contact them. This website shows only archived content.